Latest News and Comment from Education

Thursday, December 13, 2012

Morning UPDATE: LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 12-13-12 Diane Ravitch's blog

Diane Ravitch's blog:

Click on picture to Listen to Diane Ravitch





Secret Agreement Revealed Between New Jersey and Broad Foundation

The New Jersey Star-Ledger published news of a secret agreement that was leaked to the paper.
The state of New Jersey entered into an agreement with the Broad Foundation to meet the foundation’s demands; the money awarded to the state is available only so long as Governor Chris Christie remains in office.
This suggests that New Jersey has outsourced its education policy to the Los Angeles-based Broad Foundation. The foundation is known for its desire to control its grantees, but the idea of controlling a large northeastern state seems audacious indeed.
A crazy idea, but then the state’s Acting Commissioner of Education Chris Cerf is a graduate of the unaccredited Broad Superintendents Academy, as is Cami Anderson, the superintendent of the Newark public schools, as are a few other of the state’s superintendents.
Remember when we thought that the policies of the public schools were determined by the citizens of the district or the state?


When Brookings Honored a Governor Who Supports Vouchers

Louisiana Governor Bobby Jindal gained a valuable national platform at the Brookings Institution in Washington, where he explained that vouchers were the path to excellent education for all.
Of course, he didn’t use the V word. Like all Republicans pushing a stealth agenda, he calls them “opportunity scholarships.”
Here is a


A Brilliant and Disturbing Analysis of the Future of Teacher Education

Bruce Baker of Rutgers has taken it on himself to dissect the claims and plans of the “reformers” about teacher education.
The reformers hate traditional ed schools, even those connected to major flagship universities. They blame them for accepting bottom third students and then training them poorly.
Baker looks at the issues and examines the “cures” offered by the reformers, none of which will solve any of the problems that identify.
Baker pointed out in an earlier post (and repeats it here) that most of master’s degrees in education are now 


Teacher: When I Dared to Ignore the Standards

A teacher writes:
“I went to the Thinking in the Deep End blog, as you suggested, and returned to your site resisting the urge to cry. As a recent arrival to the teaching field — as a creative writer/poet and journalist who did so at the ripe age of 48, that is — I am utterly distressed at the test-centric atmosphere of the urban high school where I teach Language Arts. The again, I feel like a giddy young rebel, as I recently decided to guide my students on a creative writing assignment with fewer parameters (read: no detailed rubric abiding strictly by the common core standards) than any of them are used to. It was initially confusing for some — as they are so used to being told 



The Civil Rights Issue of Our Time

EduShyster here explicates the civil rights issue of our time.
She learned that the Feds were investigating the public schools of Fall River, Massachusetts, for their high suspension rate.
But, oh my, she discovered a group of schools with even higher suspension rates than Fall River.
Worse, these schools 



Advice to David Coleman: Revise the Common Core Standards

Dear David,
I know you must be pleased that the Common Core standards have been adopted in 46 states.
And now as president of the College Board, you will be able to align the content of the SAT with the Common Core.
But David, the Common Core is becoming a laughing stock at the same time that it has become Official 



Vouchers in Chile: Lessons Learned

Now that many Republican dominated states like Louisiana, Indiana, Michigan, and Wisconsin are enacting vouchers, it is a good time to look at the experience of vouchers in Chile. The Pinochet military dictatorship became infatuated with free-market ideas and imposed vouchers in the early 1980s.
To learn about the Chilean experience with vouchers, I turned to one of Mexico’s best-known independent researchers, Eduardo Andere.
Eduardo Andere writes:
“I began doing research about Chile in 2005. I was most struck by the fact that Chile is the country, perhaps together with New Zealand, that initiated a long and deep stream of education policy reforms since the 1980s . In 


What is Governor Tom Corbett’s Record on Education?

As Pennsylvania gears up for the next gubernatorial election, Governor Corbett’s spokesperson says the governor is proud of his education record. He claims that he has raised state spending on education to its highest levels.
Not so fast.
This Pennsylvania

Who Was Behind Michigan “Right to Work” Law

This past week, Michigan became the 24th state to pass a Right to Work (for Less) bill.
Wherever did the legislation originate?
The Center for Media and Democracy knows: it was copied almost verbatim from ALEC model legislation to quash unions.
ALEC, if you did not know, is a secretive organization with 2,000 or so members who are state legislators. It is 

Diane in the Evening 12-12-12 Diane Ravitch's blog

coopmike48 at Big Education Ape - 4 hours ago
Diane Ravitch's blog: *Go Figure!* Tony Bennett Lands on his Feet in Florida by dianerav Tony Bennett, the defeated state superintendent from Indiana, has landed the job as state commissioner in Florida. Bennett is the hero to the rightwing “reform” sector, a champion of privatization, vouchers, charters, online for-profit schools, and the Common Core. His last action in Indiana was to lower standards for new trackers and Pennsylvania Should Veto Every Virtual Proposal by dianerav Pennsylvania has 16 online charter schools for K-12. They all get terrible results. Some are fo... more »




City charter system smells of insider trading cronyism « Larry Miller's Blog: Educate All Students!

City charter system smells of insider trading cronyism « Larry Miller's Blog: Educate All Students!:


City charter system smells of insider trading cronyism

By Dominique Paul Noth
Editor, Labor Press
Posted December 13, 2012

 
Marva Herndon (right) upset about greased wheels trickery in city charter approval also advocates for playwgrounds at voucher schools, a campaign that last summer brought support from now state senator Nikiya Harris.
By Dominique Paul Noth
Editor, Labor Press
Posted December 13, 2012

Charter schools are public schools funded by state taxes. They are approved by review committees with little input from local citizens and less control by voters than exists with elected school boards.
The city’s charter school system is a rampant demonstration of how to lock out parents and educators with more sophisticated viewpoints. They’re getting away with it because of an aura surrounding the term “charter schools.” Major player Capital Roundtable is even holding conferences citing the boom in “Private Equity Investing in For-


City Officials Limit Public Comment on Charter Schools

So what are they trying to hide?
By Lisa Kaiser Thursday, Dec. 13, 2012 ExpressMilwaukee.com
In the accelerating privatization of public schools, taxpayer-funded charter schools seem to have a better reputation than voucher schools because they are linked to a public entity—typically the city, a school board or an institution of higher learning—and they’re accountable to the public.
But an examination of the oversight of the handful of schools chartered by the city of Milwaukee shows that public meetings allow for no public comment; major decisions are made by a committee that doesn’t have its own website or report its meetings or activities on the city website; and a small network of charter school 

How do U.S. Students Compare with their Peers around the World? | toteachornototeach

How do U.S. Students Compare with their Peers around the World? | toteachornototeach:


How do U.S. Students Compare with their Peers around the World?

How do U.S. Students Compare with their Peers around the World?
5-Its-a-Small-World-Slideshow
by Arne Duncan
New international assessments of student performance in reading, math, and science provide both encouraging news about American students’ progress and some sobering cautionary notes.
The encouraging news is that U.S. fourth grade students have made significant progress in reading and mathematics in the last five years. In fact, our fourth graders now rank among the world’s leaders in reading literacy, and U.S. student achievement in math is now only surpassed, on average, in four countries.
Unfortunately, these signs of real progress are counterbalanced by the fact that learning gains in fourth grade are not being sustained through eighth grade–where mathematics and science achievement failed to measurably 

Ed Notes Online: Nightmare on 8 Mile Road After Randi Negotiated Worst Contract in History

Ed Notes Online: Nightmare on 8 Mile Road After Randi Negotiated Worst Contract in History:


Nightmare on 8 Mile Road After Randi Negotiated Worst Contract in History

Detroit Public Schools consultants are creating phony negative evaluations of experienced teachers in a “monstrous plot” to fire anyone making too much money and destroy the teacher’s union, according to Superintendent Dr. John Telford. “Some of the stories would make you cry,” Telford said Wednesday on the Charlie Langton Talk Radio 1270 show.
Remember that "great" contract hailed as "ground breaking" Randi helped the Detroit teacher union negotiate a few years ago and ratified in Jan. 2009? Rich Gibson in Substance predicted the death spiral after the contract was negotiated, calling it "The worst contract in the history of school-based bargaining."

Detroit schools in final death spiral?

Rich Gibson - November 27, 2010
The Detroit Federation of Teachers (DFT) may be on its last legs. This was a once-proud union that fought like hell, alongside other workers, not only for the school worker force, but for kids. Last 

Engaging Parents In School… » Quasi-Interesting Survey On Parents Volunteering In Schools

Engaging Parents In School… » Quasi-Interesting Survey On Parents Volunteering In Schools:


Quasi-Interesting Survey On Parents Volunteering In Schools

The Corporation for National and Community Service in partnership with the National Conference on Citizenship has just released the results of a survey of parent volunteering in schools. I learned about it from the Hartford Courant, which is where this graphic was originally published. You can also learn more about the study here.

Board games - News - Local Stories - December 13, 2012 - Sacramento News & Review

Board games - News - Local Stories - December 13, 2012 - Sacramento News & Review:


Board games

Activists, teachers call school board's replacement-pick side step undemocratic, push for special election




This article was published on .

spacer
When Ellyn Bell decided to leave the Sacramento City Unified School District Board of Trustees earlier this year—so she could live closer to a new job in San Francisco—her colleagues on the board decided it was too late and too expensive to call an election to fill her seat.
They decided instead to pick their own replacement to represent the district’s Area 1 (Land Park, Curtis Park and the grid) for the remainder of Bell’s term, which ends in December 2014.
This is allowed by state education law. But some community activists and labor leaders say it’s undemocratic and are now calling for a special election to replace Bell.
And they’re threatening a petition drive that would force an election, even if the board makes its own pick, which is expected to happen on December 20.
Annette Deglow is leading the effort. She was also one of the community activists who helped to write and pass measures J and K, which brought area elections to the district and replaced the at-large system in 2006. Deglow says the school board’s decision to appoint a new board member rather than allowing area residents to pick their own representative undermines the 

Fiscal cliff talks: One lousy civics lesson for students

Fiscal cliff talks: One lousy civics lesson for students:



Fiscal cliff talks: One lousy civics lesson for students



(Charles Dharapak – AP)
The parties to the “fiscal cliff” negotiations — namely Congress and the Obama administration — have presented U.S. students with one lousy lesson in civics while violating the principles of cooperative learning and failing to follow good work/study habits.
One or both of the parties have procrastinated, blown deadlines, failed to set a timetable for getting their work done, engaged in name calling and scare tactics, refused to compromise for the good of the country, exaggerated or outright lied, blown their budget, failed to be transparent and show their work, and thoughtlessly ruined everybody’s holiday vacation.
Grade: F

Florida's real school reform record


Florida is in the education news again with the appointment of Tony Bennett as the Sunshine State's new education commissioner, this after the voters of Indiana decided they didn't want him to be in charge of their public schools anymore. Florida, of course, is home to Jeb Bush, the former Florida governor who launched school reforms more than a decade ago that have had influence across the country. Hailed as a "miracle," the reforms have not lived up to their hype. Here is a look at Florida's education reform record, by Julian Vasquez Heilig, an award-winning researcher and Associate Professor of Educational Policy and Planning at the University of Texas at Austin. A version of this appeared on his Education and Public Policy blog.
Read full article >>


Are exhausted students learning in school?


Encouraged by parents who want their teenagers to get more sleep, Montgomery County Public Schools Superintendent Joshua Starr is assembling a work group to study whether it makes educational and practical sense to push back the start of school.
Read full article >>

Parents, Teachers Put Scott, Board of Ed and Bennett On Notice | Scathing Purple Musings

Parents, Teachers Put Scott, Board of Ed and Bennett On Notice | Scathing Purple Musings:


Parents, Teachers Put Scott, Board of Ed and Bennett On Notice

The state’s established parent groups – including the PTA – began signaling the day before Tony Bennett’s appointment as Florida’s new education commissioner that the BOE’s  selection of candidates promised to be so divisive that it would  assign them as the spiraling out of control status quoers.. They did it anyway.  Blind to the realities of what Florida’s collapsing multiple accountability system actually means, the BOE unanimously appointed the one candidate who could deliver the most fuel to the fire.  The Herald-Tribune writer Lloyd Dunkelberger has this statement from FEA president Andy Ford:
The Florida Education Association is disappointed and disheartened at the selection of Tony Bennett to be Florida’s education commissioner. Bennett proved to be divisive in his tenure in the same position in Indiana and was voted out of office last month in the conservative state. He is a champion of the testing mania, unchecked expansion of charter schools and voucher programs and has proven to advance the Jeb Bush education agenda that has drawn fire from teachers, parents and experts in the field. That’s the same approach that has led to a flawed and chaotic 

Seattle Schools Community Forum: Smith-Blum New School Board President

Seattle Schools Community Forum: Smith-Blum New School Board President:


Smith-Blum New School Board President

: From: Office of Public Affairs
Sent: Wednesday, December 12, 2012 7:04 PM
Subject: School Board elects new officers

Seattle School Board elects new officers

The Seattle Public Schools Board of Directors on Wednesday night elected the following new officers for the 2013 calendar year:

Kay Smith-Blum – President

Betty Patu – Vice President

Sharon Peaslee– Member at Large

Smith-Blum was elected by a 4-3 vote, with Directors Betty Patu, Sharon Peaslee and Marty McLaren voting for her election and Directors Michael DeBell, Harium Martin-Morris and Sherry Carr voting against. Director Carr 

Why a privatized GED will fail students Coalition for Public Education/Coalición por la Educación Pública

Coalition for Public Education/Coalición por la Educación Pública:


Why a privatized GED will fail students
Monty Vyse reports on the fallout from the takeover
of GED testing by for-profit Pearson Education--and
what it will mean thousands trying to take the exam
each year.


December 11, 2012-- socialistworker.org

SINCE THE 1940s, adult learners who have left high school without a diploma have had the option of taking the General Educational Development (GED) test. Nearly 700,000 people took the GED test in 2011--about half are Black or Latino [1].

Test-takers come disproportionally from under-funded, urban school districts. In New York state, for example, 63 percent of GED test-takers last year were in New York City. The average age for test takers is 26, making the GED a vital resource for adult learners in the workforce.

In 2011, Pearson Education, the world's largest for-profit testing company, entered into a "partnership" with the non-profit American Council on Education, the parent organization that created GED Testing Service, which in 

Nonprofits seek influence with political giving | California Watch

Nonprofits seek influence with political giving | California Watch:


Nonprofits seek influence with political giving

As executive director of the Friends of the San Francisco Public Library, Scott Staub raises money to give to the city’s libraries. In his spare time, he raises money to give to politicians.
Staub heads a political action committee that is attempting to increase the political clout of the nonprofit sector in federal elections. Most of the committee’s members are affiliated with charitable organizations.
“We want to be a political player in a positive way,” said Staub, chairman of the Association of Fundraising Professionals PAC, an umbrella organization for charitable fundraisers. “There are lots of interest groups, and we decided we needed to have a greater voice for philanthropy.”
The PAC was formed about a decade ago and since then has contributed $68,000 to politicians who support pro-charity causes, especially maintaining the charitable tax deduction.
Charities are prohibited from donating to political campaigns as a condition of their tax-exempt status. But their 

Wednesday, December 12, 2012

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: The corporate big boys have already OK'ed the deal

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: The corporate big boys have already OK'ed the deal:


The corporate big boys have already OK'ed the deal

Honeywell CEO David Cote OK's the deal
Why am I so sure that the deal has already been done on the so-called fiscal cliff?

Because, according to this report in the NYT, the big boys have already given Obama and Boehner to increase taxes on the wealthiest 4% of Americans in exchange for cuts in so-called entitlements, ie. medicare benefits and social sec. By the big boys, I mean the real power in the country, including CEOs of Goldman Sachs, Honeywell, Dow, Morgan Stanley, G.E. and the rest. 

According to the Times, on Wednesday, several hedge fund managers, including Daniel Och, the billionaire founder of Och-Ziff Capital Management, will meet with Valerie Jarrett, a top adviser to the president, and 

Blue Jersey:: Alternate Route to Undermining Teaching

Blue Jersey:: Alternate Route to Undermining Teaching:

Alternate Route to Undermining Teaching

by: A New Jersey Farmer

Sun Dec 09, 2012 at 08:55:17 PM EST

Diary rescue. Don't know why this wasn't frontpaged the day it was posted. It's good. - RosiCross-posted at A New Jersey Farmer
It's not enough that the Christie Administration has bashed teachers as union mules and the source of New Jersey's fiscal ills. It's not enough that the governor has promoted private partnerships with public schools to avoid paying the state's fair share of education aid to school districts in need of money. It's not enough that he's advocated for merit pay based on an evaluative model that is reliant on faulty research. And it's not enough that he's attacked NJEA officials personally because of their private organization salaries.
Now the governor's administration wants to make it easier for charter schools to hire lesser qualified teachers simply, it seems, for ideological reasons. How is he doing this? By proposing that alternate route teachers who want to work in charter schools be able to earn teaching licenses with fewer requirements than those people who want public school teaching certificates. If you ever need any more evidence that the governor hasn't a clue about how to attract and train quality teachers, then here's your proof.
A New Jersey Farmer :: Alternate Route to Undermining Teaching
Let me state from the outset that I have taught the alternate route New Pathways to Teaching in New Jersey (NPTNJ) program since 2003. It's a wonderful program that has trained thousands of people in New Jersey to 

“Bennett Choice Good for Board of Ed, Not Kids” | Scathing Purple Musings

“Bennett Choice Good for Board of Ed, Not Kids” | Scathing Purple Musings:


“Bennett Choice Good for Board of Ed, Not Kids”

I’m taking myself out of the business of predicting what Rick Scott will do. I predicted he’d say no to JD Alexander on his Poly Tech university and was wrong. I had hoped Scott would stand up to Jeb Bush on Tony Bennett, but he didn’t. Looks like Florida has another dangerous education ideologue in the governor’s mansion who will appear to be reasonable. He’s not, and the man he made no attempt to stop from being our next education commissioner isn’t either. Maybe its just that Scott didn’t have the juice to just say no to Bush – even if he had wanted to. A leading Florida parents group feels the same way.
“What did Florida’s children, taxpayers and voters do to deserve Tony Bennett? Last month, in an astounding non-partisan consensus, 1.3 million Indiana voters removed Tony Bennett and his extreme reform agenda from office. Bennett’s Indiana loss cannot be blamed on the 40,000 members of the teachers union. The people of Indiana spoke loud and clear. Why on earth would the Florida Board of Education select a man who was fired for putting education reform ideology ahead of what’s best for children?” asked Kathleen Oropeza, co-founder, Fund Education Now.
“We are calling on Governor Scott to confirm that Florida’s children are more important than 

Jersey Jazzman: International Test Score Freak Out!

Jersey Jazzman: International Test Score Freak Out!:


International Test Score Freak Out!

It's like a reflex: international test scores come out, and reformy types like RiShawn Biddle instantly start bashing our horrible schools and stupid students:

65

The average score gap between the average American fourth-grader and a Singapore peer on the 2011Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study, which along with PISA and PIRLS, are the three main assessments of international student achievement. The between the two countries is 11 points lower than in 2003.
A word about Singapore:
Singapore has the world's highest percentage of millionaires, with one out of every six households having at least one million US dollars in disposable wealth. This excludes property, businesses, and luxury goods, which if included would further increase the number of 

Race to the Top: Mixed Reactions in the Bay Area « InterACT

Race to the Top: Mixed Reactions in the Bay Area « InterACT:


Race to the Top: Mixed Reactions in the Bay Area

Today’s education news includes the announcement of Race to the Top grant recipients, with this round of grants going to districts instead of states.  California had three winning districts, as EdSource Today reports:
Three California school districts are among 16 winners in the latest round of the federal Race to the Top funding competition. The relatively small districts beat out several of the state’s largest districts, which didn’t even make it into the final round.
This round of funding was the first in the series of Race to the Top competitions to be made available to individual districts. New Haven Unified in Union Citywith about 13,000 students, was the largest of the California winners. Lindsay Unified, in the Central Valley midway between Fresno and Bakersfield, and  Galt Elementary District,  south of Sacramento, also won. Each of those districts has around 4,000 students. 

Report: Nearly all of Newark's most disadvantaged students attend failing schools | NJ.com

Report: Nearly all of Newark's most disadvantaged students attend failing schools | NJ.com:


Report: Nearly all of Newark's most disadvantaged students attend failing schools

booker-anderson.JPG
Mayor Cory Booker and Newark Superintendent Cami Anderson,
 together in an October photo. 
Jennifer Brown/The Star-Ledger

NEWARK — A report released today by Newark Public Schools details an alarming finding — nearly all of Newark's most disadvantaged elementary and middle school students attend failing schools.
The report, commissioned by the district and prepared by consulting company Parthenon, analyzed student proficiency in math and reading, college readiness and test score growth in 85 charter and district schools across the city. Charter high schools were excluded from the analysis.
It classified about 14,000 K-8 students as "highest need," looking at factors such as poverty, race, language barriers or special needs. Kids were ranked in three groups. Among the neediest group, fewer than 5 percent of students are enrolled in a charter or district school with high test scores and high test score growth, the report found.
Officials from the district, the Newark Charter School Fund and the Foundation for Newark's Future said they hope to use the report's findings as a benchmark to boost learning among targeted groups of students that are struggling the most across the 


Evaluations earn an 'F' - Editorials - The News Herald

Evaluations earn an 'F' - Editorials - The News Herald:


Evaluations earn an 'F'

Published: Wednesday, December 12, 2012 at 08:00 AM.


The children of fictional Lake Wobegon from Garrison Keillor’s “Prairie Home Companion” were said to be “above average.” The same can be said of Florida’s public school teachers — if the state’s new evaluation system is to be believed.

It isn’t.

Credit the Florida Education Association for being consistent. Union officials and members didn’t moderate their opposition to the system even after the first round of results released last week showed that an astounding 96.5 percent of the state’s 130,000 teachers rated as being “effective” or better. Indeed, the unrealistically high figure only bolstered the FEA’s contention that the state is using unreliable and inaccurate data to judge teacher effectiveness.

The new system is part of the education reforms passed in 2011. Beginning in 2014, the evaluations will determine teacher salaries 

Modern School: Detroit Wild Cat Strike Shuts Down 2 School Districts

Modern School: Detroit Wild Cat Strike Shuts Down 2 School Districts:


Detroit Wild Cat Strike Shuts Down 2 School Districts




They say Michigan’s new Right to Work (RTW) law is now a done deal. That didn’t stop thousands of teachers and other union members from taking the day off to protest at the state capital this week. In Detroit, so many teachers called in sick that two school districts, (Taylor Public Schools and Warren Consolidated Schools), were closed for the day, according toDetroit News. Detroit Public Schools (DPS) remained open, though Detroit Federation of Teachers (DFT) President Keith Johnson did urge members to go to Lansing.

The state’s new RTW bills would make it illegal to require employees to join a union or pay union dues as a condition of employment. This would significantly reduce unions’ ability to raise funds to support their members, while allowing freeloaders to reap the benefits of union-negotiated contracts without providing any material support for this service. RTW states have