Friday, January 14, 2011

NJ Spotlight | Opinion: NJ's 'Fatally Flawed' Merit Pay Program

NJ Spotlight | Opinion: NJ's 'Fatally Flawed' Merit Pay Program

Opinion: NJ's 'Fatally Flawed' Merit Pay Program
Our problem in New Jersey is not the lack of a merit system. Our problem is how we’ve chosen to measure merit.

In Tuesday’s State of the State speech, Governor Chris Christie declared education reform his highest priority.

"The time for a national conversation on tenure is long past due," Christie asserted. "I propose that we reward the best teachers, based on merit at the individual teacher level.… I am committed to improving the measurement and evaluation of teachers."

Been there, done that, Guv.

New Jersey has had a merit pay system for teachers for years. True, leaders of the New Jersey Education Association (NJEA) deny it exists. President Barbara Keshishian said recently that any merit pay proposal is "fatally flawed." That's just semantics. Our problem in NJ is not the lack of a merit system. The problem is how

Supreme Court Remands Abbott v. Burke to Lower Court for Fact Finding
Justice's order appears to put burden of proof on Christie administration

In the Assembly chamber of the Statehouse on Tuesday, justices of New Jersey’s Supreme Court listened as Gov. Chris Christie in his State of the State address made a not-so-subtle jab at the Abbott v. Burke school funding case.

“We must end the myth that more money equals better achievement,” Christie said. “It is a failed legal theory, and we can no longer waste our children’s time or the public’s money waiting for it to work.”

Two days later, the justices answered back: "Not so fast."

The court yesterday ordered the latest Abbott challenge to Christie’s $1.1 billion in school aid cuts be remanded to a lower court for fact-finding hearings. The justices are

N.J. Supreme Court orders state to prove Christie's funding formula is sufficient | NJ.com

N.J. Supreme Court orders state to prove Christie's funding formula is sufficient | NJ.com

N.J. Supreme Court orders state to prove Christie's funding formula is sufficient

'Special master' will hold further hearings and report by end of March on constitutionality of the current funding levels

N.J. superintendents group sues to block Gov. Christie's planned salary cap

Vic Yepello/The Star-LedgerParsippany superintendent LeRoy Seitz, who Gov. Chris Christie called the "new poster boy for all that’s wrong with the public school system that is being dictated by greed." A group representing 600 superintendents has sued the state to...

N.J. superintendents group sues to block Gov. Christie's planned salary cap

Vic Yepello/The Star-LedgerParsippany superintendent LeRoy Seitz, who Gov. Chris Christie called the "new poster boy for all that’s wrong with the public school system that is being dictated by greed." A group representing 600 superintendents has sued the state to...

Charters schools' windfall is public kids' loss as state has city on hook for $32 million

Charters schools' windfall is public kids' loss as state has city on hook for $32 million

Charters schools' windfall is public kids' loss as state has city on hook for $32 million

Friday, January 14th 2011, 4:00 AM

Public school kids are the ones who suffer in charter school snafu.
He for News
Public school kids are the ones who suffer in charter school snafu.

New York City's charter schools are getting a windfall increase of 9% in funding this year, even as city public schools are forced to cope with cuts of more than 4%.

The unexpected hike for charters - from $12,443 a child to $13,527 - is the result of a legislative screw-up that Albany lawmakers failed to address before they went out of session last month.

The hike affects the entire state. That means urban districts, where most charters are located, are being forced to redirect scarce dollars they had earmarked for traditional public schools.

The city's Department of Education, for example, will need to shift more than $32



Read more: http://www.nydailynews.com/ny_local/education/2011/01/14/2011-01-14_charters_windfall_is_public_kids_loss_state_snafu_has_city_on_hook_for_32m.html#ixzz1B0yRRIXC

The Answer Sheet - What reformers are doing to urban kids (or 'it's terrible what they are doing to these schools')

The Answer Sheet - What reformers are doing to urban kids (or 'it's terrible what they are doing to these schools')

What reformers are doing to urban kids (or 'it's terrible what they are doing to these schools')

This was written by Natalie Hopkinson, a fellow of the Interactivity Foundation and a contributing editor to The Root, a daily online magazine devoted to the black experience. She is co-author of he co-author of "Deconstructing Tyrone: A New Look at Black Masculinity in the Hip-Hop Generation." This post first appeared on The Root. By: Natalie Hopkinson Something wasn't right at the high school that Darwin Bridgers' son attends, so he sat in on the class to see for himself. All morning long, the instructor at the Washington, D.C., charter school pointed to a list of ground rules, a detailed list of rewards and punishments posted on a wall near the front of the class filled with black and Latino students. Then the students filled out worksheets. That's how it went: rewards and punishments, then worksheets. No instruction, just worksheets. At the end of the class, Bridgers, who works as

Math class: What’s the right order?

In what order should students take math? Should Geometry come before or after Algebra 2? Here are some of the ways schools are working through the issue. Below are responses school counselors around the country to a request for information about the order that high school students take math classes. The query was issued by Jean Crowder, director of the Mathematics, Engineering, Science Achievement (MESA) Program at Sacramento State University and University of California at Davis. The responses were sent to her via the e-list of the National Association for College Admission Counseling. She gave me permission to publish the responses (keeping them anonymous), which I found revealing about how schools experiment with math. The original query to counselors from Crowder: "I am working with a local high school site that is considering altering the enrollment/completion order for mathematics for students. This possible new completion order would be as follows:

Kirst: Critics of State Board are off-base | Thoughts on Public Education

Kirst: Critics of State Board are off-base | Thoughts on Public Education

Kirst: Critics of State Board are off-base - by John Fensterwald - Educated Guess

State Board of Education President Michael Kirst says he and his new colleagues on the Board already have gotten a bad rap. According to Kirst, defenders of the seven Board members whom Gov. Jerry Brown didn’t reappoint have dismissed new members as opponents of education reform and ready to launch a “war on charter schools.” [...]

NYC Educator: Deals with the Devil

NYC Educator: Deals with the Devil

Deals with the Devil

After years of the DOE reneging on promises, stabbing us in the back, planting nonsense in the tabloids, complaining about contracts it signed, deals it made, UFT leadership still shows far too little evidence of having learned anything. Months back, UFT President Michael Mulgrew made a deal to incorporate value-added metrics into teacher ratings. This has great potential to backfire, just as Ms. Weingarten's deal to examine value-added has, rather spectacularly, blown up in the faces of all the UFT experts who deemed this a good idea.

Ms. Weingarten was determined not to be a stereotypical cigar-chomping union boss, forever demanding more money and better working conditions. And indeed, with inflation, teachers are not making more money. Ms. Weingarten didn't hesitate to toss away decades of hard-fought professional rights for a compensation increase that failed to match the NYC inflation rate. For this, she won accolades from anti-

School Tech Connect: A Shoe That Does A Whole Lot More Than Pinch

School Tech Connect: A Shoe That Does A Whole Lot More Than Pinch

A Shoe That Does A Whole Lot More Than Pinch

One more post from the Springfield tapes:

First up, I've got the great Barbara Flynn Currie (D-Chicago), explaining how the temporary tax hike works and why it's now or never. I'd vote for Currie for president-- the woman tells it like it is. I've also added here, at about the 6 minute mark or so, her little dressing-down of Roger Eddy, a Republican from somewhere. I didn't include Eddy's subsequent tantrum.

Miguel Del Valle on Stand for Children. « Fred Klonsky's blog

Miguel Del Valle on Stand for Children. « Fred Klonsky's blog

Miguel Del Valle on Stand for Children.

‎”The same people who gave Madigan and Cullerton all that money to push their agenda to break up the public schools, Stand for Children, are putting money into the mayor’s race too. And so obviously they’re not giving any to me. Nor


hank you Ms Lippen-Holz and Mrs. Gayley!

Dear Mr. Klonsky,

Thank you for your coverage of the Del Valle event tonight. I can bring this to your attention solely due to the vigilance of educators such as yourself, but there’s an unnecessary apostrophe in “Clerk’s” in the fifth quote listed in the post.

I am not certain whether the credit should go to Ms. Lippen-Holtz from the fourth grade of Bethany Elementary, or Mrs. Gayley from the fifth.

Warm regards,

Erika

Groundhog Day and Education Reform

Groundhog Day and Education Reform

Groundhog Day and Education Reform



I’m not surprised that Justin Cohen, school turnaround expert and all-around smart guy, fully appreciates the virtues of Groundhog Day, a movie whose deceptively profound aspirations are so perfectly realized that it has emerged over time as one of greatest comedies ever made.

But Justin’s reason for bringing it up–an upcoming Fordham Institute event organized around the premise that “When it comes to low-performing schools, we seem to be witnessing the same thing over and over—not unlike the classic movie, Groundhog Day”– illustrates how the movie’s underlying message has become a bit obscured

Is LAUSD Another Bell? by Stuart Goldurs (Es LAUSD Un Otra Bell?) - Perdaily.com

Is LAUSD Another Bell? by Stuart Goldurs (Es LAUSD Un Otra Bell?) - Perdaily.com

Is LAUSD Another Bell? by Stuart Goldurs (Es LAUSD Un Otra Bell?)

Stuart Goldurs MTR.jpg

(Mensaje se repite en Espaรฑol)

For a national view of public education reform see the end of this blog post


(Yesterday, you heard Susan Lee Schwartz talk about New York City public education reality. Today, Stuart Goldurs, who calls himself "L.A. Public Education Examiner," takes a shot at describing LAUSD's version of the same premeditated failure - DO YOU SEE THE SIMILARITY?


Recently, the City of Bell, California made the headlines when the long term corruption of its city officials came to

Fads and Fetishes; Choices and Committments | Mr. Teachbad's Blog of Teacher Disgruntlement

Fads and Fetishes; Choices and Committments | Mr. Teachbad's Blog of Teacher Disgruntlement

Fads and Fetishes; Choices and Committments

“These people drop every ball they pick up.” –A Beloved Former Colleague, speaking about our administration

How many ideas do you think there are for improving the academic achievement of low-income, minority students?

Nevermind…It’s too many. Let’s make it smaller. How many ideas do you think there are for doing vocabulary work before a difficult reading? (Then multiply these ideas by a differentiation factor.)

How many ideas are there about the best student data to track and how to track it? (Dear Lord, how we go round and round on this one…) How should students be grouped? How often should I call parents, since they’re the

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: IN MY MAILBOX

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: IN MY MAILBOX

IN MY MAILBOX

Dear Michael Klonsky,

I want to thank you for your chapter "Power Philanthropy" in The Gates Foundation and the Future of U.S. "Public" Schools. I found it very helpful and quoted it in my article in the new issue of Dissent magazine. Below is the link to the article which I

Thursday, January 13, 2011

Did DOE set up JFK for failure? - The Riverdale Press

Did DOE set up JFK for failure? - The Riverdale Press
Did DOE set up JFK for failure?
By Nikki Dowling

During a typical dismissal, hundreds of students can be seen surging off the Kennedy campus.

They carry backpacks, iPods and textbooks. They joke with their friends as they walk down Tibbett Avenue, talk on their cell phones and greet the crossing guard waiting on the corner of West 230th Street with a nod, smile or fist bump.

It is impossible to tell which ones hail from the Bronx School of Law and Finance, where students have access to state-of-the-art technology. You cannot pick out who is from the Marble Hill School for International Studies, which was one of only five schools in the City to receive more than 100 points on its Progress Report in 2009-2010.

But when you check out the statistics, talk to teachers and look at students’ downcast, worried faces it is easy to tell that John F. Kennedy High School doesn’t belong.

In December, the Department of Education proposed that Kennedy be phased out and replaced with two schools by 2014. JFK has suffered for years from low test scores, corruption, violence and overcrowding. But how can a school that shares the same building as some of the top schools in the

Has Sandra Day O’Connor’s Site Just Added A Weird & Insulting Game On Immigration? Or Am I Being Too Sensitive? | Larry Ferlazzo's Websites of the Day...

Has Sandra Day O’Connor’s Site Just Added A Weird & Insulting Game On Immigration? Or Am I Being Too Sensitive? | Larry Ferlazzo's Websites of the Day...

Has Sandra Day O’Connor’s Site Just Added A Weird & Insulting Game On Immigration? Or Am I Being Too Sensitive?

Former Supreme Court Justice Sandra Day O’Connor has created a website to help students learn about civics issues.

I’ve previously posted about the site, and its games. One of them — Cast Your Vote — is pretty good, and it’s on The Best Websites For Learning About Civic Participation & Citizenship. There are a lot of interactives there, but I think most of them are overly-complicated — even for native English speakers. “Cast Your Vote,” though, puts you in the role of a person at a political debate asking questions and evaluating the

Blagosphere for Miguel Del Valle gathers at a local cafe. « Fred Klonsky's blog

Blagosphere for Miguel Del Valle gathers at a local cafe. « Fred Klonsky's blog

Blagosphere for Miguel Del Valle gathers at a local cafe.

I am here at a Chicago north side cafe with a dozen and a half other bloggers who are supporting Miguel Del Valle for mayor of Chicago.

People are introducing themselves, their histories, their work and why they support Del Valle for mayor.

“I worked for Harold.”

“The City Clerk’s office works now.”

Schools Matter: Wake County Segregationists Become Most Visible Tea Partiers

Schools Matter: Wake County Segregationists Become Most Visible Tea Partiers

Wake County Segregationists Become Most Visible Tea Partiers

The Atlantic Wire has a round-up of reactions to the WaPo news piece that has put Wake County on the map in ways that are an embarrassment to most Wake Countians:
Presented By
Have Tea Party conservatives made their first major statement on how public schools should operate? The Washington Post's Stephanie McCrummen suggests they have. She takes us to North Carolina's Wake County, where a "majority-Republican school board backed by national tea party conservatives" abolished long-standing policies designed to promote school integration, which the majority criticized as social engineering.

Some background is helpful: In the 1970s, officials in Raleigh--North Carolina's state capital--knit the city and its suburbs together into one vast Wake Country School District so that children in

Teachers' Union Boss Randi Weingarten - BusinessWeek

Teachers' Union Boss Randi Weingarten - BusinessWeek

Teachers' Union Boss Randi Weingarten

The president of the American Federation of Teachers on public schools, teacher bonuses, and why unions are so unpopular

http://images.businessweek.com/mz/11/04/370/1104_mz_80etchardchoices.jpg

Andy Cutraro for Bloomberg Businessweek

My parents were not union activists. My mother was a teacher who went on strike at terrific financial sacrifice to the family, and my father was an electrical engineer who lost his job through no fault of his own. It made me question the central notion of capitalism—that if you work hard, you'll have plenty of opportunity.

After finishing law school, I went to work on Wall Street and then became counsel at the United Federation of Teachers, the union for educators in New York City public schools. In 1998, I became president. When I first joined UFT, the city