
Saturday, July 15, 2017
CURMUDGUCATION: Why Is Kiddie PISA a Thing
CURMUDGUCATION: Why Is Kiddie PISA a Thing:
Why Is Kiddie PISA a Thing

Every so often the OECD throws a big fat standardized test (the PISA) at fifteen-year-olds from a bunch of nations that have different cultures and speak different languages and then use the results to stack rank those nations, leading to a paroxysm of pearl clutching and teeth gnashing over the results. And it's always good for some trauma because as long as the test has existed, the United States has ranked, to be generous, in the mediocre middle.
What could possibly make the whole PISA business even better?
How about giving a computer-based PISA to five year olds!
Over in the UK they're about to attempt a 300-student pilot of this extraordinarily hare-brained idea. And the US is supposedly also in on this, though Germany, Sweden, Denmark and Belgium (among others) have said they will not be participating. Other reports are that the OECD is looking for three to six countries to play along.
The pilot will involve around 300 children, and uses games and stories on tablet computers to map pupils’ early capabilities – which will then be linked to educational performance at 15 through the international PISA tests given to teenagers across the globe every four years.
Is there some good reason to do this? Officials have tried to make a case for it.
Researchers say the study will give countries an in-depth insight into children’s learning at a critical age enabling them to share best practice.
The Early Learning and Child Well-being Study will be run on 3,000 students internationally in CURMUDGUCATION: Why Is Kiddie PISA a Thing:
Why Is Kiddie PISA a Thing
Every so often the OECD throws a big fat standardized test (the PISA) at fifteen-year-olds from a bunch of nations that have different cultures and speak different languages and then use the results to stack rank those nations, leading to a paroxysm of pearl clutching and teeth gnashing over the results. And it's always good for some trauma because as long as the test has existed, the United States has ranked, to be generous, in the mediocre middle.
What could possibly make the whole PISA business even better?
How about giving a computer-based PISA to five year olds!
![]() |
| That'll be quite enough of that, you little slacker. |
Over in the UK they're about to attempt a 300-student pilot of this extraordinarily hare-brained idea. And the US is supposedly also in on this, though Germany, Sweden, Denmark and Belgium (among others) have said they will not be participating. Other reports are that the OECD is looking for three to six countries to play along.
The pilot will involve around 300 children, and uses games and stories on tablet computers to map pupils’ early capabilities – which will then be linked to educational performance at 15 through the international PISA tests given to teenagers across the globe every four years.
Is there some good reason to do this? Officials have tried to make a case for it.
Researchers say the study will give countries an in-depth insight into children’s learning at a critical age enabling them to share best practice.
The Early Learning and Child Well-being Study will be run on 3,000 students internationally in CURMUDGUCATION: Why Is Kiddie PISA a Thing:
Trump wants to spend millions more on school vouchers. But what’s happened to the millions already spent? - The Washington Post
Trump wants to spend millions more on school vouchers. But what’s happened to the millions already spent? - The Washington Post:
Trump wants to spend millions more on school vouchers. But what’s happened to the millions already spent?
Trump wants to spend millions more on school vouchers. But what’s happened to the millions already spent?
Congress dedicates $15 million a year to a program that helps low-income D.C. students pay tuition at private schools, but it’s impossible for taxpayers to find out where their money goes: The administrator of the D.C. voucher program refuses to say how many students attend each school or how many public dollars they receive.
It’s also not clear how students are performing in each school. When Congress created the program in 2004, it did not require individual private schools to disclose anything about student performance. And private schools can continue receiving voucher dollars no matter how poorly their students fare.
President Trump has said the D.C. voucher program is “what winning for young children and kids from all over the country looks like,” and he has freed up millions of dollars in federal funds to expand it, allowing nearly triple the number of students to participate by next school year.
He and Education Secretary Betsy DeVos have also pledged to expand private-school choice programs across the country, many of which now make it difficult to track how tax dollars are Trump wants to spend millions more on school vouchers. But what’s happened to the millions already spent? - The Washington Post:
Seattle Schools Community Forum: Conversation on HCC, Part Two
Seattle Schools Community Forum: Conversation on HCC, Part Two:
Conversation on HCC, Part Two
For this part of the discussion, I want to reiterate a few things I said in Part One.
There are some parents don't believe that there could be that many children who are highly capable. To that I can only say that the feds, the state and the district all believe it is true and have allocated resources and services to that end. I note that the new McCleary budget includes extra dollars for programs like Sped, ELL and yes, highly capable.
There are some parents believe it's all based on a single test score in order to get into the program. That is not true and you can examine the application process and how the district's own committee decides on admission.
There are some teachers/administrators don't like HCC because some of their best learners leave the school after they are admitted into the program. One reason could be the loss of test scores. Another reason is the loss of students who help teachers drive the classroom by being generally engaged.
I can understand their unhappiness but it is not the right of a teacher or principal to decide what program parents want their children to be in for the best academic outcomes.
If your belief system on highly capable students falls into either of those two groups, you probably won't be interested in what follows.
This discussion is about changes to make the Highly Capable Cohort program more equitable and stronger. In Part Three, we can discuss the other two parts of Advanced Learning, Spectrum and ALOs.
I will base most of this discussion not around what is currently provided in HCC but around how to find and serve as many students who could benefit from the program. That's where the equity deficiency is and that's what needs the most attention.
That brings me to the Work Session in late spring called "Equity in Highly Seattle Schools Community Forum: Conversation on HCC, Part Two:
Conversation on HCC, Part Two
For this part of the discussion, I want to reiterate a few things I said in Part One.
There are some parents don't believe that there could be that many children who are highly capable. To that I can only say that the feds, the state and the district all believe it is true and have allocated resources and services to that end. I note that the new McCleary budget includes extra dollars for programs like Sped, ELL and yes, highly capable.
There are some parents believe it's all based on a single test score in order to get into the program. That is not true and you can examine the application process and how the district's own committee decides on admission.
There are some teachers/administrators don't like HCC because some of their best learners leave the school after they are admitted into the program. One reason could be the loss of test scores. Another reason is the loss of students who help teachers drive the classroom by being generally engaged.
I can understand their unhappiness but it is not the right of a teacher or principal to decide what program parents want their children to be in for the best academic outcomes.
If your belief system on highly capable students falls into either of those two groups, you probably won't be interested in what follows.
This discussion is about changes to make the Highly Capable Cohort program more equitable and stronger. In Part Three, we can discuss the other two parts of Advanced Learning, Spectrum and ALOs.
I will base most of this discussion not around what is currently provided in HCC but around how to find and serve as many students who could benefit from the program. That's where the equity deficiency is and that's what needs the most attention.
That brings me to the Work Session in late spring called "Equity in Highly Seattle Schools Community Forum: Conversation on HCC, Part Two:
by Melissa Westbrook / 3h
I forgot to post this on the Friday Open Thread but Director Leslie Harris is having a community meeting today. It's from 3-5 pm at the Southwest Branch of Seattle Public Library, 9010 35th Ave SW. Don't let her sit there alone; it is the
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)







