Latest News and Comment from Education

Friday, March 1, 2013

Best of the Ed Blogs | National Education Policy Center

Best of the Ed Blogs | National Education Policy Center:





Best of the Ed Blogs

Yo Congress: Sequester This!



The Case for Rereading the High School Classics - Entertainment - The Atlantic Wire

The Case for Rereading the High School Classics - Entertainment - The Atlantic Wire:


The Case for Rereading the High School Classics

If the act of rereading a book is partly about remembering the you who paged through it the first time, and comparing that version of yourself to the one dipping into that book again, the classics that we read in high school offer endless possibilities for rediscovery, for looking at ourselves then and now. That's part of what makes Kevin Smokler's new book, Practical Classics: 50 Reasons to Reread 50 Books You Haven't Touched Since High School, so much fun. His homages to 50 titles, including Pride and PrejudiceThe Great GatsbyThe Bluest EyeThe Heart Is a Lonely Hunter, and even The Scarlet Letter (he writes, "I don't like it either," but argues for rereading it nonetheless), offers a truly enjoyable trip down one's personal memory lane of books. It's also a love letter to the act of reading, to continual learning, and to making an effort to slow down and savor the good books in life.
Not all of the works Smokler writes about fall into the category of Y.A., or, for that matter, are even books (and his book, of course, is intended for grownups). There are William Shakespeare plays and Emily Dickinson poems and even the fantastic David Foster Wallace essay, "A Supposedly Fun Thing I'll Never Do Again." Many of the books he reconsiders, for instance, To Kill a Mockingbird and The Catcher in the Rye, while not explicitly intended for teens by their authors, have been huge hits among that readership. The Phantom Tollbooth is widely considered a book for younger readers, and A Separate Peace andThe Bell Jar—the latter of which a friend told him, "is for teenage girls what On the Road is for teenage boys"—are surely read most by people under 20. But more than whether the books are Y.A. or not, the idea of reading what you read then to know yourself better now is part of why I started the Y.A. for Grownups column in the first place. I wanted to reevaluate books I'd read as a kid with grownup eyes ... and I did that, but I also developed an appetite for new Y.A., and a desire to look at what it means to read those books in "reverse," as 

Modern School: L.A. Administrators Challenge Deasy and School Board on A-G

Modern School: L.A. Administrators Challenge Deasy and School Board on A-G:


L.A. Administrators Challenge Deasy and School Board on A-G


Last year, the Los Angeles School Board mandated that all students pass several A-G courses with a C or better. A-G courses are those that are accepted by the University of California (UC) and California State University (CSU) systems as prerequisites for their courses and are seen by many reformers as the minimum we should be expecting from our students under the misguided expectation that all students can and should go to college. In support of the mandate, Superintendent Deasy argued that A-G was a glowing success in other districts (e.g., San Jose).

Indeed, many districts, including my own, have also mandated that all students take A-G courses, but they do not all require a C or better for graduation. In many districts, students who 

In remote Alaskan villages, teachers struggle to make school meaningful | Hechinger Report

In remote Alaskan villages, teachers struggle to make school meaningful | Hechinger Report:


In remote Alaskan villages, teachers struggle to make school meaningful

In remote Alaskan villages, teachers struggle to make school meaningful
Wagner Iworrigan, a 17-year-old high school senior on St. Lawrence Island in Alaska, knows a lot about biology, meteorology, and math. He’s an expert at telling whether a walrus is too sick to eat, if the weather is likely to turn dangerous, and the best angle for throwing a harpoon at a surfacing bowhead whale. On a recent unseasonably warm day last fall, he skipped class to join his uncle on their boat. With nets and hooks, they motored through the choppy gray waves of the Bering Sea until the lights of their village, Savoonga, seemed farther than the stars above. They hoped to catch a seven-foot halibut or plump seal to feed the rest of the family: Wagner’s two younger sisters, a younger brother, four cousins, and a grandfather. All 10 of them share a three-bedroom house. Wagner might make a good scientist, but he’s not planning on going to college. He feels 

The Non-reformy Lessons of KIPP | School Finance 101

The Non-reformy Lessons of KIPP | School Finance 101:


The Non-reformy Lessons of KIPP

We’ve all now had a few days to digest the findings of the most recent KIPP middle school mega-study. I actually do have some quibbles with the analyses themselves and the presentation of them, one of which I’ll address below, but others I’ll set aside for now.  It is the big picture lessons that are perhaps most interesting.
I begin this post with a general acceptance that this study, like previous KIPP studies, and like studies of charter effectiveness in markets generally characterized by modest charter market share and dominance of high flying charter chains, typically find that the kids attending these charters achieve marginal gains in math, and sometimes reading as well (as in the new KIPP study). These findings hold whether applying a student matching analysis or lottery based analysis (though neither accounts for differences in peer group).
In the past few years, we’ve heard lots of talk about no excusesness and its (supposed) costless (revenue 

Geoffrey Canada joins chiefs of high finance to do what, exactly? #sequester? – @ the chalk face

Geoffrey Canada joins chiefs of high finance to do what, exactly? #sequester? – @ the chalk face:


Geoffrey Canada joins chiefs of high finance to do what, exactly? #sequester?

This isn’t getting much coverage, I don’t think. But Geoffrey Canada, vaunted head of Harlem Children’s Zone, joined a couple of members of high finance to write an op-ed for the Wall Street Journal on the looming sequester. What on earth would this man have to say about it? Well, some interesting stuff, actually. Let’s see.
One of us is a Democrat; one, an independent; another, a Republican. Yet, together, we recognize several hard truths:
Government spending levels are unsustainable.
Soft, sentimental opener. But is there really an ideological difference, by and large, between these three individuals? Not much. All right, moving on.
Most consequentially, the growth in spending on entitlement programs—Social Security, Medicaid 

The Educated Reporter: Clock Ticks Down to Sequestration Deadline

The Educated Reporter: Clock Ticks Down to Sequestration Deadline:


Clock Ticks Down to Sequestration Deadline

If you’re thinking that sequestration -- across-the-board budget cuts set to take effect today at every federal agency -- doesn’t seem like the most thoughtful course of action for Congress to try and balance its books, you have plenty of company.

“I’ve been at this for 35 years, and this is the most insane thing ever,” said Joel Packer, executive director of theCommittee for Education Funding, a nonpartisan lobbying group representing a diverse range of organizations, including K-12 school districts, higher education, research firms, and coalitions of public employees.

The Atlantic’s Molly Ball has a pithy overview of who’s really to blame for sequestration, and the New York Times has also put out an explainer of how the cuts might be carried out. As I've mentioned previously, there are more questions than answers as to how school districts might choose to make up their budget shortfalls. With personnel costs accounting for at least two-thirds of most district's budgets, it's going to be tough to fill the hole without shedding jobs. And those cuts are likely to hurt the poorest schools, which already depend more on 

MORNING UPDATE: LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 3-1-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all:

Click on picture to Listen to Diane Ravitch




Oregon: Legislator and Teachers Speak Out Against High-Stakes Testing

When I was in Portland, Oregon, last year, I met a very impressive and thoughtful state legislator, Lew Frederick.
Please watch this video, which begins with Representative Frederick’s passionate plea for a new vision of the outcomes that matter most for students–not test scores on a single day–but the kind of person they are, the kind of lives they might live, the kind of contribution they will eventually make to society.
This is the text of the bill under consideration.
Representative Frederick is followed by teachers, who explain the time lost to test prep and how their students 


Indiana: Here Comes Carpe Diem, Like It or Not

Karen Francisco,  one of our nation’s best education writers, cares about the future of public education. Writing for the Fort Wayne Journal-Gazette, she has closely watched the games that privatizers play.
In this article, she describes a startling decision by a state board to authorize Carpe Diem, an unproven charter school, in Fort Wayne, Indiana.
As it happens, Fort Wayne has excellent community public schools. I visited some of them when I was there a year ago.
But Indiana is a red, red state and the legislature and governor are determined to introduce charters and 

PTA Mom Explains Why She Marched to Save Public Schools

Kim Burkett went to Austin with her children to speak out for public schools and her community.
She noticed there were two different rallies. On one side of the building was a school choice rally, advocating for vouchers, attended by 30 people, including lobbyists.
On the other side were thousands of parents, students, grandparents, and educators.
Read her account. It gives a good portrait of the battle not only in Texas, but in many states.

Pearson: 2012 Was a Terrific Year

Coach Bob Sikes has been reading Pearson’s report to investors. 2012 was a really good year.
No mention of Pineapplegate:
” The Partnership for Assessment of Readiness for College and Careers (PARCC), a consortium of 23 states, awarded Pearson and Educational Testing Service (ETS) the contract to develop test items that will be part of the new English and mathematics assessments to be administered from the 2014-2015 school year. The assessments will be based on what students need to be ready for college and careers, and will measure and track their progress along the way.
” We continued to produce strong growth in secure online testing, an important market for the future. We 

Turning Water into Wine: The Florida Faux Miracle

Julian Vasquez Heilig of the University of Texas is one of our greatest debunkers of educational miracles. And what good timing, because Jeb Bush was in town to tout the Florida miracle, where (he say) test scores go up as costs go down. It’s all a matter of more testing, more accountability, vouchers, charters, and lots of new technology (to replace teachers).
Seems kind of strange to come to Texas to sell the virtues of testing, at a time when Texans have grown sick of testing.
Yes, Florida’s fourth grade students got higher test scores, but the longer they stay in school in Florida, the 

Welfare for the Rich?

Yesterday, the GOP legislature rushed through legislation for tax credits. This is what you need to know about ta credits and who really benefits. StudentsFirst rushed to applaud this program to benefit the few at the expense of the many, proving that Michelle Rhee deserved her title as a (rightwing) Radical.
Valerie Strauss reviews the various tuition tax credit programs, which are spreading as a form of school choice.
Unfortunately, in some of these states, the tax credits go to wealthy corporations and individuals and in some cases, subsidize private school tuition for families that can afford to pay for it without public help.
And more:
According to the National Conference of State Legislatures, there were 14 tuition tax credit programs in 11 

A Great Voice for Public Education in Arizona

If you live in Arizona and you care about your community’s public schools, then you must know Robin Hiller.
Arizona is often known as “the Wild West of charter schools,” where charters are allowed to get public money with nearly no supervision and are allowed to ignore laws about nepotism and conflicts. Remember the Arizona 

Will Republicans Kill Vouchers in Texas and Wisconsin?

When I was in Texas last week, several people–including state legislators–told me that they believe that rural Republicans will join Democrats in voting down vouchers. The rural Republicans know that vouchers would kill their local public schools, and they don’t believe that would be right.
Something similar may be happening in Wisconsin. Governor Scott Walker is eager to expand vouchers to new parts of the state, and Republican Senators are less than enthusiastic. Some say they want any voucher 

Diane in the Evening 2-28-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

coopmike48 at Big Education Ape - 3 hours ago
Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all: A Teacher Writes New Book about the Corporate Reform Movement by dianerav One of the readers of this blog, experienced teacher Brian Ford, has written a new book. It seems to encapsulate the major themes of today’s privatization movement. Respect for Teachers and the Rhetoric Gap: How Research on Teaching and Schools is Laying the Ground for New Business Models in Education (A New Economy Story about the State of the Union) Author: Brian Ford Publisher: Rowman & Littlefield Summary of Book For the last 30 years we ... more »

Kelli Stargel’s Top-Shelf Hypocricy in Labeling Opponents to Her Parent Trigger Bill | Scathing Purple Musings

Kelli Stargel’s Top-Shelf Hypocricy in Labeling Opponents to Her Parent Trigger Bill | Scathing Purple Musings:


Kelli Stargel’s Top-Shelf Hypocricy in Labeling Opponents to Her Parent Trigger Bill

Sen. Kelli Stargel (R-Lakeland) took exception to he hometown newspaper’s thumbs down on the parent trigger bill she’s sponsoring. As most observers say that passage of this year’s bill in the senate is a slam dunk, it’s puzzling why Stargel would want to draw attention to herself and her controversial bill. She wrote this in a letter to the editor of the Lakeland Ledger:
Unfortunately, this paper has chosen the defeatist idea that parents do not know or care to have a say in what is best for their children. This is a dangerous mantra believing only the bureaucrats know what is best. I wholeheartedly disagree.
Wow.
For any Florida legislator to accuse opposition to their education agenda as engaging in mantras is rich. Calling 

School Employee Accidentally Shot During District-Sponsored Gun Class | toteachornototeach

School Employee Accidentally Shot During District-Sponsored Gun Class | toteachornototeach:


School Employee Accidentally Shot During District-Sponsored Gun Class

Glenn Geddie, Texas School Employee, 
Accidentally Shot During District-Sponsored Gun Training

By Alana Horowitz
An employee at a Texas public school was accidentally shot on Wednesday during a district-sponsored handgun safety class, KLTV reports.
According to KLTV, Glenn Geddie was a maintenance worker for the Van Independent School District. The school district voted last month to arm some teachers and other employees in the aftermath of the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting in Newtown, Conn.
District Superintendent Don Dunn confirmed that the incident occurred. Here’s his full statement, courtesy of KLTV:
At the conclusion of the CHL training on February 27, 2013, one certified person stayed for private instruction 

Jersey Jazzman: Why Is NJ BOE Targeting Special Ed Case Workers?

Jersey Jazzman: Why Is NJ BOE Targeting Special Ed Case Workers?:


Why Is NJ BOE Targeting Special Ed Case Workers?

As I reported earlier, the NJ State Board of Education, acting on recommendations from the Education Transformation Task Force, is proposing a change in state code that would allow teachers and other staff to become case managers for students with special needs.

I've received a white paper dated February 22, 2013, from a coalition of stakeholders opposed to this change (I don't yet have a link to get my readers a copy, but I'm working on it). Members include:
  • Disability Rights New Jersey (DRNJ)
  • Education Law Center (ELC)
  • NJ Association of Learning Consultants (NJALC)
  • NJ Association of School Psychologists (NJASP)
  • NJ Association of School Social Workers (NJASSW)
  • NJ Association of Speech Language Specialists (NJASLS)
  • NJ Parent Advocates
  • New Jersey Education Association (NJEA)
  • NJ Special Education Practitioners
  • Special Education Clinic at Rutgers University School of Law - Newark
  • Special Education Leadership Council of NJ
  • Statewide Parent Advocacy Network (SPAN)
  • The Arc of New Jersey
So this isn't just the teachers union complaining; these groups represent the core of special education advocacy in the state. Why are they so concerned with this change?

To answer, let's look at the Task Force's report, and their reasons for suggesting the amendment. Here's the 

Pursuit of college financial aid varies widely among high schools | EdSource Today

Pursuit of college financial aid varies widely among high schools | EdSource Today:


Pursuit of college financial aid varies widely among high schools - by John Fensterwald

Closing Schools 4 Choice (and Excellence) | EduShyster

Closing Schools 4 Choice (and Excellence) | EduShyster:


Closing Schools 4 Choice (and Excellence)

The best way to enhance the excellence of our public schools is by closing them.
It is a well-known true fact that the fastest way to improve schools in order to launch students on a path to 21st century prosperity is to close them. In fact, nine out of ten advocates of closing schools in order to promote enhanced choice and excellence have found that choice and excellence are enhanced when schools are closed. Unfortunately, closing a school while the students are still inside can prove difficult, especially in this era of putting students first.
Dear leader: know that you are not alone in your worthy cause of shuttering schools in order to offer the students who used to attend them more choice (and excellence). The outstanding experts at the Broad Foundation, which transforms urban schools by closing them, have helpfully assembled an 83 page guide to shutting ‘er down. The 

Update: Connecticut Coalition for Achievement Now Inc. fails to amend Ethics Reports - Wait, What?

Update: Connecticut Coalition for Achievement Now Inc. fails to amend Ethics Reports - Wait, What?:


Update: Connecticut Coalition for Achievement Now Inc. fails to amend Ethics Reports

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: 'We test for what we desire..."

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: 'We test for what we desire...":


'We test for what we desire..."

Howard Gardner
Harvard Prof. Howard Gardner makes a great point in his letter to the NYT in response to the D.O.E.'s announcement that Pearson was changing its admissions exam for the gifted and talented programs.
What we test for signals what we ultimately desire. The use of tests for which 4-year-olds can be prepped signals that we want to find those youngsters who can do well on future tests. In that way, the process works perfectly — whether in China or in New York City.
If we desired people who were likely to make creative advances, we would look for youngsters — be they 4 or 14 — who have a passionate interest that they pursue without a lot of prodding. If we desired people who would help build a more civil and more generous society, we would look for 10- or 12-year-olds who have found a need in their school or community and have taken steps to help 

Hooked on Reading | LFA: Join The Conversation - Public School Insights

Hooked on Reading | LFA: Join The Conversation - Public School Insights:


Hooked on Reading

By Dennis Van Roekel, President of the National Education Association
It starts early. When we are maybe age three or four or five. When we are young and impressionable. Someone close to us opens a book and reads to us about animals that talk, ghosts that live in haunted castles or pirates in search of buried treasure.
And we are hooked. We can't wait for someone to read us another story that causes our imaginations to run wild. If you've ever shared a book with a child, you know the joy and excitement this small act can bring. It's almost comical how some children want to hear the same story over and over and over — they are so spellbound by it.
Research shows that children who are read to at home have a higher success rate in school and frequently develop stronger reading skills. Reading is the foundation of education.
Unfortunately, too many children have no one to read to them. The National Center for Education Statistics tells us that almost 50 percent of children ages three to five do not get read to on a daily basis. This is staggering.
We at the National Education Association (NEA) are working to change this. We offer a number of resources to help educators improve reading instruction and to help parents develop reading skills in their children. And each year we host Read Across America, an initiative that celebrates reading and literacy and encourages more adults to
read more


New Accrediting Body for Educator Preparation Seeks Public Comment on Next Generation of Accreditation Standards and Evidence


Public Comment Period February 15–March 29
By James G. Cibulka, president, Council for the Accreditation of Educator Preparation
Education reform over the past decades has ushered in changes in standards, assessment, curriculum, and teacher evaluation.  Most recently, the focus has turned to teachers and their professional preparation; research has shown that teachers are the most significant in-school influence on student achievement. While education reform is often politicized, the opposing sides share considerable common ground. In the end, those vested in the topic of education reform agree that every student deserves the best teachers and education possible.
The Council for the Accreditation of Education Preparation (CAEP)[i] takes up its responsibilities as the new national accreditor of educator preparation providers at a time of high interest in P-12 student performance and in the capabilities of the education workforce. In this context, accreditation must be a strong lever in shaping educator preparation, assuring the public of the rigor of educator preparation programs.
read more