Monday, October 12, 2015

School-funding initiative backers keep outraising opponents - MSNewsNow.com - Jackson, MS

School-funding initiative backers keep outraising opponents - MSNewsNow.com - Jackson, MS:

School-funding initiative backers keep outraising opponents






By JEFF AMY
Associated Press


JACKSON, Miss. (AP) - The most expensive ballot initiative campaign in Mississippi history got much costlier in September, as supporters of the Initiative 42 education funding measure continued outraising opponents.
However, opponents for the first time reported substantial contributions in filings Friday.
Better Schools, Better Jobs, the committee backing Initiative 42, raised $357,000 in September, according to a filing. Of that, all but $40,000 came from the New Venture Fund, a charity that's given $2 million. Ultimately, the majority of pro-initiative money flows from the W.K. Kellogg Foundation and public school supporters Jim Barksdale and Dick Molpus.
One opposition group raised $200,000 from Gov. Phil Bryant, Lt. Gov. Tate Reeves, other officials and trade associations. Another opposition group raised $122,000, mostly from the political arm of conservative billionaires Charles and David Koch.School-funding initiative backers keep outraising opponents - MSNewsNow.com - Jackson, MS:

Informative writing from Peter Greene, but we have, have, have to… | @ THE CHALKFACE

Informative writing from Peter Greene, but we have, have, have to… | @ THE CHALKFACE:

Informative writing from Peter Greene, but we have, have, have to…




We have to come up with solutions. Something.
I’m a high school English teacher. I’m not wise enough to know the solution for an educational social justice solution in this country, and I’m not powerful enough to gather together all the people who could help work it all out. But I know enough to know that A) an increasing gap between rich and poor has exacerbated existing problems of social justice in our country, with those problems being reflected, expressed and sometimes amplified in our schools and that B) the charter choice system currently being foisted on many parts of the country doesn’t fix any of those problems.
To charter choice advocates: Your problem is a real problem, but your solution is not a solution. Whether you’re blinded by devotion to your ideology or your intent to make a buck or just your lack of understanding, your vision is impaired. You need to clean your glasses, take a step back, and look again.
All that I read prior to the above paragraphs I’ve read before. Perhaps not as concisely, but, like many others, I’m in a position that I’ve read and re-read these same arguments. When it comes time to define an alternative vision, we’ve been so exhausted by outrage that the handoff to potential solutions rarely takes place. I don’t think we get to do this anymore.
As my school’s union representative, I have a lot of teachers come to me with questions and concerns. My main roles are listening and empathizing. I can handle that. When teachers tell me about students who’ve physically assaulted them or tore up their rooms, response from administration tends to be, “Let us conduct more observations, establish a paper trail, collect more information.” That’s fine, probably necessary, but what can this teacher do in an hour, a day, a week, right now?
I ask Mr. Greene and others, “what can we do right now? What would your suggested alternatives look like a Informative writing from Peter Greene, but we have, have, have to… | @ THE CHALKFACE:

Denver district focuses on quality as schools resegregated - The Denver Post

Denver district focuses on quality as schools resegregated - The Denver Post:

Denver district focuses on quality as schools resegregated

Two decades after force busing ended in DPS, district still struggles with integration






Twenty years after a judge let Denver Public Schools end forced busing, Denver schools are again segregated and efforts to encourage natural integration have not generated many results.
A Supreme Court ruling in 1973 made DPS the first northern district to undergo court-ordered desegregation through forced busing.
But with thousands of white families leaving for the suburbs to avoid integration and a legislature that passed laws ensuring Denver couldn't annex land from the suburbs, getting enough white kids to integrate schools was a challenge.
And it remains.
When DPS was freed from the court order in 1995, more than 40,000 white students who had left did not return, and those students who were being shuffled across the city went back to their neighborhood schools despite an option to keep being transported.
(The Denver Post)
Magnet schools, open enrollment and a simplified SchoolChoice process, charter schools and enrollment zones that broaden neighborhood school boundaries all have been part of the district's attempts at encouraging voluntary integration.
Data show that schools that are most concentrated with minority or low-income students are also the ones that are lower performing and harder to staff.
"It will take more than just offering up the choices," said Laura Lefkowits, who sat on the DPS board when busing ended. "We're tolerating some schools that would not have been tolerated in the past."
A report that nonprofit A-Plus Denver provided to the School Board last month shows that 55 percent of the district's schools have concentrations of more than 90 percent minority populations.
Only 29 of the district's 188 schools are considered integrated in the group's report.
Analyzing schools based on the definition the courts used while DPS was under the busing mandate, 58 schools would be considered compliant — less than a third.
"If they're in a low-performing school, that's an equity issue," said DPS board president Allegra "Happy" Haynes. "Sure, I would love, in the process of creating high-performing schools in every neighborhood, to ensure that those kids also had an opportunity to be in an integrated school. IDenver district focuses on quality as schools resegregated - The Denver Post: 

The Student Success Act: Passed in House of Representatives | VAMboozled!

The Student Success Act: Passed in House of Representatives | VAMboozled!:

The Student Success Act: Passed in House of Representatives






As many of you may know, there is broad, bipartisan agreement that No Child Left Behind (NCLB) needs to be overhauled, if not entirely replaced. For those of you who have not yet heard, though, The Student Success Act (H.R. 5) is to help do this, by reducing “the federal footprint and restor[ing] local control, while empowering parents and education leaders to hold schools accountable for effectively teaching students” within their states.
This represents the federal government’s most serious attempt to overhaul NCLB yet, since it was last rewritten in 2001. Although this Act was initially pulled from the floor losing GOP support last spring, near the end of this past summer the House passed the Act (see more information here).
As per another post here, this has all come about given “[t]he federal government’s involvement in local K-12 schools is at an all-time high.” For example, in 2013, the federal government spent nearly $35 billion on K-12 education, under the condition that states and districts, for example, adopt growth or value-added models (VAMs) to hold their teachers accountable for that which they do (or do not do well).
Hence, The Student Success Act is to primarily:
  • Replace the current national accountability scheme based on high stakes tests with state-led accountability systems, returning responsibility for measuring student and school performance to states and school districts.
  • Protect state and local autonomy over decisions in the classroom by preventing the [U.S.] Secretary of Education from coercing states into adopting Common Core or any other common standards or assessments, as well as reining in the secretary’s regulatory authority.
  • Strengthen existing efforts to improve student performance among targeted student populations, including English learners and homeless children.
  • Ensure parents continue to have the information they need to hold local schools accountable.
Kudos go out to U.S. Secretary Arne Duncan for pushing the federal government’s role, and more specifically their accountability-based “initiatives,” so far (e.g., via Race to the The Student Success Act: Passed in House of Representatives | VAMboozled!:

How Common Core quietly won the war - POLITICO

How Common Core quietly won the war - POLITICO:

How Common Core quietly won the war

The standards that naysayers love to call “Obamacore” has become the reality on the ground for roughly 40 million students.





Note to 2016 GOP contenders: The Common Core has won the war.
Republican presidential candidates are still bashing the divisive K-12 standards. Donald Trump recently called the Common Core a “complete disaster,” and Texas Sen. Ted Cruz proclaimed they should be abolished — along with the Education Department.
Story Continued Below
But it’s too late. Ask most any third grader: Just as Common Core and rigorous standards cheerleader-in-chief, Education Secretary Arne Duncan, prepares to step down, the standards that naysayers love to call “Obamacore” have become the reality on the ground for roughly 40 million students — or about four out of every five public school kids.
The math and English standards designed to develop critical thinking have been guiding classrooms for years now, even as the political fight wages on in statehouses and on the campaign trail: Many of today’s textbooks, workbooks, software and tests are designed to teach the oft-bashed academic standards and measure whether students are meeting them. The federal Education Department gave them a big boost, but never required them, nor can it.
In more than half of all states, millions of students took new standardized tests last spring based on the standards, and the expected uproar over these test scores hasn't materialized. The conspiracy theories about how Common Core would require monitoring kids via iris scans, force teachers to use porn to help students learn to read or ban teaching cursive have largely quieted.

After years of hand-wringing, very few of the 45 states that fully adopted the standards have attempted a clean break — and those that did found it wasn’t easy to do. In Indiana, where Republican Gov. Mike Pence signed a bill last year to ditch the standards, even Common Core haters have said the new ones are just the same standards by a different name.
“The few states that have rolled it back, when you look at what they’ve actually done, the standards they are using are 95 percent the Core standards. It’s what we know needs to be taught,” Melinda Gates said last week. She’s the wife of Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates, whose foundation has been heavily involved in promoting and implementing the standards.
As Common Core becomes more commonplace in public schools (and in many Catholic schools), some prominent Republicans concede they've lost their battle. Take former Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer of Arizona. As governor, she signed an executive order banning the use of the words Common Core by state agencies, though the standards themselves were still firmly in place. She wrote in a recent column on the Fox News website that implementation of the standards is “succeeding.”
Outspoken Common Core critic Neal McCluskey of the Cato Institute agrees that the standards are likely here to stay — though that won’t stop his ongoing assault on the Obama administration using billions in incentives to nudge states to adopt the standards. What might change, he said, is how much states are held accountable for students' mastery of the standards, but “my sense is that most states are going to officially stay with Common Core or something like it.”
Karen Nussle, director of the Collaborative for Student Success, a group that helps lead the public relations charge in support of the standards, said the big fight over the standards is “a bit in the rearview mirror” as the conflict shifts to lesser skirmishes.
Standards have come under reconsideration in many states, yet some reevaluations have had a surprise conclusion — ringing support for the Common Core. That was the case for a public review in the deep red state of Mississippi. Kentucky also found wide support for the standards during a similar review.
In New York, where the uproar has been intense, Democratic Gov. Andrew Cuomo recently declared the implementation of the standards had failed. But even as he ordered a review and promised reform, he didn’t throw out Common Core.
More than 40 states are sticking with Common Core though several have ditched

Read more: http://www.politico.com/story/2015/10/common-core-education-schools-214632#ixzz3oN2YcZWY










Charter School Battle Heats Up - WSJ

Charter School Battle Heats Up - WSJ:

Charter School Battle Heats Up

As these privately run, publicly funded schools expand, traditional ones are feeling threatened







BOSTON— Natasha Brown spent five years trying to get her 14-year-old daughter and 12-year-old son into one of this state’s 80 charter schools. After entering at least 25 lotteries, she secured slots for them this fall.
Those tough odds have sparked a dispute in the state. At least 37,000 families are on waiting lists for charter schools statewide, with 13,000 of them seeking spots in Boston alone, according to data reported to the state.
In coming days, legislators at the Massachusetts State House will begin holding hearings on whether to expand or limit the number of charter schools in the state.
More than two decades since charter schools first appeared in the U.S. as an experiment, they are poised to become mainstream in many parts of the country. About 2.5 million, or 5.1% of public-school students, were enrolled in charter schools in the 2013-2014 school year, up from 300,000, or 0.7%, in 1999-2000, according to federal statistics.
Nearly every major city has charters, challenging the traditional public-school model as parents increasingly send their children to these privately run but publicly funded institutions and politicians allocate more tax dollars.
The dispute in Boston and similar clashes in Baltimore, Philadelphia and Los Angeles are surfacing as local charter schools reach or surpass a 15% to 20% market share in those cities.
“The tension is, ‘What’s the end game here?’ Is this a model to replace the traditional public school model?” said Matthew Chingos, a senior fellow who studies education at the Urban Institute, a nonpartisan policy research group.
“Once students start to leave” public schools for charter schools “in large numbers, that’s where you see a lot of the tensions,” said Nina Rees, president and chief executive of the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools, a pro-charter nonprofit.
Rashad Brown, center, watching other students take part in an improvised scenario during Ruthi Snoke's theatre class at the Roxbury Preparatory Charter School in the Roxbury neighborhood of Boston.ENLARGE
Rashad Brown, center, watching other students take part in an improvised scenario during Ruthi Snoke's theatre class at the Roxbury Preparatory Charter School in the Roxbury neighborhood of Boston. PHOTO: ZAK BENNETT FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
The charter movement offers more school choice, alternatives to lagging public schools and more autonomy from bureaucracy to try new learning approaches. Challenges have included regulating quality at charter schools, making them accessible to more students and transferring successful practices from charters to traditional classrooms.
Critics contend that charters draw more motivated families, leaving districts with fewer resources to educate the neediest students.
“They’ve turned it into a separate and markedly not equal system,” Lily Eskelsen Garcia, president of the National Education Association, the largest U.S. teachers union, said in an interview.
Supporters argue that charters are a proven, good alternative for many children from Charter School Battle Heats Up - WSJ:





TN bill would ban teaching 'religious doctrine' until high school

TN bill would ban teaching 'religious doctrine' until high school:

TN bill would ban teaching 'religious doctrine' until high school






No Tennessee public school course could include anything deemed "religious doctrine" unless the course is taught in 10th, 11th or 12th grade if a newly proposed bill becomes law.
The bill from Rep. Sheila Butt, R-Columbia, comes on the heels of complaints from some parents in several communities as to what their children are learning in middle school about Islam.
"I think that probably the teaching that is going on right now in seventh, eighth grade is not age appropriate," Butt said Friday afternoon. "They are not able to discern a lot of times whether its indoctrination or whether they're learning about what a religion teaches."
Parents in Williamson County, Maury County and several other areas have complained about information contained in courses related to world history. Some, like U.S. Rep Diane Black, R-Tenn., argue the teachings border on indoctrination.
Tennessee education officials and teachers recently argued courses were appropriate and based on secular fact during a discussion of the curriculum with The Tennessean. They acknowledged students might learn the Five Pillars of Islam or read from religious texts, but that information is used to provide historical context about the influence the religion had on regions of the world.
"The reality is the Muslim world brought us algebra, 'One Thousand and One Nights,' and some can argue it helped bring about the Renaissance," Metro Nashville PublicTN bill would ban teaching 'religious doctrine' until high school: 

Montana’s new school choice program is scheduled to launch in January, but already it’s running into constitutional problems. Proposed regulations don’t allow faith-based schools to participate in the program, which is discriminatory and unconstitutional, one attorney says.
photo by wikimedia commons
photo by wikimedia commons
Potential regulations for Montana’s new school choice program would unconstitutionally ban religious schools from participating, an attorney says.
“They’re interpreting their own constitution to require these rules, but they’re incorrectly interpreting their constitution,” said Erica Smith, a lawyer at the Institute for Justice.
IJ often helps lawmakers draft school choice bills, and it frequently intervenes successfully in anti-choice lawsuits on behalf of parents wishing to participate in school choice programs.
After the school choice bill became law last year, the state’s Department of Revenue was tasked with hammering out the details.
The proposed regulations would bar schools from participating in the program if they’re “owned or controlled in whole or in part by any church, religious sect, or denomination.”
The proposed regulations also note schools are barred if their accreditation comes from a faith-based organization.
“This is the first time I’ve seen this happen,” said Michael Chartier, state programs and government relations director at the Friedman Foundation for Educational Choice. “If the Legislature wanted to exclude private schools, I would argue that’s not a good idea, but that’s the Legislature’s prerogative. This goes outside of what the legislative intent was. If the Legislature wanted to do that, they could have done that, but they deemed it OK. It shouldn’t be the Department of Revenue’s prerogative, to essentially make laws for the state of Montana.”
Republican state Sen. Kristin Hansen, who supported the bill, said the department was out of bounds.
“It’s the opposite of the intent of the legislation,” she said. “When we drafted the bill, we intentionally drafted a substantial definition of who qualified, so there wouldn’t be any questions about who would be eligible. I think the department has exceeded its Banning religious schools from choice program could be illegal

Mayor's office withholds records on school contract scandal - Chicago Tribune

Mayor's office withholds records on school contract scandal - Chicago Tribune:

Mayor's office withholds records on school contract scandal




yor Rahm Emanuel's office was more involved in a $20.5 million school contract with a now-indicted consultant than previously disclosed, public records indicate, but his administration has refused to release hundreds of emails that could provide a deeper understanding of how the deal came to be.
Emanuel and his aides have maintained that the mayor's office had nothing to do with the contract to provide leadership training for principals that is at the center of a federal bribery indictment against ex-schools CEO Barbara Byrd-Bennett and the consulting firm where she once worked.
When asked in April if his administration had any role at all in the SUPES contract, Emanuel told reporters, "No, you obviously know that by all the information available. And so the answer to that is no."
Yet the mayor's office and schools officials have been in an ongoing struggle with the Tribune over reporters' public records requests that could bear directly on the controversy, withholding many emails for months before releasing them, several so heavily redacted that little more than the subject line and addresses remain.
The Emanuel administration has declined to provide about half of the roughly 1,000 emails requested. As part of that fight, the Tribune in June sued the city under the state Freedom of Information Act after the mayor's office redacted or withheld about two dozen emails emanating from Emanuel's office.
While much of the picture remains missing, the email logs and documents the administration did release show frequent communication among key Emanuel aides, Chicago school leaders and the heads of the SUPES Academy consulting firm in the months, weeks and days leading up to Emanuel's hand-picked school board awarding the contract in June 2013.
The consulting firm's ties date to the beginning of Emanuel's administration in 2011; in addition to recommending Byrd-Bennett, SUPES co-owner Gary Solomon helped recruit Emanuel's first schools CEO.
Specifically, the email logs indicate that key CPS officials and SUPES executives had numerous discussions about the SUPES firm and principal leadership training — a crucial element of Emanuel's education agenda — ahead of education meetings in the mayor's office in May 2013 and in June 2013, prior to the board vote. Those meetings included the mayor, his top education adviser Beth Swanson, Byrd-Bennett and top CPS officials involved in the SUPES discussions, according to copies of Emanuel's public calendar.
On Thursday, Byrd-Bennett and the co-owners of SUPES were indicted on charges that she steered them the no-bid business in return for promises of more than $2 million in kickbacks, other perks and a future job. Prosecutors alleged that Byrd-Bennett schemed with her SUPES colleagues even as she was joining CPS.
Much of the alleged scheming is laid out in the federal indictment by way of emails between Byrd-Bennett and Solomon. It's unclear what type of email accounts were involved and therefore hard to know whether the emails should have been turned over in response to Tribune requests for public records.
SUPES' work at CPS predated Byrd-Bennett's time as CEO. The firm had begun providing leadership training for school executives in 2012, months before she took over the reins at CPS.
But by early 2013, efforts to expand the program were growing, and emails obtained by the Tribune show SUPES' co-owners and CPS officials discussing how to secure more money to broaden the training. Some of those emails were exchanged on the same day in May Mayor's office withholds records on school contract scandal - Chicago Tribune:

Put Public Education Out Of Its Misery Already

Put Public Education Out Of Its Misery Already:

Put Public Education Out Of Its Misery Already




Wouldn’t it be great if we could implement some grand scheme to ensure that all children, regardless of where they live, regardless of who their parents are, get a good education?
Those who oppose Common Core, or Race to the Top, or No Child Left Behind are often nevertheless convinced that government should carry out some other kind of school reform, possibly under the auspices of the individual states. Lately, copying Finland has been a popular idea, although their government system is also beginning to crumble.
Many believe charter schools (public schools freed from many regulations) should be given more freedom and their numbers expanded. Some libertarians argue it is ethically wrong for the government to provide universal, “free,” and compulsory education, and that education should be left to the parents. But libertarians may also feel the positive ring that “providing all children with a high-quality education” has to it.
In my forthcoming book, “Education Unchained: What it takes to restore schools and learning,” I take a different approach to the role of government in education. I demonstrate that we simply cannot reform the education of “our” children “together.”The good thing is, we could easily make changes that, within a few years, would provide virtually all children with a kind of education superior to anything that has come before. But we simply cannot do it “together.”

Government Isn’t the Answer—We Are

In fact, almost no matter what kind of government reform we carry out, the quality of education in the United States, Britain, or my native Sweden will at best remain in its current abysmal state. But most commonly the net outcome of a government reform will be that education quality deteriorates even further. Despite their enthusiasm and good will, charter schools and home schoolers today constitute not even halfway houses towards reform. They are more like a tenth of a way towards it, even though in the future both groups may become the sources of great education.
Despite their enthusiasm and good will, charter schools and home schoolers today constitute not even halfway houses towards reform.
We must snap out of it and look at education clearly. First of all, education is, or at least ought to be, the outcome we seek. Schools are, or rather should be, mere tools to provide children with education. For various reasons, though, we treat schools as if they are a goals in themselves, as if they are some kind of tribal initiation rite, a ritual everyone has to go through.
Secondly, a hidden assumption is that we “know” what good education is. No, we don’t. To begin with, we all have different ideas about what good education means. Even more importantly, we do not have a meter, an instrument in our brains that can measure quality. Instead, we measure quality by comparing things. A high-quality mobile phone from 2003 is a joke today. Few would buy a high-quality car from 1951. When the government provides us with education, identical for all, by definition we have nothing to directly compare with.
We treat schools as if they are a goals in themselves, as if they are some kind of tribal initiation rite.
We have also largely forgotten how good education used to be. In fact, just how bad schools are today, compared to the schools of old, is hard for most of us to fathom. In my book, I estimate we have lost about six years of education over twelve years for academically minded pupils, compared to the government systems of, say, Sweden in 1878 or 1968. This means for practically minded pupils the fall in quality is more than 100 percent. For these children, schools today destroy value.
Thirdly, we treat education as if the laws of nature somehow do not apply. We improve, Put Public Education Out Of Its Misery Already:


Teachers unions hope Hillary Clinton will undo Arne Duncan’s work - Vox

Teachers unions hope Hillary Clinton will undo Arne Duncan’s work - Vox:

Teachers unions hope Hillary Clinton will undo Arne Duncan’s work






Education Secretary Arne Duncan pushed states into adopting Common Core standards, oversaw a massive expansion of charter schools, and urged states to tie teacher pay to performance. The next presidential administration — Republican or Democrat — could roll back that legacy.
Duncan announced October 2 that he'd step down at the end of the year. And whether Duncan's influence will endure depends on the next presidential administration. Some expert observers argue that a Clinton administration could undo Duncan's work — and teachers unions are hoping she will.
"I think she's going to be different," Randi Weingarten, president of the American Federation of Teachers, said of Clinton when the union endorsed her this spring. The National Education Association did so last week. "She’ll follow the evidence, and she’ll talk to people and give people their due, instead of thinking about things ideologically, as you’ve seen in the last 10 years."

How Arne Duncan transformed education in the US



As education secretary, Duncan used a combination of carrots and sticks — federal grants and waivers from penalties under No Child Left Behind — to get states to change their approach to education. He encouraged states to allow more charter schools, to sign on to the shared Common Core standards, and to tie teachers' professional evaluations to their students' test scores.
Under Duncan's tenure, 43 states have launched the Common Core. Thirty-five states now require test scores to be a "significant" factor in how teachers' performance is judged. States have changed their laws to be more open to charter schools.
All of these policies have been controversial, including with teachers unions. Earlier education secretaries mostly used their influence to issue important reports or bring governors together to work on shared goals. But Duncan was actually reshaping local education from Washington, actions that led one Republican senator to describe him as "chairman of the national school board."
Duncan says he just provided political cover for growing support for education reform at the state level: "You see this much change and improvement in states that didn’t get a nickel," he told me in an interview in September. "While the money was important and significant, it was actually probably less important than the space and the opportunity to do the right thing."

How Clinton could dismantle Obama's education legacy

The Clinton campaign hasn't yet released its K-12 education agenda — but there's already a battle over what type of president she would be on education. Both reformers and unions point to Clinton's lifelong interest in education to argue that she would take their side.
Clinton has so far received endorsements from the National Education Association and American Federation of Teachers, the two national teachers unions. Both have harshly criticized Duncan and his reforms.
When Clinton answered questions from the National Education Association, she provided detailed, specific answers the members liked — downplaying the role of charter schools, Teachers unions hope Hillary Clinton will undo Arne Duncan’s work - Vox:

What the increasingly oppressive climate in many schools is doing to kids - The Washington Post

What the increasingly oppressive climate in many schools is doing to kids - The Washington Post:

What the increasingly oppressive climate in many schools is doing to kids






Leslie Gaar is a former teacher who currently works in public schools training and coaching teachers. She is also  the mother of three and a blogger whose work has been featured on Scary Mommy, TODAY Parents, and Mamalode. She blogs at www.pailsandfires.com. Find her on Facebook and Twitter. In this post, she wrote about something that she disturbs her every time she sets foot into an elementary school these days: what she calls an “increasingly oppressive, harsh environment” in which many young students are educated.
By Leslie Gaar
The speaker used a firm tone of voice that left little room for discussion.
 In 30 seconds, everyone should be in line.
Ten.
Five.
Time is up.
Everyone stand up, hands behind your back, walk back to the room.
NO TALKING.
This conversation was one I recently overheard not in a prison or detention center, not in a courthouse or police station, but in an elementary school– a typical, run-of-the mill elementary school in the suburbs. It happened between a kindergarten teacher and her students. They weren’t in trouble or anything; this was just a routine bathroom break, like the ones that happen a few times each school day.
I work in public schools and can be found navigating their halls on a regular basis. I wish I could say the conversation above was an isolated incident, not representative of other schools I have been in, but that is just not the case. I’ve seen and heard exchanges like this hundreds, maybe even thousands of times, in all sorts of schools– even the “good” ones. As a teacher, I myself participated in these types of interactions daily, but it wasn’t until recently that I began seeing them in a whole new light.
A bit of history: I was a classroom teacher for eight years before taking a break to stay home with my children. When I returned to the education field a couple of years later, it was in a different capacity than before. I began training and coaching teachers, as well as working with administrators to promote best practices on their campuses. This role shift has given me a different perspective on an environment which was as familiar to me as my own skin, and it continues to be eye-opening in a number of ways.
Out of this experience, a question began to bubble up inside of me and has continued to swell so that I can no longer ignore it. That question is this:When did we start running elementary schools like prisons?
When did it become both accepted and routine to address 5 years olds (and 6 and 7 year olds) with barking orders instead of kind, encouraging words? Was it really that long ago that our own kindergarten and first grade classrooms were filled with the sounds of nursery rhymes, laughter, and children at play? Is the world today really so different than it was 20 or even 15 years ago that it warrants a new, harsher brand of education?
I don’t entirely know the answer, but I suspect that one culprit, among others, What the increasingly oppressive climate in many schools is doing to kids - The Washington Post: