Thursday, May 19, 2011

The Question Sheet: Optimally Crazy in Education

The Question Sheet: Optimally Crazy in Education

Optimally Crazy in Education

Last week I wrote about the potential benefits of signaling crazy outcomes during a negotiation. If a credible signal is sent it can shift the power of the negotiation in favor of the side willing to do crazy things, like walk away from a lucrative deal or blow up the world. Negotiating in this manner may be effective but it creates an adversarial environment where compromise is difficult to achieve, both sides cannot truly trust each other and brinksmanship pushes each side to extreme positions they would not necessarily adopt in more flexible situations. Think about the Cold War or the current right-left political climate where extreme positions are regularly adopted and celebrated.
This type of negotiation also exists in the education arena. Negotiation is an enormous part of education policy and contributes a great deal to the rancor that exists in much of the debate.

There are many issues in education that many people don’t agree on. I’m going to oversimplify things to a huge degree here so bear with me. What much of the conflict boils down to is a labor vs management relationship…with a whole bunch of other stuff added on. And it defines the debates we have. It pushes people to extremes they don’t normally occupy. Think about the major issues in play in education reform today. There are concerns that charter schools and

What a Public Bank Could Mean for California | Dissident Voice

What a Public Bank Could Mean for California | Dissident Voice

What a Public Bank Could Mean for California

California is the eighth largest economy in the world, and it has a debt burden to match. The state has outstanding general obligation bonds and revenue bonds of $158 billion, largely incurred for building infrastructure. Over $7 billion of California’s annual budget goes to pay interest on the state’s debt.

As large as California’s liabilities are, they are exceeded by its assets, which are sufficient to capitalize a bank rivaling any in the world. That’s the idea behind Assembly Bill 750, introduced by Assemblyman Ben Hueso of San Diego, which would establish a blue ribbon task force to consider the viability of creating the California Investment Trust, a state-owned bank receiving deposits of state funds. Instead of relying on Wall Street banks for credit—or allowing a Wall Street bank to enjoy the benefits of lending its capital—California may decide to create its own, publicly owned bank.

On May 2, AB 750 moved out of the Banking and Finance Committee with only one nay vote, and is now on its way to the Appropriations Committee. Three unions—the California Nurses Association, the California Firefighters, and the California Labor Council—submitted their support for the bill. The state bank idea also got a nod from former Secretary of Labor Robert Reich in his speech at the California Democratic Convention in Sacramento the previous day.

Why a State Bank?

California joins eleven other states that have introduced bills to form state-owned banks or to study their feasibility. Eight of these bills were introduced just since January, including in Oregon, Washington State,

“Bring your cell phone to the lounge…” « Fred Klonsky's blog

“Bring your cell phone to the lounge…” « Fred Klonsky's blog

“Bring your cell phone to the lounge…”

MAY 19, 2011
by Fred Klonsky
This morning we gathered in the teachers’ lounge and I handed out this phone number: 1 888 412 6570.
At the prompt we entered our home zip code and we were automatically linked to our General Assembly representatives’ voice mail.
“Vote no on SB512. Do not vote for any bill that diminishes the pension benefits of current or retired teachers. It is unfair and unconstitutional and would break a long-standing promise to teachers.”
We committed to emailing 12 friends tonight to do the same thing.
And to post it on our Facebook status.
What school in Illinois can’t do the same thing?

No pension bill today. Or tomorrow. A Madigan retreat?

SB 512 was going to come out of committee yesterday.
That’s what Boss Madigan wanted.
It didn’t happen.
Then it was going to come out today.
It has been delayed.
Maybe next week.
I’m hearing that they are losing Democratic votes because of the voice mail boxes are filled by noon each day and the emails are flooding the computers. Teachers are actually receiving prompt returns to their letters off outrage.
Republicans are smelling blood. Many are more interested in a defeat for the Democrats and Madigan then they want a pension bill.
Don’ stop believing.
Make the call.
1 888 412 6570

And we promote parent involvement while pulling stunts like this? - THE DAILY RIFF - Be Smarter. About Education.

And we promote parent involvement while pulling stunts like this? - THE DAILY RIFF - Be Smarter. About Education.

And we promote parent involvement while pulling stunts like this?



Talking Both Sides of the Mouth Award
Secret.Obama.NCLB.parentinvolvement.jpg
This just in, as reported by Alexander Russo at This Week in Education -
re: NCLB (No Child Left Behind):

NCLB: Obama's SuperSecret Special Ed Diversion Program

Wow. A little-noticed provision in the Obama education "blueprint" for NCLB --
inserted at the behest of the Gates Foundation and/or Pearson and Comcast
(no one's quite sure) -- allows schools to identify children as special needs and
divert them into a resource room for up to a full school year --without parents'
knowledge or approval or the consent of the teacher of record. According to
section 45.321, a district can "identify, at its discretion, up to 5 (five) percent of student enrollment not already identified as having special

Court Turns Down Challenge to Schools’ Labor Pact - voiceofsandiego.org: Schooled: The Education Blog

Court Turns Down Challenge to Schools’ Labor Pact - voiceofsandiego.org: Schooled: The Education Blog

Court Turns Down Challenge to Schools’ Labor Pact

Print
Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Wednesday, May 18, 2011 6:05 pm | Updated: 8:27 pm, Wed May 18, 2011.

I just got a copy of a legal decision that rejects a lawsuit against a labor pact on San Diego Unified school construction.

An appeals court found that the labor agreement didn't violate California laws about apprenticeships, as the San Diego chapter of the Associated General Contractors had argued in its suit last year.

The labor pact was deeply controversial when the school board agreed to it nearly two years ago. Such agreements typically involve a tit-for-tat in which a public agency sets rules on bidding, such as hiring workers through union halls, in exchange for unions promising not to strike.

The San Diego Unified pact requires employers to provide healthcare largely through

4LAKids - SCHOOL LIBRARIES VITAL FOR STUDENTS

4LAKids - some of the news that doesn't fit: SCHOOL LIBRARIES VITAL FOR STUDENTS

SCHOOL LIBRARIES VITAL FOR STUDENTS

THIS EDITORIAL RAN IN WEDNESDAY’S WATERLOO ONTARIO, CANADA REGION RECORD | HTTP://BIT.LY/JZ8FBC

●●smf: Mark Twain said: “First God created idiots, that was for practice. Then he created school boards”. Apparently the phenomenon is international – as is the desire for politicians to become “The Education [Whatever]”.

18 May, 2011 - Nothing liberates the mind of a young person more than a good library. For this reason, school libraries could be seen as the most important room in the entire school building. The way school libraries operate might be the subject of legitimate debate but there shouldn’t be any doubt that publicly-funded schools in Ontario should have them.

Surprisingly, one school board in the province, the Windsor-Essex Catholic District School Board, is dismantling all of its libraries. It has laid off all but four of its library technicians and has started dividing the library books at its elementary schools among individual classrooms.

This decision conforms with a trend uncovered by People for Education, an educational advocacy group. In a survey released this week, People for Education found that while 80 per cent of Ontario elementary schools employed a teacher-librarian a decade ago, only 56 per cent do so today.

That’s a huge drop. And, as a trend, it is unacceptable. A school library is more than just a collection of books — important though that is. It is

Graphs of the Day: Texas Private School Enrollments & Expenditures « School Finance 101

Graphs of the Day: Texas Private School Enrollments & Expenditures « School Finance 101

Graphs of the Day: Texas Private School Enrollments & Expenditures

Below are a series of graphs of the distribution of enrollments and average total expenditures for Texas private schools. I figure these are particularly relevant as the Texas legislature entertains the idea of providing vouchers for private schools in Texas. These data, unfortunately, are from a few years back – based on 2008 IRS tax filings of private schools. Further, because I used IRS filings to determine expenditures, certain groups of schools – most notably Catholic schools – are noticeably underrepresented in the financial analysis. That said, I was able to compile sufficient data on relatively large numbers of Independent Schools (about 75% of all nationally) and Christian Schools (nearly 1/3… not great, but reasonable numbers). Those two groups of schools represent a significant share of Texas private school enrollments.

Here’s the punchline from these graphs. If we have any expectation that a voucher program is going to provide religious neutrality in access to private schooling or to provide sufficient opportunity to attend high quality non-religious, private independent schools, then voucher levels likely need to be much higher than commonly recommended. This then raises the key policy question – if the vouchers would have to be much higher than the average current public school expenditure – and the outcomes unknown – why would we adopt such a policy?

As the larger study (link) below shows, private schools are not uniformly/systematically “cheaper” and/or “better”

Daily Kos: Time - a reflection on its dimensions

Daily Kos: Time - a reflection on its dimensions

Time - a reflection on its dimensions

There are different ways of looking at time. I can consider the task of a work week. I can look at my calender for the month. Each year has some kind of demarcation to it, with the cycle of anniversaries, birthdays, and holidays.

I can take it to a finer level of detail. How will I use the 45 minutes a class of students will spend in my room? Taking attendance, giving directions, providing opportunity for them to explore unplanned ideas.

I can obsess about getting stuck in traffic - adding 5-15 minutes to a daily commute, which can matter if I am cutting things close on my arrival for a specific responsibility. Or I can use that same time to let go and reflect.

Monday is a significant demarcation for me. It used to be the age at which most people retire, 65, although I shall not. On a smaller scale, since the last external deliverable for my students is a state test tomorrow, it begins a different part of the school year, when I introduce them to their final projects, which tend to unleash their creative juices and I begin to really see what they have learned and can do.

It will also represent a new start. Perhaps that seems odd, as I am not retiring at the end of this year. And yet each birthday seems as if it is yet another opportunity.

To look forward, I must reflect backwards.

Again I do so today. Reflecting on time in its many elements.

Considering How One 'Sees' Things - Bridging Differences - Education Week

Considering How One 'Sees' Things - Bridging Differences - Education Week

Considering How One 'Sees' Things

Dear Diane,

I'm writing you while you are probably also writing me, on Sunday the 15th because I get up at 6 a.m. tomorrow to go to a board meeting at the Panasonic Foundation and then must drive five hours to Concord, N.H., where I'll spend a few days at the Upper Valley Educators Institute with Rob Fried. The institute runs a program where would-be teachers are placed in school four days a week and take classes one day a week—in order to earn a teaching license. It's the kind of "alternative" system I applaud and is just one of many which immerses interested would-be teachers inside classrooms—day after day. More later.

Yesterday I talked for hours with Dennis Littky whose new MET one-on-one college is coming to the end of its first year. The big turning point, he said, was sending young people to far-away lands largely on their own for a few months. Maybe it's one way of shifting their perspectives, going from seeing-like-a-teenager to seeing-like-an-adult, an American. Dennis is always learning on the job!

How we take in the world is so critical to what we can understand about it. James Scott's Seeing Like a State is a must read. It gets to the heart of our problem. Aside from those who truly believe that public enterprises are

FBI’s own play book discovered in activist’s home. Now it’s public. - blue cheddar blog

FBI’s own play book discovered in activist’s home. Now it’s public. - blue cheddar blog

FBI’s own play book discovered in activist’s home. Now it’s public.

There is an episode that occurred in 2010 in Minneapolis that really disturbed me, and so when I saw this story surface again with a new twist, I was alternately thrilled at the new development and angry again.

Watch live streaming video from theuptake at livestream.com

To see the documents, go HERE.

The homes and office of peace activists with The Anti-war Committee were raided by the FBI in Minneapolis and Chicago in September 2010. Also, members of Freedom Road Socialist Organization were raided, surveilled,

Schools Matter: Montana Just Says No to More Testing Insanity

Schools Matter: Montana Just Says No to More Testing Insanity

Montana Just Says No to More Testing Insanity

The corporate education reformers (both neocon and neolib) had one big goal in mind when they rolled out NCLB under the cynical and manipulative banner of a high quality public education for all children: to use impossible testing targets that most poor children will never meet in order to undercut support for public schools and to create the demand for privatized options such as the segregated chain gang charters. In short, the goal was to blow up public education.

And so we end up 9 years after NCLB passage with the neediest children in behavioral straight jackets, learning how to bubble in anti-cultural, anti-thinking tests inside inadequate buildings without libraries or certified teachers, and with CEO principals who have a free rein to abuse his power and to steal the public dollars that fund these corporate madrassahs. Tell me the Business Roundtable doesn't have power.

In Montana, anyway, they have had enough, telling Arne Duncan and his oligarch handlers to not pass go but go directly to Hell with their unethical testing scheme that has left millions of the poorest children of America labeled as failures for life. Enough!


From the Bozeman Chronicle:
Denise Juneau, Montana's top teacher, is

What is School Choice, Really? « Cooperative Catalyst

What is School Choice, Really? « Cooperative Catalyst

What is School Choice, Really?

This is cross-posted from my Philly Teacher blog. I wanted to extend the conversation to this community of forward-thinking and innovative educators, so I have added it to the Co-op. I’m looking forward to hearing your thoughts.

Pennsylvania’s new Governor, Tom Corbett, ran on a platform of school vouchers. He and his neighbor, New Jersey Governor Chris Christie have been pushing for legislation to bring more of them to their respective states. Most of the arguments I have heard supporting school vouchers is that they support school choice.

This idea that being able to choose from a traditional public school, a public charter, a parochial school or a private independent school is true ‘choice’ is a huge falsehood.

When we talk about school choice, we should be talking about choices in instructional models. We know that not all students learn the same. We know that some students can succeed in the traditional model. We know that many do not. We also know that there are a variety of alternatives to the traditional model.