Friday, December 10, 2010

Sam Chaltain: Is Michelle Rhee Putting Students First?

Sam Chaltain: Is Michelle Rhee Putting Students First?

Like everyone else who does education for a living, I read that Michelle Rhee is launching a new national advocacy organization, Students First. And after checking out the site and hearing how she articulates its purpose, I see some reasons to feel hopeful -- and many more reasons to feel deeply concerned.

First, the good news: It's hard to argue with Rhee's four "we believe" statements for the organization. Who doesn't believe all children deserve great teachers? Who would argue with the idea that students should not need luck to get a good education? Why not start allocating public dollars where they can make the biggest difference? And who would deny the need for more parental involvement and increased efforts to engage the entire community? So let's all hop on the Rhee express, right? Well, maybe.

It's also clear Ms. Rhee understands which advocacy efforts have been most successful and what sort of work we might therefore expect from Students First: "From the National Rifle Association to

Mo Better Accountability: An IEP

Mo Better Accountability: An IEP

Mo Better Accountability: An IEP

Too much valuable instruction time is taken away from teaching meaningful tasks that could lead to more independent lives, the tests are not respectful of the students and they do not accurately reflect the goals of the students’ Individual Educational Plans, parents and educators said.

So say Maryland parents and educators unhappy with a test called the Alt-MSA, which assesses severely disabled kids and takes too much valuable time away from instruction. They claim that the IEP process ensures

Schools Matter: Charles Payne Calls Out "Militant Ignorance"

Schools Matter: Charles Payne Calls Out "Militant Ignorance"

Charles Payne Calls Out "Militant Ignorance"

I went over to Boston College the other night to hear U. of Chicago prof., Charles Payne, speak as the keynoter at the 11th annual Lynch School of Education Fall Symposium, which was originally scheduled for October but got pushed back to December. Whatever the reason, Dr. Payne shared the evening's bill with the 2010 Exemplary Teacher Awards, which served to compress the professor's remarks into a thin broth of ed reform news, with almost an equal amount of time given to two BC professors to respond to Payne's remarks. Which left the Q & A session sounding more like a hurried auction than a deliberative consideration of the esteemed professor's message. Very odd.

Given the limitations, however, Dr. Payne's overview was offered with his signature pointed humor and measured

This Week In Education: Thompson: The Link Between Bathroom Breaks & Tasers

This Week In Education: Thompson: The Link Between Bathroom Breaks & Tasers

Thompson: The Link Between Bathroom Breaks & Tasers

MurrybWhen a student asks for a bathroom pass, I always told my kids, the proper answer is "of course." If there was a reason why I could not issue a pass at a certain time, I owed the students a respectful explanation. Because the system could not assess disciplinary consequences on chronically disruptive students, I would acknowledge, the entire school remained in perpetual


Charters: Ten Things Charters Won't Tell You

From the Wall Street Journal's SmartMoney series, no less:

1. We're no better than public schools.

2. Our teachers aren’t certified.

3. Plus, they keep quitting.

4. Students with disabilities need not apply.

State agrees to go “fee free” at public schools - SignOnSanDiego.com

State agrees to go “fee free” at public schools - SignOnSanDiego.com

State agrees to go “fee free” at public schools

Settling lawsuit, officials aim to stop unconstitutional charges

Take action

• To request a refund of a student fee in San Diego, call the district’s legal office at 619-725-5630.

• To report a fee charged in violation of the Constitution, call The Watchdog at 619-293-2275 or email watchdog@uniontrib.com

California will crack down on myriad illegal school fees charged to students taking part in such programs as art, athletics, band, cheer and gym if a landmark lawsuit settlement announced Thursday is approved.

The agreement hinges on court approval and legislation that would require a standard complaint process for students, annual audits of such fees, fines for districts for charging them illegally, and resolution for families within 30 days of any illegal charges.

The state Constitution requires a free education be available to children. A 1984 Supreme Court ruling determined that extracurricular activities are an extension of that promise. Even so,

Rick Ayers: Taking Back the Narrative from Arne Duncan

Rick Ayers: Taking Back the Narrative from Arne Duncan

Secretary of Education Arne Duncan had one of those high concept PBS interviews with Gwen Ifill the other day. What struck me is how the reactionaries have seized the narrative, taken over the points of arguments that we -- progressive teachers, social justice activists and critical students -- developed in the first place.

For example: Nothing was more irritating in a faculty meeting than to hear the old-line, do-nothing elitists declare that they could not make African-American and Latino urban students succeed. It was, after all, a problem of the home, of poverty, of broader problems than we could deal with. These arguments, and their barely disguised racism, were proffered as a reason we should do nothing. After all, they seemed to say, we simply need to find the "talented" and "smart" kids, the ones like ourselves, and work with them. Ugh.

We would fight back. No, school does not have to be a sorting mechanism, it does not have to reproduce class and racial stratification. We can teach all kids and can make them successful -- but we have to rethink curriculum, we have to build community, we have to change our whole approach to school structure. As Michelle Fine argued, schools are the one place where the