Vergara v. California Appeal Underway: The Case that Will Yield No Winners
In June of 2014, defendants in “Vergara v. California” in Los Angeles, California lost the case. Plaintiffs included nine public school students (backed by some serious corporate reformer funds as per Students Matter) who challenged five California state statutes that supported the state’s “ironclad [teacher] tenure system.” The prosecution’s argument was that students’ rights to a good education were being violated by teachers’ job protections…protections that were making it too difficult to fire “grossly ineffective” teachers. The prosecution’s suggested replacement to the “old” way of doing this, of course, was to use value-added scores to make “better” decisions about which teachers to fire and whom to keep around, as based on teachers’ causal impacts on students’ “data.”
This week, this case is being appealed, back in Los Angeles (see a recent Education Week article on the appeal here; see also the Students Matter website for daily appeal updates here). This, accordingly, is a very important case to watch, especially as many agree that this case will eventually end up in no lesser than the state’s Supreme Court.
On this note, though, I came across a great article, also in Education Week, this morning, capturing as per the article’s title, the “Five Reasons Vergara Is Still Unwinnable.” I already tweeted this one out, but for those of you not following us on Twitter, I didn’t want you to miss this one.
The author — Charles Taylor Kerchner, Research Professor at Claremont Graduate University — puts the key pieces of the case in context as well as under a fair and appropriate light, more specifically explaining why “this is a case that the plaintiffs can’t Vergara v. California Appeal Underway: The Case that Will Yield No Winners | VAMboozled!:
