Latest News and Comment from Education

Monday, March 24, 2014

3-24-14 Fred Klonsky | Daily posts from a retired public school teacher

Fred Klonsky | Daily posts from a retired public school teacher who is just looking at the data.:



811004160


John Laesch. Act to abolish the Charter Commission.
Your grassroots action and leadership from State Representative Chapa LaVia has helped propell some important legislation through the House Secondary and Elementary Education Committee and onto the house floor. On March 20th, HB 3754 that would dissolve the ALEC-created Illinois State Charter School Commission passed the House by a vote of (78-33) – click to see how your lawmaker voted. Tomorrow,


Ten minute drawing. Grit.




What should we think about the unions’ Dillard Strategy?
Some readers have suggested that we move on from the discussion of the IFT and IEA’s Dillard Strategy. The election is over, they tell me. We need to focus on what’s next. But I say not so fast. The unions collectively spent over $3 million of member political donations on the Dillard Strategy. I think that kind of money deserves evaluation and accountability. The were (at least) two criticisms of

CPS continues its ethnic cleansing of its teaching faculty.
  Photo: George Schmidt, Substance. The announcement late Friday that CPS was closing three more schools – calling them turn-arounds – was an attempt to bury the story of the system’s continuing efforts at the ethnic cleansing of the teaching staff. That’s the purpose of a bad news story that is released to the press late on Friday. Bury it. The three schools - McNair, Dvorak and Gresham elementa
3-23-14 Fred Klonsky | Daily posts from a retired public school teacher
Fred Klonsky | Daily posts from a retired public school teacher who is just looking at the data.: Sunday reads.NYC Educator runs for union office. More like him should. They pissed away $3 million supporting the candidate from ALEC, an idea the membership wouldn’t buy.  The bill is the best charter bill of the season and deserves your immediate support.  David Sirota. Annual pension shortfall = $4

UPDATE: Pence Signs Bill to End Common Core in Indiana | Truth in American Education

Oklahoma on the Verge of Stopping Common Core Implementation | Truth in American Education:



Building the Machine to be Released on Monday
The Home School Legal Defense Association’s documentary on the Common Core entitled Building the Machine will be released on Monday, March 31st.  It will be released through its website – http://www.commoncoremovie.com/ where it will be free to view.Building the Machine introduces the public to the Common Core and its effects on our children’s education. Parents, officials, and the American public



Pence Signs Bill to End Common Core in Indiana
From Indiana Governor Mike Pence’s office.  The Common Core repeal bill was passed by the Indiana Senate back on March 12th.Indianapolis – Governor Mike Pence today signed Senate Enrolled Act 91, which requires Indiana to adopt its own academic standards. The Governor issued the following statement:“I believe our students are best served when decisions about education are made at the state and loc


Oklahoma on the Verge of Stopping Common Core Implementation

Filed in Common Core State Standards by  on March 24, 2014 • 0 Comments








 Oklahoma Governor Mary Fallin (R) sent out a press release Friday regarding House Bill 3399 thatpassed the Oklahoma House and will be considered by the Oklahoma Senate Education Committee today.

OKLAHOMA CITY – Governor Mary Fallin today commented on plans by the Oklahoma Senate Education Committee to consider House Bill 3399 on Monday.  The measure’s intent is to provide for the development and adoption of new English and math standards and assessments while prohibiting the state Board of Education from entering into any contract or agreement with any federal agency or private entity that would cede or limit state control.
“As a state, we must continue to raise education standards and increase accountability in public schools. Nothing is more important to the long term success of our children, nor as essential to our ability to compete in a competitive global economy that demands a highly skilled, highly educated workforce,” said Fallin.
“As we work to increase classroom rigor and raise the academic bar in our schools, I have been clear that Oklahoma must take the lead in developing and implementing our own standards and assessments. To protect the principle of local control, and to resist federal overreach from Washington and the Obama administration, I signed last year an executive order outlining Oklahoma’s independence in implementing higher standards and student assessments.
“Since then, I have listened to growing concerns from parents across the state concerning Common Core, the standards currently in the process of being implemented. In light of these 

Obama & Duncan Merely Pretend to Address School Inequity | janresseger

Obama & Duncan Merely Pretend to Address School Inequity | janresseger:



Obama & Duncan Merely Pretend to Address School Inequity

President Barack Obama’s proposed 2015 federal budget includes a new $300 million Race to the Top Opportunity initiative described as promoting equity in public schools.  While funding is frozen for the Department of Education’s large and important programs like Title I and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, the budget, if passed by Congress, would create a new competitive grant program by which states could apply for federal funds, “to help states and districts create data systems that track characteristics such as teacher and principal experience and effectiveness, academic achievement, and student coursework.  It would also give schools resources to attract and retain effective teachers, extend learning time, bolster school culture, and help students non-cognitive skills,” according to Education Week‘s Alyson Klein.
Late last week, the Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights released a brand new study to bolster the need for the new Race to the Top Opportunity proposal.  According toMichele McNeill (Education Week‘s other expert on federal policy in education), the new “federal civil rights data show persistent and widespread disparities among disadvantaged students from prekindergarten through high school on key indicators…. Minorities and students with limited English proficiency are more likely to be taught by inexperienced 

LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 3-24-14 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all:



Click on picture to Listen to Diane Ravitch


Sahlberg: The Only Standardized Test that Finnish Students Take
Finnish students almost never take a standardized test. They take tests written by their teachers. There is one test, however, that students take at the end of high school. It is the same for all students but the quality of the questions is far more complex and interesting than the questions found on the SAT or the ACT. Here Pasi Sahlberg explains the kinds of questions that Finnish students are


Peter Greene Shows How to Measure Grit
There has been much discussion in the blogosphere and elsewhere about the importance of “grit.” Some of this started with the publication of Paul Tough’s book “How Children Succeed: Grit, Curiousity, and the Hidden Power of Character,” which argued that those characteristics are crucial to succeeding in adverse circumstances and that they can be taught. It continued with the award of a MacArthur t
Anthony Cody on the Common Core: Are They “Standards”?
Anthony Cody read my post this morning about why the Common Core standards fail to meet the most minimal procedural requirements for standard-setting–the requirements laid out in detail by the American National Standards Institute–and concludes that Common Core cannot be considered standards. They were written in secret. There was no transparency or openness in the process.   Another reader asked


Comment: The Common Core “Standards” Are Not Standards
I cross-posted my article about “The Fatal Flaw of the Common Core Standards” at Huffington Post and on Valerie Strauss’ The Answer Sheet, to reach the broadest possible audience. This comment appears on Huffington Post: Craig Schultz (Craig_Schultz) 3 749 Fans·Jonah and Ahab had different perspectives Thank you Diane Ravitch for bringing up a point which has never been mentioned previously.I


Texas: Parents Opt Their Child Out of Testing and Test Prep
Kyle and Jennifer Massey in Waco, Texas, wrote a respectful letter to their child’s principal explaining why they would not permit him to take the state STAAR tests or to engage in test prep for STAAR testing. As his parents, they care more about their child than the Legislature or Governor Perry or Pearson. They clearly, in this instance, know more than the legislators who are influenced by lobby


Breaking News! Taxpayers Will Pay $1 Billion for Vouchers to Private, Religious Schools This Year
Stephanie Simon at Politico.com here documents the spread of the voucher movement, which shifts $1 billion away from the nation’s public schools to private and religious schools. Hundreds of these schools teach creationism as written in the Bible and teach other subjects, including history and even mathematics, from a religious and dogmatic perspective. She writes: Taxpayers in 14 states will bank

With VAM: All Teachers of the Gifted Are “Bad” Teachers
In this age of value-added measurement, when teachers are judged by the rise or fall of their students’ test scores, it is very dangerous to teach gifted classes. Their scores are already at the top, and they have nowhere to go, so the teacher will get a low rating. It is also dangerous to teach English language learners, students with disabilities, and troubled youth. Their scores will not go up

Jeff Bryant: The New Extremist Attack on Democracy
Jeff Bryant here describes the rise of an anti-democratic worldview that threatens not only public education but democracy itself.   Under the fraudulent guise of “education reform,” extremists seek to destroy public education and turn it over to private entrepreneurs. They trust the marketplace, not the public. They are true believers in the doctrines of free-market economist Milton Friedman, not

SAT, ACT Sued for Selling Student Data
A lawsuit was filed against the SAT and ACT for selling confidential data of students to colleges. Some states mandate that all students must take one of these tests, whether they are college bound or not. Students assume that their names and scores will be shared with colleges to which they apply, but it turns out that far more is disclosed about students, and it is sold, not just shared. It appe
The Fatal Flaw of the Common Core Standards
Across the nation, parents and educators are raising objections to the Common Core standards, and many states are reconsidering whether to abandon them as well as the federally-funded tests that accompany them. Arne Duncan, Jeb Bush, Bill Gates, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, and the Business Roundtable vocally support them, yet the unease continues and pushback remains intense. Why so much controv
Are You Attending American Education Research Association Meeting in Philadelphia?
If the answer is yes, please come to one or both of the two sessions where I am speaking on April 3. I will give the John Dewey Society lecture at the Convention Center, 100 Level, Room 114, from 4-7 pm. (Lots of time for discussion). My topic: “Does Evidence Matter?” Fair warning: The room holds only 600 people. Before the Dewey lecture, I will join Philadelphia parent activist Helen Gym and Carl
LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 3-23-14 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all
Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all: Jason Stanford: A Hard Choice in Texas: $100 for a Graphic Calculator or $15 for an App?Jason Stanford is a political journalist in Texas who keeps a close watch on the nexus between money, politics, and education. He is especially interested in how lobbyists shape decisions about where the education money should be spent. In this


3-24-14 Wait What?

Wait What?:







Guinea Pigs (aka Connecticut students) – it is time to log into the Common Core Test of a test

Today is the day… In nearly every public school in Connecticut students will put aside the learning process during the coming weeks in order to become guinea pigs for the Common Core Smarter Balanced Field Test of a test and the entire corporate education reform industry. In some states only 10 percent of students were […]The post Guinea Pigs (aka Connecticut students) – it is time to log into the


3-23-14 Wait What?
Wait What?: Another MUST READ comment from the Wait,What? reader known as jrp1900One of yesterday’s Wait,What? posts was entitled, “Election Year: Incumbent or challenger – You MUST READ this column.” The article re-posted a column written by Sarah Darer Littman and began with the statement. In a stunning piece written by pro-public education advocate and CT Newsjunkie columnist Sarah Darer Littma


3-24-14 The Answer Sheet

The Answer Sheet:





Ex-Yale president to head Coursera MOOC site
Former Yale University President Richard C. Levin is taking on a new role in education. The man who lead Yale for 20 years will in mid-April become the chief executive officer of the two-year-old online MOOC provider Coursera. Coursera offers free online access to classes from more than 100  institutions of higher education — including […]    


Jeb Bush: Common Core critics care too much about kids’ self-esteem
While Republican Sen. Charles Grassley of Iowa is trying to get the Common Core State Standards initiative defunded in Congress, other Republicans, especially former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush, keep doing everything they can to promote the Core. Bush’s latest: He said in an interview with the Miami Herald that critics of the standards  and of […]    


The brainy questions on Finland’s only high-stakes standardized test
Much has been written in recent years about Finland’s vaunted education system, which has consistently scored at or close to the top in international test scores and has the distinction of operating under policies very different from those that drive U.S. corporate-based education reform. In Finland, teachers are respected and students don’t take a mountain […]    


Ravitch: The best reason to oppose the Common Core Standards
The growing opposition to the Common Core State Standards does not all stem from the same criticisms or even from the same political wing. Included in the anti-Core camp are conservatives, moderates and liberals who don’t offer identical critiques of the initiative. Some don’t like it academically; some don’t like it politically. In this post, […]    

3-23-14 The Answer Sheet
The Answer Sheet: Kindergarten teacher: My job is now about tests and data — not children. I quit.Susan Sluyter is a veteran teacher of young children in the Cambridge Public Schools who has been connected to the district for nearly 20 years and teaching for more than 25 years. Last month she sent a resignation letter ( “with deep love and a broken heart”) explaining that she could no longer align


3-24-14 Scathing Purple Musings | Color me purple in Florida

Scathing Purple Musings | Color me purple in Florida, red in Washington, dark sky-blue in Israel and public school in Education:








About Those Teachers in Jeb Bush’s TV Spots
StateImpact’s John O’Connor reported on the start of a new TV advertising campaign from one of Jeb Bush’s foundations to promote Common Core Standards: The education foundation founded by former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush has launched a new web site and advertising campaign to support the Common Core math and language arts standards facing criticism in many states. The campaign by the Foundation For Ex


Islamic Schools Already Participating in Florida’s Voucher Program

Bob Stover, the executive editor of Florida Today, uncovered something that many Floridians will find troubling. Stover writes this in his piece critical of Rep. Ritch Workman’s (R-Melbourne) position on voucher expansion: To appreciate the Islamic connection, you have to remember that before this school year started, Workman put on his crusader armor and complained loudly to the school board abou
3-23-14 Scathing Purple Musings | Color me purple in Florida
Scathing Purple Musings | Color me purple in Florida, red in Washington, dark sky-blue in Israel and public school in Education: AIR’s Connections to Florida’s “Miserable” VAM ScoresLakeland Ledger columnist Glenn Marston dug deeper into Florida’s new testing contractor: More concerning about AIR’s Florida connections is the miserable teacher-grading program it created for the state, known as the