Latest News and Comment from Education

Wednesday, February 26, 2014

Public Pension Reform Series | Brookings Institution

Public Pension Reform Series | Brookings Institution:



In their June 2013 paper, Are Public Pensions Keeping Up with the Times?, Matthew M. Chingos, Grover J. Whitehurst, and Richard W. Johnson reported a $2.7 trillion nationwide funding gap in states’ public pension systems. In two new follow-up papers, Chingos, Whitehurst and colleagues seek to answer the inevitable question provoked by their initial work: What can be done about the rampant underfunding of public pension systems? 
Improving Public Pensions: Balancing Competing Priorities  by Patten Priestley Mahler, Chingos, and Whitehurst makes a significant contribution to the public pension discourse by providing policymakers and stakeholders with a framework for evaluating proposed reforms to pension systems – even in light of the frequently competing objectives of such systems. The authors begin by defining three essential goals of a pension system: to provide adequate retirement security; to ensure fiscal sustainability; and to maintain/improve public-sector workforce productivity.  By analyzing the performance of various pension system designs against these three goals, the authors conclude that a collective defined-contribution plan is best suited to meet the complex objectives of a pension system.
The collective defined-contribution approach to pension reform combines many of the advantages of the defined-benefit plan currently favored in the public sector with those of the defined-contribution plan prevalent in the private sector.
Whereas Improving Public Pensions provides a means by which to evaluate proposed reforms, and identifies an ideal pension plan, Pension Politics: Public Employee Retirement System Reform in Four States by Patrick McGuinn provides actionable policy recommendations for those states that are looking to enact such reforms.  McGuinn 

2-26-14 Seattle Schools Community Forum

Seattle Schools Community Forum:




Off to Austin for the Network for Public Education Conference
I am so excited to be attending this new conference.  It will be great to meet other education writers and bloggers from around the country.  The keynote speakers will be Diane Ravich and the head of the Chicago teachers union, Karen Lewis.Los Angeles special education teacher Vincent Precht will be carrying the conference on his channel here, at SchoolhouseLive.orgThe conference will begin at 8:3
District Puts Forth What is Likely Final Position on Cascade/NW Center
I attended a meeting today at the Cascade Parent Partnership school at Wilson-Pacific.  The meeting was called by Superintendent Banda who was in attendance as was Facilities chief Flip Herdon and NE Ex. Director Kim Whitworth.  The school had just finished a spelling bee and there were plenty of parents and students in attendance. I hadn't been to Wilson-Pacific in awhile.  What a pit.  There is


Boycott Common Core Assessments: Some Seattle Schools' Teachers Say Yes
The Stranger has an article (which I am in) about Common Core.   I actually didn't know that the main thrust of it was about some Seattle Schools' teachers who plan to boycott the Common Core assessments. It seems to me like the same wolf in different sheep's clothing. How could we not boycott that?" says one longtime high-school teacher. "We objected to the MAP test because we didn't kn
Waiting to Hear from Advanced Learning? Good Luck
A reader sent in the latest info from the AL webpage:If you sent an appeal to the correct address, you may assume that it has been received and filed. We do not have the resources to send individual receipts. Our office is currently swamped with emails and phone messages which would normally be answered by the same people who are scheduling and conducting assessments, making eligibility decisions



On Switching High School/Elementary Start Times

From School Start Later-Seattle:As a brief update, the school board approved transportation standards for next year that will move us to a 3-tier system in order to save approximately $3 million.  It was impossible to get the school board to consider putting secondary schools in the later tiers and elementaries in the earlier tiers.The good news is that Sharon Peaslee, board president has introduc


2-25-14 Seattle Schools Community Forum
Seattle Schools Community Forum: Great Thoughts from a Smart GuyYou know, there are some really smart people out there thinking about public education and public discourse.  I wish more people would read their writings.  It's people like Trish Millines Dziko who runs TFA Academy.  (FYI, they are having STEM Day camps during Spring Break.) Vu Le, who is the Executive Director of the Vietnamese Frie


Wait, What? Educators Highly Satisfied With Classroom Autonomy, Morale | NEA Today

Wait, What? Educators Highly Satisfied With Classroom Autonomy, Morale | NEA Today:



Wait, What? Educators Highly Satisfied With Classroom Autonomy, Morale

February 26, 2014 by twalker  
Filed under Featured NewsTop Stories
Share
By Tim Walker
Ask most teachers what workplace conditions or policies determine their level of job satisfaction, support from administration, general respect, collaborative time with colleagues, and classroom autonomy are likely to top the list. You’ll also probably be told that teacher morale has taken a serious hit over the past decade or so due to the chipping away – or outright absence – of these factors.
Then again, maybe not. A recent report from theCenter for American Progress (CAP), a progressive think-tank in Washington D.C., found that the majority of educators 1) are happy in their jobs and 2) “report high levels of autonomy over almost every aspect of teaching, including what to teach and how to teach.”
“The data suggest much different than the conventional wisdom. In fact, teachers are far more autonomous – and far more satisfied – than most people believe,” the authors write.
These findings generated considerable buzz because they obviously throw cold water on the notion that a decade of top down education “reforms” – a narrower curriculum, high stakes accountability, testing frenzy – has left the nation with a dispirited teaching force who find their work drained of creativity and autonomy. The2012 MetLife survey of the American Teacher found that teacher satisfaction had declined 23 percentage 

Schools Look to Push the U.S. Graduation Rate Even Higher
The nationwide high school graduation rate has reached 80 percent – the highest in American history. That’s what a new study released by the U.S. Department of Education revealed last month. But while more students are graduating high school than ever, the hundreds of thousands of students who drop out each year are more likely to be subject to a lifetime of poverty and lack of opportunity.Prevent
Should the U.S. Look To Singapore for Great Education Ideas?
Singapore has one of the best education systems in the world, according to international assessments. President Barack Obama and Secretary of Education Arne Duncan talk about its performance. National Education Association President Dennis Van Roekel, has praised its teacher training. And in 2012, Singapore was featured in the first-ever International Summit on the Teaching Profession as a country
NEA’s Read Across America Kicks Off in South Texas
By Brenda Álvarez Life in the Rio Grande Valley in south Texas is relatively quiet. It’s a family-oriented area, where much of the excitement surrounds local football or basketball games. On Monday, Feb. 24, however, students from two elementary schools in Hidalgo County received a special treat from local, state and national guests, who read books from the beloved author Dr. Seuss. The event was

FEB 24

Public Schools Recruiting International High Schoolers
A small town in upstate New York is joining a few other rural school districts in quietly tapping potential cash-ready international students who can bring new life to underenrolled schools. Federal statistics show that the number of international high schoolers arriving in the USA on F-1 visas has jumped from about 6,500 in 2007 to 65,000 in 2012. Federal law limits international students’ stays
Four Large School Districts to Study Racial, Disciplinary Disparities
Nashville, New York, Los Angeles and Chicago will create a network to share data and best practices in a national initiative called PASSAGE, an initiative to examine racial and disciplinary disparities and find ways to improve them. One goal is to address disciplinary disparities involving not only race but also gender, sexual orientation, foster care and transient family conditions. Source: The T

UPDATE: We can stop school closures. These infographics can help.+ Education Spring ‘Year Of Action’ Revs Up

Education Spring ‘Year Of Action’ Revs Up:



Education Opportunity Network -




We can stop school closures. These infographics can help.
In May 2013, we launched a series of infographics exposing the harmful effects of mass school closures — here they are all in one printable PDF.  read more


San Francisco Bans Suspensions for 'Willful Defiance'
Following on the heels of Los Angeles, San Francisco has become the second California school dictrict to ban suspension for 'willful defiance'. Following on the heels of Los Angeles, San Francisco Unified has become the second California school district to ban suspension for 'willful defiance'. read more




Education Spring ‘Year Of Action’ Revs Up


When President Barak Obama, in his State of the Union address, called for a “year of action,” he probably didn’t have this in mind.
An extensive and diverse coalition of forces opposed to the education policies pushed by his administration, and many state governors, is organizing on an unprecedented scale to spur a variety of protest actions, including street rallies, sit-ins, walk-outs, strikes, boycotts, and disruptive legislative actions and lawsuits.
It’s clear, last year’s emerging Education Spring that revealed a nationwide movement of diverse factions opposed to unpopular education policies has now developed substantial new organizational capacity and a more powerful voice.
The “new populism,” as my colleague Robert Borosage reveals, that is defining the economic debate in 2014 is also firing a new populist movement to reject failed education policy mandates and call for new reforms of our public education system.
“Movements grow,” Borosage reminds us, “only when harsh reality is combined with dedicated organizers and teachers.” Well, the “dedicated organizers and teachers” for a populist education movement have arrived.
Meet The Organizers And Teachers
This week, hundreds of activists are gathering in Austin, Texas for the first annual meeting of the Network for Public Education, a group with a stated opposition to the status quo education policies pushed by federal and state governments, including “high-stakes testing, privatization of 

The Myth Behind Public School Failure

Yes Magazine

“To truly understand how we came to believe our educational system is broken, we need a history lesson… To make the case for vouchers, free-market conservatives, corporate strategists, and opportunistic politicians looked for any way to build a myth that public schools were failing, that teachers (and of course their unions) were at fault, and that the cure was vouchers and privatization … In truth, standardized-test scores were going up for every economic and ethnic segment of students – it’s just that, as more and more students began taking these tests … It wasn’t a teacher problem. It was a statistical misread … Corporations recognized privatization as a euphemism for profits. ‘Our schools are failing’ became the slogan for those who wanted public-treasury vouchers to move money into private schools. These cries continue today.”
Read more …

NC Voucher Money Likely To Go To Unaccountable Religious Institutions

Raleigh News & Observer

“A new report on private schools in North Carolina finds that most of the schools available to voucher recipients are very small, unaccredited religious schools with uncertified teachers, nonstandard curricula and no public accountability … Among the key findings of the report … Only 35% of schools charge tuition that could be fully paid by a voucher (i.e., $4,200 per year or less). Of those schools, more than 90% are religious schools. At the middle and high school level, about 95% are religious schools … The voucher can be offered to any ‘nonpublic school’ in North Carolina. North Carolina has no approval process for nonpublic schools and does not require any type of accreditation or educational standards for the schools. The state does not interfere with the selection of curriculum or teachers. Although nonpublic schools must administer annual testing and make the results known to the parents, they are not required to make their test results public.”
Read more …

Boasts About Textbooks Aligned To Common Core A ‘Sham,’ Say Researchers

Education Week

“Claims from publishers that traditional instructional materials are aligned to Common Core State Standards are largely a ‘sham,’ say two researchers who have conducted extensive reviews of classroom textbooks … [The report] analyzed 40-50 textbooks covering first through ninth grades – books that are used by roughly 60 percent of U.S. school children – that were purportedly aligned to the new standards … Many were identical to the old, pre-standards textbooks … Textbook publishers generally don’t want to do thorough, meaningful revisions to accommodate the new standards … because such work is expensive and difficult.”
Read more …

Real Discipline In Schools

The New York Times

“Too many schools still use severe and ineffective practices to address student misbehavior … Rather than teaching kids a lesson, these practices increase dropout rates and arrest rates – with severe social and economic consequences. They also disproportionately affect students of color and students with learning disabilities … But these patterns can be reversed, in innovative school districts and with help from teachers’ unions … Improving school climates lessens the need for suspensions and expulsions and creates an atmosphere more conducive to learning.”
Read more …

The Student Debt Review

The New America Foundation

“Nearly 70% of students who graduated with a bachelor’s degree in 2012 took out debt for their education (above), and those with loans owed $29,400 on average (below). That represents an increase of nearly 20% in real terms over just four years. And it is a record high in both the percentage borrowing and average amount owed … The ‘Student Debt Review’ finds … especially rapid rises in student debt at private for-profit colleges: bachelor’s degree graduates at these institutions, for instance, now pay $95 more each month than their peers in 2003-04, and $153 more than students earning the same credential at public colleges.”
Read more …

FCMAT » Cali Education Headlines Wednesday, February 26, 2014

FCMAT » Fiscal Crisis & Management Assistance Team:



Fensterwald: Legislative Analyst suggests 3 ways to fix school busing formula -



Education Headlines

Wednesday, February 26, 2014
FCMAT provides links to California K-12 news stories as a service to the industry. However, some stories may not be accessible because of newspapers' subscription policies.

Parents drop Clovis Unified sex education suit

Backers of a lawsuit contending Clovis Unified's ninth-grade sex education curriculum violated state law have dropped the case and declared victory, arguing the district's standards have changed significantly since the suit was filed in 2012.

Fresno Unified leader Michael Hanson unveils first budget proposals

 Fresno Unified's superintendent hopes to spend an extra $3.5 million on school safety measures next year under an early budget plan unveiled Tuesday. The proposal would also add cash to schools' discretionary funds and reduce class sizes to 24 students in certain grades.

Roseville City School District extends kindergarten day

 Roseville City School District plans to roll out extended-day kindergarten across all 14 of its elementary campuses next school year, the result of a successful pilot program and changing curriculum standards.

Transgender law's foes won't concede defeat

Opponents of a new state law on the rights of transgender students aren't accepting defeat in their attempt to put the issue before the voters, and instead are preparing a long-shot effort to challenge the invalidation of thousands of petition signatures by county registrars.

Oakland school officials reviewing violence prevention, security at elementary school

Oakland school officials visited Fruitvale Elementary School Tuesday to review violence and safety plans and staffing levels after student cell phone videos surfaced of kids fighting on campus.

Pleasanton schools' public records now online

Want to view Pleasanton school district employee salaries, a report on complaints about a principal, or other information disclosed in response to public record requests? All that is now available on the school district's website.

Antioch's Dozier Libbey teachers file petition to form charter school

Teachers at Dozier Libbey Medical High School filed a petition this week with the Antioch Unified School District to convert the health care-themed public school to a charter.

West Contra Costa school board may seek $270 million bond

The West Contra Costa school board expects to vote Wednesday on a proposal to place a $270 million construction bond measure on the June ballot.

County trustees may move forward on appointed superintendent ballot measure

The Contra Costa County Board of Education expects to vote Wednesday on a proposal to place a measure on the June or November ballot asking voters to convert the superintendent from an elected to an appointed position.

Fensterwald: Legislative Analyst suggests 3 ways to fix school busing formula -

Bowing to pleas mainly from rural school districts, Gov. Jerry Brown and the Legislature left state subsidies for busing students to school alone when they created the Local Control Funding Formula last year, while acknowledging the $491 million program needed to be reformed.  On Tuesday, the Legislative Analyst’s Office to make the system more equitable and rational.

Frey: San Francisco Unified eliminates ‘willful defiance’ as a reason to expel or suspend students

Administrators in San Francisco Unified will no longer be able to use “willful defiance” as a reason to suspend or expel a student, beginning in the 2014-15 school year.
Tuesday, February 25, 2014

Stockton USD request for substitute pay rankles Visalia board

Pacific Law Academy Spanish teacher Charles Ulmschneider will leave work two periods early this afternoon, then travel 167 miles to Visalia, where he serves as an elected member of the Visalia Unified School District Board of Trustees.

Trustee conduct tops Alisal agenda

The Alisal Union School District Board of Trustees is preparing to muzzle itself — at least partially — at its meeting Wednesday.

EdSource: New funding law puts focus on translation for non-English speakers

School districts with high concentrations of English-learner students are facing a new challenge in ensuring that parents who need language translation are informed of their role under the funding formula for schools.

Tackling how to spend additional school funding

The additional funds are modest at first. But over the next six years, the money coming to local school districts is going up by 80 percent in some cases. And officials need to involve parents, teachers and other community members to discuss how that money — often thousands of dollars per student — can be spent to improve education.

Galt elementary teachers expected to get 5 percent pay raise under tentative agreement

Galt Joint Union Elementary School District teachers are expected to receive a 5 percent pay raise under a tentative agreement approved by the union on Friday afternoon. The action ends stalled contract negotiations.

Embattled Centinela Valley high school district schedules emergency meeting for Tuesday

The Centinela Valley Union High School District has scheduled an emergency meeting for Tuesday, providing the first opportunity for the public to address the board since a series of Daily Breeze articles detailed the big-money politics in the tiny district serving Lawndale and Hawthorne.

UPDATE: CURMUDGUCATION: Duncan, Civil Rights, & Highly Qualified Teachers + Duncan's Pre-K Top 10

CURMUDGUCATION: Duncan's Pre-K Top 10:

Duncan, Civil Rights, & Highly Qualified Teachers

Whether you're David Welch (StudentsMatter) financing the Vergara lawsuit in California, or Arne Duncan, crafting new shiny policies and talking points in DC, turning classroom teachers into a civil rights issue is all the rage. I owe thanks to Michele McNeil and Alyson Klein for some of the reporting on which this column is based.

Coming Attraction and Policy Balloons

Assistant Secretary Deb Delisle did some talking shortly after the State of the Union address about the new 50-state strategy regarding highly qualified teachers, presenting a kind of coming attractions trailer of possible policy. Fans of reformy stuff will remember that NCLB put a deadline on putting a highly-qualified teacher in front of every student in the country, and NCLB waivers initially kept that requirement in place, but the Obama administration has since quietly dropped that. George Miller, retiring top Democrat of House Education committee, NCLB co-architect, andbi-partisan educational twit, even squawked a bit about that.

This notion has floated to the surface of reformy soup at various points. There are folks who believe that we just find the Highly Effective Teachers and move them around so that they are covering the most challenging classrooms, and then a million education flowers will bloom. This 

Duncan's Pre-K Top 10


On Monday, February 23, Arne Duncan laid down some speaks on the National Governor's Association Winter Meeting. His prepared remarks touched on many areas of education, but he devoted much of his speaking to the issue of Pre-K.

Mind you, Duncan did not speak about why Pre-K is a good idea or a valuable idea, nor did he speak about what Pre-K done right would look like. In fact, he didn't really talk about the educational aspects of Pre-K at all. What he addressed was its political inevitability.

So let's see what the compelling reasons for welcoming Pre-K might be. Here's Arne's Top Ten List.

#10: There is much greater public awareness today of the importance of the early years to the long-term health, learning, and success of our children and our communities--and it is coupled with widespread public support for a big expansion of early learning.

The political ground is fertile for the planting of Pre-K support. Lots of people believe this is a good thing, although most of them are imagining something completely different from our vision. You can win votes by backing this. Also, doesn't this sound much more attractive then testing and drilling four-year-olds?

#9: A powerful, bipartisan coalition of governors are funding expansions in the states—in some cases, big expansions—of high-quality early learning programs.

There is a big bunch of money pushing this. People are going to want to be your buddy when you have the power to make them rich. Also, note the new buzzword "high-quality," which means