Thursday, May 19, 2011
Schools Matter: Join Us May 26 at Harvard Square to Protest Arne Visit
Joel Klein’s Bad Faith Argument: The Misuse Of Al Shanker | Edwize
Joel Klein’s Bad Faith Argument: The Misuse Of Al Shanker
May. 19, 2011
11:26 am
by Leo Casey
No Comments
Filed under:Education
(This is the first of two posts on Joel Klein’s essay, The Failure of American Schools, in the June issue of Atlantic Monthly.)
Last September, when Joel Klein was still at the helm of the New York City Department of Education, he delivered a luncheon talk for a business roundtable, the Association for a Better New York (ABNY). I attended on behalf of the UFT. In his spoken presentation, Klein attributed to the late UFT and AFT President Al Shanker the following phrase:
When school children start paying union dues, that’s when I’ll start representing the interests of school children.
Long before Joel Klein worked this line into his stump speech, I had come across it on the far right precincts of the web, where it is a staple of feverish discussions of the ‘malevolence’ of teacher unions.* Given the lack of source citation and the way in which the words rung so hollow as something Shanker would say, I was more than a tad bit suspicious about its authenticity.† Over the course of time, I asked a number of people — some who had worked with Shanker for many years and others who had studied his life and career as scholars — if they knew of any instance when he had spoken or written these words. Without exception, every person consulted had no knowledge
Save Seattle Schools Community Blog: UW and TFA - Part One
UW and TFA - Part One
After the Board decided SPS just HAD to give TFA the ability to come into the district, I realized they had not announced a higher ed sponsor (which they needed). In January, I contacted the College of Education at UW whose dean, Tom Stritikus, is the first TFA alum to head a college of education. There was an exchange of e-mails and a date and time set up for a meeting complete with a faculty member (his call). But it never happened as his aide called and said there was a family issue and he couldn't make it.
That's fine so I politely waited two months. I called again and this time his aide was out on jury duty and no one else could make the appointment (really). But, I never heard from the aide again.
I contacted UW's Communications who really couldn't say much about it but that I should talk to the communications person in the College (who I didn't know existed). I was somewhat irritated by then so I contacted the Vice-Provost whose office "lost" my e-mail so I re-sent it. Seeing a pattern?