Latest News and Comment from Education

Saturday, November 3, 2018

Top Posts This Week 11/3/18 #VOTE #VoteTuesday


Top Posts This Week 11/3/18  #VOTE




NPE Action - Political Endorsements - http://npeaction.org/ on @NPEaction


Posts This Week 11/3/18
TODAY

Thurmond vs Tuck and how FAKE Democrats are fooling voters with help from Alt-Right Billionaires | Crazy Normal - the Classroom Exposé

Thurmond vs Tuck and how FAKE Democrats are fooling voters with help from Alt-Right Billionaires | Crazy Normal - the Classroom Exposé Thurmond vs Tuck and how FAKE Democrats are fooling voters with help from Alt-Right Billionaires Politico.com reported on November 1, five days before the 2018 election, “In the race to be California’s top educator, charter schools ally Marshall Tuck registered a


Dr. Rosa Castro Feinberg: How and why to avoid Florida’s flaws | Cloaking Inequity

How and why to avoid Florida’s flaws | Cloaking Inequity HOW AND WHY TO AVOID FLORIDA’S FLAWS It’s not too late to improve state ESSA plans. Approved state ESSA plans can be amended at any time. That’s both good news and bad 
Political Issues In Public Education - A Guide For Beginners | Blue Cereal Education

Political Issues In Public Education - A Guide For Beginners | Blue Cereal Education Political Issues In Public Education - A Guide For Beginners It’s election time again, and – in some places, at least – education-related disputes are once again all over social media and the local news. Given that it’s rare for such a traditional, local issue to break through our current national insanity, some
John Thompson: Insights on the Origins of “A Nation at Risk”: A Conversation with James Harvey and John Merrow | Diane Ravitch's blog

John Thompson: Insights on the Origins of “A Nation at Risk”: A Conversation with James Harvey and John Merrow | Diane Ravitch's blog John Thompson: Insights on the Origins of “A Nation at Risk”: A Conversation with James Harvey and John Merrow John Thompson, retired teacher and historian in Oklahoma, shares his thoughts about the Network for Public Education Conference in Indianapolis. He begins
CURMUDGUCATION: Is School Choice At Odds With Community?

CURMUDGUCATION: Is School Choice At Odds With Community? Is School Choice At Odds With Community? A couple weeks back, Amy Lueck in the Atlantic took a look at how public high schools shaped communities in this country, depicting a relationship between school and community that certainly still looks familiar to those of us who live in ruralish areas where among grown-up adults, "Which high school

YESTERDAY

The World Mourns for Jews After Pittsburgh’s Synagogue Shooting. What About Other Targets of Hate? | gadflyonthewallblog

The World Mourns for Jews After Pittsburgh’s Synagogue Shooting. What About Other Targets of Hate? | gadflyonthewallblog The World Mourns for Jews After Pittsburgh’s Synagogue Shooting. What About Other Targets of Hate? When a white supremacist killed 11 people and wounded 6 others at a Pittsburgh synagogue last weekend, the world took notice. Lights dimmed at the Eiffel Tower and Empire State bu
CURMUDGUCATION: Failing Brown v. Board of Education

CURMUDGUCATION: Failing Brown v. Board of Education Failing Brown v. Board of Education If you're not regularly exposed to the problem, you might think that finding the ways in which non-white non-wealthy students are shortchanged would require deep and nuanced research. As it turns out, finding the ways in which education fails to serve those students requires no more careful research than findi
Values that Express Our Idea of Public Education: The Values that Should Steady Us in this Tumultuous Week | janresseger

Values that Express Our Idea of Public Education: The Values that Should Steady Us in this Tumultuous Week | janresseger Values that Express Our Idea of Public Education: The Values that Should Steady Us in this Tumultuous Week This blog, which usually posts Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, and Friday, will post on neither election day nor the next morning. Look for a new post on Thursday, November
Unanswered Questions in the Race for California State Superintendent of Public Instruction

Unanswered Questions in the Race for California State Superintendent of Public Instruction Unanswered Questions in the Race for California State Superintendent of Public Instruction We are largely unable to accept new offers to complete questionnaires” – Marshall Tuck Campaign The California Charter School Association and their allies have provided Marshall Tuck with enough cash to flood the airw

NOV 01

ACLU of Northern California Executive Director to EdVoice: Stop Misleading Voters | ACLU of Northern CA

ACLU of Northern California Executive Director to EdVoice: Stop Misleading Voters | ACLU of Northern CA ACLU of Northern California Executive Director to EdVoice: Stop Misleading Voters ACLU of California Statement on Misleading Campaign Ad . @edvoice Your mailer uses the ACLU's name in a manner that misleads voters. You are not a fly by night organization, and with your decision, you have damage
The Education Wave That Began In West Virginia May Change Politics For The Nation

The Education Wave That Began In West Virginia May Change Politics For The Nation The Education Wave That Began In West Virginia May Change Politics For The Nation Whether Democrats take back the House in the midterm elections may come down to races like the one in West Virginia’s third Congressional District. “Richard Ojeda has taken a district that Trump won by almost 50 points … and turned int
What Should We Really Learn From New Orleans After the Storm? A Q&A With NEPC Fellow Bruce Baker | National Education Policy Center

What Should We Really Learn From New Orleans After the Storm? A Q&A With NEPC Fellow Bruce Baker | National Education Policy Center What Should We Really Learn From New Orleans After the Storm? A Q&A With NEPC Fellow Bruce Baker Learn More: NEPC Resources on Charter Schools NEPC Fellow Bruce Baker discusses his critique of a recent policy brief that attributed positive outcomes to market-based re
Lawsuit Accuses Betsy DeVos And Her Deputies Of Being Motivated By Sexism | HuffPost

Lawsuit Accuses Betsy DeVos And Her Deputies Of Being Motivated By Sexism | HuffPost Lawsuit Accuses Betsy DeVos And Her Deputies Of Being Motivated By Sexism The lawsuit says that the education secretary’s decision to scrap Obama-era rules governing sexual assault on campus was based on bias and stereotypes. A new filing in a lawsuit against the Trump administration accuses Secretary of Educatio
What’s Wrong with America’s Schools? David Berliner Blames America’s Failure to Eradicate Child Poverty | janresseger

What’s Wrong with America’s Schools? David Berliner Blames America’s Failure to Eradicate Child Poverty | janresseger What’s Wrong with America’s Schools? David Berliner Blames America’s Failure to Eradicate Child Poverty Despite lots of evidence about why we shouldn’t use test scores as a measure of school quality, for nearly twenty years, government programs like No Child Left Behind and Race t

OCT 31

Confronting Inequity and Structural Racism by Building Community Schools | Schott Foundation for Public Education

Confronting Inequity and Structural Racism by Building Community Schools | Schott Foundation for Public Education Confronting Inequity and Structural Racism by Building Community Schools The last few decades of disinvestment and privatization have devastated public schools across the country, especially those in poor and distressed neighborhoods and communities of color. But we shouldn’t simply t
How Teachers Might Save Arizona Schools from the Kochs | OurFuture.org by People's Action

How Teachers Might Save Arizona Schools from the Kochs | OurFuture.org by People's Action How Teachers Might Save Arizona Schools from the Kochs “A change in education is Arizona’s No. 1 issue,” Garcia said in a televised debate . “It is my strength, it is Ducey’s weakness, and it’s going to be the difference.” (Photo: Victoria Pickering /flickr/cc) The moment Beth Lewis realized the powerful pol
We Discover Outstanding Candidates That Support Our Public Schools - NPE Action Endorsements - NPE Action

Endorsements - NPE Action We Discover Outstanding Candidates That Support Our Public Schools - NPE Action Endorsements - NPE Action NPE Action Endorsements NPE Action Endorsements When we discover outstanding candidates that support our issues, and it is a race that we are able to support, we endorse. Candidates must complete a questionnaire and have the support of our supporters in the area. We
CURMUDGUCATION: Jobs' XQ Institute Plugs Competency Based Education

CURMUDGUCATION: Jobs' XQ Institute Plugs Competency Based Education Jobs' XQ Institute Plugs Competency Based Education Laurene Powell Jobs is one of the major players in the reformster world. Steve Jobs's widow is the fourth richest woman in the world , and she has been a player in the world of education venture philanthropy for a while, logging time with NewSchools Venture Fund (We raise contri
Kids’ apps are filled with manipulative ads, according to a new study - Vox

Kids’ apps are filled with manipulative ads, according to a new study - Vox Apps for preschoolers are flooded with manipulative ads, according to a new study New research looks at how gaming apps ads are pushing very young children to spend money. In the children’s gaming app Doctor Kids , a popular purchase in the Google and Amazon app stores, kids get to play doctor in a children’s hospital. Th
Teachers Are Testing Us: In State Elections, Will We Reject the Anti-Tax, Pro-Privatization Orthodoxy of the Far Right? | janresseger

Teachers Are Testing Us: In State Elections, Will We Reject the Anti-Tax, Pro-Privatization Orthodoxy of the Far Right? | janresseger Teachers Are Testing Us: In State Elections, Will We Reject the Anti-Tax, Pro-Privatization Orthodoxy of the Far Right? In an extraordinary photo essay, USA Today profiled a day 
Chicago Teachers Union educators at Acero/UNO vote overwhelmingly to strike. – Fred Klonsky

Chicago Teachers Union educators at Acero/UNO vote overwhelmingly to strike. – Fred Klonsky Chicago Teachers Union educators at Acero/UNO vote overwhelmingly to strike. CHICAGO, Oct. 30, 2018 —Chicago Teachers Union educators at Acero/UNO charter schools voted overwhelmingly today to strike. 96% of Acero CTU members turned out to vote, and of those voting, 98% voted to strike. Of the CTU’s 536 me
Halloween and The Value of Make-Believe to Reading and Emotional Development

Halloween and The Value of Make-Believe to Reading and Emotional Development Halloween and The Value of Make-Believe to Reading and Emotional Development It is not mere childish escapism. There is a political aspect to it – we won’t try to change this world unless we are able to imagine another reality. One could say all change starts with fantasy. ~Cornelia Funke, German author of children’s fic

OCT 30

Education philanthropy: why the billions spent aren’t working - Vox

Education philanthropy: why the billions spent aren’t working - Vox Billionaires are spending their fortunes reshaping America’s schools. It isn’t working. Here’s the problem with education philanthropy. Philanthropists need to take a step back from the American education system before it ruins them, they ruin it, or both. Major philanthropies like the Gates , Walton Family , and Broad Foundation
How America Is Breaking Public Education

How America Is Breaking Public Education How America Is Breaking Public Education The ultimate dream of public education is incredibly simple. Students, ideally, would go to a classroom, receive top-notch instruction from a passionate, well-informed teacher, would work hard in their class, and would come away with a new set of skills, talents, interests, and capabilities. Over the past few decade
Young voters will determine the outcome of the 2018 midterms

Young voters will determine the outcome of the 2018 midterms Youth will determine the outcome of the 2018 midterms That’s why Republicans are trying to stop them The stakes are high in the upcoming midterm elections, but few races have commanded as much national attention as the one for Texas senator between Republican incumbent Ted Cruz and Democratic U.S. Rep. Beto O’Rourke of El Paso. O’Rourke
No School Is “Doomed.” Continuous Improvement, Not School Closure, Must Be the Goal | janresseger

No School Is “Doomed.” Continuous Improvement, Not School Closure, Must Be the Goal | janresseger No School Is “Doomed.” Continuous Improvement, Not School Closure, Must Be the Goal I have read Eliza Shapiro’s reporting in POLITICO for years and I respect her as a reporter, but her story in Friday’s NY Times baffles me: New York Knew Some Schools In Its $773 Million Plan Were Doomed, They Kept Ch

OCT 29

NPE Indianapolis: “We Are Winning!” | tultican

NPE Indianapolis: “We Are Winning!” | tultican NPE Indianapolis: “We Are Winning!” Diane Ravitch opened the fifth Network for Public Education (NPE) conference stating, “We are the resistance and we are winning!” She noted that “reformers” were envious of our domination of social media. When they hired mercenaries to staff their own multimillion dollar web-publications to counter us; they failed.
Zombie Ideas Are Killing Public Education - The Crucial Voice of the PeopleThe Crucial Voice of the People

Zombie Ideas Are Killing Public Education - The Crucial Voice of the PeopleThe Crucial Voice of the People Zombie Ideas Are Killing Public Education “Zombie ideas … are policy ideas that keep being killed by evidence, but nonetheless shamble relentlessly forward, essentially because they suit a political agenda.” Paul Krugman Zombie Ideas!?! Exactly! Policymakers have been using zombie ideas to d
Submission: Marshall Tuck’s track record proves him unfit as state superintendent candidate | Daily Bruin

Submission: Marshall Tuck’s track record proves him unfit as state superintendent candidate | Daily Bruin Submission: Marshall Tuck’s track record proves him unfit as state superintendent candidate ROBERT D. SKEELS Business banker Marshall Tuck is running for California superintendent of public instruction again. He’s backed by ideologically charged billionaires – several of whom supported reacti
Public school fees go largely unchecked in Louisiana, prompting reform proposals | Education | theadvocate.com

Public school fees go largely unchecked in Louisiana, prompting reform proposals | Education | theadvocate.com Public school fees go largely unchecked in Louisiana, prompting reform proposals Ursula Clark-Holmes, who has three children attending public schools in Baton Rouge, is beset by so many student fees that she even offered to offset the charges by volunteering at the schools. "I can't affo
Seattle Schools Community Forum: Washington State Charter School Law Upheld

Seattle Schools Community Forum: Washington State Charter School Law Upheld Washington State Charter School Law Upheld On October 26, 2018, in a split decision, the Washington State Supreme Court ruled that the charter school law created by the Legislature, after a voter initiative was thrown out in 2012, is valid under our state's constitution. Here's the ruling . As someone who has never suppor
Betsy DeVos’ Family Gives $2 Million to Far-Right Candidates | Diane Ravitch's blog

Betsy DeVos’ Family Gives $2 Million to Far-Right Candidates | Diane Ravitch's blog Betsy DeVos’ Family Gives $2 Million to Far-Right Candidates During her confirmation hearings, Betsy DeVos pledged not to make political contributions while she was Secretary of Education. But, knowing her penchant for parsing words, we may now assume that she was not covering the political donations of her family
Six Reasons Not To Get Excited About The New SAT Scores

Six Reasons Not To Get Excited About The New SAT Scores Six Reasons Not To Get Excited About The New SAT Scores Today's big-- well, not big. Medium-sized, maybe--news comes from the College Board, which announced that both participation and scores are up, as well as the percentage of college-ready students . Here's why you can comfortably not care. It's 8 Points The average score "jumped" from 10
Choosing Democracy: Teachers Respond to Hate

Choosing Democracy: Teachers Respond to Hate Teachers Respond to Hate As I stood at a vigil at Temple Emanuel in New York City today to honor the Tree of Life synagogue victims, I couldn’t stop thinking about how hate has become a fact of life in our country. Hateful rhetoric and words of incitement have fueled heinous acts of violence across our nation over the past week: pipe bombs mailed to el
Research evidence on bullying prevention at odds with what schools are doing - The Hechinger Report

Research evidence on bullying prevention at odds with what schools are doing - The Hechinger Report Research evidence on bullying prevention at odds with what schools are doing Punishing the bullies doesn't really help, researchers say. But what does work? I n September 2018, I wrote about the so-called “Trump effect” on bullying in schools, citing a study that found higher bullying rates in GOP

OCT 28

CURMUDGUCATION: ICYMI: Scary Time of Year Edition (10/28)

CURMUDGUCATION: ICYMI: Scary Time of Year Edition (10/28) ICYMI: Scary Time of Year Edition (10/28) Just a few things to catch up on. Remember, sharing is caring. Documenting Maine's Failure To Implement Proficiency Based Education Maine tried to turn the whole state into proof of concept for PBL/CBE. Things didn't work out. Here are some of the details. Maine Went All in on Proficiency Based Lea
Dahlia Lithwick: Who Is Responsible for the Epidemic of Hate Crimes? | Diane Ravitch's blog

Dahlia Lithwick: Who Is Responsible for the Epidemic of Hate Crimes? | Diane Ravitch's blog Dahlia Lithwick: Who Is Responsible for the Epidemic of Hate Crimes? Dahlia Lithwick writes in Slate about where the responsibility lies for the horrendous hate crimes of the past week. We have been told over and over that we are not to take this President literally, or seriously, or jokingly, or truthfull
The names. – Fred Klonsky

The names. – Fred Klonsky Pittsburgh Synagogue Shooting Victims Identified Fundraiser by Shay Khatiri : Tree of Life Shooting’s Victims - https://www.gofundme.com/tree-of-life-synagogue-shooting on @gofundme The names. – Fred Klonsky
Despite US Fixation on Testing, ACT Results Slip; ACT Board Doing Just Fine | deutsch29

Despite US Fixation on Testing, ACT Results Slip; ACT Board Doing Just Fine | deutsch29 Despite US Fixation on Testing, ACT Results Slip; ACT Board Doing Just Fine On October 17, 2018, ACT released a report, “Condition of College and Career Readiness 2018.” Beginning with the passage of No Child Left Behind (NCLB) in January 2002, standardized testing has increasingly been the central focus of pu

OCT 27

The Pittsburgh Community is Stronger Than the Synagogue Shooter’s Hate | gadflyonthewallblog

The Pittsburgh Community is Stronger Than the Synagogue Shooter’s Hate | gadflyonthewallblog The Pittsburgh Community is Stronger Than the Synagogue Shooter’s Hate There’s a popular yard sign in the Squirrel Hill neighborhood of Pittsburgh. In bands of green and blue and yellow, it projects the same message in Spanish, English and Arabic: “No matter where you are from, we’re glad you’re our neigh
CURMUDGUCATION: A Teacher's Opinion and the Classroom Door

CURMUDGUCATION: A Teacher's Opinion and the Classroom Door A Teacher's Opinion and the Classroom Door Twice this week the issue of teachers and their opinions cropped up, first in David Berliner's thoughtful piece at The Answer Sheet and again in Robert Pondiscio's reaction to a math teacher's tweet about the Kavanaugh hearings. Berliner was not wrong in answering student questions about how he w
NYC Public School Parents: A growing class divide in education: small class size vs. computerized learning; how Silicon valley is very aware that the ed tech they're foisting on our schools is dangerous to kids

NYC Public School Parents: A growing class divide in education: small class size vs. computerized learning; how Silicon valley is very aware that the ed tech they're foisting on our schools is dangerous to kids A growing class divide in education: small class size vs. computerized learning Three articles in today’s NY Times well worth reading, with some excerpts below, explore the growing class d
Sacramento Unified School District Budget Update - The Result of 20 Years of Corporate Education Reform - Please Vote for People Who Really Support Public Schools

Budget Update Sacramento Unified School District Budget Update The Result of 20 Years of Corporate Education Reform Please Vote for People Who Really Support Public Schools Dear Community Member, Last night our Board of Education voted to continue working with our local Sacramento County Superintendent, fiscal advisor and labor partners to address the district’s budget deficit. Voting to continue


Top Posts This Week 10/27/18 #VOTE

Top Posts This Week 10/27/18 #VOTE This Week In Trump's 'Alternative Facts' : NPR Tuck’s Ethnocentrism Contradicts Californian Values - LA Progressive Top Posts This Week 10/20/18 #NPE18INDY Anna Molander for School Board DeVos 




Dr. Rosa Castro Feinberg: How and why to avoid Florida’s flaws | Cloaking Inequity

How and why to avoid Florida’s flaws | Cloaking Inequity

HOW AND WHY TO AVOID FLORIDA’S FLAWS

It’s not too late to improve state ESSA plans. Approved state ESSA plans can be amended at any time. That’s both good news and bad news.
I fear the premature approval by the U.S. Department of Education (USED) of Florida’s plan to implement the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) could have a negative impact on plans from other states whose policy makers may be aware of and seek the same dispensations accorded Florida. The good news is candidates for state office are on the campaign trail in 46 states, listening to voters. Education stakeholders can forestall backsliding and pave the way for improvements by making public their support for, or their disappointment with, their state ESSA plan.
My fundamental objection to Florida’s ESSA plan is that its failure to comply with the letter of the law, respect its civil rights legacy, and honor its goals can harm children. Two examples from Florida’s plan illustrate the problem and suggest its causes.
No effort to provide native language assessments
Using the Official English amendment to the state constitution as a shield, Florida has made no effort at all to comply with this requirement.
However, the amendment never mentions education and includes no prohibitions. While the state indicates “government services in languages other than English ” are ruled out, the truth is a multiplicity of such services are provided or required by the Florida Department of Education (FLDOE) and described on its web site.
Why would the FLDOE advance an argument so lacking in credibility? Why squander the opportunity for federal funding to get an accurate and valid measure of the content knowledge of 10% of the state’s students? Why would the FDOE abdicate its leadership role in cultivating the treasures multicultural, international, and emerging bilingual students bring to the state?
In 1988, 84% of Florida voters supported the Official English amendment. Language is still a hot button issue. In September, Florida newspapers published two articles on language issues. Readers on both sides of the language divide had reasons to take offense and noted their reactions (and in several instances, their anti-immigrant animus) in the comments sections of the articles.
One out of every four Florida residents is Hispanic, including over a million Puerto Ricans who moved to Florida by Continue reading: How and why to avoid Florida’s flaws | Cloaking Inequity


Thurmond vs Tuck and how FAKE Democrats are fooling voters with help from Alt-Right Billionaires | Crazy Normal - the Classroom Exposé

Thurmond vs Tuck and how FAKE Democrats are fooling voters with help from Alt-Right Billionaires | Crazy Normal - the Classroom Exposé

Thurmond vs Tuck and how FAKE Democrats are fooling voters with help from Alt-Right Billionaires



Politico.com reported on November 1, five days before the 2018 election, “In the race to be California’s top educator, charter schools ally Marshall Tuck registered a substantial 12-point lead (48 percent to 36 percent) over state Assemblyman Tony Thurmond, as Tuck takes his second shot at the position. …
“The state superintendent race has attracted the most outside spending of any statewide contest, some $35 million: Teachers unions have showed up big for Thurmond, while rival EdVoice — whose campaign warchest is stocked by a small cast of individuals that includes Bill Bloomfield, Arthur Rock, Eli Broad, Richard Riordan and Jim Walton — have poured it on for Tuck. Both sides are saturating the airwaves; illustrating the stakes, the California Democratic Party just launched a $2.3 million ad blitz for Thurmond, and Sen. Kamala Harris appeared in a new pro-Thurmond.”
If that isn’t enough to point out the FAKE Democrat, maybe this will. At the State Democratic Convention, who did the Democrats in the audience boo off the stage? The Washington Post answered that question: “Both men are registered Democrats, but Tuck has the support of many Republicans. With the state Democratic Party supporting Thurmond, Tuck was booed off the stage at the California Democratic Party convention earlier this year.”



When was the last time a Democratic candidate was support by Republicans?

Back in 2015, the Alt-Right, Bill Bloomfield, Arthur Rock, Eli Broad, Richard Riordan and Jim Walton, et all. Poured it on for another fake Democrat by the name of Steve Glazer, and The Mercury News asked, “Will the ‘real Democrat’ please stand up?”
“They support Democratic touchstone issues such as environmentalism, gun control, gay marriage and abortion rights. But they’re often seen as party pariahs for espousing ideas like rolling back public workers’ pensions, Continue reading: Thurmond vs Tuck and how FAKE Democrats are fooling voters with help from Alt-Right Billionaires | Crazy Normal - the Classroom Exposé


Political Issues In Public Education - A Guide For Beginners | Blue Cereal Education

Political Issues In Public Education - A Guide For Beginners | Blue Cereal Education

Political Issues In Public Education - A Guide For Beginners

It’s election time again, and – in some places, at least – education-related disputes are once again all over social media and the local news. Given that it’s rare for such a traditional, local issue to break through our current national insanity, some of you might be wondering just what it is all these teachers keep whining about and why no one can presumably fix what seem to be pretty basic concerns.
None of these are intended as comprehensive or especially detailed, nor will they apply in every local variation of every argument. My hope, however, is that you’ll find them useful as a starting place for further research if you discover you care about those specifics, or as enough information to decipher those who ARE worked up and insist on talking about this stuff over and over and over and over…
Why are so many teachers opposed to testing? What’s wrong with accountability?
It can sometimes be difficult to narrow down exactly what it is states and taxpayers want public education to accomplish (not to mention the things we intrinsically value as educators). Prepare children for college, prepare them for the workforce, prepare them to be happy, personally fulfilled adults, teach them to be useful citizens of a voting republic, teach them character and personal responsibility, teach them to read, to think, to care, to problem-solve, to adapt, and give them grit, hope, respect for authority, and a deep personal sense of security and meaning in a fallen world.
Oh, and algebra – they need to know algebra.
Of these (and there are often more, depending on who’s in the state legislature that Continue reading: Political Issues In Public Education - A Guide For Beginners | Blue Cereal Education

John Thompson: Insights on the Origins of “A Nation at Risk”: A Conversation with James Harvey and John Merrow | Diane Ravitch's blog

John Thompson: Insights on the Origins of “A Nation at Risk”: A Conversation with James Harvey and John Merrow | Diane Ravitch's blog

John Thompson: Insights on the Origins of “A Nation at Risk”: A Conversation with James Harvey and John Merrow



John Thompson, retired teacher and historian in Oklahoma, shares his thoughts about the Network for Public Education Conference in Indianapolis. He begins by trying to wrap his brain around my provocative claim that “We are winning.” After I received his post, I explained to him that everything the Reformers have tried has failed. Every promise they have made has been broken. They have run American education for a decade or a generation, depending on when you start counting, and they have nothing to show for it. I contend there is no “reform movement.” There is instead a significant number of incredibly rich men and women playing with the lives of others. The Billionaire Boys Club, plus Alice Walton, Laurene Powell Jobs, and a few other women. This is no social movement. A genuine movement has grassroots. The Reformers have none; they have only paid staff. If the money dried up, the “reform movement” would disappear. It has no troops. None. Genuine movements are built by dedicated, passionate volunteers. That’s what we have.
Thompson writes:


The Network for Public Education’s fifth annual conference was awesome. It will take me awhile to wrestle with the information about the “David versus Goliath” battle which is leading to the defeat of corporate school reform. But I will start by thinking through the lessons learned from retired PBS education reporter John Merrow and Jim Harvey, who was a senior staff member of the National Commission on Excellence in Education and the principle author of “A Nation at Risk.” Harvey is now executive director of the National Superintendents Roundtable.
Merrow explained that charters are producing “a scandal a day.” Using the type of turn of a phrase for which he is well known, Merrow said that charters have had “too much attention but not enough scrutiny.” He says that some mom and pop charters are excellent, but online charters should be outlawed. Then he punched holes in the charter-advocates’ claim that rigorous accountability systems could minimize the downsides of charters.
Merrow says that one reason why it isn’t really possible to scrutinize the costs of charters is that there is no longer a real difference between for-profit and nonprofit charters. Choice has created a system of “buyer beware.”


Harvey added that journalists have been accused of cherry-picking charter scandal reports but “there are so many cherries.” Then he Continue reading: John Thompson: Insights on the Origins of “A Nation at Risk”: A Conversation with James Harvey and John Merrow | Diane Ravitch's blog



CURMUDGUCATION: Is School Choice At Odds With Community?

CURMUDGUCATION: Is School Choice At Odds With Community?

Is School Choice At Odds With Community?

A couple weeks back, Amy Lueck in the Atlantic took a look at how public high schools shaped communities in this country, depicting a relationship between school and community that certainly still looks familiar to those of us who live in ruralish areas where among grown-up adults, "Which high school did you go to" is still a legitimate conversational item and nothing much happens on autumnal Friday nights because football.

Lueck also took a moment to suggest that school choice is a threat to the sense of community that US high schools have fostered for a century or so. As you might expect, some reform types took exception.

Drawing the reformster rebuttal short straw at Fordham Institute was Brandon Wright, who took to the Fordham blog to say, "Oh, pshaw!" I can't say that I found it very convincing.

But she’s wrong in believing that working to give children and parents more options “reflects a distrust of education as a communal goal, not just an individual one.” Lueck erred in accusing school choice of “dismantling” this model. Proponents are not “leaving the public high school for greener pastures,” and the realization of our goals would not be an “abandonment of the American high school” or “the democratic project of the ‘common school’ that helped shape the American city.”




None of these points are his best choice for arguments. I don't know that choice reflects a distrust of community goals versus individual ones, but it certainly values individual choices over community goals. "Why should I sacrifice my child to your public school?" is a common refrain among reform parents. I don't even think it's a terribly unreasonable one, though it is more compelling from something other than white parents using choice as a means of escaping Those People's Children. But choice is, of course, all about making the best choice for your own child, community be damned. That doesn't make you evil, but it does represent a shift in the relationship with the community school.




And proponents are, of course, leaving for greener pastures. That's exactly the whole point of years Continue reading: 
CURMUDGUCATION: Is School Choice At Odds With Community?


Friday, November 2, 2018

The World Mourns for Jews After Pittsburgh’s Synagogue Shooting. What About Other Targets of Hate? | gadflyonthewallblog

The World Mourns for Jews After Pittsburgh’s Synagogue Shooting. What About Other Targets of Hate? | gadflyonthewallblog

The World Mourns for Jews After Pittsburgh’s Synagogue Shooting. What About Other Targets of Hate?


When a white supremacist killed 11 people and wounded 6 others at a Pittsburgh synagogue last weekend, the world took notice.
Candlelight vigils were held nationwide – including in Boston, Houston, Washington D.C., Philadelphia, New Orleans, Atlanta, Chicago, New York City and Los Angeles.
host of international leaders from the Pope to Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau to German Chancellor Angela Merkel expressed outrage, sadness and solidarity.
I’ll admit that as a native Pittsburgher and person of Jewish descent, it touched me deeply.
For a moment, it seemed like the whole world had stopped spinning and from every corner of the globe people were with us in our tragedy.
But at the same time, it was troubling.
Chin110118RallyAgainstAntisemitismMet5


CURMUDGUCATION: Failing Brown v. Board of Education

CURMUDGUCATION: Failing Brown v. Board of Education

Failing Brown v. Board of Education


If you're not regularly exposed to the problem, you might think that finding the ways in which non-white non-wealthy students are shortchanged would require deep and nuanced research. As it turns out, finding the ways in which education fails to serve those students requires no more careful research than finding the nose on the front of your face.

The Journey For Justice Alliance is based in Chicago, but it's an alliance of grassroots community, youth, and parent-led organizations in 24 cities across the country. They are working and organizing for community-driven alternatives to the privatization of and dismantling of public school systems. They're the folks behind the #WeChoose movement  (as in "we choose education equity, not the illusion of school choice." Look at their member groups and you'll find honest-to-goodness community grass roots organizations, not just one more astroturf group funded by Gates, Walton, et al. Their director, Jitu Brown, is one of the most powerful speakers for education and equity it has ever been my pleasure to hear.




Last spring they issued a report-- "Failing Brown v. Board"-- that looks at the gap between the schools that serve primarily wealthy white families and those that serve non-wealthy families of color. Their findings are not encouraging.

The fact is, public schools in Black and Latino communities are not “failing.” They have been failed. More accurately, these schools have been sabotaged for years by policy-makers who fail to fully fund them, by ideologues who choose to experiment with them, by “entrepreneurs” who choose to extract public taxpayer dollars from education systems for their own pockets. 

The report also rejects the notion that money doesn't matter, or that somehow the children and their families are responsible. And they know what successful, fully-resourced schools look like

They offer a culturally relevant, engaging and challenging curriculum, smaller class sizes, more experienced teachers, wrap-around emotional and academic supports, a student-centered school climate and meaningful parent and community engagement. These are the hallmarks of what Journey for Justice calls sustainable community schools. 

J4J performed a fairly simple piece of research-- looking at course offerings in various schools Continue reading: 
CURMUDGUCATION: Failing Brown v. Board of Education




Values that Express Our Idea of Public Education: The Values that Should Steady Us in this Tumultuous Week | janresseger

Values that Express Our Idea of Public Education: The Values that Should Steady Us in this Tumultuous Week | janresseger

Values that Express Our Idea of Public Education: The Values that Should Steady Us in this Tumultuous Week



This blog, which usually posts Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, and Friday, will post on neither election day nor the next morning. Look for a new post on Thursday, November 8.
We have been surrounded by hate crimes this week—in Kentucky and in Pittsburgh and in the bombs mailed to politicians and George Soros. And we are being barraged in the media by the story of migrants coming north to find sanctuary from violence—desperate people who will now be met by thousands of soldiers sent to the border to protect us from these “outsiders.” By contrast, over the centuries, a consensus has continued to grow about our public schools’ inclusive mission—to serve all children in settings that are physically and emotionally safe.
As a foil for what we are watching, hearing and reading in the press, here are some simple principles from experts who have considered the purpose of public education. These statements describe values which I believe most Americans continue to expect our public schools to model.
As you prepare to vote next Tuesday I hope you will steady yourself by reflecting on some of the values the writers quoted here describe.
On the Purpose of Public Education
From Benjamin Barber in An Aristocracy of Everyone: “This book admits no dichotomy between democracy and excellence, for the true democratic premise encompasses excellence: the acquired virtues and skills necessary to living freely, living democratically, and living well.  It assumes that every human being, given half a chance, is capable of the self-government that is his or her natural right, and thus capable of acquiring the judgment, foresight, and knowledge that self-government demands. Not everyone can master string physics or string quartets, but everyone can master the conduct of his or her own life. Everyone can become a free and self-governing adult… Education need not begin with equally adept students, because education is itself the equalizer. Equality is achieved not by handicapping the swiftest, but by assuring the less advantaged a comparable opportunity.  ‘Comparable’ here does not mean identical… Schooling is what allows math washouts to appreciate the contributions of math whizzes—and may one day help persuade them to allocate tax revenues for basic scientific research… The fundamental assumption of democratic life is not that we are all automatically capable of living both freely and responsibly, but that we are all potentially susceptible to education for freedom and responsibility. Democracy is less the enabler of education than education is the enabler of democracy.” (pp. 13-14)
From Mike Rose in Lives on the Boundary: “The economic motive has always been a significant factor in the spread of mass education in the United States, and as someone from Continue reading: Values that Express Our Idea of Public Education: The Values that Should Steady Us in this Tumultuous Week | janresseger



Unanswered Questions in the Race for California State Superintendent of Public Instruction

Unanswered Questions in the Race for California State Superintendent of Public Instruction

Unanswered Questions in the Race for California State Superintendent of Public Instruction


We are largely unable to accept new offers to complete questionnaires”
– Marshall Tuck Campaign
The California Charter School Association and their allies have provided Marshall Tuck with enough cash to flood the airwaves with misleading ads, but with less than a week to go before the election, a whopping 16% of the electorate are still undecided or will not vote on the question of who will become the next California State Superintendent of Public Instruction. This should not be unexpected in a race where the goal has been to obscure the facts in favor of creating fear. It is a favorite tactic of the charter school industry.

Part of Tuck’s strategy is to only appear in controlled environments where he will not have to reveal too much about his history, his supporters or the strategy to privatize our public school system. When asked questions directly, he simply refuses to answer them. He claims to be a progressive Democrat but is receiving the majority of this support from Republicans and appears on slate mailings alongside Gubernatorial candidate John Cox. When the progressive organization, Northridge Indivisible, sent him an endorsement questionnaire in September, his campaign replied that they were “largely unable to accept new offers to complete questionnaires.” His opponent, Tony Thurmond did respond and received the endorsement.
Tuck worships at the Betsy DeVos altar of imagined school-choice, even if it results in a system of separate and unequal education. Given that he wants us to believe that Continue reading: Unanswered Questions in the Race for California State Superintendent of Public Instruction
Image result for Unanswered Questions in the Race for California State Superintendent of Public Instruction