Latest News and Comment from Education

Saturday, March 9, 2019

DeVos Illegally Delayed Special Education Rule, Judge Says - The New York Times

DeVos Illegally Delayed Special Education Rule, Judge Says - The New York Times

DeVos Illegally Delayed Special Education Rule, Judge Says



WASHINGTON — A federal judge has ruled that Education Secretary Betsy DeVos illegally delayed an Obama-era rule that required states to address racial disparities in special education programs.
In a decision on Thursday, Judge Tanya S. Chutkan of the United States District Court for the District of Columbia called the Education Department’s delay of the special education rule “arbitrary and capricious.” The rule, drafted under the Individuals With Disabilities Education Act, would require states to identify districts with “significant disproportionality” in the number of minority students channeled into special education services, segregated in restrictive classroom settings or disciplined.
The rule, passed in the final weeks of the Obama administration, required districts to examine policies and practices that contributed to the disparities and fund remedies.
The judge’s ruling vacates Ms. DeVos’s decision to put off the regulation by two years. Instead it will take effect immediately. Leaders in the Education Department said last summer that they needed time to study the rule’s potential consequences because they were concerned that it could promote unconstitutional “racial quotas.”

Civil rights groups hailed the ruling as a victory over one of the most significant policy moves that Ms. DeVos has made to date. While the department has rescinded nonbinding guidance documents, which championed Obama-era practices for addressing racial bias, the special education rule is binding, and states had been preparing to enforce it for more than a year.
Denise Marshall, executive director for the Council of Parent Attorneys and Advocates, an advocacy organization that sued the department over the delay last year, said the decision, “assures states CONTINUE READING: DeVos Illegally Delayed Special Education Rule, Judge Says - The New York Times


Bill & Melinda Gates Don’t Discuss Their Takeover of America’s Public Schools

Bill & Melinda Gates Don’t Discuss Their Takeover of America’s Public Schools

Bill & Melinda Gates Don’t Discuss Their Takeover of America’s Public Schools



Bill and Melinda Gates’s 2019 letter “We Didn’t See This Coming,” is filled with their concerns and optimism about everything from commodes to climate change. Always eager to discuss their global initiatives to help the poor, and a variety of other endeavors, they say little about the aggressive ways they are remaking public education to their liking.
Almost every nonprofit created to disparage public schools or the teaching profession has the Gates Foundation as a major donor.
Maybe they don’t notice, or didn’t see coming, how they promoted charters at the expense of public schools. Perhaps they didn’t mean to criticize the teaching profession by meddling with their teacher effectiveness initiative, and supporting Teach for America types. Didn’t they realize the hubbub they’d create wanting to collect massive amounts of data on children?
They don’t seem to understand that public ownership of public schools is critical to a democracy. That’s what is at stake here.
Many educators and parents, however, insist that Bill and Melinda Gates are about privatizing public schools, making the workers they want for the future economy, and replacing teachers with technology.
Yet the dynamic duo dodge discussion about how they’re dismantling public CONTINUE READING: Bill & Melinda Gates Don’t Discuss Their Takeover of America’s Public Schools


Jonathan Sackler’s Bouncer Foundation: Opioid-Funded Ed Reform | deutsch29

Jonathan Sackler’s Bouncer Foundation: Opioid-Funded Ed Reform | deutsch29

Jonathan Sackler’s Bouncer Foundation: Opioid-Funded Ed Reform


Purdue Pharma is the company that produces the opioid, OxyContin.
IMG_1450
The Sackler family– including noted ed reformer Jonathan Sackler— owns Purdue Pharma.
IMG_1452

Jonathan Sackler
In June 2018, the Commonwealth of Massachusetts sued Purdue Pharma and Sackler family; on January 31, 2019, Massachusetts attorney general, Maura Healy filed an amended, longer, suit, for Purdue Pharma’s having “created the [opioid drug] epidemic and profited from it through a web of illegal deceit.” From the amended lawsuit:
Dangerous opioid drugs are killing people across Massachusetts. Prescription medicines, which are supposed to protect our health, are instead ruining people’s lives. Every community in our Commonwealth suffers from the epidemic of addiction and death.
Purdue Pharma created the epidemic and profited from it through a web of illegal deceit. First, Purdue deceived Massachusetts doctors and patients to get more and more people on its dangerous drugs. Second, Purdue misled them to use higher and more dangerous doses. Third, Purdue deceived them to stay on its drugs for longer and more harmful periods of time. All the while, Purdue peddled falsehoods to keep patients away from safer alternatives. Even when Purdue knew people in Massachusetts were addicted and dying, Purdue treated doctors and their patients as targets to sell more drugs. At the top of Purdue, a small group of executives led the deception and pocketed millions of dollars. …
Defendant Purdue Pharma Inc. is a drug company incorporated in New York with its principal place of business in Connecticut. …
The seventeen individual defendants are current and former directors of Purdue Pharma Inc. …
Defendants Richard Sackler, Beverly Sackler, David Sackler, Ilene Sackler Lefcourt, Jonathan Sackler, Kathe Sackler, Mortimer Sackler, and Theresa Sackler controlled Purdue’s misconduct. Each of them took a seat on the Board of Directors of Purdue Pharma Inc. Together, they always held the controlling majority of the Board…. They directed deceptive sales and marketing practices deep within Purdue….
According to March 04, 2019, STAT News, Purdue Pharma has filed a motion to CONTINUE READING: Jonathan Sackler’s Bouncer Foundation: Opioid-Funded Ed Reform | deutsch29

#RedforEd Protests Driving 'Substantial' Increases in Education Funding

#RedforEd Protests Driving 'Substantial' Increases in Education Funding

#RedforEd Protests Driving ‘Substantial’ Increases in Education Funding

teacher strikes education funding

Arizona, North Carolina, Oklahoma and West Virginia are among the states that made the deepest cuts to education in the decade since the Great Recession. In 2018, however, lawmakers in these states boosted school funding. It’s no coincidence, according to a new paper issued by the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities (CBPP), that these improvements came soon after educators launched successful strikes to protest the chronic underfunding of their public schools.
“Protests by teachers and others helped drive substantial school funding increases over the last year,” writes Michael Leachman, Senior Director of State Fiscal Research at CBPP and co-author of the paper.
The funding gains were significant, especially in Oklahoma, where lawmakers increased formula funding per student by 19 percent, adjusting for inflation. Arizona, North Carolina, and West Virginia also saw significant gains, ranging from 3 percent to 9 percent per student, again after adjusting for inflation.
“Oklahoma became the poster child for the funding crisis that led to teacher walkouts in numerous states and cities,” said David Blatt, executive director for the Oklahoma Policy Institute, in a conference call on Tuesday with Leachman and reporters. “For the first time since 2013, we’re no longer No. 1 among states making the deepest cuts to education.” (That would be Texas, where funding per student is now 20 percent below 2008 levels.)
Whether it’s in Oklahoma, Arizona, West Virginia, or most recently in Oakland, CA.,educators are hitting the picket lines to demand a reinvestment in public education, says NEA President Lily Eskelsen García.
“Educators all over the country are #RedforEd,” said Eskelsen García. While specific issues vary state to state, “there are some issues they all share: The concern that CONTINUE READING: #RedforEd Protests Driving 'Substantial' Increases in Education Funding



Oklahoma Prosecutors Defy the Will of Voters Seeking Criminal Justice Reform - Living in Dialogue

Oklahoma Prosecutors Defy the Will of Voters Seeking Criminal Justice Reform - Living in Dialogue

Oklahoma Prosecutors Defy the Will of Voters Seeking Criminal Justice Reform


A first post described Oklahoma Christian University’s Complex Dialogues with Bryan Stevenson, and Stevenson’s passionate call for ending mass incarceration. His keynote address followed a series of panel discussionson the criminal justice system that appealed to both our emotions and intellects.
Christy Sheppard’s introductory presentation personified the forum’s balanced appeal to “the Head” and “the Heart.” She poignantly introduced a fact-driven discussion on the injustices of our system, as well as Stevenson’s call for grace and mercy. Ms. Sheppard is the cousin of Debbie Carter, whose murder in Oklahoma led to the wrongful convictions featured in Netflix’s “The Innocent Man,” based on the true story which inspired John Grisham’s famous novel. The two men convicted for the crime spent more than a decade in prison before being exonerated by DNA evidence. Sheppard is now a widely admired reform advocate.
Other forum participants included the ACLU/OK’s Ryan Kiesel, former Speaker of the Oklahoma House Kris Steele, a public defender, an assistance district attorney, a judge, a journalist, former inmates, and many others who are intimately familiar with Oklahoma’s horribly flawed criminal justice system.
Stevenson’s keynote was devoted to a renunciation of the “politics of revenge,” and a call for “friends of faith … to lift up our voices.” However, the noted attorney and author was free to make such a passionate case because he has three decades of experience in using facts to defend his clients. Stevenson also made an understated observation which helps explain what may be the greatest flaw of the system. He explained, “Our courts are too committed to finality, not fairness.”
Ryan Kiesel was more blunt in describing what I (a former legal historian) would indict as the original sin of the system. Prosecutors drive a system where 95 or more percent of cases are settled with a plea bargain. The system would break down if many defendants asserted their right to a jury trial. This means that district attorneys exercise their unchecked power to overcharge, to intimidate defendants into accepting a plea CONTINUE READING: Oklahoma Prosecutors Defy the Will of Voters Seeking Criminal Justice Reform - Living in Dialogue

Really, the United States has to tear down its public schools and start over? | Crazy Normal - the Classroom Exposé

Really, the United States has to tear down its public schools and start over? | Crazy Normal - the Classroom Exposé

Really, the United States has to tear down its public schools and start over?


I do not know how I ended up on a list that keeps sending me e-mails from The Medium. Most of the time I delete those e-mails without opening them, but recently I noticed that The Medium was publishing a series of posts that attacked America’s public schools and teachers and it seems every day there was another assault.

This is one of those hatchet jobs: 20 Ways American Schools Fail Students.

Megan E. Holstein starts with, “Everyone knows the American school system is broken.”  A few sentences later, she says, “American Education is broken beyond repair. We need to scrap the entire thing and start over.”
Here is my response (revised for this post) that I left in a comment following Holstein’s alleged propaganda hack piece that I think was written to help destroy what’s left of the U.S. public education system. To be clear, the American school system is not broken. Public education is underfunded and teachers are being blamed for the results of too much useless testing that only benefits the corporations that profit from it.


If the American school system is broken, then some very wealthy and powerful individuals like Betsy DeVos, David Coleman, Arne Duncan, Bill Gates, and the Walmart Walton family are responsible.


However, the NAEP is the Nation’s Report Card, and it clearly shows improvement and progress in the nation’s public schools starting in 1969 up until NCLB in 2001. After that, the progress flattened out. The No Child Left Behind Act ushered in an era of high-stakes, rank-and-punish tests and abandoned what was working.
The NAEP report said, “As noted earlier, one of the national educational goals calls for increases in students’ academic achievement. A stated objective of this goal is that the performance distribution for minority students will more closely reflect that of the student population as a whole. In some of the subject areas assessed by NAEP, results indicated progress toward meeting this goal.” — Page xi
In addition, a study released by Stanford University offers more evidence that America’s public school are not failing: “Poor ranking on international test misleading about U.S. student performance, Stanford researcher finds”
“There is an achievement gap between more and less disadvantaged students in every country; surprisingly, CONTINUE READING: Really, the United States has to tear down its public schools and start over? | Crazy Normal - the Classroom Exposé

Friday, March 8, 2019

UPDATE: Community leaders come together to launch 'Save Sac Schools' from state takeover | abc10com #Unite4SACKids #WeAreSCTA #WeAreCTA #strikeready #REDFORED #SCTA #CTA

Community leaders come together to launch 'Save Sac Schools' from state takeover | abc10.com

Community leaders come together to launch 'Save Sac Schools' from state takeover
The Sacramento City Unified School District announced at its board meeting Thursday it will cut 30 administrative positions as part of its efforts to prevent a state takeover.


Big Education Ape: Amid fiscal turmoil, Sac Unified faces possible state takeover | Capitol Weekly #Unite4SACKids #WeAreSCTA #WeAreCTA #strikeready #REDFORED #SCTA #CTA - https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2019/02/amid-fiscal-turmoil-sac-unified-faces.html



SACRAMENTO, Calif. — The Sacramento City Unified School District announced at its board meeting Thursday it will cut 30 administrative positions as part of its efforts to prevent a state takeover.
District officials said the cuts will reduce the general fund by an estimated 4 percent, adding to the already $1 million recently cut from the administrator's office.
The district said it will also work with teacher and staff unions to make other changes including "having employees provide plans to use their vacation time and not allow it to accrue over time."


Before the board meeting started, a group of parents, custodians, bus drivers, cafeteria and maintenance workers gathered at the district headquarters to launch a campaign called "Save Sac Schools."
Dozens of community, labor, and business leaders spoke at the rally with one message: No state takeover.
"Being taken over by the state is not an option," said Cassandra Jennings with the Greater Sacramento Urban League.
Michelle Rubalcava, a parent and former PTA president, urged all parties to work together for students' future.
"I implore all of you who care about our children, please come to the table and have a real conversation about how to put our students first," Rubalcava said.
Sacramento NAACP President Betty Williams added, "Because we are here, we are not against anyone, but we are for everyone to give their fair share in supporting our school district and the children."
Among those who attended the rally was Mike Beverly, a machinist who's been with the district for more than 30 years.
"I graduated from C.K. McClatchy, my mother worked for the district, my son works for the district, I work for the district, and its all about getting these kids an education," Beverly said.
Richard Owen, Executive Director for United Professional Educators, explained what he's hoping to see next following the launch of the Save Sac Schools initiative.
"We're just hoping that the district, and particularly SCTA, will come together and resolve their differences," Owen said. "We're not just interested in resolving the immediate budget crisis, we want to change the culture of the Sac City school district so that this never happens again," Owens explained.
Continue the conversation with Daniela on Facebook.
________________________________________________________________
The Sacramento City Unified School District may start the 2019-2020 school year two-weeks earlier than it has in previous years.





Sac City Unified School District needs more sunshine

Preston Jackson.jpg
Preston Jackson





As an elected school board member, I have a much different take on the concerns raised in the Sacramento City Unified School District than do Marcos Bretón, the Sac City school board and some others who appear to be trying to sweep fiscal mismanagement and potential conflicts of interest under the rug.
I was elected to the school board in the Washington Unified School District in West Sacramento and I have taught in the SCUSD since 2005. I also serve on the bargaining committee of the Sacramento City Teachers Association (SCTA).
I believe these different experiences give me a unique insight into what’s happening in the SCUSD.
As a school board member, I would not have approved allowing a superintendent simultaneously to be employed by another institution and our district. Our students deserve a full-time superintendent. CONTINUE READING: Sac City Unified School District needs more sunshine

Big Education Ape: ATTENTION SACRAMENTO CITY UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT: CHICKENS COMING HOME TO ROOST - http://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2019/03/attention-sacramento-city-unified.html

Educator to build on historic teach-in to end Trump's incarceration of immigrant children - Education Votes

Educator to build on historic teach-in to end Trump's incarceration of immigrant children - Education Votes

Historic teach-in to end Trump’s incarceration of immigrant children energizes teachers
Image result for Historic teach-in to end Trump̢۪s incarceration of immigrant children energizes teachers


Sarahí Monterrey’s daughters felt unsettled about the trip that would take their mom 1,600 miles from them and their daily routines together. Monterrey comforted them by counting aloud   ̶ “one, two”   ̶ the number of nights before she returned.
“Mommy’s going to help and be a voice for children,” she explained.
Reassurances to her children aside, Monterrey, the 2019 Wisconsin Teacher of the Year, was not quite sure what to expect at last month’s national teach-in in El Paso, Texas. But when she met another teacher on her outbound flight to the daylong event, the chance run-in reinforced her decision.
The goal of Monterrey, other Teachers of the Year, fellow educators, community leaders, and students is to raise awareness and demand an end to the Trump administration’s incarceration of more than 11,000 immigrant toddlers, children, and teens, some as young as 5 months old. The event was organized by Teachers Against Child Detention, a group founded by Mandy Manning, the 2018 National Teacher of the Year.
There have been more than 4,500 complaints from October 2014 to July 2018 about sexual abuse of incarcerated immigrant children by adult staff, including fondling, kissing, and rape, the U.S. Justice Department revealed last week. The complaints spiked when the Trump administration hastily introduced its “zero tolerance” policy of separating migrant families at the border.
In December, two children — a 7-year-old girl and an 8-year-old boy — died from illness while detained.
Monterrey, an English Learner teacher at Waukesha North High School, gathered with the other educators on a mostly sunny and brisk day less than half a mile from the U.S.-Mexico border. They took turns delivering lesson blocks related to immigration and immigrant children, including one about long-lasting emotional CONTINUE READING: Educator to build on historic teach-in to end Trump's incarceration of immigrant children - Education Votes


Eli Broad weighs in at last minute with $100,000 donation in L.A. school board race - Los Angeles Times

Eli Broad weighs in at last minute with $100,000 donation in L.A. school board race - Los Angeles Times

Eli Broad weighs in at last minute with $100,000 donation in L.A. school board race
Philanthropist Eli Broad inserted himself into a pivotal Los Angeles school board race at the last second this week, making the largest individual donation to any candidate.
Broad’s $100,000 didn’t go directly to a candidate for the open District 5 seat, but to a union running its own campaign on behalf of Heather Repenning. Such independent campaigns have no donation limits.
The election day contribution went to a political action committee run by Local 99 of Service Employees International, which represents school district employees. Broad has frequently opposed unions politically.
Local 99’s ideological alliances have sometimes shifted. It has typically supported board members running for reelection regardless of who else supports them.
Repenning’s campaign is currently on hold as more than 4,700 ballots still are being counted. She is just behind Graciela Ortiz, in a virtual tie, for the second spot in a May 14 runoff for the office; after the initial vote count on Tuesday, only 53 votes separated them. Only one of them will make it to the ballot to face Jackie Goldberg, who far outpaced all other candidates.
In Tuesday’s vote, Repenning and Ortiz finished about 35 percentage points behind Goldberg, who nearly won a majority of votes, which would have eliminated the need for a continue reading: Eli Broad weighs in at last minute with $100,000 donation in L.A. school board race - Los Angeles Times

CURMUDGUCATION: TX: Charters Don't Want To Serve All Students

CURMUDGUCATION: TX: Charters Don't Want To Serve All Students

TX: Charters Don't Want To Serve All Students


The  charter school pitch often focuses on the idea that all students deserve choices, that families should be able to explore options.

Here's the CEO of KIPP Texas, speaking about the big Texas KIPP merger:

We realized our organizations wanted to improve student success across the state and we wanted to create an environment to serve more KIPPsters.

And here's Starlee Coleman, CEO of the Texas Charter School Association (as well as co-founder of SchoolForward, a choice PR firm; policy advisor at the State Policy Network; VP of Communications, National Alliance for Public [sic] Charter Schools; and various high-level positions with the Goldwater Institute), just last fall:


Don’t you deserve the chance to explore a variety of options, just like you have when making other decisions that impact your family’s future?

It turns out that when Coleman says "you," she doesn't actually mean "you everybody." Only certain select "you."

Here she is earlier this week, arguing against a "bad idea" that has "taken root" in the legislature. What is the bad idea? What is she railing against as a threat to charter schools in Texas?

A proposal that charter schools should have to accept all students.

Charter schools in Texas have some pretty cushy deals. For instance, in Austin, charters actually get $1740 more per students than the public system. And charters also have a fun item in Texas law-- they do not have to accept any student who has a record of disciplinary issues.

To read Coleman's piece, one would think we're talking about young felons with a rap sheet a mile CONTINUE READING: 
CURMUDGUCATION: TX: Charters Don't Want To Serve All Students


DeVos’s New Tuition Tax Credit Voucher Proposal Is Dead on Arrival in Congress | janresseger

DeVos’s New Tuition Tax Credit Voucher Proposal Is Dead on Arrival in Congress | janresseger

DeVos’s New Tuition Tax Credit Voucher Proposal Is Dead on Arrival in Congress


Even if you believe public schools are among America’s most important public institutions, you have to give Betsy DeVos credit. She is perfectly consistent and doggedly persistent. Last week she proposed a new $5 billion federal tuition tax credit neo-voucher program.  She is determined to privatize the public schools; fortunately she doesn’t seem to be getting anywhere.
For the NY TimesErica Green describes DeVos’s pitch: “She called it a ‘bold’ proposal that gives ‘hundreds of thousands of students across the country the power to find the right fit for their education… The biggest winners will be America’s forgotten children, who will finally have choices previously available only for the rich, the powerful and the well-connected.'”
So… what is Betsy proposing in 2919?  The Washington Post‘s Laura Meckler explains: “The proposal would authorize a 100 percent credit for contributions to any state-sanctioned scholarship fund, meaning donors could get back their entire donation through their federal taxes… The maximum credit would be set at 10 percent of an individual’s adjusted gross income, or 5 percent of a business’s net taxable income.  Overall, the program would be capped at $5 billion a year.”
The thing is that, except for Texas Senator Ted Cruz  and Rep. Bradley Byrne of Alabama, who are among the proposal’s sponsors in Congress, nobody seems to think DeVos’s new tuition tax credit vouchers are a good idea.
Meckler reports: “A similar federal tax credit was pushed in the first year of the Trump CONTINUE READING:DeVos’s New Tuition Tax Credit Voucher Proposal Is Dead on Arrival in Congress | janresseger
Image result for  Dead on Arrival

Choosing Democracy: SCUSD Plans for Teacher Lay Offs #Unite4SACKids #WeAreSCTA #WeAreCTA #strikeready #REDFORED #SCTA #CTA

Choosing Democracy: SCUSD Plans for Teacher Lay Offs

SCUSD Plans for Teacher Lay Offs


Sac City Unified Board decided to give 163 Lay Off notices to current teachers for the coming year in a vote on March 7, 2019.  In 2018/2019 the district received more money from Local Control Funding ( LCFF). Than in prior years, however they have a new deficit.  The board members argue that savings that could be made by changing the funding of health benefits.  This claim is related to a dispute over the existing contract between the district and the Teaches Union.   The Board voted unanimously  to issue the lay off notices. 

The district is at https://www.scusd.edu

The teachers union is currently conducting a vote by its members  for permission to  prepare for a strike. 
The budget challenges  faced by the district have placed the district  under the threat of state takeover as it wrestles with a $35 million budget gap. The district has yet to respond with a budget revision that would resolve the funding gap. 
It appears from the hearing that the district does not have a plan to resolve the budget shortfall.  Instead, they continue a public relations attempt to force the teachers union to accept a unilateral revision of the already signed contract. 
Board of Education Members 
Jessie Ryan, President, (Trustee Area 7)
Darrel Woo, Vice President, (Trustee Area 6) Michael Minnick, 2
nd Vice President, (Trustee Area 4) Lisa Murawski, (Trustee Area 1)
Leticia Garcia, (Trustee Area 2)
Christina Pritchett, (Trustee Area 3)
Mai Vang, (Trustee Area 5)
Rachel Halbo, Student Member 

Choosing Democracy: SCUSD Plans for Teacher Lay Offs


Big Education Ape: ATTENTION SACRAMENTO CITY UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT: CHICKENS COMING HOME TO ROOST - https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2019/03/attention-sacramento-city-unified.html