Latest News and Comment from Education

Show All

Wednesday, July 29, 2026

TODAY'S TOP NEWS - YESTERDAY'S BEST BLOG POSTS JULY 29, 2026

TODAY’S TOP NEWS - YESTERDAY’S BEST BLOG POSTS
JULY 29, 2026
REMEMBER IN NOVEMBER


Here are today's top news stories for July 29, 2026, organized across each requested category:

U.S. NEWS

  • Seattle Center Shooting: Investigation continues into a mass shooting incident at the Seattle Center that left three people dead and several others injured.

  • ICE Immigration Operations: Federal immigration authorities are expanding targeted operations ahead of the expiration of Temporary Protected Status (TPS) for specific national groups.

  • DOJ Disclosure Order: A federal judge ordered the Department of Justice to disclose internal communications regarding recent subpoena actions involving news organizations.

  • Historic Landmark Protections Revised: A federal panel overseeing national heritage policies voted to ease selected preservation regulations on historical sites.

  • Capitol Ceremonies for Sen. Lindsey Graham: Tributes and Capitol ceremonies took place following the passing of long-serving South Carolina Senator Lindsey Graham.

POLITICS

  • Trump–Netanyahu White House Summit: President Donald Trump hosted Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in Washington to discuss Middle East security and diplomatic strategies regarding Iran.

  • Trump–Zelenskyy Discussions: Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy met with White House officials and congressional leaders to address security aid and defense cooperation.

  • Supreme Court Emergency Voting Appeal: The Trump administration filed an emergency appeal asking the Supreme Court to allow executive rules regarding mail-in ballot screening.

  • Independent Trade Stance: President Trump reiterated a preference for bilateral and independent trade positions over broad regional frameworks with North American partners.

  • Justice Department Drops Labor Case: Federal prosecutors moved to dismiss criminal charges involving California SEIU leader David Huerta.

WORLD AFFAIRS

  • U.S. Intercepts Ballistic Missiles: U.S. Central Command intercepted multiple ballistic missiles targeting coalition military bases in the Middle East.

  • Joint U.S.–Saudi Airstrikes in Iraq: American and Saudi forces conducted targeted strikes against militia infrastructure in Iraq following recent drone attacks.

  • Major Earthquake in Japan: A 6.8 magnitude earthquake struck southern Japan, triggering regional emergency response protocols.

  • Strait of Hormuz Maritime Security: Tensions remain elevated in the Persian Gulf as diplomatic efforts focus on keeping key shipping channels open.

  • Commonwealth Games Underway: The Commonwealth Games produced major international headlines, including Flynn Southam securing gold in the 100m freestyle.

EDUCATION

  • Title IX & Admissions Investigations: The U.S. Department of Education launched civil rights reviews into public school districts and select medical schools regarding admissions practices and parental notification rules.

  • Workforce Pell Expansion: States are integrating new P–20W data systems to implement federal Workforce Pell regulations linking vocational training to local industry needs.

  • Global EdTech Rankings Published: Industry reports highlighted significant global growth in digital learning, led by platforms expanding beyond language learning into math and science.

  • Consolidated State Education Governance: Indiana introduced a unified $26 billion education vision designed to streamline K-12, higher education, and workforce development agencies.

  • Federal Deregulatory Actions: The Department of Education announced streamlined compliance guidelines for career and technical education programs nationwide.

ECONOMY

  • Fed Rate Policy Decision: The Federal Reserve met for its July policy review, with markets weighing whether benchmark interest rates will remain held in the 3.50%–3.75% range.

  • Global Tech & Chip Stock Pressure: Semiconductor shares experienced pullbacks driven by heavy corporate AI expenditure and emerging international supply developments.

  • Crude Oil Price Fluctuations: Brent crude stabilized near $86.50 a barrel as energy markets balanced diplomatic news with Middle East supply risks.

  • Cooling Core Inflation: Underlying Consumer Price Index (CPI) figures showed core inflation moderating to 2.6%, accompanied by steady labor market growth.

  • Data Center Permitting Pauses: Local municipalities are increasingly pausing new data center developments to evaluate regional electrical grid capacity.

TECHNOLOGY

  • Open Secure AI Alliance Formed: Over 30 leading tech firms—including Nvidia, Microsoft, IBM, and SpaceX—partnered to release open-source defensive tools against AI threats.

  • Major AI Developers Skip Alliance: Top closed-source AI developers (OpenAI, Google, and Anthropic) notably did not sign on to the newly created defense coalition.

  • Open-Source AI Policy Letter: Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang delivered an open letter signed by 50 tech leaders advising Washington against restricting open-weight AI models.

  • Enterprise Multi-Model Strategy: Industry experts urged businesses to implement multi-model AI architectures to maintain flexibility across competing AI systems.

  • Data Privacy Debate: Renewed scrutiny emerged over public search indexing and user conversation handling across major conversational AI platforms.

HEALTH

  • Insulin Protein Mechanism Uncovered: Researchers discovered a crucial helper-protein pathway in pancreatic cells that prevents misfolded insulin, opening new targets for diabetes treatment.

  • Type 2 Diabetes Prevention Nuance: A long-term study demonstrated that weight loss alone may be insufficient to prevent Type 2 diabetes in certain genetically high-risk groups.

  • GLP-1 Impact on Brain Craving Circuits: Neuroscience findings revealed that oral GLP-1 compounds directly dampen reward-driven eating circuits in the brain.

  • Dietary Shift & Agricultural Emissions: A landmark environmental health report indicated that global shifts toward plant-rich diets could reduce livestock land-use emissions by up to 85% by 2050.

  • Calorie App Precision Study: A nutritional audit revealed that popular AI calorie-tracking apps often underestimate meal caloric content by up to one-third.

SPORTS

  • MLB Mid-Summer Action: Major League Baseball feature games included a 14-0 blowout by the Tigers over the Orioles alongside crucial late-July pennant races.

  • Chicago Cubs Roster Shift: The Cubs designated veteran starting pitcher Jameson Taillon for assignment during a mid-season rotation retool.

  • NFL Preseason Camps Open: NFL franchises across the league officially opened summer training camps in preparation for the upcoming 2026 kickoff.

  • FIFA & UEFA Governance Debate: European soccer governing body UEFA voiced pushback against FIFA proposals to sell equity stakes in future World Cup tournaments.

  • Commonwealth Games Aquatics: Swimming and aquatic events dominated international sports headlines with several record-setting performances.




Tennessee: Big Money Backing Marsha Blackburn for Governor https://dianeravitch.net/2026/07/28/tennessee-big-money-backing-marsha-blackburn-for-governor/ via @dianeravitch 


Miles Taylor: Trump Just Quietly Tripled His Personal Hires for Top Jobs https://dianeravitch.net/2026/07/28/miles-taylor-trump-just-quietly-tripled-his-personal-hires-for-top-jobs/ via @dianeravitch 





Carol Burris: School Choice Is Weakening Public Schools, Which Enroll Most Children https://dianeravitch.net/2026/07/28/carol-burris-school-choice-is-weakening-public-schools-which-enroll-most-children/ via @dianeravitch 








Big Tech Chokes Off Popular Blogs That Challenge Them https://dianeravitch.net/2026/07/28/how-big-tech-chokes-off-popular-blogs-that-challenge-them/ via @dianeravitch 









Big Education Ape: STRIKE SECTION 219 FROM THE FY2027 NDAA: WHY THE U.S. MILITARY SHOULDN’T MARRY ITS LONGTIME HOOKUP WHILE THE PARTNER KEEPS IGNORING THE SAFE WORD https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2026/07/strike-section-219-from-fy2027-ndaa-why.html 






Big Education Ape: THE VOUCHER VULTURES ARE CIRCLING AGAIN SAME GRIFT, SHINY NEW ACRONYM https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2026/07/the-voucher-vultures-are-circling-again.html 








Big Education Ape: WHOSE BRIGHT IDEA WAS THIS? A 40-YEAR POST-MORTEM ON AMERICA'S SELF-INFLICTED STUDENT LOAN CATASTROPHE https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2026/07/whose-bright-idea-was-this-40-year-post.html 







Big Education Ape: TODAY'S TOP NEWS - YESTERDAY'S BEST BLOG POSTS JULY 28, 2026 https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2026/07/todays-top-news-yesterdays-best-blog_01269830616.html 







Big Education Ape: MORNING NEWS UPDATE: JULY 28, 2026 https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2026/07/morning-news-update-july-28-2026.html 









More About Robot Teachers – Tennessee Education Report https://tnedreport.com/2026/07/more-about-robot-teachers/ 






This Week’s Free & Useful Artificial Intelligence Tools For The Classroom    Larry Ferlazzo's Websites of the Day... | The latest news and resources in education since 2007 https://larryferlazzo.edublogs.org/ 





Critical Studies of Education & Technology: Digital Degrowth and Education – Q&A | National Education Policy Center https://nepc.colorado.edu/blog/digital-degrowth 






How Big Tech Chokes Off Popular Blogs That Challenge Them https://dianeravitch.net/2026/07/28/how-big-tech-chokes-off-popular-blogs-that-challenge-them/ via @dianeravitch 





The Best Correspondent’s Dinner Message That Should Not Go Unnoticed! - Nancy Bailey's Education Website https://nancyebailey.com/2026/07/28/the-best-correspondents-dinner-message-that-should-not-go-unnoticed/ 





glen brown: Threatening Seashells? https://teacherpoetmusicianglenbrown.blogspot.com/2026/07/86-47.html 






Miles Taylor: Trump Just Quietly Tripled His Personal Hires for Top Jobs https://dianeravitch.net/2026/07/28/miles-taylor-trump-just-quietly-tripled-his-personal-hires-for-top-jobs/ via @dianeravitch 





Teacher Tom: Transforming How We Speak With Children https://teachertomsblog.blogspot.com/2026/07/transforming-how-we-speak-with-children.html 






Kids who own cellphones have poorer reading comprehension scores     Education Research Report https://educationresearchreport.blogspot.com/ 






Sandy Rosen, presente | JD2718 https://jd2718.org/2026/07/28/sandy-rosen-presente/ 







TRUMP IN THE NEWS TODAY
REMEMBER IN NOVEMBER


Here are the top news stories surrounding President Donald Trump for July 29, 2026:

1. High-Stakes Diplomacy: Back-to-Back Meetings with Netanyahu and Zelenskyy

President Trump hosted consecutive meetings at the White House with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy.

  • Iran Conflict & Diplomacy: In his talks with Netanyahu—their first meeting since launching joint strikes against Iran earlier this year—Trump discussed the current pause in military strikes and ongoing indirect negotiations with Tehran. While Trump noted that "good talks" were taking place, he reiterated threats of target strikes if a peace agreement is not finalized.

  • Ukraine Defense Cooperation: President Zelenskyy met with Trump to discuss anti-ballistic missile defense systems and broader strategic cooperation, while also attending ceremonies in Washington honoring the late Senator Lindsey Graham.

2. Emergency Push to the Supreme Court on Mail-In Voting

The Department of Justice filed an emergency request asking the Supreme Court to allow a March executive order to take effect ahead of the November 2026 midterm elections.

  • The order directs federal and state agencies to establish "state citizenship lists" to restrict the distribution of mail-in ballots.

  • Lower courts in 23 states and Washington, D.C., had previously blocked the order following multi-state lawsuits challenging the administration's authority over state election rules.

3. Policy Mandate: Ban on High-Risk "Gain-of-Function" Research

The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) officially released a sweeping framework prohibiting federally supported, dangerous gain-of-function (DGOF) research.

  • The policy fulfills a prior presidential executive order aimed at overhauling oversight across federal life-sciences research and biosecurity protocols.

4. Senate Advances Russia Sanctions & DNI Confirmation

  • Intelligence Leadership: The U.S. Senate confirmed Jay Clayton as Director of National Intelligence (DNI).

  • Tariff Authority: The Senate voted to advance a new Russia sanctions package that includes provisions granting expanded presidential tariff powers.



Notable concurring opinions from this term | SCOTUSblog https://www.scotusblog.com/2026/07/notable-concurring-opinions-from-this-term/ 

Eliminate the summer recess | SCOTUSblog https://www.scotusblog.com/2026/07/eliminate-the-summer-recess/ 

San Francisco mayor backs national robotaxi rules after Waymo meltdowns - POLITICO https://www.politico.com/news/2026/07/28/san-francisco-waymo-washington-01013227

Trump-Netanyahu meeting: Why Trump’s Saudi nuclear deal is making Israel uneasy | Vox https://www.vox.com/podcasts/496828/trump-netanyahu-saudi-nuclear-deal-israel-iran-enrichment-abraham-accords 

Data center boom sparks lobbying surge - POLITICO https://www.politico.com/news/2026/07/28/data-center-boom-sparks-lobbying-surge-01010295 

The island without childcare for babies https://hechingerreport.org/the-island-without-childcare-for-babies/ 

Former Newsom aide challenges his version of their affair - POLITICO https://www.politico.com/news/2026/07/28/former-newsom-aide-ruby-rippey-affair-01013608 

Trump administration appears not to have asked Supreme Court to rehear birthright citizenship case | SCOTUSblog https://www.scotusblog.com/2026/07/trump-administration-appears-not-to-have-asked-supreme-court-to-rehear-birthright-citizenship-ca/ 

United Auto Workers Divests From Israel - In These Times https://inthesetimes.com/article/united-auto-workers-divests-from-israel-uaw-palestine-gaza 

AFSCME Leader Lee Saunders to Retire as Unions Face New Opposition - The New York Times https://www.nytimes.com/2026/07/28/us/politics/lee-saunders-afscme-retirement.html 

Teachers Want Schools to Stop Young Children From Using AI - Freedom For All Americans https://freedomforallamericans.org/teachers-young-children-ai-schools/# 

Not every California student can afford to transfer. Community college bachelor’s degrees could help | EdSource https://edsource.org/2026/california-community-college-bachelor-degrees/762949 

Georgia High School Shooter Discussed His Notoriety With Mom | HuffPost Latest News https://www.huffpost.com/entry/ap-us-georgia-high-school-shooting_n_6a68ec2be4b0fddbd711e067 

State Department will dispense $600M for vaccines RFK Jr. held up, Collins says - POLITICO https://www.politico.com/news/2026/07/28/vaccines-rfk-collins-gavi-rubio-01013690 

Mikie Sherrill refuses DOJ demand for data on NJ noncitizen voters, citing privacy laws - POLITICO https://www.politico.com/news/2026/07/28/sherrill-doj-demand-data-noncitizen-voters-privacy-01013856

Trump administration bans foreign-made robots and power gear amid fears of Chinese influence - POLITICO https://www.politico.com/news/2026/07/28/trump-administration-bans-foreign-made-robots-and-power-gear-amid-fears-of-chinese-influence-01013995 

Investigation of School Epstein Helped Finds Abuses Went Beyond Him - The New York Times https://www.nytimes.com/2026/07/28/arts/music/jeffrey-epstein-interlochen-arts-abuse.html 

Trump commemorates Graham’s life — with sunny Netanyahu and Zelenskyy meetings - POLITICO https://www.politico.com/news/2026/07/28/trump-zelenskyy-netanyahu-graham-01013912 

AI staffers urge US to help ‘deliberately pace’ tech development - POLITICO https://www.politico.com/news/2026/07/28/ai-staffers-urge-u-s-to-help-deliberately-pace-tech-development-01014132 

OpenAI's rogue models roamed the internet for 4 days and staged a second attack - POLITICO https://www.politico.com/news/2026/07/28/openai-rogue-models-hugging-face-breach-01014572 

Jensen Huang presses lawmakers for lighter touch on AI - POLITICO https://www.politico.com/news/2026/07/28/jensen-huang-presses-lawmakers-for-lighter-touch-on-ai-01014510



Posted by at

Tuesday, July 28, 2026

STRIKE SECTION 219 FROM THE FY2027 NDAA: WHY THE U.S. MILITARY SHOULDN’T MARRY ITS LONGTIME HOOKUP WHILE THE PARTNER KEEPS IGNORING THE SAFE WORD


STRIKE SECTION 219 FROM THE FY2027 NDAA

WHY THE U.S. MILITARY SHOULDN’T MARRY ITS LONGTIME HOOKUP WHILE THE PARTNER KEEPS IGNORING THE SAFE WORD

Picture the scene. The United States military and Israel have been dating for decades—casual, beneficial, occasionally intense, with plenty of shared interests in high-tech toys and mutual enemies. Aid packages, joint exercises, Iron Dome co-funding: the classic “we’re exclusive but keep our own apartments” arrangement. Then along comes Section 219 of the House version of the Fiscal Year 2027 National Defense Authorization Act, and suddenly someone is whispering about moving in together, combining bank accounts, and sharing the Netflix password for life.

What in the every-loving hell is the rush to formalize this at a moment when the Netanyahu government continues operations in Gaza, the West Bank, and beyond that many American policymakers—and large swaths of the American public—view as running roughshod over U.S. preferences, leverage, and stated values? The U.S. has been dating Israel for a long time. That does not mean marriage, complete with joint checking and “till death do us part” supply-chain vows, is the smart next step.

Section 219 (born from the bipartisan U.S.-Israel FUTURES Act) establishes the United States–Israel Defense Technology Cooperation Initiative. It directs the Secretary of Defense to designate a Pentagon “executive agent” whose job is to synchronize, accelerate, and expand bilateral R&D, testing, evaluation, integration, and industrial cooperation. Priority domains include counter-drone systems, missile and air defense, artificial intelligence and autonomous systems, quantum technology, cyber and electronic warfare, directed energy, data fusion, and co-production. The agent is charged with identifying Israeli-origin or jointly developed tech for insertion into U.S. programs of record, creating fast tracks into procurement, and fostering joint ventures and U.S.-based manufacturing partnerships with Israeli firms.

Proponents—Reps. Ronny Jackson and Don Davis, Sens. Ted Budd and Kirsten Gillibrand among them—frame it as smart leverage of battlefield-tested Israeli innovation to keep American forces ahead of swarming drones and other modern threats. Fair enough on paper. But critics across an unusually broad spectrum see something closer to a structural merger of critical pieces of the two defense industrial bases, with consequences that make traditional military aid look positively reversible by comparison.

Embedded Co-Dependence Makes Decoupling “Impossible”

Traditional aid is like sending money or shipping hardware. Congress or the White House can condition it, delay it, or pause it when priorities diverge. Section 219 turns the relationship into shared plumbing. Embed Israeli software, components, sensors, and platforms deep inside U.S. systems and procurement pipelines, and any future attempt to apply pressure over strategy or human rights suddenly risks degrading American readiness. You don’t just stop writing the check; you start dismantling your own supply chain. That is not alliance management. That is mutual hostageship dressed up as efficiency.

Sourcing, “Data Fusion,” and Field-Testing Concerns

The provision pushes tighter integration of AI, autonomous systems, and intelligence feeds—including “data fusion,” the melding of sensor and intelligence streams into shared operational pictures. Human rights organizations note that some of the surveillance data and algorithmic targeting models Israel has fielded in Gaza and the West Bank have drawn sharp criticism for reliability problems and civilian harm. Adopting and co-funding those methodologies does not merely buy capability; it risks importing the methods and the legal-political baggage that comes with them.

Legal and Strategic Complicity, Plus Loss of Sovereignty

International legal bodies and civil society groups have raised serious allegations regarding civilian casualties and humanitarian conditions in ongoing conflicts. Formalizing deep technological co-production moves support out of the visible, conditionable foreign-aid lane and into internal Pentagon R&D and acquisition frameworks. That reduces daylight and accountability. Critics—including the Quincy Institute—argue the executive agent’s authority can bias institutional processes and potentially sidestep normal technology-security reviews. The result is an unusually privileged position for one foreign partner inside U.S. defense planning that exceeds typical NATO-style arrangements.

Security and counterintelligence risks are not theoretical. Historical friction points, including past refusals to share full source code on systems the U.S. helped fund, illustrate the limits of “trust us” in proprietary foreign tech. Opening deeper pathways into Pentagon networks and procurement also expands the surface for intelligence vulnerabilities and intellectual-property complications.

Erosion of Oversight and Policy Flexibility

By burying the initiative inside the must-pass NDAA rather than subjecting it to standalone debate, Congress reduces its own future leverage. Future administrations or lawmakers who want to recalibrate the relationship will face a far higher practical and political cost. Preferential fast-tracking further tilts the bureaucratic playing field. And all of this is happening while regional operations continue to generate intense domestic and international controversy—precisely when many argue the U.S. should be increasing, not decreasing, conditionality.

Who Is Pushing Back?

The opposition is not a fringe. Progressive and non-interventionist lawmakers including Sen. Bernie Sanders, Rep. Ro Khanna, Rep. Thomas Massie, Sen. Chris Van Hollen, Sen. Elizabeth Warren, and Sen. Jeff Merkley have sought to strip the provision. Think tanks such as the Quincy Institute warn of structural bias in procurement and diluted congressional control. Human rights and Arab-American groups, including Amnesty International and the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee, cite geopolitical and rights concerns. On the “America First” right, figures including former National Counterterrorism Center Director Joe Kent and various nationalist commentators flag sovereignty and foreign-influence risks. Massie and Khanna’s bipartisan amendment to remove Section 219 was blocked from floor consideration; the House still passed the broader bill with the section intact on a narrow 216–212 vote. The Senate version contains a parallel provision, so the fight is far from over.

The U.S.-Israel defense relationship has delivered real capabilities. Cooperation on specific systems can continue without locking the two industrial bases into a permanent, hard-to-unwind embrace. Long-term dating is one thing. Signing a prenup that effectively makes divorce catastrophic for your own military readiness is another—especially when the partner’s current behavior is generating precisely the kind of friction that would normally prompt a serious relationship talk.

Strike Section 219. Keep the useful collaboration. Reject the structural merger. American military sovereignty and policy flexibility are not optional extras; they are the point of having a military in the first place.


List of Primary Sources and Links

Here is a curated list of key sources used for the article on Section 219 of the FY2027 NDAA (United States–Israel Defense Technology Cooperation Initiative). These include official reporting, analysis, and primary coverage from the period around the House passage of the bill (July 2026).

Core News & Reporting

Analysis & Think Tank / Advocacy

Official / Legislative References

These sources cover the provision’s content, House passage (216–212 on July 22, 2026), bipartisan opposition efforts (Massie-Khanna amendment), and the main critiques regarding sovereignty, oversight, data fusion, and entanglement.



Posted by at

THE VOUCHER VULTURES ARE CIRCLING AGAIN SAME GRIFT, SHINY NEW ACRONYM


THE VOUCHER VULTURES ARE CIRCLING AGAIN

SAME GRIFT, SHINY NEW ACRONYM

They're baaack.

Right on cue, like a flock of well-heeled buzzards who've been watching public education from a thermal updraft since Milton Friedman first scrawled "vouchers" on a cocktail napkin in 1955, the school choice industrial complex has landed another glossy report. This time it's the American Federation for Children — Betsy DeVos's old home away from home — breathlessly announcing that 51.7 million American children are eligible for the new federal Education Freedom Tax Credit (EFTC), taking effect in 2027.

Fifty-one million children! That's almost everyone! What a coincidence that 91.7% of all K–12 students somehow qualify for a program explicitly designed to funnel public tax dollars into private and religious schools. It's almost as if they want this to sound like a universal entitlement and not a privatization scheme with a bow on it.

Let's be clear about what the AFC is: a 501(c)(4) advocacy machine bankrolled by Jeff Yass (billionaire), the DeVos family (billionaires), William Oberndorf (also, shockingly, a billionaire), the Walton Family Foundation (heirs to a fortune built on destroying local retail, now applying the same strategy to local schools), and a constellation of pass-through dark money funnels with soothing names like DonorsTrust. When this crew drops a "report," it isn't research. It's a press release with footnotes and a PhD byline attached for credibility's sake.

The new federal mechanism — the EFTC, tucked into the Big Beautiful Tax Bill — gives individuals a dollar-for-dollar federal tax credit of up to $1,700 for donating to state-certified Scholarship Granting Organizations (SGOs), which then hand out private school tuition money to "eligible families." It sounds almost charitable! Except: the credit is uncapped at the federal aggregate level, the income eligibility stretches to 300% of Area Median Income (covering nearly everybody), and "qualified expenses" include tuition, tutoring, technology, homeschool curriculum, and educational transportation. In other words, it's a federal tax shelter dressed up as educational opportunity.

And the "opt-in" mechanism? Pure political theater. Over 30 states have already signaled participation. In several states with Democratic governors, Republican legislatures overrode vetoes to force compliance. California, Oregon, and a handful of others have held out — and you can bet the AFC report exists specifically to shame them into capitulating. "Think of the children" is a powerful rhetorical cudgel when you're the one holding it over a state treasurer's head.

But let's talk about the children, since we're all supposedly here for them.

Who actually benefits from these programs? In Arizona, over 70% of new ESA applicants had no prior public school enrollment — they were already in private schools. In Arkansas, roughly 95% of initial universal voucher recipients had never set foot in a public school. Florida and Iowa clock in around 70%. The pattern is consistent, the logic is simple: when you create a universal subsidy, the people best positioned to capture it are the ones who were already paying out of pocket. Lower-income families face a "tuition gap" that vouchers rarely close, plus transportation, lunch costs, and the near-total absence of private school infrastructure in rural communities. The rural voucher dream largely exists on paper.

And the academic outcomes? Targeted, small-scale voucher programs from the 1990s sometimes produced modest or neutral effects for low-income students in urban districts. The modern statewide universal expansions? Studies from Notre Dame, Duke, and the UCLA Civil Rights Project found statistically significant drops in math and reading scores for students who transferred from public to private schools via vouchers. Learning losses comparable, in the researchers' phrasing, to major systemic disruptions. You know what's a major systemic disruption? A generation of public school defunding.

There are some honest data points in the mix — long-term graduation rates in Milwaukee and Florida show some improvement, and parent satisfaction surveys are consistently high. Parents generally like what they chose. That's not surprising. It's also not a substitute for public accountability, civil rights protections, standardized reporting, or the basic democratic principle that public money should fund public institutions answerable to the public.

Which brings us to the real agenda. This was never primarily about educational outcomes. Milton Friedman said the quiet part loud: vouchers were designed as a mechanism to break the institutional power of public education and open the sector to market competition. The culture war overlay came later — when it turned out that "educational freedom" is a very efficient delivery vehicle for public dollars into religious schools free to discriminate against LGBTQ+ students, ignore disability rights requirements, and teach whatever history fits the donor class's preferred narrative.

The AFC's report isn't analysis. It's a lobbying document dressed in academic clothes, designed to manufacture urgency ahead of the 2027 EFTC launch, pressure holdout governors, and sustain the political careers of the lawmakers who made this possible. It's the latest chapter in a 70-year campaign to turn public education into a market, and public school children into a customer base.

The answer remains what it has always been: public funds for public schools. Universal, accountable, democratically governed public schools — not a patchwork of SGOs, ESAs, and tax shelters that benefit families who were already fine.

The voucher vultures have shiny new acronyms. They have billionaire money and federal tax credits and a 52-million-student talking point.

We have the November ballot.

Use it.



SOURCES & LINKS
The Voucher Vultures Are Circling Again — Big Education Ape

THE AFC REPORT & THE EFTC

MILTON FRIEDMAN & THE ORIGINS OF VOUCHERS

WHO VOUCHERS ACTUALLY SERVE

THE ACADEMIC RECORD: VOUCHERS AND STUDENT OUTCOMES

THE MONEY MACHINE: AFC DONORS & POLITICAL SPENDING



Posted by at
Subscribe to: Posts (Atom)