Latest News and Comment from Education

Monday, March 4, 2013

Big Education Ape - SPECIAL Mid Day Banana Break 3-4-13 #soschat #edreform



Big Education Ape - Mid Day Banana Break




Sequestration Cuts Forcing Schools That Serve Military, Native American Students To Squeeze

When President Barack Obama signed an executive order Friday night mandating across-the-board spending cuts known as sequestration, Henry Strom, the superintendent of public schools in Mt. Adams, Wash., was prepared. But the preparations hurt.

Mt. Adams serves Washington's Yakima Reservation -- many of its students are Native Americans who live in poverty. That means that unlike most U.S. school districts, Strom counts on a funding stream straight from the federal government, called "Impact Aid," to pay for one-fifth of his budget. This school year, Strom cut five teachers and five assistants -- small cuts that feel big in a tiny rural district that only has 63 teachers to begin 


Bobby Jindal's Education Reform Law Struck Down By Republican Judge

Months after a court struck down Lousiana Gov. Bobby Jindal's (R) school voucher program, the Republican star is suffering another major judicial blow to his education agenda. On Monday, a Baton Rouge judge threw out Jindal's major education-reform package, reports the Associated Press.

The 2012 law ended the practice of firing teachers in reverse order of their seniority, a major win for the reform crowd. It also made it harder for teachers to get tenure, required that the state schools chief review all school superintendent contracts, and pulled back on the power of local school boards.

Republican Judge Michael Caldwell had previously upheld most of the law after overruling the piece that limited 


What does it mean to be ‘aligned to the Common Core?’



Hite to discuss teachers contract on Radio Times

Superintendent William Hite, along with retired teacher and activist Ron Whitehorne and education analyst Andrew Rotherham, will discuss the pending teachers' contract on WHYY's Radio Times Tuesday morning.
The current contract is due to expire in August. The District's opening proposals -- leaked last week to the press-- include a steep salary cut, restructuring of the compensation system, an end to seniority and elimination of many provisions around working conditions, such as access to water fountains.
read more

Closure critics: Mayor Nutter, help us stop school closings

Popout
Opponents of the mass school-closings plan stood in front of City Hall this morning appealing to Mayor Nutter for help in stopping the District from closing 29 Philadelphia schools.
read more

Afternoon Video: "Good Luck Reading Beowulf, You Monsters!"


Afternoon Video: "Good Luck Reading Beowulf, You Monsters!"


Why Was Someone Wearing a KKK Robe at Oberlin? The Theories So Far

Oberlin College, in northern Ohio, cancelled classes today a few hours after someone (it's unclear who) wasspotted wearing KKK garb on campus. As the latest chapter in a string of hate-filled incidents at the famously liberal alma mater of Lena Dunham, Michelle Malkin, and Adam Moss, it spurred several media outlets — including GawkerThe New York Times, and The Huffington Post — to look for answers, just as campus outlets like The Oberlin Review (which documented the recent spate of homophobic and racist graffiti) and Oberlin Microaggressions, a group Tumblr that broke the news of the KKK sighting, have been doing for the past month. Here's a guide to what we know — and don't know — so far.

Theory No. 1: An Oberlin Staff Member Did It

Shortly after Gawker published an Oberlin-wide email reporting the incident and announcing that classes had 

Statement on Chancellor’s Parent Advisory Council’s Efforts To Undermine Real Parent Power

In the March 3rd issue of The New York Post, parents and other readers learned that members of the Chancellor’s Parent Advisory Council (CPAC) are going to Albany to present four position papers to legislators as part of their Lobby Day activities.  The position papers are entitled “College and Career Readiness”, “School Closings”, “Co-locations” and [...]

Paul Thomas on Mathematica KIPP Study | Diane Ravitch's blog


Student-led ballot initiative taking hold prior to March on State Capitol

As students descend on the capital and demand that more be done to increase the quality and decrease the cost of education, an extraction fee for oil and natural gas championed by UC Berkeley students is rapidly increasing its support among this core constituency. The California Modernization and Economic Development Act, or CMED, was just submitted to the Attorney General’s office, and summary and title are expected near the end of April. The 9.5% fee on oil and natural gas extracted from the state and sold on the global market would raise approximately the same amount of revenue as Senate Bill 241, a similar proposal in the Senate by Senator Noreen Evans.
However, the Evans’ bill would allocate virtually all of the revenue towards education spending, with some of the revenue allocated for the purposes of maintaining state parks. By contrast, The California Modernization and 

#huffpost lovin the “faith based reformers”

“Research shows that when expectations are raised, students rise to meet them. Adapting to higher standards and raising expectations may prove challenging, but they are the steps we must take so that our kids are successful in high schools and prepared for colleges and careers. Readiness is worth a celebration.”
Illinois Lieutenant Governor Sheila Simon made this concluding statement in her recent post at Huffington Post.
That’s it. “Research shows…”  What research?  How about an example of just one study in a peer reviewed journal?  Or is just assumed that when a person of political power makes an assertion that it must be true?  I mean why would HuffPost want to check on the validity of an assertion made by an education reformer? It’s obviously a proven fact that “faith based reforms” work.  How do we know this?  Because people like Sheila Simon said so.  And that’s enough for HuffPost.

The Education Games Endure

Writing about his students exploring George Orwell’s Nineteen Eighty-FourChris Gilbert explains:
This idea is relevant because corporate education reformers deliberately mask history.  In fact, their reforms require a forced forgetting, as the public will only embrace irrational notions if opposing ideas are concealed. Orwell’s words (below in quotes) are used here, as they were in my classroom, to expose misguided narratives and the history they obscure.
“The most effective way to destroy people is to deny and obliterate their own understanding of their 

A Parade of Women

One of the highlights of Women’s History Month this March will be various commemorations of one of the most famous civil-rights demonstrations of all time, the Woman Suffrage Parade of 1913 when an estimated 8,000 people marched down Pennsylvania Avenue in Washington, D.C., on March 3. Organized by the suffragist Alice Paul for the National American Woman Suffrage Association, the parade took place on the day before the inauguration of President Woodrow Wilson to draw attention to the exclusion of women from voting.
Rowdy crowds met the marchers, and the battle had barely begun. It would be seven more years before theNineteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution was ratified, prohibiting any citizen from being denied the right 

Update: Direct Fundraising Lags Behind

New disclosure reports available from LA City Ethics reveal that direct fundraising by candidates — limited to $1,000 per individual contributor —  continues to lag far behind outside fundraising, which is unlimited. One possible interpretation is that candidates are hoping that outside expenditures will be enough to fuel their campaigns.  Another is that candidates are waiting to see if they make it through the March 5 primary before focusing on direct appeals.
District 2 (Downtown – East Los Angeles): Robert Skeels has raised a total of $19,000, adding $2,000 since the last reporting period last month; Annamarie Montanez has raised $9,200 altogether, adding less than $100 since last month; Abelardo Diaz has raised $3,900 altogether, adding only a few dollars to his coffers since last 

Reactions to DeKalb school board ruling. Governor says time of the essence to name new board.

Among the reactions to the federal court ruling late today that the suspensions of the DeKalb board members can stand and replacements can be named:
DeKalb School Board Chair Melvin Johnson: “I respect the judge’s opinion, and appreciate the judge providing an opinion in a timely manner, because time is of the essence. It is essential that 

Daily Kos: Is teaching an art or a science?

Daily Kos: Is teaching an art or a science?:


Is teaching an art or a science?

The thoughts in this piece were occasioned by a conversation where i was asked if I thought teaching more of an art rather than a science.  I responded that the question was a false frame, and was asked to explain.
My explanation comes in part from my background and formal education in music.
I think what we are seeing in education is neither art nor science, but the attempt to turn education into an engineering problem.  In engineering, it is of course important to have rigorous standards.  In manufacturing the ideal of exactly the same interchangeable parts is an important component of mass production, which provides consistency, and may even save on cost.
But students are not, and should not be, widgets or other manufactured outputs.  They are absolutely unique individuals, and should be respected as such, even as we try to assist them in growing and developing and learning how to learn.  Please note that last phrase - learning how to learn -  we thereby empower them to lifelong learning that does not depend upon a formal school/educational setting.
Is music composition an art or a science?   Is performance of a pre-composed piece an art or a science?  Is the improvisation one sees in jazz, which is part of fulfilling the continuo of many baroque works, which was originally what was done in the cadenza of a concerto, an art or a science?
The answer is, as far as I can tell, both and to a lesser degree neither.  It is both because it is not an absolute 

Diane in the Evening 3-4-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all:








Walmart Foundation vs. Walton Foundation

Earlier today when I posted about President Obama’s decision to name the Sylvia Mathews Burwell, CEO of the Walmart Foundation, to become the head of the Office of Management and Budget, I made the error of identifying her as CEO of the Walton Family Foundation. It was obviously a mistake, and readers quickly called my attention to it. I made the change at once. I didn’t realize that the Walton billionaires have two different foundations. In addition, members of the family give a lot of money to political campaigns for candidates and issues, always on the same side of the political spectrum.
The Walton Family Foundation has given $158 million for each of the

Whose Side Are Duncan and Obama On?

Earlier today, I posted about the battle in New Mexico over the confirmation of Hanna Skandera. Skandera wants to import Jeb Bush’s “Florida Model” of testing, school grading, charters, vouchers, and online corporations to New Mexico. She worked for Bush, Spellings, and Schwarzenegger. Her views are identical to those of Romney. Yet as the linked article points out, Skandera was invited to the White a house and warmly praised by Duncan. What gives?
I am reminded that Duncan hailed Bobby Jindal’s choice of John White as state superintendent and lavishly praised him as a “visionary leader.” I am reminded that he was a featured speaker at Jeb Bush’s “summit” last 

CEO of Walmart Foundation Picked for Key Obama Job: UPDATE

Sylvia Matthews Burwell, the head of the Walmart Foundation, has been selected by President Obama to take charge of the Office of Management and Budget.
This is one of the most important policy jobs in the federal government. The director of OMB decides how money should be allocated, which programs should live and which should die. There are often intra-agency battles, but 


New York: Educators Have “Initiative Fatigue”

Please this article that appears in the latest issue of the journal of the New York State School Board Association.
It describes how many teachers, principals, and superintendents are feeling overwhelmed by the changes raining down on them.
Then comes these paragraphs:
“John King is on the wrong side of history,” author and blogger Diane Ravitch told On Board. “He is acting like a 

Paul Thomas on Mathematica KIPP Study

Paul Thomas is unimpressed by the latest study of KIPP by Mathematica Policy Research.
He firmly rejects the “no excuses” model of schooling, in which students are constantly monitored and disciplined for the smallest infractions. He believes it is classist and racist.
His main point is that the means do not justify the ends. If one’s only goal is higher test scores, they can be produced by coercion. But that is not good education. It old be akin to amputating a limg as a means of weight loss: it works but why would you do it.
Thomas quotes David Whitman, who wrote a book lauding “the new paternalism.” It is called “Sweating the Small 

Are Standardized Tests Worthless?

In response to my post earlier today about the growing movement against testing–and its misuse for rewards and punishments–Robert D. Shepherd sent the following comment:
“I think that it’s empirically demonstrable that these tests aren’t even valid and reliable as tests of reading, writing, and math abilities, much less of teacher and school performance. What’s next–shall we use the tests to 

Deborah Meier on Standardized Testing

Deborah Meier responded to an earlier post about the growing movement against testing.
I said that testing is misused now, as a way to punish (or reward) students, teachers, principals, and schools.
Deborah says that standardized testing is in itself problematic, for all the reasons she gives here:
Standardized testing was not intended to serve all its many misused purposes.
But even as a measure of an individual student it has enormous imitations. The score is “accurate” only within a very broad range==a so-called year on or off, and in 1/3 of the cases wider than that. That’s its statistical range of reliability.
However, since it only covers a certain percentage of the skills and aptitudes involved in reading or math it may

LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 3-4-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

coopmike48 at Big Education Ape - 3 hours ago
Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all: [image: Click on picture to Listen to Diane Ravitch] Why Does the National Media Ignore School Closings? by dianerav Bruce A. Dixon of Black Agenda Report asks a simple question: Why does the national media ignore mass closings of public schools? He says that if the national media gave as much attention to the school closings as it did to the privatization propaganda films “Waiting for Superman” and the “Won’t Back Down,” the public would be informed and outraged. Frankly, the idea of blaming schools for low test... more »

No Kid Hungry Starts with Breakfast — Whole Child Education

No Kid Hungry Starts with Breakfast — Whole Child Education:


Kumar Chandran

No Kid Hungry Starts with Breakfast

No Kid Hungry - Share Our Strength
More than 16 million children in the U.S. struggle with hunger, or one out of five American kids. Teachers see this hunger first-hand in their classrooms. In a recent survey, three out of five K–8 public school teachers said they taught kids who regularly came to school hungry because they weren't getting enough to eat at home.
What if I told you that there was a solution? There is, and it's called school breakfast.
Anecdotally, we constantly hear of schools that serve breakfast to all their kids, but only during testing week because educators acknowledge the connection between breakfast and success. New analysis released by whole child partner Share Our Strength's No Kid Hungry campaign backs up that connection with research showing that the simple act of feeding kids a healthy school breakfast has the potential for a dramatic impact on their academic, health, and economic futures.
In Ending Child Hunger: A Social Impact Analysis (PDF), a new report by Deloitte and the No Kid Hungry Center for Best Practices, data underscores the fact that federal programs like school breakfast are not only important in the fight to end childhood hunger, but also have potential long term positive impacts on academic achievement and job readiness. Deloitte analyzed publicly available data and academic research findings and 

Jersey Jazzman: NJ Special Education Under Attack

Jersey Jazzman: NJ Special Education Under Attack:


NJ Special Education Under Attack

Last week, I reported on proposed changes to the NJ administrative code that would shift the responsibility for special education case management away from full-time Child Study Teams. These changes would allow districts to fire case managers and either dump their caseloads on to teachers and other staff, or allow the privatization of special education case management.

This is a horrendous idea. Under the guise of "flexibility," special education students would no longer have a full-time, in-district case managers advocating for their needs. Parents of general education students should be as concerned about this as parents of special education students: the burdens of case management will undoubtedly take even more of a teacher's time away from actual instruction.

coalition of teachers unions and special education advocates are calling for parents and teachers to make their voices heard to the NJ State Board of Education, which must approve these changes. Below is their take on one of the proposals, which comes from a white paper authored by the coalition that I received a few days ago.

Let's start with the code as it's currently written. The change,. proposed by Governor Christie's

UPDATE: Seattle Schools Community Forum: Complete Letter to AG about 1240

Seattle Schools Community Forum: Complete Letter to AG about 1240:



Student Database Raises Alarms

From Reuters, well, I'll let their headline say it all:  "K-12 Student Database Jazzes Tech Startups, Spooks Parents."  (Bold mine)

An education technology conference this week in Austin, Texas, will clang with bells and whistles as startups eagerly show off their latest wares.

But the most influential new product may be the least flashy: a $100 million database built to chart the academic paths of public school students from kindergarten through high school.

In operation just three months, the database already holds files on millions of children identified by name, 


Complete Letter to AG about 1240

Here's the complete letter sent to Attorney General Bob Ferguson's office by the League of Women Voters, El Centro de la Raza, and the WEA.  From the first paragraph:

We request that your office investigate and promptly institute legal proceedings to remedy the constitutional violations arising from ...(it continues on with the RCWs in question).

Specifically, the Charter School Act improperly diverts public school funds to private non-profits in violation of the Washington Constitution and is otherwise unconstitutional on multiple grounds, including but not limited to the following:


And then they put forth their arguments.  Here's my summation:

- the "common schools" wording in the Constitution seems at odds with charter schools.  It states the definition as "that is common to all children of proper age and capacity, free, and subject to, and under the control of the qualified voters of the school district."  Well, a school controlled by a private board and/or overseen by an appointed commission is not under the control of voters.

- "general and uniform system of public schools"  - obviously charters are not uniform in the manner that regular schools are.  I find this a weak argument. as education often tries to give more options in order to reach as many students as possible.  Passing a law to further that objective has happened before.

violates the "paramount duty".  "The Charter School Act interferes with the State's progress toward compliance