Latest News and Comment from Education

Monday, June 27, 2011

Shanker Blog » College Isn't Quite The (Self-Perceived) Middle Class Ticket It Used To Be

Shanker Blog » College Isn't Quite The (Self-Perceived) Middle Class Ticket It Used To Be

College Isn’t Quite The (Self-Perceived) Middle Class Ticket It Used To Be

In a previous post, I presented some simple data on “subjective class identification,” which is the practice of asking people to place themselves within a class structure. The data show that, despite constant political rhetoric appealing the U.S. “middle class,” more people actually consider themselves to be working class than middle class, and that this hasn’t changed much over the past thirty years.

I also noted that there is even a fairly significant “working class presence” – about 25 percent – among the highly educated (those with a bachelor’s or higher). This struck me as interesting, given the fact that having a college degree is sometimes called “the ticket to the middle class,” and also given that the income advantage for college graduates – the “college wage premium” – is substantial (and it’s actually increased over the long term). I found myself wondering whether the relationship between having a college degree and “gaining entrance” to the middle class (at least by one’s own judgment of his or her class position) had changed over time. In other words, when it