Wednesday, December 11, 2013

LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 12-11-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all:

Click on picture to Listen to Diane Ravitch


Anthony Cody: Common Core and Creation Myths
Anthony Cody has discovered that there are many organizations that have published a list of “myths and facts” about Common Core standards. There seems to be a concerted effort to convince educators and the public that the standards were written by educators, or by the states, or by a huge collaboration of educators and administrators and governors, all working together. As Cody shows, there was no
NY Daily News: KIPP in NYC Has “Padded Room” for Disobedient Students
Rachel Monahan and Ben Chapman of the New York Daily News (whose editorial board strongly supports charter schools) report that the KIPP Star School in Washington Heights (upper Manhattan) has a tiny padded room where students are sent to “calm down.” According to the story: A tiny padded room at KIPP Star Washington Heights Elementary School was a real-life nightmare for two young boys who were r

Is TFA Your Favorite Charity?
Teach for America is a powerful organization. It has collected hundreds of millions of dollars in the past few years. One of its most recent IRS forms showed $300 million in assets. Its board of directors includes some of the nation’s biggest corporate and media leaders. Yet TFA is considered a charity, and many corporate funders ask you to make gifts to it, as if were the Red Cross or a homeless
Pasi Sahlberg Explains Finnish Philosophy of Education to Rhode Island Policymakers
Rhode Island won a Race to the Top grant, so of course the state is obsessed with competition, accountability, and high-stakes evaluations of students, teachers, principals, and schools. Fortunately, the great Finnish educator Pasi Sahlberg was invited by the University of Rhode Island to describe an alternate universe where entering teachers meet the highest standards, students do not take stand

The Education Agenda of the Walton Family
This post is a comprehensive review of the education priorities of the Walton Family Foundation. The Walton family has made many billions of dollars from the Walmart stores. Walmart comes into a region and undersells every local retail store. In time, the mom-and-pop stores–beloved community institutions handed down in some cases from generation to generation– close their doors, and mom and pop be

A Parent Reports on John King’s Stacked Forum in Brooklyn
New York Commissioner John King held his first meeting in New York City on the rushed implementation of the Common Core and the tests whose cut score was set so high that only 31% of students across the state passed. Among English learners, only 3% passed. Among students with disabilities, only 5% passed. The pass rates among African American and Hispanic students was 15-18%. In NYC, the passing r
Eva’s Success in Getting Whatever She Wanted from Bloomberg Administration
Eva Moskowitz is a tough taskmaster. Lucky for her, the New York City Department of Education was willing to do whatever she demanded, no matter the cost. As this article reports, what Eva wants, Eva gets. That may explain why Eva closed her schools this fall and led a protest march across the Brooklyn Bridge to demonstrate her opposition to Bill de Blasio’s demand that her charter chain pay rent
Amy Prime: What Is the Right Answer to This Test Question?
Amy Prime teaches second grade in Iowa. She wrote this post about a confusing question. The following question appeared on a test for her students. She posted it on her Facebook page to see how adults would answer it. Here is the question: Read and answer the following: Animal Alley rescued Cloud and Clip. One night, a helper saw two baby animals. They were hungry. They were dirty. The helper fed
Thanks to StudentsFirst, John King Gets a Friendly Forum in New York
Commissioner John King finally got a friendly forum about Common Core. At the only hearing in Brooklyn, a borough in New York City with four million residents, every speaker but one praised Common Core and many accused its critics of racism. Reports from those on the scene (directly to me) as well as in the media said that the speakers’ list consisted of people who were affiliated with Michelle Rh
Tom Loveless: Does the Common Core Matter?
In the spring of 2012, Brookings scholar Tom Loveless set off a firestorm when he wrote a study of the Common Core State Standards and concluded that they would make little or no difference in student achievement. He did not pass judgment on the quality of the standards but on the question of how much standards matter. He wrote: “The finding is clear: The quality of state standards has not mattere
The Most Important Post of the Day: The Rightwing Assault on the Public Sector
Jan Resseger here links to a startling expose that appeared in the Guardian, a U.K. newspaper. The Guardian gained access to secret documents showing the ties that bind a far-right network of public policy groups called the State Policy Network. There is a public policy institute in almost every state, all sharing the same far-right ideology. This group, which operates in tandem with the ALEC agen

LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 12-10-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all
Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all: AFT Video: The Real Lessons of PISAThe AFT prepared an excellent video about the real lessons of PISA. It shows graphically what the high-performing nations are doing. It shows that poverty matters. It shows that equitable resources matter. It shows that teachers need to be supported and to work in a collaborative environment. It s



12-11-13 The Answer Sheet

The Answer Sheet:





StudentsFirst gives NY ed commissioner a friendly audience for Common Core forum
New York State Education Commissioner John King was on a “listening tour” this fall to ostensibly talk with the public about the Common Core State Standards and school reform but it got cut short when people in the crowd challenged him. Some forums were cancelled, but he is back on the circuit — and on […]    

The 10 school districts with the most charter school students
A new report on charter schools says that charter school enrollment around the country has grown 80 percent over the past five years — but represents only 5 percent of  total public school enrollment (a statistic that may seem surprising given all of the attention that school reformers give to charters). The report, which is  issued […]    



12-10-13 The Answer Sheet
The Answer Sheet: Millions in private money poured into Common Core promotionIt cost money to implement and promote the Common Core State Standards. Here’s a post about where some of the funding is coming from, written by award-winning Principal Carol Burris of South Side High School in New York.  Burris has  chronicled on this blog the many problems with the test-driven reform in New York (here,

12-11-13 Wait What?

Wait What?:






State Department of Education continues to flaunt Connecticut’s Freedom of Information laws
The Malloy administration, in general, and Commissioner Stefan Pryor and his State Department of Education, in particular, may very well go down as the least open and least transparent government entity since the adoption of the Connecticut Freedom of Information Act nearly forty years ago. By constantly and consistently violating the spirit and letter of […]The post State Department of Education
Malloy’s Campaign donation controversies continue to grow
Governor Malloy’s fundraising operation continues to raise serious legal and ethical issues that harken back to the “pay to play” tactics of disgraced Governor John Rowland. In addition to a number of reports that state contracts have side-stepped Connecticut law and donated to Malloy’s re-election plans via the Democratic State Central Committee’s “federal account,” comes […]The post Malloy’s Cam
12-10-13 Wait What?
Wait What?: Jepsen, Malloy and playing politics with the law…Call it naรฏve, but some would claim that while politics is political, America’s legal system is supposed to be above or separate from the day-to-day world of politics. But as we Americans we are learning, our legal system is, in fact, extremely political and appears to becoming more political by the day. At the federal […]The post Jepsen


12-11-13 Schools Matter

Schools Matter:




KIPP Using Padded Isolation Room for Disruptive Kindergarten Students
The latest example of why children call it the Kids in Prison Program. Click below to begin CBS News video coverage.  Text is below the video.NEW YORK (CBSNewYork) — A Manhattan mother says her 5-year-old son was locked in a padded room at school, leaving the kindergartner so traumatized he had to go to the hospital.Taneka Hall said the “safe-calm room” at KIPP Star Elementary School in Washington


Colonizing Measures
by Doug Storm:Colonizing MeasuresThe UCR [Uniform Crime Reports which originated in 1929] reveals more about police behavior that it does about criminality. Some law enforcement agencies falsify the reports they submit to the FBI. Once a citizen reports a crime, police must make an official record for the crime to be counted in the UCR. Sometimes, however, law enforcement officers do not complete


MSNBC Leaning Forward into Teenage Prison Programming
This past weekend while channel surfing I found that Microsoft-NBC has reached new lows in its weekend prison programming.  It has now moved beyond desensitizing and voyeuristic window-peeping into staged adult prison life to now focusing on a cleansed view of incarcerated teenagers.  Below is the a post from almost five years ago, which seems as relevant now as it was then:MSNBC, The Prison Chann
Mark Naison Tells It Like It Should Be: Get Lost, Tisch
To Mark, thank you.From Mark:Bronx Common Core Forum where I call for the resignation of Regents Chair Merryl Tisch

New York City Council Declares Opposition to the Majority of Murders
FromEd Week, followed by my comment:The New York City Council has passed a resolution asking state officials to replace high-stakes standardized tests with multiple measures that collectively gauge student achievement.The city council's education committee approved Resolution 1394 on Monday, and the full council approved it Tuesday by a vote of 49-0, according to a staff member in Councilmember Ro

Seeking Equity: Not “If,” But “How” and “Why”
Fiction offers avenues to Truth, often hard Truths, that remain closed or less often traveled otherwise. While many people associate Middlesex, by Jeffrey Eugenides, with themes addressing sexuality and gender, this novel also confronts readers with a vivid and insightful consideration of class, race, and cultural heritage.* Toward the middle of the novel, the life of the main character, Calliope/
12-10-13 Schools Matter: Did AFT Offset Costs of Anti-Corporate Crusade with Corporate Cash?
Schools Matter: Did AFT Offset Costs of Anti-Corporate Crusade with Corporate Cash?: Did AFT Offset Costs of Anti-Corporate Crusade with Corporate Cash?The following is from AFT in 2009, when the future for corporate ed reform seemed ascendant, and Randi was on a wave.  AFT has scrubbed the video from their site, but I plugged it in to where it had been previously deleted from the Press Release.  

12-11-13 Scathing Purple Musings | Color me purple in Florida, red in Washington, dark sky-blue in Israel and public school in Education

Scathing Purple Musings | Color me purple in Florida, red in Washington, dark sky-blue in Israel and public school in Education:

Florida Council of 100

Time for Rick Scott and Florida’s Republican Legislators to Admit SB736 Was a Bad Idea
From this morning’s Daytona Beach News-Journal: Florida teachers got high marks for the 2012-13 school year, but the grades were so good — compared to student performance — that some skepticism and concern on the part of taxpayers and parents are warranted. For example, evaluations of instructional staff in the 2012-13 school year found that 97.9 percent of Florida teachers and instructional sta

Charter Schools USA’s Predicatable Rhetoric Over Hillsborough Board Decision
The editors of the Tampa Bay Times write: …the board was right to follow the staff’s recommendation to reject the plan, because the sponsors were inconsistent about the leadership structure. In its application, the foundation said a local governing council of base leaders, parents and others would have “direct oversight” of the school, including “authority to oversee the school’s finances” with th

mark as read

Charter Schools USA’s Predicatable Rhetoric Over Hillsborough Board Decision
The editors of the Tampa Bay Times write: …the board was right to follow the staff’s recommendation to reject the plan, because the sponsors were inconsistent about the leadership structure. In its application, the foundation said a local governing council of base leaders, parents and others would have “direct oversight” of the school, including “authority to oversee the school’s finances” with the foundation providing “broader strategic direction.” But the application blurred the lines of authority. In recent days, sponsors made matters worse by insisting the local council was — contrary to t
Top Bennett Aide Implicted in Grade Scandal Resigns Florida Post
From Jeffrey S. Solochek from the Tampa Bay Times Gradebook: Dale Chu, chief of staff to former Florida education commissioner Tony Bennett, resigned his post one day after his boss quit the department. Chu came to the Florida Department of Education with Bennett from Indiana, where he had been assistant state superintendent, overseeing Indiana’s education reform initiatives. He came as part of a team of Indiana transplants whom Bennett relied upon as some of his core advisers. Chu’s name also appeared on several of the emails that became the crux of an Associated Press report indicating that
What Do Jeb Bush’s Breathtaking Denials Mean?
In a stunning defense of disgraced education commissioner Tony Bennett,  Jeb Bush picked up his pen today in an attempt to save Bennett’s legacy – and perhaps his own. He wrote from his perch with Foundation for Florida’s Future. Lets take a look at a few of Bush’s stunning positions as they are published in the Miami Herald:  A man accused of trying to undermine public education, in fact, had dramatically improved it. He took on both the political left and the political right, and that cost him his job. Nobody who objectively assesses the job Tony has done in Florida can conclude he should be

DEC 09

Sick of ObamaCare? Consider JebSchools
Last year’s abrupt departure of Florida’s education commissioner, Tony Bennett, put the brakes on the ideological insanity that drove the state’s education policy-making. After three straight commissioners who were tools of Jeb Bush’ s foundations, it was time to have someone different. Pam Stewart has brought much-needed deliberate, thoughtful process back to the table. The Orlando Sentinel’s exc

DEC 08

Florida Council of 100 Uses Sketchy “Skills” Data to Justify Common Core
Tampa Bay Times reporter Danny Valentine sought out Florida leaders for quotes in the aftermath of the state’s poor PISA outcomes. Among them were the Florida Council of 100. Susan Pareigis, president and CEO of the Florida Council of 100, said in an email that the PISA results translate directly into a larger talent gap in the economy. She cited recent numbers showing that roughly 70 percent of f
Shaky Grant From For-Profit Charter School Ensnares Miami Republican Sen. Anitere Flores
Sen. Anitere Flores (R-Miami) never met a piece of legislation that benefited the for-profit charter school industry she didn’t like. Just pay no attention to the little matter that she works for one. This week’s revelations that the one she works for  received a tax-payer funded grant marks the beginning of another episode in the shady relationships between Florida legislators and the for-profit
The Week’s Florida Test Data Spin From Jeb Bush and Michelle Rhee
From Sunshine State News: Bad news for Florida’s education system: Students in the Sunshine State who took international tests in math, reading and science last year did worse than other teens in the country and performed far worse than teenagers in the world’s top-performing education systems in Asia, according to Program for International Student Assessment (PISA) scores released Tuesday mornin
Common Core’s Chickens Are Coming Home to Roost in Florida
There’s a nifty little site I can  calculate the number of days it has been since my last post – 116 to be exact. More on my sabbatical later. But it seems ironic now that my last post on August 15th was  It’s Begun: Florida County’s Republican Assembly Officially Demands Explanations on Common Core. While some Washington republicans like Sen. Marco Rubio and the Republican National Committee have