Tuesday, October 6, 2015

Judge: Nashville schools can fire non-teaching staff without appeal

Judge: Nashville schools can fire non-teaching staff without appeal:

Judge: Nashville schools can fire non-teaching staff without appeal



School board approves budget by narrow vote


Metro's director of schools has the power to dismiss non-teaching employees without giving them an appeals hearing.
That’s the conclusion of a recent ruling by Davidson County Chancery Court Judge Ellen Lyle, who dismissed the case of two employees saying former Director of Schools Jesse Register fired them without allowing for an appeal to the school board, breaking Metro Charter.
State law, however, supersedes the charter and allows for a board to create policies detailing the process in which the director hires and fires personnel, according to Lyle's ruling. Metro's employee handbook for support staff doesn't spell out an appeal process.
Tanya Aina-Labinjo and Janice Jones chose not to appeal Lyle's Aug. 18 ruling, marking a win for the district in the longstanding case.
The ruling also effectively upholds the board's policy governance model, as well as state law, granting numerous powers over to the board's director of schools. Boards in Tennessee are required to run their district in a corporate-style of governance and must assign a list of powers over to the director, as directed by state law.
MNPS adopted its governance management model in 2003 and sets guidelines for the director.
The board's policies state that the board must not give direction to persons who report directly or indirectly to the director, will not formally evaluate any staff member and, except as required by law, will not participate in decisions or actions involving the hiring, evaluating, discipline or dismissal of any employee.
"The board may change its ends and executive expectations at any time, therefore shifting the boundary between board and director domains," the board's policies state. "By doing so, the board changes the latitude of choice given to the director. However, as long as any board-specified delegation of authority is in place, the board will respecJudge: Nashville schools can fire non-teaching staff without appeal:

Two Edina elementaries hire recess consultant - StarTribune.com

Two Edina elementaries hire recess consultant - StarTribune.com:

Two Edina elementary schools hire recess consultant



Two Edina elementary schools, worried about the politics of the playground, are taking an unusual step to police it: They have hired a recess consultant.
Some parents have welcomed the arrival of the firm Playworks, which says recess can be more inclusive and beneficial to children if it’s more structured and if phrases like, “Hey, you’re out!” are replaced with “good job” or “nice try.”
But some of the kids at Concord and Normandale Elementary say they are confused, or that the consultants are ruining their play time.
“The philosophy of Playworks does not fit Concord,” said Kathy Sandven, a parent of twin boys who attend the school. “It is a structured philosophy — an intervention philosophy — not allowing kids for free play.”
The two schools have joined a growing number of districts that have hired consultants to remake the playground experience into more structured and inclusive play time. The games and activities, like four square and jumping rope, are overseen by adults and designed to reduce disciplinary problems while ensuring that no children are left out.
Edina school officials spent about $30,000 on the recess initiative over the summer, and some administrators are already becoming believers.Two Edina elementaries hire recess consultant - StarTribune.com:

Why There’s Little Demand for Charter Schools in the Suburbs - The Atlantic

Why There’s Little Demand for Charter Schools in the Suburbs - The Atlantic:

Why Don’t Suburbanites Want Charter Schools?
Politics and personal preferences are at play




Soccer or lacrosse, Whole Foods or the farmers market, microbrew or Pinot Noir? Suburbanites tend to relish their many options for food and entertainment. At block parties, neighbors engage in hearty debates about the best place to vacation or the optimal car for shlepping one’s kids. So wouldn’t these very same parents—individuals who likely enjoy the privilege of choosing between a week on a beach or ski slope—want more choice when it comes to their children’s schools?
Not always. The data suggests that one form of school choice—charter schools—are less popular in suburbs than in cities. Why? Experts say that politics and personal preferences are at play.
Charter schools are funded by taxpayer dollars and, as such, can’t charge tuition or discriminate against children based on race, ethnicity, or disability. But as long as they fulfill certain accountability expectations, they’re able to operate on their own terms and, often, under their own governance structures. Some are organized by grassroots groups composed of teachers or parents, while others have been founded by organizations that run networks of schools, often in multiple states.


These schools have been hotly contested since the early 1990s, when Minnesota passed the country’s first charter-education law in the country. Proponents highlight their ability to innovate and serve diverse populations, as well as their freedom from the kinds of rigid bureaucratic rules that constrain traditional public schools. Advocates often cite the successes of well-established charter-school operators like Knowledge is Power Program (KIPP). Critics, meanwhile, argue that they drain funds from public schools and “cream skim” the best students from a community. They point to charters that have come under scrutiny amid allegations of corruption or those that have produced poor academic outcomes and consequently shut down.
A little over 6,700 charter schools now operate in the United States, triple the number in 2000,  according to “The State of the Charter School Movement,” a new report from the nonprofit consulting group Bellwether Education Partners. They serve close to 3 million students—or 6 percent of the total U.S. public-school enrollment—in 43 states and Washington, D.C, with most of the growth happening in 15 states, including California, Florida, and Ohio. Bellwether projects that charter schools could educate as many as one- to two-fifths of the country’s students by 2035, though that’s a liberal estimate.


Charter schools are concentrated in urban and less affluent areas—and it’s not just because of practical reasons, such as available infrastructure and philanthropic funding. According to the Bellwether report, 56 percent of charter-school students live in cities, versus just 29 percent of all U.S. children. (The remaining charter-school students are about evenly split between rural areas and the suburbs.) Relatedly, nearly two-thirds of the charter-school population is nonwhite, compared to about half of its regular public-school counterpart.


There are, of course, variations in the trends depending on the specific state and city. For example, 7 percent of students in New York City attend charter schools, compared to almost all—91 percent—of their peers in New Orleans. While California opened hundreds of new charters in the last four years, only two dozen were opened in Maryland during the same time frame. And just a small percentage of Colorado’s charter-school population is identified as low-income, versus a solid majority of the students attending charters in D.C.


Asked why there are so few suburban charter schools, Michael Petrilli, president of the charter-friendly Fordham Institute, said “it’s by design.” The first few states that signed charter-school legislation—like Wisconsin, California, and Colorado—had broader rules, enabling a wide range of charter schools to exist in those areas, he explained. These early-adopter states were able to enact looser laws because the opposition hadn’t yet fully organized, according to Petrilli. “The teachers’ unions”—which at the time were fighting vouchers—“were caught flat Why There’s Little Demand for Charter Schools in the Suburbs - The Atlantic:

New Orleans Model Is Not Such a Model After All | janresseger

New Orleans Model Is Not Such a Model After All | janresseger:

New Orleans Model Is Not Such a Model After All





In the five years from 2006 to 2011, I visited New Orleans at least twice a year.  I have been baffled since that time by the one-sided research created to paint the transformation of the city’s schools as a sort of miracle.  The reality is very troubling and far more complicated.  I recommend Gary Rivlin’s extraordinary new book, Katrina: After the Flood, because Rivlin’s stories of real people’s return or failure to return—their hard work and their despair—their financial losses—and their courage to keep on keeping on—create a real sense of the depth of the struggle, particularly for African American families in Gentilly and New Orleans East. But Rivlin doesn’t really cover the transformation of the schools.  For an authoritative summary of what has happened since all of the teachers and staff were laid off in the fall of 2005 and the schools progressively turned into a mass of privately managed charter schools, one must read the new brief by Frank Adamson, Channa Cook-Harvey, and Linda Darling-Hammond from the Stanford Center for Opportunity Policy in Education, Whose Choice? Student Experiences and Outcomes in the New Orleans School Marketplace.  (If you want to read further, a much longer report on the research is provided.)  All references in this post are to the shorter research brief.
While the schools of New Orleans are now virtually all charter schools, some schools that were high-performing prior to the hurricane and were not seized by the state remain under the control of the old Orleans Parish School Board (OPSB).  The research brief calls these Tier I schools. Another tier of schools are three kinds of schools authorized by the Louisiana Recovery School District (RSD)—charter, stand-alone, and direct run.  Then there is a third tier made up of alternative schools, those students volunteer to attend and those to which some students are assigned.  “It is clear that the organization of schools in New Orleans is highly stratified: The school tiers sort students by race, income, and special education status, with the most advantaged students at the top and the least advantaged at the bottom.  Only the top two sub-tiers within Tier 1 have any appreciable number of white and Asian students and any noticeable number of students who are non-poor.”  The authors remind us that, “Louisiana’s charter law explicitly allows some schools to engage in selective enrollment practices that New Orleans Model Is Not Such a Model After All | janresseger:

Data-Driven Teaching Practices: Rhetoric and Reality | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice

Data-Driven Teaching Practices: Rhetoric and Reality | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice:

Data-Driven Teaching Practices: Rhetoric and Reality



Much has already been written on the U.S. obsession with standardized test scores.  Add to the obsession the passionate belief that policymakers who gather, digest, and use a vast array of numbers can reshape teaching practices.

I refer to data-driven instruction–a way of making teaching less subjective, more objective, less experience-based, more scientific. Ultimately, a reform that will make teaching systematic and effective. Standardized test scores, dropout figures, percentages of non-native speakers proficient in English–are collected, disaggregated by ethnicity and school grade, and analyzed. Then with access to data warehouses, staff can obtain electronic packets of student performance data that can be used to make instructional decisions to increase academic performance. Data-driven instruction, advocates say, is scientific and consistent with how successful businesses have used data for decades in making decisions that increased their productivity.

Not a new idea. Teachers had always assessed learning informally before state- and district-designed tests. Teachers accumulated information from pop quizzes, class discussions, observing students in pairs and small groups, and individual conferences. Based on these data, teachers revised lessons. Teachers leaned heavily on their experience with students and the incremental learning they had accumulated from teaching 180 days, year after year.

In the 1990s and, especially after No Child Left Behind became law, the electronic gathering of data, disaggregating information by groups and individuals, and then applying lessons learned from the analysis to teaching became a top Data-Driven Teaching Practices: Rhetoric and Reality | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice:

Portland Parent Union rallies for end to expulsions and suspensions | OregonLive.com

Portland Parent Union rallies for end to expulsions and suspensions | OregonLive.com:

Portland Parent Union rallies for end to expulsions and suspensions




Members of the Portland Parent Union advocacy group rallied against exclusionary disciplinary practices Tuesday night. 
The demonstration was part of the National Week of Action Against School Pushout, aDignity In Schools Campaign calling for positive interventions instead of expulsions or suspensions and an end to racial disparities in discipline, according to the campaign's website. The movement is also advocating for student and parent involvement in disciplinary decisions and more funding for counselors.  
About two dozen supporters clad in red shirts gathered Tuesday afternoon at the Portland Public Schools district office before attending the board meeting. Sheila Warren, founder and director of the union, passed around a megaphone for students and parents to speak and led chants for the group. 
Warren said the union supports other options for student discipline, such as restorative justice practices, which focus on relationships and dialogue instead of punitive measures. 
Portland Public Schools Superintendent Carole Smith has made reducing exclusionary discipline one of her main priorities. Restorative justice is one method the district is implementing. 
According to a recent district presentation, the percentage of students excluded from school dropped from 7 percent in 2008-2009 to 2.4 percent last year, though Portland Parent Union rallies for end to expulsions and suspensions | OregonLive.com:

Number Crunchers Often Target Support Staff For Pay Cuts - NEA Today

Number Crunchers Often Target Support Staff For Pay Cuts - NEA Today:

Number Crunchers Often Target Support Staff For Pay Cuts

Custodial work in public school


Jeanne Middleton has lived in Brighton, Illinois, for 22 years. For the last seven, she has worked with Southwestern Community Unit School District Number 9 as a bus driver, lunchroom monitor, and utility worker – all at once. Combined, the jobs provide Middleton with enough work hours to qualify her for health insurance and other benefits.
“It’s challenging,” says Middleton, president of the Southwestern Education Support Professionals Association (SWESPA). “You get use to switching from one setting to the next.”
Like so many ESPs in the district, Middleton lives, shops, votes, and worships in the same school district where she works. She spends time with neighbors whose children are among those she drives to and from school.
“I graduated from Alton High School about 15 miles from where we live now,” she says.
Many of SWESPA’s 60 members are also homegrown. They either attended the schools where they now work, have children attending these schools, or have a spouse who was born and raised in this rural farming community. They are rooted.
Yet, in the eyes of the superintendent and school board members, they are expendable. Since June, district ESPs have been working on an expired contract. After meeting throughout the summer, once under the supervision of a federal mediator, SWESPA members overwhelmingly rejected a school district proposal for a two-year Number Crunchers Often Target Support Staff For Pay Cuts - NEA Today:

NYC Educator: Meet the New Boss, Even Worse Than the Old Boss

NYC Educator: Meet the New Boss, Even Worse Than the Old Boss:

Meet the New Boss, Even Worse Than the Old Boss





There's a very interesting piece up at US News by Andrew Rotherham, AKA Eduwonk. I don't agree with Rotherham about a whole lot in education, but I find myself wishing I agreed with a whole lot of this particular column. Rotherham certainly has a way with words, whether you agree with him or not:


It's too soon to fully judge Duncan's tenure. There are lots of strong opinions in Washington and around the country about Duncan. Privately, insiders' views range from "he's the most committed and effective secretary of education in the department's history" to "he's a jock who's in way over his head on policy."

Wow. I wish I agreed with that. But with the entire country embracing Race to the Top, Gun to the Head policies like Common Core, I'm not feeling the love. The high-stakes testing and developmentally inappropriate tasks for our children (and not his, or Duncan's, or Obama's) are intolerable. That's not to mention the junk-science teacher ratings that have been foisted upon us, rejected by none other than the American Statistical Association.


Education is apparently on the president's "Eff-It" list. At this year's White House Correspondents Dinner, President Obama said that he didn't have a bucket list, but with time running out on his administration, he did have something that rhymed with it. The president's choice of John King* to oversee the department after Duncan is a signal he's not that concerned with education politics at this point.  

That's clever, but not precisely accurate. It appears to me that President Obama, who's certainly in a position to say "Eff-it" to pretty much anything, has decided to continue with the reformy policies that are King's signature. While it wasn't clear to UFT President Michael Mulgrew, 
NYC Educator: Meet the New Boss, Even Worse Than the Old Boss:

Learning Matters: The Truth about Our Schools—In England and the U.S.

Learning Matters: The Truth about Our Schools—In England and the U.S.:

Learning Matters: The Truth about Our Schools—In England and the U.S.

photodune-5569089-england-flag-xs


School privatization is happening around the world. It should come as no surprise that many countries have the same draconian reforms foisted on their public schools like the U.S. I find it interesting to learn how other countries run their schools and the similarities and differences between their systems and ours.



Learning Matters: The Truth About Our Schools is by Roger Titcombe, who frequently posts about education issues in England on the respected Local Schools Network (LSN). While some language differences exist with terms, it is easy to see the likenesses in our systems.



Their Academies are like our charter schools, and when reading about them it is a bit uncanny to see the similarities. Roger writes:



Academies are independent schools and despite being paid for by the taxpayer the sponsors have had complete power to dictate how and what pupils learn. Much bizarre and educationally doubtful experimentation was taking place based on the Learning Matters: The Truth about Our Schools—In England and the U.S.:

Is the Los Angeles school board speaking truth to power, or was that Pope Francis? — PS connect

Is the Los Angeles school board speaking truth to power, or was that Pope Francis? — PS connect:

Is the Los Angeles school board speaking truth to power, or was that Pope Francis?



When I say AALA, think Associated Administrators of Los Angeles, not Allah. This was no mosque, after all.
The AALA Fall Reception took place last Wednesday at the Plaza Center at the Cathedral of Our Lady of the Angels. Maybe, with Pope Francis making the most sense of anyone in the halls of Congress last week, AALA was hoping some of that holy mojo would rub off on all the board members, senior district staff and administrators present. There was no mention of any sacredness of the spot by AALA president, Juan Flecha, separation of church and state and all. Still, it was not business as usual.
The AALA event was rousing. The speakers--especially the board members--seemed inspired.

California State Superintendent, Tom Torlakson offered a benediction of sorts and then the more personal messages followed. Board President Steve Zimmer, with his usual preachy oratorical flare, paid tribute to the superintendent.
"What Ray Cortines has done is one of the most incredible acts of public service I have ever seen," Zimmer said. He went on to thank the administrators, particularly in light of the horrific news of the high number of shootings in Los Angeles neighborhoods over the weekend, for being the rock that students and families lean on in such times. He reminded everyone there that school is the center of many communities.

Zimmer closed by reassuring the administrators in the wake of the privateers' declaration of war against LAUSD, saying, "We are going to walk through this fire together."

George McKenna offered the parables and personal anecdotes to which we've become accustomed. "We can't just fight to fight; we have to fight to win. When the elephants fight, only the grass gets trampled," he said.

McKenna's best line, which seemed to either search for encouragement or to serve as a warning, was, "We're either going Is the Los Angeles school board speaking truth to power, or was that Pope Francis? — PS connect:

John King’s appointment signals Obama isn’t backing down on an aggressive education agenda - The Hechinger Report

John King’s appointment signals Obama isn’t backing down on an aggressive education agenda - The Hechinger Report:

John King’s appointment signals Obama isn’t backing down on an aggressive education agenda




esident Obama doubled down on his commitment to the nation’s underserved students by selecting Dr. John King to succeed Arne Duncan as Acting Secretary of Education. Clearly, this administration has no plans of backing away over the next fifteen months from the aggressive education reform agenda it began pursuing six years ago.

At his heart, King is a passionate advocate for kids. He knows what it’s like to need an advocate, having lost both of his parents at age twelve. He also knows how important an individual teacher can be, having been personally uplifted by the too-often-overlooked educators who dedicate their lives to teaching the nation’s students.

His dedicated heart comes to this new position encased in a body bearing numerous battle scars. His previous experience as commissioner of education for the state of New York will serve him well in the legislative wrestling ring that has been made of the nation’s capital. He knows the fault lines in the fast-moving education policy environment.

Related: What Arne Duncan did to American education and whether it will last

Having pushed an aggressive state agenda of Common Core State Standards, more rigorous assessments, teacher evaluations, charter schools, and other education reforms, King will draw upon his experience of successes and setbacks in his deep commitment to do the right things for kids. My guess is that King will acknowledge making mistakes, but transforming the U.S. education system from the classroom to the legislative committee room requires both change and occasional failures. What is important is what is learned — and improved upon — from these experiences.

King left New York while the hard work of implementing higher standards and increasing support for teachers in implementing these standards across 700 districts began sapping political support from the statehouse. By stepping down, he removed the obvious symbol for growing opposition while giving his successor the opportunity to continue consolidating gains, including the commitment to providing professional development support to ensure there is a well-prepared teacher in every classroom.

King is ready to continue advancing the Obama administration’s agenda, including fighting against sequestration cuts to education programs and unveiling regulations to measure and improve the quality of teacher preparation programs. He has been an ardent supporter of the DREAM (Development, Relief, and Education for John King’s appointment signals Obama isn’t backing down on an aggressive education agenda - The Hechinger Report:

Duncan’s successor must make sure to partner with the disenfranchised - The Hechinger Report

Duncan’s successor must make sure to partner with the disenfranchised - The Hechinger Report:

Duncan’s successor must make sure to partner with the disenfranchised

Reform should be done with communities, not to them






Arne Duncan will go down as the most influential secretary in U.S. history.

He maximized federal powers to push states to serve all students when those states clearly were not. But pushing from the top isn’t sustainable.

And after Duncan’s seven hard-fought years, we may have realized the zenith of federal authority because of Duncan’s tenure.

Although Congress is negotiating authorization of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act – the legislation that outlines the federal role – improvements will have to come from the bottom up for the foreseeabA bottom up approach may be for the better; black and brown families certainly can’t trust states to create equitable educational systems. Students of color are less likely to have experienced and effective classroom teachers.

States impose racially biased out-of-school suspension and expulsion policies that hurt black and brown communities. Merit-based student financial aid programs favor middle- to upper-income families instead of first-generation collegians. And the stubborn outcomes for black, brown and low-income families say more about a system of inequality than anything about student potential.

The same legislators who erode voting rights for minority groups, permit housing discrimination and enforce racist criminal justice systems also write public education policy. In education, the federal government has a similar role in protecting citizens from civil rights violations.

The historic inabilities of states to deliver quality public schools for disenfranchised groups consistently confirm the fed’s most important role – enforcing civil rights violations, especially those facilitated by state policy. Duncan served this role very well.

Black, brown and low-income folks need higher academic standards. The rigor behind Common Core had even middle class whites crying to opt out. Families and policymakers also need data that can tell us how well students are learning.

Duncan’s insistence for common metrics addressed this need. Families also need states to intervene when it’s clear that little is being done to turnaround failing schools. Duncan doubled down on Bush’s No Child Left Behind accountability system. The only relief states could receive from NCLB’s hard penalties was to accept a reform package from Duncan.Duncan’s successor must make sure to partner with the disenfranchised - The Hechinger Report:





We must despise our kids: Our ugly war on teachers must end now - Salon.com

We must despise our kids: Our ugly war on teachers must end now - Salon.com:

We must despise our kids: Our ugly war on teachers must end now

Republicans and Democrats can agree on one thing: Demonizing teachers. It's the "reformers" doing the most harm



We must despise our kids: Our ugly war on teachers must end now


Last week’s jobs report showed the labor market decelerating. This appears to be thefifth straight year that promising signs in the winter end up softening in the summer and fall. And indicators like the labor force participation rate (which is at a 38-year low) and wage growth (which has stagnated for decades, including in what should be a surge period since the Great Recession) make it look even worse.
But Elise Gould of the Economic Policy Institute dug out perhaps the worst numbers in the report. With September’s data in, we can see how many teachers went back to school this year. And Gould finds that the tremendous gap that opened up when local budgets crashed during the recession has not come close to being filled.
At the peak, we had 8.1 million public K-12 education teachers and staff in July 2008. Seven years later, we have far less, 7.8 million, despite a larger population of students that need to be served. According to EPI, the local public education shortfall, accounting for additional student enrollment, is 410,000 jobs.
This means that classrooms built for 25 or 30 students now have 35 or 40 in them. It means that kids don’t get the same level of personalized instruction, or in some cases any attention at all. It means that programs like art and music have to be excised, or extracurricular activities, simply because there are no resources available to staff them.
Obviously the main culprit of this tremendous and damaging shortfall in student learning is austerity budgeting around the country. Most funding for public schools comes from the states, and they have not rebounded to pre-recession funding levels, nor have they made education enough of a priority to keep up. Though teaching children is routinely stated as our nation’s most important priority in political campaigns, we treat it in the exact opposite manner in budget documents.
But there’s a bigger point to be made here, first brought up by blogger Duncan Black, aka Atrios. Speaking of teachers, Atrios wrote, “who could have predicted that demonizing them, cutting salaries and benefits, and reducing job security might make it a slightly less attractive option for people.”
The amazing thing is just how bipartisan this campaign to denigrate the American teacher has been. We know about the war on public employees on the Republican side, from Scott Walker on down. States under Republican control have routinelyeliminated collective bargaining rights, cut retirement benefits, and generally made teaching a less lucrative profession. They’ve also painted a picture of greedy teacher’s unions who deserve “a punch in the face,” according to presidential candidate Chris Christie. Another candidate, John Kasich, signed a law to create a “CEO” position for school districts, armed with the power to override some elements of union contracts.
But putting that expected belligerence aside, teachers have faced assault from their nominal allies for the entirety of the Obama administration. The end of Arne Duncan’s tenure as education secretary puts this into stark relief.
Duncan’s support for charter schools with fewer worker protections, and a “Race to the Top” program that used federal money as a carrot to force states to change their education policies, won rebuke from major teachers unions. He pushed getting rid of “bad teachers” through evaluations that many have criticized as inaccurate. He said that Hurricane Katrina was the best thing to ever happen to the education system in New Orleans, basing this notion on certain test scores improving (largely by We must despise our kids: Our ugly war on teachers must end now - Salon.com:



The Dismal Toll of the War on Teachers

The Dismal Toll of the War on Teachers:

The Dismal Toll of the War on Teachers






What is among the first actions that brutal totalitarian regimes take upon assuming power? They imprison, exile or “disappear” teachers.
Dictators employ such harsh tactics because of the role teachers play in society. Teachers provide not only a crucial link to our cultural past but also exercise critical influence on the present and the future. Teachers train future citizens on how to think and creatively challenge accepted wisdom, which can threaten the power of tyrants.
But before we rush to congratulate ourselves on how well teachers are treated in our free society, we need to recognize the multiple ways in which damage has been caused to the profession.
The United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) established World Teachers’ Day—celebrated every year on October 5 since 1994—as a result of concerns about the historically low status of teachers and their mistreatment.
As a researcher who studies the history of schooling in the United States, I can testify that Americans have long had a deep and enduring ambivalence about teachers: We value their work, but we pay them less respect and less moneythan those in many other comparable professions. There are plenty of signs that teaching as a vocation is in trouble in the U.S.
The Problem of Teacher Turnover
Look at how enrollments in teacher preparation programs have plummeted in the last few years in U.S. schools.
The hardest-hit state—California—experienced a 53 percent decline between 2008 and 2013. Other states are not too far behind—Michigan, for instance, experienced a 38 percent drop, and Texas a 19 percent reduction, during the same period.
Several high-profile educators have either decided to “hang up their chalk” or encouraged others to avoid the profession altogether.
And what is causing good, experienced educators to flee the ship of teaching?
Teacher turnover has long been an area of concern (teachers depart at a higher rate than comparable professions). The more precise reasons for recent departures are under scrutiny, but we can point to a variety of likely causes.
First, teachers have experienced heavy attacks from a number of directions over the past 15 years.
Ever since the passage of the No Child Left Behind Act in 2001, which accelerated an ongoing education accountability movement, teachers and schools have felt under immense pressure to improve the annual yearly progress of their students on statewide standardized tests and demonstrate that they are “highly qualified.”
Researchers who investigated these concerns found that teachers generally applaud efforts to improve academic standards, instruction and teacher qualifications. But many of these policies have had profound unintended consequences.
For example, because of the differences between state policies, teachers and schools in one state can be punished for student achievement scores that in other states would be rewarded.
Second, the accountability movement has led many policymakers, especially those keen on finding ways to measure the worth of all things, to fasten onto “value-added measures” (VAM) as a way of evaluating teacher performance.
The idea behind VAM is that yearly student test scores can be used not only to track student achievement but also as a way to measure the instructional impact of their teachers.
Dealing With Tests and Fixing Poverty
On the face of it, such instructional assessments might seem like a reasonable approach. But there are many pitfalls to using a test originally designed to measure students to evaluate teachers.
So much so that eminent scholars in the field of statistics, economics, psychology and education have issued urgent warnings to policymakers that VAM are far too flawed to be of any value in teacher assessment.
Despite such caution, many states have moved forward with the implementation of evaluation systems that employ VAM as a primary mechanism for teacher evaluation, a development that is sure to signal to many The Dismal Toll of the War on Teachers:

Are changing labor laws silencing the teachers’ voice? | Brookings Institution

Are changing labor laws silencing the teachers’ voice? | Brookings Institution:

Are changing labor laws silencing the teachers’ voice?




Many states have made significant changes to the laws governing public sector labor relations in recent years, changes that are already impacting teachers unions’ efforts to maintain membership. Most of the controversy in Wisconsin – and other states undergoing similar labor retrenchment – has centered on economic consequences such as government spending and worker wages. Yet, states’ ongoing efforts to redesign public sector labor law may prove even more consequential for the political power and influence of public employees unions in the years ahead.
As his critics are quick to emphasize, Gov. Scott Walker weakened collective bargaining rights for the public employees whose unions have historically been strong supporters of the Democratic Party (e.g., teachers and state, county, and municipal employees). This change leaves the state’s more Republican-friendly police and firefighter unions intact, showing that politicians believe union-friendly labor laws help enhance the political effectiveness of union interest groups. In a forthcoming article in The American Journal of Political Science, Patrick Flavin (Baylor University) and I examine just how instrumental one union-favored policy—mandatory public sector collective bargaining laws enacted in the 1960s and 1970s—have been to union efforts to mobilize their supporters in electoral politics.
In particular, we looked at data on the political participation of public school teachers from 1956 to 2004. During this time period, 34 states adopted mandatory collective bargaining laws for teachers, which enabled us to compare the political activity of individual teachers before and after their unions operated with the benefit of a mandatory bargaining law. Substantively, our quantitative analysis found that the effect of a teacher working in a mandatory bargaining law environment significantly influences his or her likelihood of participating in politics (e.g., campaign contributions, volunteering, attending political meetings).  The big surprise is that this effect of the bargaining law environment is greater than the effect of a teacher’s household income, education, and union membership status. We further identified increased contact (outreach) from organized groups (i.e. teacher unions) seeking to mobilize rank-and-file teachers as a likely explanation for this finding.
What specifically about mandatory bargaining laws helped catalyze political participation among teachers? For one thing, the onset of collective bargaining in the public sector conferred an assortment of benefits (often formal and contractual) to teacher unions at the organizational level, benefits that in turn made it easier and less costly for unions to focus on recruiting rank-and-file employees to participate in politics. To mention just two small examples: it is quite common to find collective bargaining agreements (CBAs) that provideAre changing labor laws silencing the teachers’ voice? | Brookings Institution: 

High-stakes testing, Common Core focus of education forum - City & Region - The Buffalo News

High-stakes testing, Common Core focus of education forum - City & Region - The Buffalo News:

High-stakes testing, Common Core focus of education forum






Two leading advocates in a movement to scale back high-stakes testing in schools will be featured at an education forum at 6:30 p.m. Tuesday at Niagara Falls High School.
Carol Burris, a retired principal who has frequently written about the impact of testing and other education reform measures, will be the guest speaker at the event, “Public Education Now: Reform, Resistance and Solutions in New York State.” Diane Ravitch, a former assistant secretary in the U.S. Department of Education, education historian and author, will deliver a message via video during the event.
The forum is free and open to the public. Seats and parking are available on a first-to-arrive basis.
Burris was a principal at South Side High School on Long Island until earlier this year, when she retired to advocate for rolling back high-stakes tests linked to teacher evaluations, the Common Core standards and other controversial policies New York State leaders have rolled out in public schools in recent years. Burris, who was named Principal of the Year by the School Administrators Association of New York State 2013, is now the executive director of the Network for Public Education. Burris and Ravitch spoke Monday night at West Seneca West High School.
The forum will include discussions
on the impact of the Common Core standards and high-stakes testing, the movement to refuse state standardized tests, education reform and local control issues.

At the forum on Monday, organizers said, Burris criticized a new task force created by Gov. Andrew Cuomo to review the Common Core standards as a “sham” and called for a larger effort on behalf of parents to refuse state standardized assessments.High-stakes testing, Common Core focus of education forum - City & Region - The Buffalo News: