Latest News and Comment from Education

Saturday, December 7, 2013

All Week @ The Answer Sheet 12-7-13

The Answer Sheet:





Video: Maya Angelou’s moving tribute poem to Mandela
Here is a poem that Maya Angelou wrote and delivered as a tribute to the great Nelson Mandela, who died Thursday at the age of 95. Watch it. It is worth the four minutes and 40 seconds it will take to listen.      


Four reasons it would be shocking if Kaya Henderson becomes NYC schools chief
Articles about the possibility that Mayor-elect Bill de Blasio will pick D.C. Schools Superintendent Kaya Henderson as New York City’s new schools chancellor are popping up in the New York press, apparently fueled by a recent phone conversation that de Blasio initiated with Henderson. Nobody’s reported definitely what the discussion was about, but that hasn’t […]    


Why the ‘good school’ vs ‘bad school’ debate is all wrong
Here’s an interesting look at what we mean when we talk about school and schooling, and how school reform has affected the meaning of both. This was written by Anne Pomerantz, senior lecturer in educational linguistics at the University of Pennsylvania, Graduate School of Education. By Anne Pomerantz Philadelphia’s NatIhanial Hawthorne Elementary is now a condominium […]    
The dangers of PISA envy
This was PISA week, for anybody who slept through it and managed to miss the avalanche of coverage about the newly released results of the 2012 Program for International Student Achievement, which showed U.S. students scored average in reading, math and science. Naturally there were many calls to look for best practices from the countries […]    

 mark as read

UC system president Napolitano ‘deeply skeptical’ about Education’s college rating system
Janet Napolitano, who was President Obama’s Homeland Security secretary before being named president of the University of California system this past summer, said Friday that she was “deeply skeptical” of a plan by the administration to rate colleges according to specific criteria because it is too hard to develop meaningful data points. Napolitano, who was […]    
Education ‘Day of Action’ set Monday in 60-plus cities
A coalition of education, labor, civic and civil rights organizations, led by the American Federation of Teachers, is staging a “National Day of Action” on Monday with dozens of coordinated events in cities across the country that are aimed at building a national movement to fight corporate-influenced school reform and offer alternative ways to improve public […]    
The future of high school math education
A few weeks ago a group of senior mathematicians, teachers, statisticians, and curriculum developers met in Boston to discuss the future of high school mathematics, revisiting issues addressed by a 2008 conference organized by the Center for Mathematics Education at the University of Maryland. This time, the Common Core State Standards was front and center […]    

DEC 05

A quick message for school reformers
From Montgomery County Schools Superintendent Joshua Starr — a tweet that education policymakers who like to tell educators what to do should consider: Labor Secretary Tom Perez: “what do you think” is one of most important sentences for any workplace. — Joshua Starr (@mcpssuper) December 5, 2013      
Why educating the educators is complex
One of the biggest debates in public education today is over how to best educate student teacher for the rigors of the classroom. Here is a thoughtful piece on the essence of teaching and the kind of teacher education programs we really need from Mike Rose, who is on the faculty of the UCLA Graduate […]    

DEC 04

School district to pay students up to $300 for ACT scores
The school board in Huntsville, Alabama, has unanimously decided to pay students for achieving benchmark scores on the ACT college admissions test in an effort, members said, to get kids to take the test more seriously. WHNT News voted Tuesday night for the cash incentives, which will work this way: Benchmarks scores will be set, […]    
New SAT delayed to 2016
 (Correction: The College Board corrected the message sent to members clarifying that the date for the new PSAT/NMSQT® is fall 2015. The original message had two different dates.) The new version of the SAT college admissions exam that was due to be unveiled in 2015 is now being delayed until spring 2016. David Coleman, the […]    
Harvard College’s median grade is an A-, dean admits
Grade inflation lives at Harvard University. The Harvard Crimson, the student newspaper, has reported that the median grade at Harvard College is now an A- and students most frequently get A’s. The news was delivered by Dean of Undergraduate Education Jay M. Harris on Tuesday. The paper reported in this story by Matthew Q. Clarida and […]    

DEC 03

Four lessons on new PISA scores — Ravitch
Here, from education historian and activist Diane Ravitch, the leading figure in the movement against corporate-influenced school reform, is a post with her views about the newly released scores from the 2012 Program for International Student Assessment, which showed that U.S. 15-year-old students have retained their no-better-than-average rankings in math, reading and science. Her latest […]    
A PISA contradiction
Should Americans use the newly released Program of International Student Assessment scores, which show U.S. students have retained their very average rankings, as a tool to improve education policies? It all depends on whom you ask. Here’s what the new report titled “Lessons from PISA 2012 for the United States,” from the Organization for Economic Cooperation […]    
The only international test score info you need to know
It’s PISA Day, meaning that the latest results from the Program for International Student Assessment  have just been released, and — brace yourself – the average scores for U.S. students were not very much different from any of the previous comparison years. They were generally in the middle of the pack of 65 countries and individual […]    
Key PISA test results for U.S. students
Here are highlights of the newly released 2012 scores from the Program of International Student Assessment, an exam given every three years to 15 year olds around the world in reading, math and science. In this administration of PISA, 65 countries and education systems participated. Connecticut, Florida, and Massachusetts each participated for the first time […]    
Are Finland’s vaunted schools slipping?
Finland has for years been a leader in education, scoring at or near the top of international assessments and capturing the attention of the world for its successful approach to education. But Finland is no longer at the top of international test rankings (though they  haven’t fallen very far), as newly released results from the […]    

DEC 02

Catholics split over Common Core standards
Catholic educators, scholars and bishops are engaging in an increasingly vocal debate about the Common Core State Standards, with a major split developing between those who support the Core and those who don’t. More than 100 dioceses have already approved the standards for their Catholic schools, but others are rejecting them, including the Diocese of […]    
Why is a country the size of New Mexico beating the U.S. in academic performance?
Tuesday is “PISA Day,” that is, the day that the 2012 results of reading, math and science tests will be released from the Program for International Student Assessment, or PISA, which tests 15 year olds every three years in more than 65 countries and education systems. The United States can be expected to do pretty […]    
Obama administration backtracks (again) on teacher equity
President Obama and Education Secretary Arne Duncan have talked the talked about the importance of teachers, but when it comes to providing kids with equitable access to great teachers, they haven’t exactly walked the walk. Here is a post on the issue by Tara Kini, senior staff attorney at Public Advocates, a nonprofit law firm […]    

DEC 01

How public opinion about new PISA test scores is being manipulated
This Tuesday, new reading, math and science results will be released from the  Program  for International Student Assessment, or PISA, given every three years to 15-year-old students in more than 65 countries and education systems by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development. The results are always big news — and the usual average U.S. scores […]    
Rosa Parks’s official arrest report: She refused to give bus seat to white man 58 years ago today
Here’s a piece of history: the arrest report from Montgomery, Ala., police for Rosa Parks on Dec. 1, 1955, the day she rode a  Montgomery city bus and refused to get up and move to the back of the bus so a white man could take her seat, as she was expected to in that […]    
Amazing product placement: ‘American Girl’ backpack comes with mini Pearson math book
You’ve got to give it to Pearson: They do great product placement. Who would expect an “American Girl” miniature backpack set for a doll to include a tiny math book with a cover that comes from a Common Core-aligned textbook line put out by the education publishing giant? Yes, educator and blogger Chris Cerrone found that […]    

NOV 30

The 21 books Obama bought on D.C. shopping trip
President Obama went book shopping on Saturday with daughters Malia and Sasha, taking recommendations from the staff of Politics and Prose in Northwest Washington and walking out with 21 books (see list below) that were presumably for gifts, as they were aimed at a wide age-range of readers. The president strolled in with virtually no […]    
Teacher slams scripted Common Core lessons that must be taught ‘word for word’
A public school teacher in Delaware wrote the following moving piece but asked not to be identified out of fear of retaliation. It explains what is happening to many teachers who are being given scripted lessons  aligned to the Common Core State Standards by their principals and district superintendents.  Note that this teacher is not opposed […]    
How thinking like an engineer can help school reform
Arthur H. Camins, director of the Center for Innovation in Engineering and Science Education at Stevens Institute of Technology in Hoboken, N.J., suggests a new way to make progress in education policy — through engineering design thinking.  The ideas expressed in this article are his alone and do not represent Stevens Institute.  His other writing […]    

12-7-13 Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Schooling in the Ownership Society All Week


Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog:
Schooling in the Ownership Society

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk 
Schooling in the Ownership Society


 mark as read

The struggle continues
Nelson Mandela after he was sentenced to life imprisonment in June 1964Bridget Murphy writes, re. community resistance to the military coup at Ames Middle School:The referendum drive is in full swing.  40 parents will be meeting at Ames (1920 N. Hamlin) this morning (Friday, Dec 6th) at 10:30am to continue collecting signatures door to door. We will be out on the doors every day between now and Dec 15th. Come join a pair of doorknockers! Don Washington (Mayoral Tutorial) admits he's guilty of a little hyperbole here but I think he's right-on.Mayor Rahm Emanuel is already running for re-electio
Just how much abuse will we accept?
Find out just what any people will quietly submit to and you have the exact measure of the injustice and wrong which will be imposed on them. -- Frederick Douglass If the great Illinois pension robbery holds up in the courts, many career teachers and other public workers stand to lose upwards of $200,000 in retirement income over the next decade or so as their cost-of-living adjustments are capped. This is not money that was being "given" to them as a gift. It's money that we have contributed to our own retirement accounts and money that was contractually promised us and Constitution
Chris Hayes on PISA: 'Global capitalism is like the Olympics'
Hayes says he's "skeptical of the American schools are failing line." But, he says, "global capitalism is like the Olympics.g"AFT Pres. Randi Weingarten, former elementary school teacher and schools activist Sabrina Stevens (union hunter Russo tweeted, she worked for the AFT -- horrors) and Gov. Christie's guy, Durrell Bradford offer their takes of the latest  PISA scores.I like the sports metaphor. I call PISA the World Cup of standardized testing. Only difference is, in the World Cup, the soccer field is even. PISA, like all standardized testing regimens, tilts towards th

DEC 04

No Tolerance for Zero Tolerance
Finally, it appears that school districts are rethinking their Zero Tolerance policies. Many of us have been arguing for years that ZT does little to reduce school violence and does great harm to the culture and content of schools. Now, according to the New York Times, cities and school districts around the country are rethinking their approach to minor offenses.Broward Supt. RuncieRather than pus

DEC 03

Taking Names
Retirees put sellout Rep. Mussman up against the wallCarol Marin on Chicago Tonight: "It's like WWIII down there [in Springfield] in terms of phones ringing off the hook."Ralph Martirie, with some support from IFT Pres. Dan Montgomery, did a great job on last night's panel. He blew away each and every point made by pension thieves, Msall and Tillman. His main point -- the pension bill is
PISA -- The World Cup of Testing
It's that time again -- the silly season when the countries of the world have their schools rated on the basis of the PISA tests. It's like the World Cup of standardized testing. And like the World Cup, the U.S. continues to wind up in the middle of the pack, somewhere behind Ireland and Poland. Look for a new round of racial theories about Asians being smarter, and lots pissing and moaning about

DEC 02

Weekend Quotables
Peter Buffett, son of billionaire investor Warren on the conflict between capitalism and humanism: "You can't have both." -- Big Philanthropy and Philanthro-FeudalismIFT Pres. Dan Montgomery“This is a grotesque taking of employees’ retirement security that seems both patently illegal and unfair. It’s a sharp jab in the eye — and the heart — of public employees. There’s a lot of anger out

NOV 29

Chicago teacher and 'urban mom' responds to Duncan on Common Core
Carolyn Alessio, a teacher at Cristo Rey Jesuit High School in Chicago's Pilsen neighborhood, has a piece on the Common Core in today's Tribune. Allessio is the recipient of fellowships from the National Endowment for the Arts and the Illinois Arts Council. She's also a writer of nonfiction and fiction.Notice, she refers to the Common Core as a "curriculum" and not just as state standard

 mark as read

Sen. Warren warns Duncan: Don't be a 'lapdog' to the banks
The U.S. Department of Education risks becoming a “lapdog” as a result of recent actions toward financial companies such as Sallie Mae, Sen. Elizabeth Warren charged Thursday.“The Department of Education needs to be aggressive in watching out for students, not for profit-making loan servicers,” Warren said. “They’re there for our students, not to help loan servicers make a profit.”Run, Elizabeth run!
Why doesn't Moskowitz pay rent?
From deutsch29, Mercedes Schneider's EduBlog:Since 2006, Eva Moskowitz has been running a small charter empire that has at least $50 million in government per-pupil funding, at least $30.9 million in total, end-of-year assets, and the support of hedge fund millionaires. Why is it, then, that her Success Academies have never paid a dime in rent for the public school space occupied by her charter schools?Recently-elected New York Mayor Bill de Blasio wants to put an end to the rent-free usage of public school space by charter schools.Moskowitz’s response? Read the rest here
From Walmart to the White House
Sylvia Mathews BurwellAs Wal-Mart workers are engaging in protests and Black Friday job actions nationwide, to shine another spotlight on the company's anti-worker policies and unlivable wages, the Obama White House is building a new, cozy relationship with the company.Remember back in 2007, when candidate Barack Obama told union voters, "I won't shop at Wal-Mart" and when 8 days later, Michelle Obama resigned from the board of the anti-union company's supplier? My, how times have changed.Since April, Sylvia Mathews Burwell, the former president of the Walmart Foundation, has been se

NOV 26

The wild expansion of privately-managed charters
NEWS RELEASE NATIONAL EDUCATION POLICY CENTERFor Immediate Release November 26, 2013 Contact:  Jamie Horwitz, 202-549-4921, jhdcpr@starpower.netPrivate Education Management Organizations Running Public Schools Expand –44 Percent of Charter School Students in 2011-12 Attended Schools Operated by EMOs New report shows 908,000 students in 2011-2012 attended privately-managed schools in 35 states plus