Latest News and Comment from Education

Tuesday, April 9, 2013

MORNING UPDATE LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 4-9-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all:

Click on picture to Listen to Diane Ravitch




Bobby Jindal Admits a Mistake

Louisiana Governor Bobby Jindal backed off his big Thatcherite idea of reforming the tax code.
He wanted to eliminate income taxes and corporate taxes and raise sales taxes.
That way, the poor would subsidize the rich.
But his poll numbers plummeted, and legislators told him that his plan would be defeated, even by his faithful followers, who want to be re-elected by the voters in their districts.
So he backed off his regressive plan.
The New York Times mentions that Governor Jindal’s health secretary resigned recently “amid reports of a


Indiana University Students Plan Anti-Testing Strike

Students at Indiana University’s education school will go on strike on April 11 and 12 to protest the excessive and toxic testing in K-12.
As they say in their statement, they are the children of No Child Left Behind.
Read the entirety of their statement.
Here is an excerpt:
“As striking students at Indiana University, we are struggling against the corporatization of our school, lack of diversity on campus, and ever-increasing tuition and fees which are fast making an education here inaccessible to all but the most privileged. As we begin these important conversations here at IU we also recognize their systemic nature. We stand in solidarity with others throughout the nation working to rescue education from those who seek to profit from it. We recognize the bravery and commitment of the teachers, students, and parents in 


Congratulations, Carol Burris, New York Principal of the Year!

Readers of this blog are familiar with the writings of Carol Burris, principal of South Side High a school in Rockville Center, New York.
Her fellow principals across the state just named her Principal of the Year..
Carol is a dedicated, passionate educator who is a leader of the fight against the state’s educator evaluation system. She and her colleague Sean Feeney created a petition drive and signed up more than third of the other principals in the state to oppose this ill-considered approach. Thousands of parents and fellow citizens signed their petition.
It is not too late. You can sign too.
Congratulations, Carol!

Bruce Baker Challenges the Logic of Privatization

Bruce Baker of Rutgers is one of the wisest and sharpest critics of the privatization movement (aka “reform”).
In this post, he analyzes two favorite terms of the privatizers: “relinquishment,” which means “give up,” abandon your antique belief in public education, turn your school over to private management and get over it. The other is “sector agnosticism,” which means pretty much the same thing as relinquishment.
You have to wonder where these guys get this jargon. Do they make it up all by themselves? Or do they hire Republican pollster-linguist Frank Luntz to help them figure out words and terms that will make them sound high-

Will Connecticut Put a Charter Operator on State Board?

Jonathan Pelto asks whether the Connecticut House of Representatives will approve the nomination of a charter school executive to the State Board of Education.
Governor Dannell Malloy nominated Andrea Comer, the chief operating officer of a charter school to the state board, where she will exercise influence over issues that directly affect her organization, as well as the continued expansion of charter schools in that state.
Malloy is mad about charter schools. He chose a charter school founder, Stefan Pryor, to be his state commissioner of education.
“If Andrea Comer, the Chief Operating Officer of FUSE/Jumoke Inc., finds herself on the State Board of 

Jonathan Kozol Will Be Honored by FairTest on May 9

If you live anywhere near Cambridge, you should plan to attend this FairTest event on May 9 when FairTest will honor Jonathan Kozol.
FairTest will present Jonathan with the Deborah W. Meier Award for Heroes in Education for his lifelong 

Why Texas Is Sick of The Testing Mania

Texas is fed up with the testing obsession. The state has handed over nearly a billion dollars to Pearson in recent years, even as the Legislature cut $5.4 Billion from public education.
For an insiders’ view of the revolt against high-stakes testing in Texas, read Jason Stanford.
He says only two people n the state still defend the testing deluge, and one of them is paid to lobby for Pearson.
That would be Sandy Kress, the same man who is widely acknowledged as the architect of No Child Left 

The Washington Post Is Wrong About Texas

The Washington Post has a great education blog, Valerie Strauss’s The Answer Sheet.
I wish the editorial board would read The Answer Sheet.
.
Instead, they wrote this absurd editorial, chastising Texas for backing away from test mania.
At present, Texas spends more on testing–$100 million yearly to Pearson –than any other state.
Students in Texas are expected to pass 15 end-of-course tests to graduate from high school. This is more

Uh-Oh, Bad News for Ohio Charters

Ohio is very friendly territory for charter schools.
Governor Kasich loves charter, vouchers, and virtual schools.
But the charters are not doing so well.
Read the following comment and the link with it:
I have been following your work closely since reading your most recent book a few years ago. My local paper, the Akron Beacon Journal, today ran an article analyzing the impact of the new state report card system on public schools, particularly the charter schools. The link is below to the article. The part that jumped out at me was the comments from the vice president of research and accountability for the Ohio Alliance for Public Charter 

Jay Mathews Reverses His Views About Teacher Evaluation

Jay Mathews has been a strong supporter of using test scores.
No longer.
He describes his change of view here.
Jay writes:
“I used to think student test score gains were a good way to rate teachers. I don’t think that any more. Grading individual teachers with scores is too approximate, too erratic and too destructive of the team spirit that makes great schools. Rating schools, rather than teachers, by test score gains is better, at least until we find a way to measure deeper indicators of learning.”
And more.
“We would be better off rating teachers the old-fashioned way. Let principals do it in the normal course of 

Why the “Alabama Accountability Act” Is a Hoax

Larry Lee is an Alabama native who cares about public schools. He has a particular interest in rural schools and community schools. He is a member of the board of the Network for Public Education. This is his analysis of the recently passed “Alabama Accountability Act,” which enacted tax credits and is a stealth voucher plan.
Larry Lee writes:
Have you ever made a promise you knew you couldn’t keep? I sure did every time mama took a switch to me. “I promise, I promise I won’t ever do it again,” I hollered as I tried to dance out of her reach.
Unfortunately when you strip all the rhetoric away, when you cast aside all the pleadings that “this is for the children” and when you look at the starkness of the numbers, you see that this is what our legislature did when 

Diane in the Evening 4-8-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

coopmike48 at Big Education Ape - 4 hours ago
Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all: Jeff Bryant on the United Opt Out Protest by dianerav Last weekend, United Opt Out sponsored a protest rally in front of the U.S. Department of Education in Washington, D.C. The event was called Occupy the DOE. Jeff Bryant of North Carolina reports on the protests here. I spoke on Thursday afternoon of the first day. The crowd was small, which was not surprising, because it was a workday and it is expensive to travel a distance. And the event organizers had no money for travel. Everything was handmade and impro... more »

Best of the Ed Blogs | National Education Policy Center

Best of the Ed Blogs | National Education Policy Center:





Best of the Ed Blogs

Show Up For Tests and Win + Big data strikes again with Coursesmart, #highered take notice – @ the chalk face

Big data strikes again with Coursesmart, #highered take notice – @ the chalk face:


Big data strikes again with Coursesmart, #highered take notice

According to the NYT, professors can now track how students are reading digital materials:
Major publishers in higher education have already been collecting data from millions of students who use their digital materials. But CourseSmart goes further by individually packaging for each professor information on all the students in a class — a bold effort that is already beginning to affect how teachers present material and how students respond to it, even as critics question how well it measures learning. The plan is to introduce the program broadly this fall.
The kicker?
CourseSmart is owned by Pearson, McGraw-Hill and other major publishers, which see an opportunity to cement their dominance in digital textbooks by offering administrators and faculty a constant stream of data about how students are doing.
Nice. But as a college professor, I would have no real need whatsoever for this kind of information. Plus, this kind


Show Up For Tests and Win Some FUN!

This has got to be one of the lowest forms of bribery I’ve heard about in a long time.  Today, a middle school principal in a New York State school district offered the following bribe to the student body:
If we get 98% participation rate on the state tests, we will reward you with a FUN party!
"Every day we're bubblin'!"“Every day we’re bubblin’!”
This, of course, is in direct response to the rapidly growing and motivated opt-out movement spreading across New York State like wildfire.  I’ve heard inspiring stories of middle school kids myself, as they choose to refuse the tests.  Now, this principal is deliberately putting them on the spot by making them the “bad guys” if the participation rate falls below 98%.  Those kids will be responsible for the loss of this “fun party.”
So, this principal–this so-called “educator”–has just set up the scenario for embarrassment, ostracism, and shame, all so he could offer something that his students probably never get in a testing culture: FUN.

Wilcox school chief applauds student effort to integrate proms, but stresses that these aren’t school events | Get Schooled

Wilcox school chief applauds student effort to integrate proms, but stresses that these aren’t school events | Get Schooled:


Wilcox school chief applauds student effort to integrate proms, but stresses that these aren’t school events

downeyart (Medium)Wilcox County Schools finds itself in the unflattering eye of a social media storm after reports of its integrated proms — a vestige of 1970s integration when many high schools stopped sponsoring proms and it fell to parents to organize the dances  –  hit the newspapers, TV stations and Facebook.
The south Georgia school system is now addressing the surge in media attention, correcting a few misconceptions. Namely, that it sponsors these black and white proms.
In a general statement, Wilcox Superintendent Steven Smith said:
A recent article stated that Wilcox County High School is hosting its first integrated prom. Unfortunately, the article failed to provide all of the relevant facts related to proms in Wilcox County. Wilcox County High School has never hosted a school-sponsored prom.
In recent history, there have been two private parties that have been referred to as their  “proms” by two different groups of students. When the ladies mentioned in the article approached …

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: Sun-Times takes a tour of 'underutilized' school. Guess what they find?

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: Sun-Times takes a tour of 'underutilized' school. Guess what they find?:


Sun-Times takes a tour of 'underutilized' school. Guess what?

“Our guarantee is that no child will go to a school that is lesser performing than the school that they’re in,” Byrd-Bennett explains, adding that for many years students have been “trapped in under-utilized and under-resourced schools.” 
The S-T editorial board goes from classroom to classroom at supposedly "half-empty" Garvey Elementary and finds every one of them in use.
 In fact, during a visit on Monday to the school, where colorful and neatly displayed student projects and artwork line bright yellow walls, we didn’t see a single room going unused. Garvey has air-conditioned classrooms, a well-stocked library, a garden, an art room, a computer lab, several small science labs and the kind of discipline and order in the classroom and hallway that tell a visitor this school has its act together. 
“They’re taking kids from a calm, family environment and putting them in a stressed one,” says Garvey parent, Krista Thomas. “This is not a wasteland.” (Kate N. Grossman photo) 
None of that seems to matter to Rahm's hand-picked school board which has been given its marching orders to vote in May, to close Garvey and send its students to ill-equipped and lower-performing Mt. Vernon, several blocks away.

The party line, shaped carefully in the office of CPS Liar-in-Chief Becky Carroll, is that students are "trapped" 

The absolute worst story (and video) about standardized testing

The absolute worst story (and video) about standardized testing:


The absolute worst story (and video) about standardized testing

fcat1I recently ran a post about how the state of Florida was forcing a 9-year-old blind boy who was born with a brain stem but without most of his brain to take the state’s standardized test, known as the Florida Comprehensive Assessment Test.
The piece, written by veteran educator Marion Brady, explains that this travesty came to light when a state legislator, Linda Stewart of Orlando, heard about the boy, named Michael, and asked Rick Roach, a member of the Orange County School Board, to check out the story.
It was true. According to a story by News 13, a woman named Judy Harris who owns an Orlando care facility for children, the Russell House, said Michael came to her shortly after he was born, blind and missing most of his brain, and has been there ever since. The News 13 story says in part:
A teacher works with him twice a week for an hour, but Harris wouldn’t call it schooling.

“Michael loves music, he loves to hear, and he loves for you to talk to him and things like that, but as far as testing him, or questioning him on what is an apple and a peach

Eugenics, Standardized Tests Schools Matter: Feds Making More on Student Loans Annually Than Ford Motor Co.

Schools Matter: Feds Making More on Student Loans Annually Than Ford Motor Co.:



Past and Present: Eugenics, Standardized Tests, and the Politics of School Reform

[Editor's note: An early draft version was posted in error.  This has been corrected.]

*Guest Post by John Loflin

Past and present: Eugenics, standardized tests, and politics of school reform

 “If such a thing as a psycho-analysis of today’s prototypical culture were possible such an investigation
   would needs show the sickness proper to the time to consist precisely in normality.”                                                         
                                                                                                   -- Theodore Adorno, Minima Moralia

“Consistent with notions of American identity, standardized testing, as an opposition to a cultural other,
  represents the normalization of whiteness, richness, and maleness.”

                                                                                                            -- Andrew Hartman


YESTERDAY: THE HOOSIER CONNECTION: THE CULT OF EFFICIENCY

Ellwood P. Cubberly, Lewis Madison Terman, and David Starr Jordan: Eugenics scientific school management, and measuring “intelligence”
As the population grew during pre- and post-WW I America, public education had to adapt to the 



Feds Making More on Student Loans Annually Than Ford Motor Co.

With cuts to public universities and students in debt to the tune of a trillion dollars, the Feds are raking in $34,000,000,000 each year on loans that students are working two jobs to repay.  Now that obscenity could get worse if loan rates are allowed to double in July.  From the NYTimes:
. . . .On Tuesday, the day before the White House plans to send its budget to Congress, student advocacy groups are releasing an issue brief charging that the federal government should not be profiting from student loans, while more and more students bear a crushing debt burden.
The brief, citing a February report from the Congressional Budget Office, said the federal government makes 36 cents in profit on every student-loan 

Legislators Are Against Making Teacher Evaluations Public… Except When They Aren’t in Parent Trigger | Scathing Purple Musings

Legislators Are Against Making Teacher Evaluations Public… Except When They Aren’t in Parent Trigger | Scathing Purple Musings:


Legislators Are Against Making Teacher Evaluations Public… Except When They Aren’t in Parent Trigger

In a curious story that largely sailed under the radar, the Florida Times-Union has sued the Florida Department of Education to make value-added data from SB736 public. The Florida Education Association has joined the FLDOE in opposition. The Florida legislature has weighed in. Topher Sanders reports in the Times-Union:
About a week after an appeals court agreed to hear the Times-Union’s lawsuit to obtain the state’s value-added teacher data, a bill aimed at exempting the data from the public has been filed in the Legislature.
House Bill 7161 was filed Monday by Rep. Janet Adkins, R-Fernandina Beach.
Adkins said she believed the Legislature intended there to be an exemption.
“This is really, in my opinion, consistent with the position of the Legislature when [it] passed the 

UPDATE: NYC Educator: My Latest Unity-New Action Mass Email

NYC Educator: My Latest Unity-New Action Mass Email:


Rating the Fliers

Since Unity/ New Action persists with the fiction of opposing one another, I've been receiving campaign fliers from three caucuses. Despite my misgivings about New Action, I think theirs was the best, particularly the second one. It had a whole lot of appealing things on the front, and were I not well-aware of who they are, I'd probably vote for them.  They did not mention their deal with Unity at all, and they did not mention they'd endorsed Mulgrew until the fourth page. While I found that disingenuous, I also found it persuasive, particularly to a busy teacher disinclined to read the whole thing through. While I'm no New Action fan, I give their flier an A for effectiveness.

It's probably clear to anyone who reads this blog that I voted for MORE. However, their fliers were not as strong as they could be. I speak to people each and every day, and the thing that troubles my members 




My Latest Unity-New Action Mass Email

Today's mass email complained bitterly about receiving mass email. In fact, it compared mass email to spam. The fact its sender was doing exactly the same thing was apparently not relevant. Actually, this too came from someone I know and like. Yet it was riddled with misconceptions.

One thing that was true was that there are indeed Unity-New Action people who work hard. You'd have to be a fool to say the union, dominated by Unity-New Action,  never done anything of value or fought for anyone. I've got someone from Unity trying to help a colleague in deep trouble right now. I can't predict the outcome, but I've got faith this person will do all she can.

But there were other statements that were questionable, at best. The first was that this CL was Unity by choice. Now I'm certain this CL chose to be Unity. However, that choice is only extended by invitation.