Latest News and Comment from Education

Friday, January 8, 2010

Education Week: Incentivizing Educational Ingenuity


Education Week: Incentivizing Educational Ingenuity:

"Over the past 25 years, high-profile school reform efforts have addressed false problems with flawed solutions. By imposing blanket reforms on varying local circumstances, policymakers have stifled educational ingenuity. To actually improve the education of America’s children, state and federal policymakers should formulate and implement policies that provide incentives for problem-solving in local settings.

To do this, they will first need to recognize that some of the “problems” our public schools are called upon to solve are problematic in themselves. These include claims that U.S. productivity lags behind that of other countries, that students’ achievement here is far eclipsed by their international peers’, that academic achievement translates into worker productivity, and that we have a shortage of workers with math and science skills."

The Educated Guess � CTA advises local unions not to sign MOU


The Educated Guess � CTA advises local unions not to sign MOU:

"One day before the deadline for commitments to Race to the Top, state education officials were again encouraging ambivalent school districts to sign on. The California Teachers Association, for the first time, was explicitly encouraging union locals not to. And that could spell trouble for the state’s application.

State officials said they needed signed memorandums of understanding by Friday, so that they could finish the budget for the Race to the Top proposal by Jan. 19, when it’s due in Washington. Nearly 800 superintendents and charter school leaders, in charge of more than 60 percent of state’s students, had indicated they would participate in the program, if California wins a piece of the $4.3 billion competition."

Schools Matter: More Segregated Corporate Charter Schools Approved by MA House


Schools Matter: More Segregated Corporate Charter Schools Approved by MA House:

"The Mayor of Boston was out and about this week using his bully pulpit to urge passage of state legislation intended to remove legal obstacles to the unlimited growth of apartheid corporate charter schools in urban areas of the Commonwealth. Side benefits of the new legislation for the Broad, Gates, and Boston Foundations include the crippling of collective bargaining and tenure for teachers, the limiting of school committee oversight in favor of the CEO model of goverance, and the imposition of teacher evaluation based on test scores. As he walked and talked, Mayor Menino was heard to use the bold corporate reformers' advertising jingle: 'Education is the civil rights issue of this generation.'"

What Race to the Top Tells Us About the Future of the ESEA | NewAmerica.net


What Race to the Top Tells Us About the Future of the ESEA | NewAmerica.net




On Monday Ed Week published an article positing that the priorities outlined in Race to the Top, a $4.35 billion competitive grant program created by the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act, could be a template for the reauthorization of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA). One former Department of Education official interviewed for the story suggested that these priorities - including improving supports for struggling schools, quality and distribution of teachers, state data systems, and standards and assessments – could become compulsory for states receiving ESEA Title I funds, a wide departure from the current requirements for these funds that focus on equitable distribution of funds.

While the Race to the Top priorities closely reflect the Obama administration’s agenda for education, the administration made it clear from the beginning that they wanted an ESEA that was strong on outcomes but not on methods. One of No Child Left Behind’s greatest weaknesses, they believed, was that it was very strict about methods (i.e. testing and teacher qualifications) but weak on outcomes (i.e. standards and assessments).

In other words, 50 states currently measure student achievement based on 50 different sets of academic standards, resulting in vastly different ability levels across the county. A reauthorized ESEA that mandates the types of activities supported by Race to the Top would be considered exceptionally strict on methods in addition to being potentially strong on outcomes.

Fluency at issue as ex-teacher's suit goes to SJC - Lowell Sun Online


Fluency at issue as ex-teacher's suit goes to SJC - Lowell Sun Online:

"BOSTON -- Should a teacher who can't speak fluent English to her students be allowed to stay in the classroom?

The outcome of Phanna Rem Robishaw's case against the Lowell School Department and Lowell School Committee holds statewide ramifications for the state's educational system.

Today, the state Supreme Judicial Court was scheduled to hear arguments from Robishaw, a former Lowell teacher who was fired for failing an English-fluency test, after a lower-court judge upheld the firing, saying the teacher's English proficiency was 'utterly incomprehensible.'

In 2002, Massachusetts' voters passed Question 2, requiring all school superintendents to attest to the English fluency and literacy of their teachers where 'the teacher's fluency is not apparent through classroom observation and assessment or interview assessment.'"

voiceofsandiego.org | News. Investigation. Analysis. Conversation. Intelligence. - Bright and Early: The Education Newsblitz


voiceofsandiego.org | News. Investigation. Analysis. Conversation. Intelligence. - Bright and Early: The Education Newsblitz:



"It's good to be back from vacation. Something just doesn't seem right when I don't start my days combing through educational news. It's what makes your newsblitz:



Vista schools and their teachers union are stalled after three years of bargaining, the Union-Tribune reports. Class sizes in middle and high school and how teachers are transferred are sticking points.
More from Vista: The North County Times writes about the debate over when to transfer students into a brand-new campus, which will be ready in a few months.
I forgot to include this yesterday: OBRag argues that a recent Union-Tribune editorial on the idea of San Diego Unified eliminating the superintendent job got its facts wrong.


New commissioner opens a conversation with R.I.’s best teachers | Education | projo.com | The Providence Journal


New commissioner opens a conversation with R.I.’s best teachers | Education | projo.com | The Providence Journal:

"PROVIDENCE — On a recent visit to North Providence High School, Education Commissioner Deborah A. Gist noticed a lanky student with a scruffy haircut slouched in a chair, looking adrift.

Gist said she made a beeline over to him and asked what he was working on.

“He said he was working on his senior project, and he just lit up,” Gist told a gathering of 35 of the state’s best teachers, principals and superintendents on Wednesday. “He told me he was a drummer and his project was on drums, and he started talking about it … I was totally blown away.”"

Gov. Butch Otter warns cuts are coming to Idaho schools | Local News | Idaho Statesman


Gov. Butch Otter warns cuts are coming to Idaho schools | Local News | Idaho Statesman:

"If Idaho public schools are asked to immediately cut spending this year, several local districts say they have the cash reserve to get through it.

It won't be easy, but superintendents say they prefer using their own surplus accounts to getting an advance on next year's appropriation, which is an idea legislative leaders have suggested and Gov. Butch Otter embraces.

Otter said Thursday that he'll announce more funding cuts for this year in Monday's State of the State address, though he won't say how severe they will be or how much they will affect public education. Next year's budget, he said, will hold the line with this new, pared-back spending plan."

Gibbons' education plan would replace voter-elected board - Friday, Jan. 8, 2010 | 1:50 a.m. - Las Vegas Sun


Gibbons' education plan would replace voter-elected board - Friday, Jan. 8, 2010 | 1:50 a.m. - Las Vegas Sun:

"Gov. Jim Gibbons’ proposed overhaul of public education would include the dismantling of the State Board of Education, a 10-member panel elected by voters.

Gibbons’ proposal would replace the State Board with a five-member advisory panel – three people appointed by the governor, with the Assembly speaker and Senate majority leader each getting one pick.

The governor would also choose the state superintendent of public instruction, who is now appointed by the State Board.

The State Board also sets policy for Nevada's 17 school districts. The board can suspend or revoke teacher licenses and is the conduit for federal education money awarded to Nevada."

Bredesen, teachers union at odds over tenure rules | tennessean.com | The Tennessean

Bredesen, teachers union at odds over tenure rules | tennessean.com | The Tennessean:



"Gov. Phil Bredesen will push ahead with a proposal to tie teacher evaluations to test scores without the full support of the state's biggest teachers union, saying Thursday that he doubted he could reach a compromise on a crucial issue before the start of a special legislative session next week."



Bredesen said he will ask the legislature Monday to appoint an independent committee to come up with a new system for deciding whether teachers are awarded tenure in their fourth year. The new system will be based significantly on student test scores, meaning that teachers' careers could soon hinge on whether their students show improvements on standardized tests.
Bredesen plans to move forward without the endorsement of the Tennessee Education Association. The group, which represents more than 55,000 schoolteachers statewide, says it accepts the notion of using test scores in tenure decisions, but it wants to limit the extent to which they are a factor.
The group also says it wants the committee that will devise the new system to include its members and for the legislation to ensure that its recommendations will not be set aside by the State Board of Education.

City schools contract with PFT nearing deadline | Philadelphia Inquirer | 01/08/2010

City schools contract with PFT nearing deadline | Philadelphia Inquirer | 01/08/2010:


"With a contract deadline next Friday, talks between the Philadelphia School District and its largest union, the 17,000-member Philadelphia Federation of Teachers, are accelerating.
But both sides are also focused on a more immediate date.

By Wednesday, the union and the district must agree to collaborate on sweeping changes for Philadelphia schools to enter the $4.35 billion Race to the Top. The competitive federal program rewards districts that promise to revamp teacher salary structures and evaluations and to turn around failing schools.

The Philadelphia district could be eligible for as much as $8 million. The grant could pay for changes that Superintendent Arlene Ackerman has long insisted on, and that the union has long opposed."

Minority groups want more input on school books | Houston & Texas News | Chron.com - Houston Chronicle

Minority groups want more input on school books | Houston & Texas News | Chron.com - Houston Chronicle:


"AUSTIN — Minority advocacy groups urged their members to attend a State Board of Education public hearing next week to appeal for more Hispanic and African-American historical figures in public school textbooks.

Registration to give public testimony starts today for Wednesday's hearing at the William B. Travis Building, where the Texas Education Agency is located.

The 15-member board planned to take a preliminary vote later in the week before final action in March on new standards for the social studies curriculum, which will influence how history and government books are written for the state's 4.7 million public school children.

Hispanic school children already make up a small majority in early elementary grades, and they will soon will be the majority in the entire public school system."

State teachers union lays out plan to improve education

State teachers union lays out plan to improve education:

"The Pennsylvania State Education Association wants to be leading the conversation about improving education, not reacting.

So it has pulled together what it considers the best proven ways to enhance education in a 169-page report intended to reach political candidates and the general public.

The report, released yesterday, is titled 'The Power of a Great Education: PSEA's 20/20 Vision for the Future -- Strong Schools, Successful Children, Vibrant Communities.' It can be found at www.psea.org/vision.

'The primary purpose is we want to get out there as we're entering the 2010 election cycle and engage politicians and policymakers,' said PSEA President James Testerman."

Chesterfield cuts could force closure of governor's schools | Richmond Times-Dispatch


Chesterfield cuts could force closure of governor's schools | Richmond Times-Dispatch:

"Central Virginia's two full-time governor's schools could face severe changes or even closure if Chesterfield County eliminates its participation in them.

Chesterfield school officials sent a survey to its employees Tuesday asking them to choose ways to cut nearly $40 million from its proposed fiscal 2011 budget.

Among the many options is to stop sending students to Appomattox Regional Governor's School for Arts and Technology in Petersburg and Maggie L. Walker Governor's School for Government and International Studies in Richmond.

In an impact statement accompanying the survey, Chesterfield acknowledges that if it ends its participation at the governor's schools, a $2 million savings, 'this option would likely result in both schools closing.'"

Some capital-area school districts sit out race for federal funds - Sacramento News - Local and Breaking Sacramento News | Sacramento Bee


Some capital-area school districts sit out race for federal funds - Sacramento News - Local and Breaking Sacramento News | Sacramento Bee:

"California politicians scurried for months to pass legislation to ensure state schools have a chance to compete for federal Race to the Top stimulus funds. But many local districts have decided to watch the race from the sidelines.

Roseville City Unified Elementary School District, Camino Union Elementary School District and Sutter Union High School District are just a few that have decided not to apply for a piece of the $4.35 billion funding."

Bill to fix low-performing schools clears panel | courier-journal.com | The Courier-Journal

Bill to fix low-performing schools clears panel | courier-journal.com | The Courier-Journal:


"FRANKFORT, Ky. — The House Education Committee passed a bill Thursday morning that officials hope would better position Kentucky to win federal money to improve the academic performance of public schools"




House Bill 176, sponsored by Rep. Carl Rollins, D-Midway, would allow school districts to close low-performing middle and high schools and restart them under the management of a private or non-profit operator, known as an educational-management organization, or EMO.
“I think (the bill) helps us be a little more competitive in the Race to the Top,” Kentucky Education Commissioner Terry Holliday said after the committee meeting. “It shows we have a real good plan to help turn around low-performing schools.”
The bill passed 24-1, with two members abstaining. Rollins said he hopes the full House could vote on the measure early next week.
Kentucky could receive up to $200 million through President Barack Obama's Race to the Top contest. The competition pits states against each another and awards those who develop plans to improve student achievement.

House bill would give superintendents more authority - The Boston Globe

House bill would give superintendents more authority - The Boston Globe:


"Superintendents would gain broad new powers to make dramatic changes at the state’s worst schools, including the removal of ineffective teachers, under the education bill approved by the House early yesterday."




The bill, which must now be reconciled with a version approved by the Senate late last year, would also give Boston the right to open and control four charter schools without union approval.
Mayor Thomas M. Menino had aggressively sought that concession for months, making phone calls to key House leaders during their marathon session that ended early yesterday morning.
At a press conference outside his City Hall office yesterday morning, Menino said the bill was “made in heaven.’’
“This is a new era for all of us when it comes to public education,’’ Menino said, surrounded by city school leaders and legislators.
Other education leaders were more reserved in their response as they tried to unravel - and, in some cases, just to get a copy of - the flurry of last-minute 

NY1 | 24 Hour Local News | Education | Hundreds Rally To Keep Queens School Open


NY1 | 24 Hour Local News | Education | Hundreds Rally To Keep Queens School Open:

"A spirited rally was held Thursday night outside Jamaica High School in Queens.
More than 500 parents, students, teachers and alumni rallied against plans to replace the school with several small high schools in the same building.

'We're here to tell them that our school is a viable place, and it's a good school, and it's been around for 118 years. It deserves to be around as Jamaica High School for 118 more,' said Jamaica High School teacher James Eterno.

Inside, more than 100 signed up for speaking slots to tell officials why the doors to Jamaica High should stay open.

'We're here tonight to show our support because Jamaica is a great school. We have great academics, great programs,' said Jamaica High School student Rachael Ali. 'What's not to like here? We have a great atmosphere, we have a great, beautiful campus. Why do they want to close our school down?'

The Department of Education cites the high school's 46 percent graduation rate and falling enrollment, but teachers say statistics are improving."

In Pursuit of School Grants, New York Governor Seeks Changes to Law - NYTimes.com


In Pursuit of School Grants, New York Governor Seeks Changes to Law - NYTimes.com:

"Gov. David A. Paterson on Thursday proposed a host of changes in state education law, including eliminating the cap on the number of charter schools, which he said would make the state more likely to receive $700 million in federal grant money.

The governor’s bill would also repeal a 2008 law that banned the use of standardized test scores in tenure decisions, as well as give the state the ability to pay for charter school construction and allow the state to take over low-performing schools."

Lawmaker predicts MTA student fares won't be cut - NYPOST.com


Lawmaker predicts MTA student fares won't be cut - NYPOST.com:

"A lawmaker with oversight of the MTA predicted today that student fares won’t be cut for hundreds of thousands of students – and that the state and city will be footing the bill.

Assemblyman Richard Brodsky said he agrees that the MTA shouldn’t have to fork over any funds to pay for free and reduced-fare student MetroCards – the transit agency used to be the only in the nation to do so.

'We're confident there's going to be a good outcome,' he said after a committee hearing.

Yet Brodsky, Assemblywoman Joan Millman and Assemblyman Kevin Kavanaugh – who also attended the hearing – were three of the legislators to approve Gov. Paterson’s massive cut to student fares last December, prompting the MTA to cancel the program totally."