Monday, December 16, 2013

12-15-13 Ed Notes Online

Ed Notes Online:





Ed Notes Reprint, Nov. 2007: Welch, Tweed, Farina, and Creative Destruction
Thanks to Tim-Parent's comment at Gotham for digging up this ednotes piece from November 14, 2007, with discussion over a 2003 Carmen Farina quote in Businessweek that seemed to support the Jack Welch philosophy. But in 2007 Farina clarifies what she said with this:Farina's comment posted on the listserve Sunday, Nov. 11, 2007:"Complacency is not the same as complicity in how to evaluate scho

12-15-13 Ed Notes Online
Ed Notes Online: Change the Stakes end of year meeting - Tuesday 12/17, 5:30Join what promises to be a lively discussion about the issues and how we – as parents, teachers and students – can respond individually and collectively.....Change the Stakes Press Conference re: City Council Resolution on High-Stakes Testing - On December 9th, Change the Stakes participated in a press conference held on t


12-16-13 teacherken at Daily Kos

teacherken at Daily Kos:








Family values hypocrisy
is the title of this terrific Washington Post op ed by E. J. Dionne. He begins : Politicians talk about family values but do almost nothing to help families. They talk about parental responsibility but do almost nothing to help parents. They talk about self-sufficiency but do precious little to make self-sufficiency a reality for those who must struggle hardest to achieve it. And the occasion of h

YESTERDAY

Krugman: Why Inequality Matters
is the title of this Monday op ed in the New York Times.   It is a well-reasoned and thorough piece, full of relevant links. Krugman reminds us that inequality is not a new issue, starting with a reference to Oliver Stone's 1987 movie Wall Street with the famous Gordon Gekko quote "Greed is Good."  While politicians may have shied away from addressing inequality, Krugman believes the ele
Ann Seltzer has done a 2016 Des Moines Register Iowa Poll
and the results, which you can read here, might surprise people. Republican      Favorable        Unfavorable Candidate Paul Ryan          73                   10 Mike Huckabee   68                   17 Rick Santorum   58                    21 Rick Perry          55                   19 Chris Christie     51                   30 Jeb Bush           51                   26 Rand Paul         51      

12-14-13 teacherken at Daily Kos: 222 years ago today
Daily Kos: 222 years ago today: 222 years ago todaythe Bill of Rights was ratified and went into effect. We do not honor this day as we do Constitution Day, the day the Convention accepted the document that established our system of government. We should. George Mason would not sign the original because it lacked a Bill of Rights, and after all, he was the author of the Virginia Declaration of Rig



12-16-13 Perdido Street School

Perdido Street School:





Cowardly Cuomo Continues To Run From His Own Education Reform Agenda
From Newsday:Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo didn’t bite Monday when asked about a proposal by Sen. John Flanagan (R-East Northport) to eliminate some student testing, re-evaluate the Common Core academic standards and tighten student-data privacy. Flanagan, chairman of the Senate Education Committee, unveiled his proposed legislation last week. "Who is this?" Cuomo said when a reporter asked him a

Bloomberg Strokes His Ego On The View
In touting his accomplishments as mayor - including making the school system "dramatically better" - Bloomberg said the following when asked by the hosts of The View what he might do next:“I’ve always thought that Santa Claus is a short, Jewish, balding 72-year-old guy, so I’ll give it a go,” he quipped.Ha ha ha ha ha ha - that line is almost as funny as the one about making the school s


Regent Betty Rosa Says NYSED Rigs Data To Make NY State Schools Look Like Failures
A very important article from the Times Union about discord on the Regents Board as well as accusations that NYSED rigs the data to push its agenda:Regent Betty A. Rosa wants people to know that her board of 17 members aren't all in agreement about the public education reform agenda that's currently upsetting many parents, teachers and school administrators statewide.In fact, she thinks the Common


Wash Post & Politicker: Carmen Farina Likely To Be Named Chancellor
From Politicker:According to The Washington Post, Bill de Blasio is reportedly “likely” to name Carmen Farina, a former adviser and deputy schools chancellor, to be the schools chancellor in his incoming administration–possibly on an interim basis. A source following the process relayed similar information to Politicker yesterday.We'll see.
Daily News: 140 Principals Write De Blasio, Say Eval System Needs Overhaul
Having just undergone my second observation of the year, with two more to go, I can say that yes, the system is insane: More than 100 New York City principals are in full-fledged revolt against key Bloomberg administration reforms of the last 12 years. In an open letter to Mayor-elect de Blasio, the principals call for “completely” overhauling the new teacher and principal evaluations, among other
12-15-13 Perdido Street School
Perdido Street School: Mary Pat Christie Isn't Laughing This WeekendThe George Washington Bridge traffic lane closures scandal in New Jersey just gets more and more troublesome for Governor Blustery himself, Chris Christie.In the beginning, when critics first began to ask questions about why Christie's Port Authority appointees closed lanes to the GWB on the NJ side in September for an alleged tra



Terry Grier and San Diego Unified: What might have been | UTSanDiego.com

Terry Grier and San Diego Unified: What might have been | UTSanDiego.com:

Terry Grier and San Diego Unified: What might have been



In January 2008, the San Diego Unified School District proudly hired Terry Grier, a nationally admired reformer with a long track record of success, as superintendent. “Dr. Grier is exceptionally, exceptionally qualified,” board President Katherine Nakamura said.
A year and a half later, Grier was gone, taking a job as superintendent of Houston schools. Bruising fights over policy, budgeting and his authority led Grier to believe that the new majority that had taken control of San Diego’s school board after the November 2008 elections cared more about helping adult employees, especially teachers, than students.
Grier’s replacement at San Diego Unified, retired Adm. William Kowba, was miscast as superintendent — something board members who wanted a pliant administrator considered a plus. Kowba retired earlier this year to be replaced by Central Elementary School Principal Cindy Marten, another unconventional choice who shows promise but whom to date has been extremely cautious about saying anything that might cross the teachers union.
Earlier this month came another reminder of what San Diego Unified lost when Grier left. A new Reason Foundation study hailed Houston 

Shanker Blog » More Effective, Less Expensive, Still Controversial: Maximizing Vocabulary Growth In Early Childhood

Shanker Blog » More Effective, Less Expensive, Still Controversial: Maximizing Vocabulary Growth In Early Childhood:

More Effective, Less Expensive, Still Controversial: Maximizing Vocabulary Growth In Early Childhood

Posted by  on December 16, 2013

Our guest author today is Lisa Hansel, communications director for the Core Knowledge Foundation. Previously, she was the editor of American Educator, the magazine published by the American Federation of Teachers.
With all the chatter in 2013 (thanks in part to President Obama) about expanding access to high-quality early childhood education, I have high hopes for America’s children finally getting the strong foundation of knowledge and vocabulary they need to do well in—and enjoy—school.
When children arrive in kindergarten with a broad vocabulary and a love of books, both of which come from being engaged in conversations with caregivers daily and being read to frequently, they are well prepared for learning to read and write. Just as important, their language comprehension makes learning through teacher read-alouds and conversations relatively easy. The narrower the children’s vocabulary and the fewer experiences they’ve had with books, the tougher the climb to come. Sadly, far too many children don’t make the climb; they mentally dropout in middle school, and are physically adrift soon thereafter.
I can’t blame them; I can’t even imagine what it would feel like to be 6 years old and 2 years behind, or 13 years old and 5 years behind. But I can imagine an education system that does not let children down. It would start prenatally, to ensure healthy babies and parents who know the importance of conversing and reading with their children. It would be collaborative and community-oriented from infancy through high school, with schools, parents, day care centers, libraries, after school programs, museums, and other local resources building meaningful partnerships to give all 

Schooling in the Ownership Society: Pearson caught in the act. Says they're sorry.

Schooling in the Ownership Society: Pearson caught in the act. Says they're sorry.:

Pearson caught in the act. Says they're sorry.

Pearson, the textbook/testing publishing giant, was caught misusing its non-profit arm to bribe N.Y. and other state educators with international junkets. The British-based conglomerate which has made billions in profits as a result of its dominant role in Common Core testing, was fined a paltry $7.7 million and let off the hook for its misdeeds.

According to WSJ:
State Attorney General Eric Schneiderman opened the investigation in 2011 into whether the company mixed business with foundation work. The foundation put on conferences in countries from Brazil to Singapore, flying in state education officials for trips described by the foundation as educational.
 According to Schneiderman, Pearson executives believed the Common Core work performed by their nonprofit arm could later be sold by the for-profit organization and generate “tens of millions of dollars” for the company.

The Washington Post reports:
The adoption of the Common Core has created a lucrative opportunity for educational publishers, as states and schools rush to buy products “aligned” to the new standards.According to the 

NYC Public School Parents: City's Education Councils Seek Reforms in Message to the New Mayor

NYC Public School Parents: City's Education Councils Seek Reforms in Message to the New Mayor:

City's Education Councils Seek Reforms in Message to the New Mayor





Education Councils representing parents citywide have signed on to a letter to Mayor-elect de Blasio.  In this unprecedented show of unity, the Councils have issued a statement to de Blasio raising concerns in numerous areas, including the decision-making processes put in place by the Bloomberg administration. A copy of the letter is below.

The statement calls for, among other things, reform of the Panel for Education Policy, a return to a Community School District structure, serious changes to the way that decisions are made concerning the space allocations to schools and future construction and educational programming, and reversal of the contested co-locations approved by Bloomberg’s Panel for Education Policy late this year.  

The statement seeks immediate review of the City’s assessment and delivery of special education services.  In addition, the statement seeks parental and community input into the selection of the next chancellor, urges the City to follow state law concerning payment of rent for charter school co-locations, seeks engagement on the Common Core, seeks a moratorium on the use of standardized testing in high-stakes decisions, and asks the mayor-elect to protect student privacy.

As of December 16, Community Education Councils for Districts 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 12, 13, 14, 15, 17, 20, 21, 22, 25, 26, 28, 29, 30, and 31, as well as the Citywide Council on English Language Learners, Citywide Council on Special Education, and the Citywide District 75 Council and individual signatories from the Citywide Council on High Schools and Community Education Council 23 have signed on to the letter.  Additional Community Education Councils and Citywide Councils are expected to be added throughout the month of December.   A press release with contact information is posted here.

Louisiana Educator: State Takeover Schools Produce Low ACT Scores

Louisiana Educator: State Takeover Schools Produce Low ACT Scores:

State Takeover Schools Produce Low ACT Scores




This report is based on data provided by the Louisiana Department of Education.
The following are important questions that should be asked concerning the proper use of our taxes and the management of our public schools:
Is it good policy to allow the Louisiana State Department of Education to take over schools from our locally elected school boards? Can the state really do a better job of running schools than locally elected school boards? Why have the leaders in the states of Michigan and Tennessee been led to believe that a state recovery school district modeled after the one in Louisiana is a great way to improve student achievement?

The underlying assumption that justifies takeover recovery districts is that the takeover schools will improve the performance of their students. Otherwise it does not make sense to allow a state government to take over schools established by local citizens through their locally elected school boards. My post of December 13 pointed out that average student performance as measured by LEAP tests in Recovery District schools rank among the lowest in the state, even after 5 to 8 years of state control.

Another way to judge the effectiveness of school takeover is by comparing ACT scores of students. 2013 is the first year that all eligible students at each public high school in Louisiana were required to take the ACT test. I wanted to examine how state run schools performed compared to local school board operated 

Contradiction of School and Classroom Cultures (Part 2) | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice

Contradiction of School and Classroom Cultures (Part 2) | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice:

Contradiction of School and Classroom Cultures (Part 2)



In the last post, I described a visit to a Southern California urban high school’s four social studies classes where the dominant culture expressed values of doing the least amount of work to pass the academic course. For most of the students, classroom habits revealed far more tedium than enthusiasm for, or even interest in, learning. Most of the disengaged students treated the classes like buzzing mosquitoes that had to be endured for 43 minutes before freedom came when bells ended the period.
Then after the class observations, I walked down the hallway and watched an assembly of a few hundred juniors and seniors sitting quietly and respectfully  honoring three school athletes who, through hard work, self-discipline, and display of skills had become national all-stars. They also had football scholarships to universities in hand. These players were on a team that had consistently beat rivals and was on the cusp of becoming state champions.
The disconnect between what values and habits I saw in these classrooms and 

Great Teachers on California EdChat | InterACT #caedchat #EdChat

Great Teachers on California EdChat | InterACT:

Great Teachers on California EdChat

DECEMBER 16, 2013
a96024fc03859eef71bf0240a2c9bdc6Sunday nights at 8:00 PM (PT), California EdChat (#caedchat) is my favorite place to be online. Educators from all over our state, along with a few dropping in from elsewhere, take up all sorts of topics relating to teaching. I think in the past several months I’ve probably participated about half the time, but missed the chat last night. Too bad, because it was a topic that seemed quite appropriate for our network, Accomplished California Teachers. The discussion for the evening focused on what separates a good teacher from a great teacher. I would find it challenging to simply label myself or others “good” or “great” – but I do think one of the greatest traits  teachers can have is the ability to be honest with themselves about ways in which they are both “great” and… less than that.
On those occasions when I miss the live interaction of #caedchat, I always go back to review what I missed and look for new and interesting people to follow on Twitter. Since this topic was so interesting and important, I decided to pick out ten excellent tweets to share. I encourage you to add your own thoughts about what makes a great teacher, or perhaps responses to specific tweets below. (If you see a tweet that starts off A1, A2, A3, etc., that means it’s an answer to a specific question from the moderator, with questions identified in sequence, Q1, Q2, Q3, etc.). And note – 

Common Core and the Food Pyramid :: Frederick M. Hess

Common Core and the Food Pyramid :: Frederick M. Hess:

Mike Rose Sorts Out Debate about Quality of Teacher Education | janresseger

Mike Rose Sorts Out Debate about Quality of Teacher Education | janresseger:

Mike Rose Sorts Out Debate about Quality of Teacher Education

This morning Valerie Strauss has published the second in a series of three articles by UCLA education professor and writer Mike Rose about college programs in teacher education.  I blogged on the first piece in the series here.
You might think a series of articles about the education of teachers sounds boring, but stop and think about the hot debate these days on this topic.  After all, Congress just re-inserted  the Teach for America exemption into the continuing resolution on the federal budget and the President signed it into law.  This is the provision that rates young people who have come through just five-weeks of summer training “highly qualified teachers.”  And there are proposals to stop all pay incentives for teachers to earn masters degrees in the subject they teach or for taking courses to improve their teaching practices.
Personally I think this series by Mike Rose is Valerie Strauss’s holiday gift to us all.  I urge you to read today’s article and also the one that preceded it.  Today Rose addresses this question: What’s right—and very wrong—with the teacher education debate?
Should we make teaching programs more selective and close smaller programs in state universities and local colleges.  Rose wisely notes, “I think we need to be cautious about conflating academic achievement with the ability to teach.  The two are intimately related, but not one and the same.”  He remembers the teachers he observed as the basis of his widely 

Do you think charter schools “know how to do middle school really well?” | Ward 8 DC Teacher

Do you think charter schools “know how to do middle school really well?” | Ward 8 DC Teacher:

Do you think charter schools “know how to do middle school really well?”

According to DCPS Chancellor Kaya Henderson, charter schools “know how to do middle school really well.” When it comes to defining the phrase “really well,” are education reformers basing their narrative on quantity over quality, i.e. proficiency rates versus growth? What do you think? In this piece, you can compare the data between charter and traditional public middle schools within DC’s most notorious ward. The data in this piece is available here and here. After examining the “tale of the tape” between Ward 8 charter and traditional public middle schools, feel free to offer your perspective, or “sound off,” in the comment section.
2013 DC School Equity Reports: Ward 8 Middle Schools
Two PCS
Three Traditional Public Schools
Tale of the Tape
Image
Breakdown
The chart above illustrates the total number of Ward 8 D.C. middle school students enrolled in one of the five Ward 8 middle schools. According to the data, Hart Middle School enrolls the highest number of students in Ward 8. In fact, Hart Middle School is almost double the size of the 

Politics of LA school board may shift | Pass / Fail | 89.3 KPCC

Politics of LA school board may shift | Pass / Fail | 89.3 KPCC:

Politics of LA school board may shift

LA Schools

Damian Dovarganes/AP

Deceased Los Angeles school board member Marguerite Lamotte
The Los Angeles school board is scheduled to decide Tuesday how to fill the seat left vacant after the death of board member Marguerite Lamotte. 
Lamotte was a close ally to the teachers' union, and her absence from the board could compromise labor's voice in district policy. She represented South Los Angeles on the board.
The seven-member school board is split. Some favor union causes, others align themselves with Superintendent John Deasy. 
Charles Kerchner is a professor at Claremont Graduate University and said with an open seat, there is a chance to swing the board further in either direction.
If a special election is held, he said expect special interest groups to come with their checkbooks in hand.
"I think that is regrettable," Kerchner said. "All kinds of interest groups jockeying 

Ethics Board responds to Parents United lobbying complaint | Parents United for Public Education

Ethics Board responds to Parents United lobbying complaint | Parents United for Public Education:


Ethics Board responds to Parents United lobbying complaint




(Cartoon: Eric Joselyn, 2011)
(Cartoon: Eric Joselyn, 2011)
Helen-about us[Updated]   If it walks like lobbying and talks like lobbying, is it lobbying?
That’s the question Parents United for Public Education and our partners asked a year ago to the City Ethics Board regarding an independent contract between the William Penn Foundation and the Boston Consulting Group (BCG) to re-make Philadelphia’s public schools. Our complaint was the very first challenge to the City’s new lobbying law which had gone into effect in 2012. The Ethics Board agreed with us that the written contracts between BCG and the William Penn Foundation “create the appearance that BCG was working for the Foundation, not the School District,” began a year-long investigation, and now we have a response.
In December 2012, Parents United and our partners – the Philadelphia Home and School Council and the NAACP – filed a lobbying complaint around the William Penn Foundation/BCG contract, to which the District was not a formal party. The BCG contract promoted charter expansion, third party management networks, the privatization of certain labor contract, and identified 60 schools for closing. BCG was presented to the public as a consultant who would study the District and make recommendations. Lo and behold, when the final “blueprint” came out, it was nearly identical to the contract that had been signed months earlier.
The William Penn Foundation solicited donors specifically for the purpose of paying for the BCG contract, and then oversaw a fund at a separate foundation that disbursed those donations directly to BCG. This structure 

John Thompson: Are Charitable Groups Crossing the Line Into Politics? - Living in Dialogue - Education Week Teacher

John Thompson: Are Charitable Groups Crossing the Line Into Politics? - Living in Dialogue - Education Week Teacher:

John Thompson: Are Charitable Groups Crossing the Line Into Politics?

Guest post by John Thompson.


I do not intend to give legal advice without a license.  It has been nearly three decades since I was a legal historian and a quarter of a century since I was a legislative lobbyist who studied the federal tax code and state laws on political activity.  Back then, we were extra careful in distinguishing between our  organization's charitable 501(c)(3) and our 501(c)(4) lobbying arm. My sense is that today's politics are more free-wheeling. So, I will limit my thoughts to the spirit of the law and the democratic principles that we should be practicing.
The IRS is proposing new rules on charitable organizations.  Most commentators are focusing on organizations such as Karl Rove's Crossroads GPS and Tea Party groups, but in education we need to ask whether new rules will apply to the "astroturf" organizations that corporate reformers use to attack teachers.   As NPR's Tamara Keith explains, 501c(4) organizations can now deny they are primarily political and still send the seemingly political message that "candidate X is terrible, call him and tell him to stop being so terrible." Under the proposed rules, that would no longer count as social welfare.
We in education know Students First as Michelle Rhee's blood-in-the-eye anti-teacher, anti-union organization, and it is a 501 C(4). Seed money for this political organization came from the Broad Foundation. In 2011, they fought the recall of Michigan Governor Paul Scott. In 2012, they spent nearly $2 million to support 105 candidates; 90 were Republicans. We could say that they exist to defeat teachers and unions in order to help schools, or we could say they exist to fight the people