Latest News and Comment from Education

Saturday, January 4, 2014

1-3-14 With A Brooklyn Accent Go BATs All Week

With A Brooklyn Accent:

With A Brooklyn Accent Go BATs All Week





The Rich Who Hate Unionized Government Workers
I have rarely met a wealthy person who does not publicly express contempt for unionized public workers- police officers, firefighters, sanitation workers, teachers- and doesn't think they are lazy and over paid. Many blame them for bankrupting government and undermining the dynamism of the American economy. This from people whose salary and compensation often exceeds those they are attacking in mu

YESTERDAY

Thoughts on Socialism, Liberty, and Government and Corporate Powe
   As long as there is a huge concentration of wealth at the top of the society, as we have now in the US, we cannot assume that centralized government initiatives will have positive consequences. Government at all levels has become the tool of powerful corporations.  This makes the historic socialist identification with strong government highly problematical. In the US today, policies which are e

JAN 02

otorious Phd’s Quick Tips for College Teaching in the Liberal Arts.
Notorious Phd’s Quick Tips for College Teaching in the Liberal Arts.1. Make sure that the reading materials you assign are inspiring as well as informative. Don't be afraid to include literature as well as non-fiction. Students need to use their imagination as well as intellect.2. When you are lecturing, always stop and say. "Do you understand what i am trying to get across." "Do yo

DEC 31 2013

Restore Recess Party New York State- Education Program REVISED!
1. Restore Recess. No use of Recess or Physical Education time for Test prep2. Cut the state testing budget in half and use the money to lower class size and fund arts programs, sports programs and school counselors.3. No Data Sharing. No information about children can be shared with anyone outside of the school district without parental permission4 Create a new Education Policy Committee to repla

DEC 30 2013

Standing Up for Children and for Freedom of Speech
As we approach the New Year, I am more and more grateful for the existence of BATS United Opt Out and Lace to the Top. Every day, I read, or am sent, stories of teachers being intimidated by administrators for speaking out against new curricula and evaluation methods, and micromanaged to the point that all joy departs from their jobs. Along with these come stories of children tested to the point o

DEC 29 2013

What BATS Do
Last night, somebody asked me what BATS do. Here is what I answered - with a few additions1. Working to elect people to school boards, union offices, city councils and legislatures who stand strong for public education and rolling back testing.2. Testifying at all of the institutions represented above when they hold public forums.3.  Supporting ballot initiatives and petition drives which work tow

DEC 27 2013

Tough Questions to Ask About Charter Schools
The powers that be in the Democratic Party, including our President, have made Charter Schools their main vehicle for educational renewal in low income communities. And there are more than a few civil rights leaders, and elected officials in Black and Latino communities who view them as a chance to give families in their neighborhoods better educational opportunities. We have now had six years of

DEC 21 2013

The Child Abuse Taking Place in our Classrooms - A Bronx Teacher Reflects on the Toll from Uncontrolled Testing
I had a student leave my classroom in an ambulance last year during the middle of a practice test. He was having an asthma attack brought on by panic. He kept saying, "I can't do this." As his teacher, I knew him. I knew that "school" was hard for him and he was trying his best. We all were trying our best to support him: his mom, brother, teachers old and new, staff at school,
Ras Baraka for Mayor of Newark
Another important Mayoral election in the struggle to protect public education- this time in Newark- where Cami Anderson is the Superintendent and former Mayor Corey Booker worked arm in glove with NJ Gov Chris Christie to privatize local schools. The lead Mayoral candidate, Ras Baraka, is a public school principal and the most outspoken opponent of the Christie/Anderson strategy to turn Newark in

DEC 18 2013

What Veteran Teachers Should Do to Protect Themselves From Being Driven out of the Profession
The more I talk to teachers around the country, the more I am convinced that School Reformers and Government Officials are making a systematic effort to drive the best veteran teachers out of the profession, both to save money and destroy the historic memory of a time when teachers had real autonomy and input into decisions about pedagogy and curriculum. The harassment and micromanagement such tea
Video of Dr Mark Naison, Co-Founder of BATS, Calling for Resignation of NY State Regents Chair Merryl Tisch
Link to Video of Dr Mark Naison, Professor at Fordham University, and Co-Founder of Badass TEachers Association, Calling for the Resignation of Regents Chair Merryl Tisch at Common Core Forum in the Bronxhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-z1Vyrfh6r0

DEC 17 2013

The 2 Falso Principles on Which School Reform is Built
It never ceases to amaze me how many people who should know better buy the following dominant principles of the School Reform narrative 1. American schools as a whole are failing because American students are being pampered, both by their parents and teachers. We need to demand more of them to meet Global Competition 2. Schools in high poverty and moderate income neighborhoods are failing becaus

DEC 14 2013

The Crisis in Public Education is Caused by Bad Policies, not Bad Teachers
Gates, Duncan, Broad et al say they want to attract more talented people to the teaching profession but they 1. Support teacher evaluation frameworks combine humiliating observation protocols (Danielson rubric) with scripted curricula (Common Core) and use of student test scores in such a way that the most talented veteran teachers are leaving the profession in droves.2. Give financial support for

DEC 12 2013

Why A "One Size Fits All" Curriculum is a Catastroph
Today, I had lunch in Riverhead with parent activist Al Wicklund. Our meeting symbolized the new alliances being forged in the anti-testing movement- the Cop and the Professor; the Marine Corps Veteran and former anti-war protester united in an effort and to prevent Common Core and uncontrolled testing from demoralizing students and driving out our best teachers.The lunch was illuminating in many
When Common Core Is Viewed as "Just War"- The NY State Ed Dept's Politics of Cynicism
After seeing  NY State Regents Chair Merryl Tisch in action at the Bronx Common Core Forum without Commissioner King present, I am convinced the Regents are approaching the transition to Common Core as a "just war" in which they are willing to accept a very high number of casualties. The only way to stop them, since their own children will not be among the casualties, is to make the pric

DEC 11 2013

The Regents and Collateral Damage- Thoughts from a Bronx Common Core Forum
The amount of "collateral damage" those who call themselves "School Reformers" are willing to endure in their quest to prepare children ( including those not yet born) ready to compete in the Global Economy never ceases to amaze me. They claim to be motivated by idealism and a passion for equity, yet they are totally unmoved by stories of real life hardship, difficulty and abus

DEC 10 2013

“Change Course or Get Lost” Speech to Bronx Common Core Forum
Regent Chair Tisch: As a teacher and coach for more than 45 years, as a Professor of African American studies and History at Fordham, and as someone who spent years doing community history projects in Bronx schools before they were driven out by the misuse of testing to rate schools and teachers. I am here to ask for your resignation as Chair of the NY Board of Regents. Well before the recent impo
Summary of My Remarks to Regents Chair Tisch at Common Core Forum in the Bronx
What I will say to Regents Chair Tisch after describing the fear and humiliation and demoralization among students and teachers in Bronx schools that have been inspired by testing, test based evaluation of schools and teachers, school closings, and now the imposition of Common Core aligned tests scored artificially low by the New York State Education Department, thereby designating over 70 percent

DEC 08 2013

Terry Pruess Announces Her Candidacy for Presidency of Broward Teachers Union- With My Endorsement
FROM:  Terry Preuss, NBCT, Career Public Educator, BTU Executive Board Member, District Advisory Council Appointee @ www.terrypreuss.comFOR FURTHER INFORMATION AND PHOTOS CONTACT:Terry Preuss, NBCT, SBBC Teacher 954-665-5052 terrypreuss@yahoo.com www.terrypreuss.comMark Naison, BAT Co-Founder, Professor, Fordham University  (917) 836-3014!  mnaison@aol.comHerman Smith, SBBC Guidance Counselor  (95

DEC 05 2013

BATS and the Pedagogy of Joy
One of the reasons that BATS continue to grow and thrive is that we expound a Pedagogy of Joy that stands in sharp contrast to the Pegagogy of Fear and Pain which dominates current education policy. The Arne Duncans and Michelle Rhees and John Kings of the world advocate using schools to "whip students in shape" to meet the demands of global competition. Their vision turns teachers into
untitled

DEC 04 2013

My Personal Stake in Defending Teachers
My parents, children of immigrants who became public school teachers, were harder working and more capable than any wealthy and prominent people I met in my journey from Brooklyn streets and schoolyards to an Ivy League college and a Professorship at Fordham. And so is my wife Liz, a public school principal. Attacking the dignity and integrity of such people, while undermining their autonomy and j

DEC 03 2013

Job Description for New Teachers
Job Description: New Teacher.Your Mission: To Squeeze Excellent Test Results out of Frightened and Angry Children and Shatter The Achievement GapThings to Ignore: Hunger, Homelessness, Disability, Language, Chronic Illness, Family and Neighborhood Violence, Children's Talents, Personalities and Aptitudes.Things to Sacrifice: Play, Recess, The Arts.Job Security: Dependent on Results on Standardized

DEC 02 2013

A Tennessee Teacher's Letter to President Obama
November 29, 2013Dear Mr. President,I generally don't remember my dreams, and I generally don't dream about presidents, but this time, I did both. Go figure. Anyway, in my dream, I had the opportunity to meet you and talk to you face to face. You have to understand, in my dream, I am totally excited- this is a historic moment for me- since I voted for you twice, think you are an incredibly intelli

Stephen Krashen Blog 1-4-14

SKrashen:





Academic Jibberish
Stephen Krashen, RELC Journal. 43 (2): 283-285, 2012. “Some scholars have slipped so far into the stylized talk – excuse me, discourse – of academia that important ideas are rendered virtually incomprehensible to most people. Because it sometimes seems that scholarship is valued by other academics in direct proportion to its inaccessibility, some individuals may have an instinctive aversion to
untitled
A Short Paper Proposing That We Need to Write Shorter Papers
Stephen Krashen, Language and Language Teaching 1,2: 38-39. 2012 When we ask the time, we don't want to know how watches are constructed.   Georg Christoph Lichtenberg  (1742-1799)Our current journals in language education are full of long papers.  A typical journal might have, at most, five major papers. Sometimes we have to write long papers, but much of the time, it's unnecessary: the papers

YESTERDAY

STEM Fever
Sent to the Wall Street Journal, Jan. 3Sandra Stotsky thinks that the "Common Core Doesn't Add UP to STEM Success" (Jan 3) and that all high school  students should be required to take trigonometry and precalculus to be ready for the brave new world of Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math. Even if the STEM crisis were real, this is not a good idea. Of course, advanced math classes

JAN 02

The common core ignores the evidence
Sent to the Los Angeles Times, January 2, 2013Al Austin, in his letter to the Times (Jan 2) notes that the common core calls for "a sharp reduction" in literature in schools in favor of increased exposure to informational text. This policy was created without any empirical evidence. The common core designers ignored  (or were not aware of) not only studies showing that reading literature

JAN 01

Japan's 2020 push to English: A suggestion to the "panel of experts"
Sent to the Japan Times, May 31, 2013.Experts have criticized Japan's reform plan for English for not including enough hours of English instruction to accomplish its goals and have also noted the lack of resources and staffing ("English to get 2020 push but teachers not on the same page," Dec. 31, 2013).There is an easy way to help solve both of these problems and ensure that growth in E

DEC 31 2013

The Compelling (not just interesting) Input Hypothesis.
Stephen Krashen The English Connection (KOTESOL). 15, 3: 1It is by now well-established that input must be comprehensible to have an effect on language acquisition and literacy development. To make sure that language acquirers pay attention to the input, it should be interesting. But interest may be not enough for optimal language acquisition. It may be the case that input needs to be not just in
The Compelling (not just interesting) Input Hypothesis.
Stephen Krashen The English Connection (KOTESOL). 15, 3: 1It is by now well-established that input must be comprehensible to have an effect on language acquisition and literacy development. To make sure that language acquirers pay attention to the input, it should be interesting. But interest may be not enough for optimal language acquisition. It may be the case that input needs to be not just in
The Compelling (not just interesting) Input Hypothesis.
Stephen Krashen The English Connection (KOTESOL). 15, 3: 1 It is by now well-established that input must be comprehensible to have an effect on language acquisition and literacy development. To make sure that language acquirers pay attention to the input, it should be interesting. But interest may be not enough for optimal language acquisition. It may be the case that input needs to be not just

DEC 30 2013

Lifetime readers (October, 2004)
Letter published in Education Week October 20, 2004, as More on How to Produce Lifelong Reading Habits In his letter to the editor, Hugh Calkins asks what reading method is most likely to produce lifelong readers ("Why Is There No Answer to This Reading Question?"Letters, Sept. 29, 2004). A number of studies describe how dedicated readers developed their interests in reading, but a val

DEC 28 2013

What research really says about "explicit and structured" phonics
Sent to the West Australian (Dec. 28) "New reading rules for kids," (Dec. 27) states that " ...international research has found that explicit and structured teaching of phonics - the relationship between letters and sounds - is the most effective way to teach reading."  Not so. What research says is that the impact of explicit and structured phonics is strong only on tests in w

DEC 27 2013

No shortage of high-tech workers
Sent to the Los Angeles Times, Dec. 27, 2013.In "Its no sin to be rich," (Dec. 27), Richard Riordan and Eli Broad state that jobs that don't require higher education "have left the country" and the "good jobs" that will stay require technological know-how.  They conclude that we must work harder at educating our workers in technology. It is not clear that there is a d

DEC 25 2013

Arne Duncan responds to Krashen criticisms, sort of (Jan 4, 2011) on The Situation Room (CNN)
Wolf Blitzer asks Arne Duncan about my criticisms of his Washington Post article. Duncan responds, sort of. My comments are included. Duncan Washington Post article at: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp- dyn/content/article/2011/01/02/AR2011010202378.html?referrer=emailarticle My criticisms at: http://voices.washingtonpost.com/answer-sheet/education-secretary-duncan/a- response-to-arne-duncan
A Fundamental Principle: No Unnecessary Testing (NUT)
A Fundamental Principle: No Unnecessary Testing (NUT) Stephen Krashen(An earlier version of this paper was published in The Colorado Communicator vol  32,1. Page 7, 2008)Summary: Do not invest 4.5 billion on new standards and tests. Instead, work on improving the NAEP to get a picture of how our students are performing, and continue to use teacher evaluation to evaluate individual student perfor

DEC 19 2013

Advanced math: Offer, don't require
Sent to the Denver Post, Dec. 19, 2013Sandra Stotsky thinks that the "Common Core fails to prepare students for STEM" (Dec. 17), and that all students should be required to go way beyond Algebra II to be ready for the brave new world of Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math. Even if the STEM crisis were real, this is not a good idea. Of course, advanced math classes should be offere
Show us the evidence
Posted on State Impact: Ohio - Eye on Education - http://tinyurl.com/ltoc4xqIn the class described in "How the Common Core is Changing How Kids Learn in English Class," (Dec 16), the teacher urges students to "cite evidence" for their statements, part of the push for increased nonfiction in the schools. Ironically, there is no scientific evidence that anyone can cite that suppo
Do other countries teach better?
Sent to the New York Times, Dec. 19, 2013The Times asks "Why Other Countries Teach Better?" (Dec. 18). But there is no clear evidence that they do. The most powerful factor in developing well-educated citizens, not mentioned by the Times, is poverty: When researchers control for the effects of poverty, our students score near the top on international tests. A survey from the Organization

DEC 16 2013

Are readers nerds?
ARE READERS NERDS?Adrienne Schatz, Amy Panko,  Kim Pierce, and Stephen Krashen                             Reading Improvement 47 (3): 151-153, 2010Some people think that readers are nerds, "book-worms" who don't get out much, don't do much, and are simply boring, dull people.  The research, however, does not agree with this characterizaton. In fact, the results of a number of studies

DEC 13 2013

Putin and the literacy crisis
Everybody thinks they have a literacy crisis. Putin calls for a special commission to support "literature." The common core in the US has called for more nonfiction. There is no evidence for either of these positions. Nobody mentions poverty and lack of access to books.  There is plenty of evidence for providing access to books (libraries).Putin blames "creative class" for de

DEC 05 2013

Language Parents for Second Language Acquisition
Language Parents for Second Language Acquisition Stephen Krashen International Journal of Foreign Language Education, 7(3): 2 Lonsdale (2006) presents an interesting discussion of an aspect of second language acquisition many of us are familiar with but has never, to my knowledge, been discussed in print, the concept of “language parents.” A “language parent,” like an actual parent, is somebod
Do we need a new test for teacher-candidates?
Sent to Education Week, Dec 4, 2013Developing and requiring a new test for teacher-candidates is based on the belief that something is wrong with teacher preparaton ("Performance-Based Test for Teachers Rolls Out," Dec. 4).The evidence suggests the opposite is the case. When we control for the effects of poverty, American students rank near the top of the world on international tests. Al

DEC 03 2013

The common core is NOT the answer to low PISA scores.
Sent to the San Francisco Chronicle, Dec 3, 2013The media has learned nothing from the extensive research done on international test scores in the last decade ("U.S. Students Get Stuck in Middle of the Pack on OECD Test," December 3). Study after study shows that the strongest predictor of high scores on these tests is poverty, a conclusion that is backed by a number of other studies sho

CCSS: The Black Hole of Education | Ward 8 DC Teacher

CCSS: The Black Hole of Education | Ward 8 DC Teacher:

CCSS: The Black Hole of Education

Image
Stop me if you’ve heard this one before: the Common Core is “Obamacore.” No? If you haven’t, then you’ve been living under a rock, somewhere. Yes, the infamous Common Core State Standards (CCSS) has drawn criticism from the political left, and the right. It’s fascinating to witness both sides of the political spectrum unite against the CCSS. If only they could do the same for a host of other issues and policies. Nevertheless, the CCSS is the most controversial, yet distracting, piece of education reform. It literally consumes almost all education reform discussions and debates via social media. This is why I call the CCSS: The Black Hole of Education.
Now, before you think this piece will add to the long-list of criticisms and concerns, let me assure you that it will not. I’ll not express my concerns about the CCSS. I’ll not offer criticisms or credit, either. Instead, I wish to express why, I believe, the CCSS has distracted educators from doing what they do best: collaborating. I’m genuinely concerned that educators are becoming so comfortable in complaining about the CCSS, that collaboration, via social media, is often neglected. Why? Well, more and more, I’m finding it difficult to discuss anything other than the CCSS. For this reason, and this reason alone, I’ve assembled a few questions, which I believe the “black hole” of education has sucked into the ether.
#1 Is our profession reduced to criticizing education policies, alone?
There’s a wealth of knowledge among teachers, which, in my opinion, is worth sharing. I, for one,