Latest News and Comment from Education

Friday, April 12, 2019

A Day On The Picket Line | Larry Ferlazzo's Websites of the Day...

A Day On The Picket Line | Larry Ferlazzo's Websites of the Day...

A DAY ON THE PICKET LINE





CBS News Video Segment: “Sacramento teachers on strike” | Larry Ferlazzo's Websites of the Day... - http://larryferlazzo.edublogs.org/?p=96830 on @Larryferlazzo

As you have read here (see A BEGINNING LIST OF THE BEST RESOURCES FOR LEARNING ABOUT OUR SACRAMENTO DISTRICT’S FINANCIAL FIASCO) or heard elsewhere, our school district is not doing well, and is likely to be taken over by the state soon.
We had a one-day strike today (you can get lots of background by looking at that “Best” list), and here are some photos and article about it I shared on social media. By the way, that’s my friend, colleague, and co-author Katie Hull and I in the photo at the top of this blog post.



DeVos’s Staff Blocked Researchers Trying to Investigate Federal Charter Schools Program | janresseger

DeVos’s Staff Blocked Researchers Trying to Investigate Federal Charter Schools Program | janresseger

DeVos’s Staff Blocked Researchers Trying to Investigate Federal Charter Schools Program


Writing this week for The WashingtonianRachel M. Cohen describes the responses of eighteen federal workers when she interviewed them about what it’s really like to work for the Trump administration.
Cohen quotes an anonymous staff person in Betsy DeVos’s Department of Education, someone who reflects on Departmental priorities these days and her own particular concern: “I definitely get the sense that the appointees don’t feel many functions of our agency are necessary anymore. Words like ‘regulatory overreach’ and ‘burdensome regulations’ come up a lot, and while it’s true sometimes oversight is burdensome, and ensuring efficacy and quality can feel like overreach, we give out a lot of money—and if we don’t maintain some standard for those funds, then we’re not doing our job.”
Apparently the politically appointed leadership at the U.S. Department of Education wasn’t happy when, on March 8, 2019, the Network for Public Education (NPE) tried to investigate federal oversight over one area of departmental funding by submitting a Freedom of Information Act request for documentation of routine regulation of the federal Charter Schools Program. Jeff Bryant is one of the researchers and writers of NPE’s new report, Asleep at the Wheel: How the Federal Charter Schools Program Recklessly Takes Taxpayers and Students for a Ride.  In an article published this week at AlterNetBryant shares some simple research questions he submitted to the Department of Education and the outrageous response he received: “On March 15, I received a voicemail from an official in the public affairs division of the department asking me to call her back. The message started out nice enough but then veered toward criticism. ‘Apparently you have sent this request to multiple people,’ she said (emphasis original), ‘and that just creates havoc for everyone.’ When I immediately called her back, I explained I had merely sent my inquiry to the contacts provided on the relevant sections of the department’s website. ‘That’s understandable,’ she replied, but for ‘future reference’ I was told to send inquiries to ‘a director’—though I’m not sure who that is.  And I was told again my questions had ‘created havoc’ in the office but that department staff CONTINUE READING: DeVos’s Staff Blocked Researchers Trying to Investigate Federal Charter Schools Program | janresseger

Ron DeSantis Has ‘Big, Hairy, Audacious Goals’ for Florida Education and That’s Bad | The Edvocate Blog

Ron DeSantis Has ‘Big, Hairy, Audacious Goals’ for Florida Education and That’s Bad | The Edvocate Blog

Ron DeSantis Has ‘Big, Hairy, Audacious Goals’ for Florida Education and That’s Bad
The new governor wants to arm teachers, undermine local school boards, and generally double down on decades of education reform efforts that have gutted the state’s public schools.
For years, policy makers and pundits hyped Florida as a model for “education reform” that other states should follow. The claim was never true, but now with a green-light from new Governor Ron DeSantis, Florida lawmakers have been cut loose to prove that bad education policy can always be made substantially worse.
Since 1998, when Florida state government became a GOP trifecta controlling the governor’s mansion and both chambers of the state legislature, politicians have passed dense layers of public school “accountability” policies that former Governor Jeb Bush referred to as BHAGs or “Big Hairy Audacious Goals.”
These BHAGs include using high-stakes tests, assigning schools A-F grades(labeling impoverished kids and their public schools as “failing”), retainingthird-graders who flunk the state reading test, spending billions in public funds on CONTINUE READING: Ron DeSantis Has ‘Big, Hairy, Audacious Goals’ for Florida Education and That’s Bad | The Edvocate Blog


Hitting Left with the Klonsky Brothers on Ken Davis’ Chicago Newsroom: Lori Lightfoot, Lincoln Yards, TIFs, pensions, the Left and our Dad fought in Spain. – Fred Klonsky

Hitting Left with the Klonsky Brothers on Ken Davis’ Chicago Newsroom: Lori Lightfoot, Lincoln Yards, TIFs, pensions, the Left and our Dad fought in Spain. – Fred Klonsky

HITTING LEFT WITH THE KLONSKY BROTHERS ON KEN DAVIS’ CHICAGO NEWSROOM: LORI LIGHTFOOT, LINCOLN YARDS, TIFS, PENSIONS, THE LEFT AND OUR DAD FOUGHT IN SPAIN.




Hitting Left with the Klonsky Brothers on Ken Davis’ Chicago Newsroom: Lori Lightfoot, Lincoln Yards, TIFs, pensions, the Left and our Dad fought in Spain. – Fred Klonsky

‘The Diary of Anne Frank’ Has Never Been More Important Than It is Today | gadflyonthewallblog

‘The Diary of Anne Frank’ Has Never Been More Important Than It is Today | gadflyonthewallblog

‘The Diary of Anne Frank’ Has Never Been More Important Than It is Today


The biggest mistake people make about “The Diary of Anne Frank” is to assume it’s about a little dead girl.
thumbnail_maxresdefault
It’s not.
Anne Frank is not dead.
Not in 1945. Not in 2019.
Anne was a Dutch Jew hiding from the Nazis with her family and four others in a loft above her father’s former factory in Amsterdam.
The teenager is the most famous victim of the Holocaust, but her story doesn’t end when she succumbed to typhus in the Bergen-Belsen concentration camp in the closing days of WWII.
Her physical self may be gone, but her spirit remains.
In the 1990s, she was a Muslim Bosniak child killed by Christian Serbs in the former Yugoslavia.
In the 2000s, she was a Christian Darfuri in Western Sudan killed by Arab militias.

NYC Public School Parents: The Chancellor says no final decision has yet been made on the issue of providing student information to charters for marketing purposes

NYC Public School Parents: The Chancellor says no final decision has yet been made on the issue of providing student information to charters for marketing purposes

The Chancellor says no final decision has yet been made on the issue of providing student information to charters for marketing purposes


More on this fast-developing if infuriating story in the Daily News here.

This morning at Tweed, Chancellor Carranza spoke about his opposition to the long-standing DOE practice of allowing charter schools to use the DOE mailing lists.  He said no final decision has yet been made to change this practice– contrary to what reporters had already been told about this as late as last night and parents this morning.  He asked for parents to make their voices heard about whether they wanted this practice to continue or not.
For more on this issue, see our press release here, with quotes from parent leaders, which among other things points out that DOE is the ONLY school district in the country that provides this info to charters voluntarily, helping them recruit their students, take their space and their funding, which is now costing our schools more than $2.1 billion per year.  See also Diane Ravitch's blog, which hypothesizes that the Mayor chickened out when the news leaked out prematurely and he got blowback from the wealthy and powerful charter lobby.
Grace Lovaglio streamed Carranza's remarks to CPAC on Facebook live.  He addressed the student privacy and charter school recruitment issue for about ten minutes at 36.25 minutes in.  A rough transcript of his remarks follows:
Carranza says that he has not gone to any parent meetings where he has not heard about the “predatory nature” of charters and all the mailings.   He tells the story of one parent who told him that only one of her children not to get the mailings is the one who tested gifted and not the ones w/ IEPs.  The Mayor has spoken that this is not okay. …now somehow this has become that the district is going to cut this off. I cannot speak to whether or not this is going to happen.
The charter organizations are going to the media saying that this is unfair….I want parents to have all the info they need to make an informed decision. I do not believe that it is CONTINUE READINGNYC Public School Parents: The Chancellor says no final decision has yet been made on the issue of providing student information to charters for marketing purposes

NYC: Faced with Charter Pressure, DeBlasio Backs Down | Diane Ravitch's blog

NYC: Faced with Charter Pressure, DeBlasio Backs Down | Diane Ravitch's blog

NYC: Faced with Charter Pressure, DeBlasio Backs Down


When Joel Klein was chancellor of the NYC schools in 2006, he agreed to give the charter industry access to the names and addresses of public school students at the urging of his good friend Eva Moskowitz, who wanted to give the appearance of high demand for her schools. To this day, NYC is the only city that voluntarily turns over the names and addresses of its students to charters, which are the competition. In what other realm does one competitor give his “customer” list to his competitor, who will try to poach them and their funding too? Thanks to Arthur Camins, who made this point earlier in the comments.
After years of complaints by public school parents whose mailboxes were stuffed with charter propaganda and who objected to the breach of their children’s privacy, DeBlasio told several parent leaders that he would stop this practice.
The charter association got word of what was about to happen, and it held a press conference this morning, claiming it was “unfair” to stop the practice of turning over this information to them. Apparently, DeBlasio wimped out to placate the charter industry. Shameful.
Activist Leonie Haimson wrote about this confrontation before the news broke that the mayor had been intimidated by the charter industry.
It is unacceptable that this practice has gone on as long CONTINUE READING: NYC: Faced with Charter Pressure, DeBlasio Backs Down | Diane Ravitch's blog

Indiana: Still hating public education after all these years | Live Long and Prosper

Indiana: Still hating public education after all these years | Live Long and Prosper

Indiana: Still hating public education after all these years


For the last two decades, the Indiana General Assembly has done its best to hurt Indiana’s public schools and public school teachers. This year is no different. But before we look at this year, let’s take a quick trip back to the past to see what the General Assembly has done to hurt public education in general, and public school teachers in particular.
2011 was the watershed mark for public education in Indiana. We had all been suffering through No Child Left Behind with all its onerous requirements. Then Governor Mitch Daniels (now President of Purdue University) with his sidekick, State Superintendent of Public Instruction, Tony Bennett, worked diligently with the Republican supermajority in the legislature and the Republican-leaning State Board of Education, to make things as difficult for public education and public educators as they could. Subsequent Governors Pence and Holcomb have continued down the same path. Governor Pence, especially, was blatant in his support for private schools over public (see For Further Reading at the end of this post).
Here are a few things that the Daniels-, Pence-, and Holcomb-led supermajority has done to public schools and public school teachers in Indiana

COLLECTIVE BARGAINING
The collective bargaining process has been gutted. Just like other anti-union Republicans, the legislature has passed legislation to restrict collective bargaining to only money and benefits. No longer is it required that school CONTINUE READING: Indiana: Still hating public education after all these years | Live Long and Prosper

CURMUDGUCATION: AZ: Kelly Townsend Wants To Shut Teachers Up

CURMUDGUCATION: AZ: Kelly Townsend Wants To Shut Teachers Up

AZ: Kelly Townsend Wants To Shut Teachers Up


Arizona's #RedForEd movement was long overdue. The state has been one of the nation's top playgrounds for charter profiteers, but at the same time, they have starved public schools for resources, with low and stagnant teacher pay along with the worst level of per pupil spending in the country.

The state was lucky that its teachers walked out en masse last year, because they were already walking out one at a time and not coming back. In 2017, 74% of Arizona's superintendents reported unfilled teaching positions. Arizona's leaders seem determined to destroy their public education system; the state's teachers were doing the families of the state a favor by pushing the state to take even the tiniest steps toward saving its public education system.


Two out of three isn't bad.
Of course, not all the members of the legislature saw it that way. There's this dipstick-- GOP House Leader John Allen who theorized that teachers were working two jobs because they wanted boats and bigger houses.

But perhaps no legislator has been more angry with teachers than Kelly TownsendAfter a stint as in the Navy, Townsend became a small business operator and a doula. Townsend landed in the House in 2013 and has now risen to position of majority whip.

Right on the front page of her election website, she weighs in on #RedForEd:

Since elected in 2012, I have been advocating for more dollars in the classroom, and have been consistently supportive of teachers. was not able to vote for the CONTINUE READING: 
CURMUDGUCATION: AZ: Kelly Townsend Wants To Shut Teachers Up


Thursday, April 11, 2019

Risky Business: Long-term Damage to What America Does Best | Teacher in a strange land

Risky Business: Long-term Damage to What America Does Best | Teacher in a strange land

Risky Business: Long-term Damage to What America Does Best


Here’s a book to put on your short list: The Fifth Risk by Michael Lewis.
41ZTSdtYIlL._SX331_BO1,204,203,200_
I’ve now read a number of books (somewhere between four and six, depending on how you categorize them) about the Trump campaign and presidency–by celebrated authors (Bob Woodward) and sarcastic geniuses (Matt Taibbi) and lesser-light authors and scribes. It was a weird, unprecedented campaign and an appalling, slapdash start to a presidency–everyone from Michael Wolff to Katie Tur to Chris Christie says so.
But this is the best book I’ve read, by a long chalk. It’s barely political, focusing on the present, rather than the campaign, the Russian interference, or the 2020 election. It is, however, a blood-chilling account of just what it might eventually mean, in terms of human lives and well-being, that our country is being–What? ‘Run’ isn’t the right word, nor is ‘managed.’ That our government has been taken over by a cabal of unqualified, loutish and greedy people who are in the process of dismantling decades, centuries even, of government policy that works. Just because they can.
Lewis is his usual cynical and incisive self, and the stories he presents are interesting–case studies of how the government protects people and nurtures innovation and provides basic information to make lives and livelihoods better, everything from safe energy to nutrition to the weather. The government is not perfect, or even close, of course, but it’s served us reasonably well for a couple hundred years.
Bye-bye to all that. Reading this book was the first time I considered just how much has already been undone and what some of the long-term consequences might be. Lewis has NOT written a polemic–just an inside peek at things we aren’t considering, because we’re so distracted by this administration’s behaviors, antics and moral failings.
If you’re one of those people who thinks the government is nothing but embedded CONTINUE READING: Risky Business: Long-term Damage to What America Does Best | Teacher in a strange land

Charter critics swing haymaker bills :: K-12 Daily :: The Essential Resource for Superintendents and the Cabinet

Charter critics swing haymaker bills :: K-12 Daily :: The Essential Resource for Superintendents and the Cabinet

Charter critics swing haymaker bills



(Calif.) Leaders of the state Assembly are moving a triumvirate of bills aimed at slowing the growth of charter schools in California.
Already playing defense in the Capitol against an unfriendly governor in Gavin Newsom and its long-standing rival, the California Teachers Association—charter schools were forced earlier this year to accept good governance requirements, something that charter supporters had successfully resisted for more than a decade.
But now far more serious challenges have been proposed:
  • AB 1506 would establish a hard cap on the number of charter schools that can be operated in the state.
  • AB 1505 would restrict the options charter proponents have to getting a new school authorized and to appeal denials.
  • AB 1507 eliminates the ability for a charter school to locate outside the boundaries of the district authorizer while also restricting the location of charter resource centers.
Assemblyman Patrick O’Donnell, D-Long Beach and chair of the education committee, said the time has come to revise key elements of how charter schools are governed.
“Clearly, we need to shore up the charter authorization laws,” said O’Donnell during a hearing Wednesday. “If you are a good charter operator, you don’t have anything to worry about, but more charter school reform is needed. We cannot kick this issue down the road any longer.”
After enjoying almost unqualified support from the state’s chief executive since former-Gov. Pete Wilson signed the landmark authorization bill in 1993, the charter school movement in California is facing perhaps its most serious political test.
The showdown between charters and the CTA has been brewing for years, CONTINUE READING: Charter critics swing haymaker bills :: K-12 Daily :: The Essential Resource for Superintendents and the Cabinet

Sacramento City Unified teachers walk out for one-day strike | The Sacramento Bee

Sacramento City Unified teachers walk out for one-day strike | The Sacramento Bee

Hundreds of teachers at Sacramento City Unified walk out on one-day strike


This is a developing news story. Please check back to sacbee.com throughout the day for updates.

Hundreds of teachers across the Sacramento Unified School District walked out of their classrooms and onto picket lines Thursday morning for the first time in 30 years, staging a one-day strike alleging unfair labor practices by the district.
The Sacramento City Teachers Association expected a majority of its 2,500 teachers to join the walkout. 
The district, which serves 42,000 students, told parents in advance that schools would be open and classes would be appropriately staffed. A normal school day was scheduled, with regular attendance monitoring, bus service, meals and programs.


Rosa Parks Elementary School teacher John Brindley greeted his 6th grade students with fist bumps as they walked onto campus Thursday morning, but remained out front with a protest sign rather than join them in the classroom.
“It’s important to stand up for what you believe in. That’s what we’ve been saying to our students,” said Brindley, who has been employed by the district since 2003. “If something is unequal or you think that the things you’ve been told have not been honored, you need to stand up for yourself and make sure that people honor their word.”
Amy Sheehan, a parent of two children at Theodore Judah Elementary School in East Sacramento, brought a megaphone to the picket lines.
“We are out here supporting our teachers,” she said. “As a family, we strongly support union values. We are here to say that standing up for what you believe is right is an important thing to do.”
The strike adds to the extreme pressure faced by Sacramento City Unified, which is under the threat of state takeover as it attempts to close a $35 million budget gap.
The teachers union, which was on the verge of striking just 18 months ago before a last-minute deal was brokered that included pay raises, again voted overwhelmingly last month to strike, arguing that the district is not honoring that 2017 agreement. The district maintains it is working with the union to abide by its understanding of the contract.
In a statement released Thursday morning, the teachers union said they were forced to strike, citing unfair labor practices, because the district was not honoring its contract that would reduce class sizes and improve student services.

“SCUSD officials simply need to honor the contract and obey the law,” SCTA president David Fisher said in a statement.
More than 20 teachers stood outside California Middle School at 7:30 a.m., urging motorists passing on Land Park Drive to honk their horns. A similar number turned out at Rosa Parks Elementary, along with some young children holding signs with messages such as “teachers just want to have fund$.”
At McClatchy High School, the largest school in the district, more than 100 teachers took to the picket lines Wednesday morning. Government teacher Lori Jablonski said that group was an overwhelming majority of the school’s educators.
The strike stems from allegations by the teachers union that the district is not honoring its 2017 agreement, including directing savings from a lower quality health plan strictly toward reducing class sizes and funding more health workers and counselors. The union says the district did not reconfirm those funding allocations.
“We have extremely large class sizes,” Jablonski said. “It’s about a 35-to-1 ratio and that’s standard here. We’ve always been on edge.”
Sacramento Mayor Darrell Steinberg — who helped broker the 2017 contract — and district administrators believe the millions in potential health plan savings should go toward alleviating Sacramento City Unified’s $35 million deficit before improving student services. A new health plan has not been agreed upon.
A mediation session Monday between district leaders and the union was unsuccessful, officials said. At a press conference at Success Academy in Meadowview on Thursday morning, Superintendent Jorge Aguilar acknowledged that tensions were running high throughout the district and the city.
“Today we will focus on keeping our schools open, that we provide all the services that our students and their families deserve,” Aguilar said. “But I look forward to tomorrow, to making sure we begin the process of figuring out how we are going to come together, to make sure we put ourselves in the position where we can achieve long term viable fiscal sustainability.”
Some parents opposed the strike, saying that both parties need to come to the table.
The last teacher strike in the district was Sept. 5, 1989, when more than 1,300 teachers and several hundred other certificated workers walked off their jobs on the first day of school to demand higher wages.
The district has until June 20 to balance its budget or face a state takeover.
This is a developing news story. Please check back to sacbee.com throughout the day for updates.






Sacramento Teachers Picket Outside Schools In One Day Strike Amid Budget Crisis - capradio.org

Sacramento Teachers Picket Outside Schools In One Day Strike Amid Budget Crisis - capradio.org

Sacramento Teachers Picket Outside Schools In One Day Strike Amid Budget Crisis
Andrew Nixon / Capital Public Radio
Teachers strike outside McClatchy High School on April 11, 2019.

Andrew Nixon / Capital Public Radio

Sacramento teachers and school employees are striking on Thursday in order to pressure the city school district to fully implement a deal they made back in 2017, labor leaders say.
The Sacramento City Teachers Association, the union representing 2,500 teachers and employees, is organizing the strike. It says the picket is not over salaries, but instead because school administrators aren’t following through on a promise to fund better classroom staffing.
David Fisher, president of SCTA, says the union agreed during contract negotiations in the fall of 2017 to switch employee health coverage to save the district money, but only if it spent the freed-up money on reducing class sizes and other student services.   
“We've been trying to get these services for students for over a decade,” said Fisher. “Our ratios of school nurses, school psychologists, counselors and even class sizes are the largest and the most atrocious in the area.”
The Sacramento City Unified School District denies that class sizes are a problem. Spokesperson Alex Barrios says the school district has a massive $35 million budget hole, and it needs any savings garnered through an employee health plan change to help close the spending gap.
Barrios says almost half of the budget deficit could be remedied by switching employee health benefits.
“[School] programs are at risk if we cannot find savings in other areas,” Barrios said. “In order to find those savings, we have to work with our labor partners. We have to all work together and we have to make our priorities saving our schools from a state takeover.”
Sacramento teachers received an across-the-board 7.5 percent salary increase as a result of the 2017 agreement. The district says it spends 91 cents of every dollar on salaries and benefits, and it claims this is more than the average in other districts.  
Emotions are sky high among people who run Sacramento city schools. Last Thursday’s board meeting was packed with parents and teachers concerned about the district’s massive cash flow problems. Board members like Christina Pritchett teared up.

“My heart hurts for all of our students, and everybody that is going through this with us,” Pritchett said.  
At the meeting, board members and the public heard presentations about areas of the budget that could be slashed, such as sports, music and student centers that help children with suicidal CONTINUE READING: Sacramento Teachers Picket Outside Schools In One Day Strike Amid Budget Crisis - capradio.org