Latest News and Comment from Education

Sunday, April 14, 2013

Principals as Instructional Leaders: Rhetoric and Reality (Part 2) | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice

Principals as Instructional Leaders: Rhetoric and Reality (Part 2) | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice:


Principals as Instructional Leaders: Rhetoric and Reality (Part 2)

Past and current research on principals reveal that school-site leaders perform managerial, instructional, and political roles in and out of their schools. Of these multiple (and often conflicting) roles, however, the instructional leader role has been spotlighted as a “must” for these men and women because, as the theory (and rhetoric) goes, it is crucial to improving teacher performance and student academic achievement.
Yet studies of principal behavior in schools makes clear that spending time in classrooms to observe, monitor, and evaluate classroom lessons do not necessarily lead to better teaching or higher student achievement on standardized tests. Where there is a correlation between principals’ influence on teachers and student performance, it occurs when principals create and sustain an academic ethos in the school, organize instruction across the school, and align school lessons to district standards and standardized test items. There is hardly any positive association between principals walking in and out of classrooms a half-dozen times a day and conferring briefly with teaches about those five-minute visits.The reality of daily principal actions conflicts with the theory.
Much of the rhetoric of instructional leadership flowing from true believers in the theory rings hollow whe