Latest News and Comment from Education

Saturday, November 20, 2010

N.Y. Schools Chief Names Panel on City Chancellor - NYTimes.com

N.Y. Schools Chief Names Panel on City Chancellor - NYTimes.com

Panel on Pick for Schools Has Close Ties to Bloomberg

New York State’s top education official on Friday named an advisory panel of eight experts, at least half of them with strong connections to the Bloomberg administration, to help him decide whether to approve Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg’s controversial choice to run the city’s school system.

Education Commissioner David M. Steiner

Dennis Cook/Associated Press

AndrĆ©s A. Alonso, the Baltimore schools’ chief executive.

Brad Barket/Getty Images

Louise Mirrer, president of New-York Historical Society.

Three panelists selected by David M. Steiner, the state education commissioner, worked as senior officials at the city’s Department of Education.

One of those three now works at a foundation that was, for many years, the vehicle for Mr. Bloomberg’s personal charitable donations.

A fourth panelist is the head of a museum that has received almost half a million dollars from Mr. Bloomberg in donations since he took office.

The eight panelists share deep experience in the education field as academics and administrators. It is precisely the kind of experience that Mr. Bloomberg’s choice for chancellor, Cathleen P. Black, the chairwoman of Hearst Magazines, lacks.

Mr. Steiner must decide whether to grant Ms. Black a waiver from state law requiring leaders of school districts to have substantial education credentials and experience.

Citing the prerogative of mayoral control over the schools, the Bloomberg administration has argued that she is

Schools Matter: Learning About KIPP: Lesson 3, Social Justice in Blackface

Schools Matter: Learning About KIPP: Lesson 3, Social Justice in Blackface

Learning About KIPP: Lesson 3, Social Justice in Blackface


Below is Part 3 of this chapter on KIPP. Here are links to Parts One and Two.

. . . . KIPP’s organizational compliance model
In response to an extensive New York Times Magazine article by Paul Tough (2006) that lavishly praised KIPP and its methods, researcher Howard Berlak (2006) reported at the online discussion group, Assessment Reform Network (ARN), his recent own visit to a KIPP school in San Francisco:
When I was there children who followed all the rules were given points that could be exchanged for goodies at the school store. Those who resisted the rules or were slackers wore a large sign pinned to their clothes labeled "miscreant." Miscreants sat apart from the others at all times including lunch, were denied recess and participation in all other school projects and events.
. . . . I've spent many years in schools. This one felt like a humane, low security prison or somethin

4LAKids -: DISTRICT RELEASES SCHOOL EXPERIENCE SURVEY RESULTS [Disaggregated 'School Report Card' data] + ●●smf's 2¢

4LAKids - some of the news that doesn't fit: DISTRICT RELEASES SCHOOL EXPERIENCE SURVEY RESULTS [Disaggregated 'School Report Card' data] + ●●smf's 2¢

Plummeting teacher morale in Seattle’s Public Schools — a serious issue | Seattle Education 2010

Plummeting teacher morale in Seattle’s Public Schools — a serious issue | Seattle Education 2010

Plummeting teacher morale in Seattle’s Public Schools — a serious issue

Here are some concerns I shared in a letter to School Board Director Kay Smith-Blum this week, after her disappointing vote in favor of Teach for America, Inc. I urge all members of the school board to investigate this matter of collapsing teacher morale, which is happening on their watch, largely as a result of the frenetic barrage of dubious “reforms” being imposed upon our teachers, schools and children these past three years under the current district leadership, and with this board’s mostly unquestioning approval.

I understand that we will not always agree. But I honestly believe that with full information about TFA, Inc. and those behind it and where they are heading with it and other corporate ed reform agenda items, you would have voted differently.

The Answer Sheet - The Matthew Effect, Plinko, and the achievement gap

The Answer Sheet - The Matthew Effect, Plinko, and the achievement gap

The Matthew Effect, Plinko, and the achievement gap

This was written by Jared Joiner, a graduate of Montgomery County Public Schools who is now working towards a masters degree at the Harvard Graduate School of Education. It refers to a Century Foundation report called “Housing Policy is School Policy," that said low-income students do beter in school when they are given a chance to live in better neighborhoods and attend schools with wealthier classmates. Richard D. Kahlenberg, a senior fellow at The Century Foundation, wrote about the report on this blog in response to a piece I had posted. By Jared Joiner The argument for integration of low-income students into more affluent schools is that it offers an opportunity to level the playing field and provide high expectations to students who are not traditionally held to the same schooling standards as the white upper and middle class. However, as a Black male who attended Montgomery County Public Schools

I found the exceptional qualification « JD2718

I found the exceptional qualification « JD2718

I found the exceptional qualification

NOVEMBER 20, 2010 AM30 9:52 AM

Being nominated by Michael Bloomberg is an exceptional qualification, right?

Schools Matter: NCTE passes sense of the house motion disapproving of national standards

Schools Matter: NCTE passes sense of the house motion disapproving of national standards

NCTE passes sense of the house motion disapproving of national standards

Sense of the House Motion

Passed, November 19, 2010

National Council of Teachers of English

The NCTE expresses disapproval of the concept of national standards to be applied to all students and of the specifics of those written by the National

Friday, November 19, 2010

Damn Good Education Daily

Damn Good Education Daily

Damn Good Education Daily

educationceo.wordpress.com - I have never minced words about the current attack on the public education system’s stakeholders, e.g., teachers, students, parents. Nor have I gone easy on educational ‘leaders.’ You know, the one...

EDUCATIONCEO
sfgate.com - Michael Macor / The Chronicle Students march for public education in March. For the first time, Latino students are a majority of the state's student population. Numbering more than 3.2 million, th...

mikeklonsky
coopcatalyst.wordpress.com - November 22, 2010 has been declared a Day of National Blogging for Real Education Reform, promoted by AASA and ASCD. ASCD has gathered 10 articles, in advance of Monday’s Day of National Blogging, ...

mikeklonsky
schoolfinance101.wordpress.com - This post is partly in response to the Brookings Institution report released this week which urged that value-added measures be considered in teacher evaluation: http://www.brookings.edu/~/media/Fi...

SchlFinance101
toped.svefoundation.org - By The second-largest high school district in Northern California has adopted A-G, the courses required for admission to a four-year state university, as its default curriculum. East Side Union, wh...

WA citizens surveyed on education reform

WA citizens surveyed on education reform

WA citizens surveyed on education reform

THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

OLYMPIA, Wash. -- Gov. Chris Gregoire is asking Washington citizens and educators to go online by Thanksgiving to fill out a survey on education reform.

The survey will help state officials prioritize reform efforts.

The offices of the Superintendent of Public Instruction, the State Board of Education and the Professional Educator Standards Board partnered to create a draft plan for reform.

The governor says she needs help figuring out how to focus the state's limited funds while it moves forward on education reform.

----

Online:

Education Survey: http://ospi.a03ddf506d29.sgizmo.com/s3/.

Accused Schools Official Sought Job With District Contractor - The Bay Citizen

Accused Schools Official Sought Job With District Contractor - The Bay Citizen

Accused Schools Official Sought Job With District Contractor

Months before she was accused of funneling San Francisco Unified School District funds to herself and her colleagues, a former associate superintendant sought a consulting job with a corporation for which she personally approved nearly $2.7 million in contracts, according to district officials and records. Before retiring in June, Trish Bascom, who headed the Student Support Services Department, informed the district that she planned to work for Education, Training and Research Associates, Inc. Records show that Bascom approved ETR contracts to administer a range of student health programs. A District administrator advised Bascom that the position with ETR represented a potential conflict of interest and would need to be explored further. According to documents obtained by The

Remainders: Bloomberg worries about losing Klein’s team | GothamSchools

Remainders: Bloomberg worries about losing Klein’s team | GothamSchools

Remainders: Bloomberg worries about losing Klein’s team

  • Commissioner David Steiner named the panel of experts that will screen Cathie Black. (GS, NYT)
  • Unlike Black, all of the panelists have experience in education. (State of Politics)
  • Bloomberg said he chose Black to stem “brain drain” within the Dept. of Ed. (Daily Politics)
  • A second Millenium High School could open in Park Slope next year. (InsideSchools)
  • Chancellor Klein’s lowest grades (two B’s) came from NYU’s School of Education. (NYT)
  • The prize for the winner of last night’s “The Apprentice,” was a meeting with Cathie Black. (NYT)
  • Rick Hess says he hasn’t been convinced that Black is right for the job. (EdWeek)
  • Students and teachers at John Dewey High School are fighting threats of closure. (NYT)
  • A former NYC teacher recounts some of the trauma his students endured. (GothamSchools)
  • Should teachers be trained like doctors? The question is put to Twitter. (GOOD)
  • A Queens bus driver (of a non-DOE bus) is accused of sexually abusing school children. (NYT)
  • And NY Mag suggests a Harry Potter spin-off in which Hogwarts endures layoffs. (NY Mag)

TEDx Sacramento 2010 Promo

Schools Matter: Bloomberg Launches Desperation Campaign to Save His Chatty Cathy

Schools Matter: Bloomberg Launches Desperation Campaign to Save His Chatty Cathy

Bloomberg Launches Desperation Campaign to Save His Chatty Cathy

The New York Times reports all Bloomberg markers are being called in an attempt to save the irresponsible, arrogant, and disrespectful appointment of party chum and personnel disposal expert, Cathy Black, as head of NY City Schools:
She reached former Mayor Edward I. Koch at home, and pressed for his advice on how to navigate the rough-and-tumble world of New York politics. (“Never walk away from a reporter,” he admonished her.)

She exchanged little more than polite pleasantries with the Manhattan borough president, Scott M. Stringer, during what he called a “record-setting conversation — it was timed at less than a minute.”

When she could not reach City Councilman Robert Jackson, she left a message, but no number

The Teaching Experience

The Teaching Experience

The Teaching Experience

The idea that experience doesn’t matter after five or so years incorrectly implies that test scores are the only relevant outcome.”

Good, well-thought-out article which presents a balanced look at the controversy that seems to be dominating education news - what is the value of experience in the classroom? As it turns out, there can be a lot of value.


What Diane Ravitch Told KIPP and Teach For America

What Diane Ravitch Told KIPP and Teach For America: This article from The Washington Post says much...

The University and the Ruins of the Present « occupy california

The University and the Ruins of the Present « occupy california

The University and the Ruins of the Present

from WeAreTheCrisis:

Our $800 fee hike is the direct result of an unstable global financial system.

As of the Regent’s meeting vote on November 18th, UC tuition has gone up over $800. A year at UCLA, Berkeley, Santa Cruz, Davis and Irvine now costs over $11,000 when in 2000 it cost $3,429. That means if you make $10 an hour, you’ll have to work 80 more hours next year, or if you’re a Freshman, take out $2,400 more in debt before you graduate. The tremors of the economic crisis continues to spread, and our chances of getting a job we want with our degrees becomes more and more slim. This is our future…

How can we understand this tuition hike in the context of broader social conditions? We find ourselves in the midst of the greatest economic crisis since the Great Depression. 2008 was a shock to the economy as a whole and will no doubt render the world we lived in before unrecognizable. Overproduction of and speculation on real estate, the creation of unsustainable financial tools to be invested in, rising mortgage, credit card and student loan debt — all of these created a crisis in which banks couldn’t lend, people couldn’t pay their bills and abandoned their homes, and states and governments ran out of money to spend. In order to cope with the massive problems caused by the financial crisis, governments around the world have responded in two major

Community or Constituency?

from bicyclebarricade:

Events in UCD’s Mrak Hall Thursday evening unfolded according to a familiar pattern: fees tuition goes up, so students get angry and march on the admin building. A sit-in is staged, demands are made, administrators pretend to dialogue while mobilizing police. Speakers speak, drums drum, and catharsis is reached. Or not. In the end we either stay or we go.

What is the purpose of a sit-in? Is it to force the administration to negotiate? If so, it’s a poor tactic, in itself, because it rarely works. Last November, after the Mrak arrests, the administration was reluctant to send in police during the second building occupation because, well, arresting another 50 students would have made them look even worse. So they “negotiated.” We all remember Janet Gong’s list of empty promises. Negotiation with the administration is futile because it allows them to retain the appearance of reasonableness and because students have no way to force them to keep their word.

When a sit-in refuses to disband itself, the dynamic changes. A minor nuisance becomes a threat to authority and productivity. The riot cops must be called, with them come the media, and the UC receives another black eye. It no longer seems quite so reasonable to raise students’ tuition and then arrest, club, pepper spray and, quite possibly, shoot them into submission. Administrators are nothing if not aware of status and public

Shaky Math in Charter School Studies - WSJ.com

Shaky Math in Charter School Studies - WSJ.com

Studies That Grade Charter Schools Rely on Imperfect Math

Charter schools are getting very confusing report cards.

Researchers have assessed the thousands of charter schools that have opened around the U.S. in the last two decades. The results from those studies are starting to flood in. But policy makers hoping to learn whether these scholastic experiments have been successful will be disappointed: Some studies say charter schools are outperforming their traditional counterparts. Other studies put charter and conventional schools on par, or even show charters trailing their peers.

The chief explanation for the lack of consensus is that the prominent studies on charter schools rely on different methodologies—all of which have flaws.

Education researchers face a big challenge: how to separate the results of charter schools' educational techniques from the quality and motivation of the students themselves. So far, scholars have been only partially successful at making this distinction, other education experts say.

To study charters, researchers typically measure how well students score on standardized tests compared with their peers at nearby traditional public schools. And head-to-head comparisons give charters a big edge. In 2007, for instance, charter schools in Georgia had graduation rates

A mistake and a typo prompt good humor between two rivals | GothamSchools

A mistake and a typo prompt good humor between two rivals | GothamSchools

A mistake and a typo prompt good humor between two rivals

Though they are at times each others’ harshest critics, Chancellor Joel Klein and noted education historian Diane Ravitch proved last week that they can occasionally share a laugh.

Last week, Klein e-mailed Ravitch asking for the “latest draft op-ed.” The message was an accident — presumably Klein meant to send it to the Department of Education’s press secretary, whose name is quite similar. “That’s what they get for getting a PR person named R-a-v-i-t-z,” Ravitch said when she forwarded us the e-mail.

A humorous exchange followed. Read from the bottom up:

—–Original Message—–
From: Diane Ravitch
Sent: Friday, November 12, 2010 6:11 PM
To: Klein Joel I.

May God be with you

I was afraid for a second that I mistyped “luck”

Whew

Sent from my iPhone

On Nov 12, 2010, at 5:00 PM, “Klein Joel I.”

wrote:

> Thanks. While I’m sure it’s just a typo, I love the Freudian slip