Friday, September 25, 2026

HOLY TAX DOLLARS, BATMAN! WELCOME TO THE RELIGIOUS CHARTER SCHOOL BUFFET

 

HOLY TAX DOLLARS, BATMAN! WELCOME TO THE RELIGIOUS CHARTER SCHOOL BUFFET

A holy dispatch from the front lines of America's newest constitutional food fight

Step Right Up, Pick Your Faith, Get Your Voucher!

Forget Chick-fil-A versus Popeyes. America's real culture war is now being fought in the hallowed halls of publicly funded education, where U.S. District Judge David L. Russell just fired a starting pistol that sent every religious organization in the country sprinting toward their nearest school board application form.

Thanks to a preliminary injunction ruling out of Oklahoma, the National Ben Gamla Jewish Charter School Foundation is poised to become the nation's first publicly funded religious charter school — and somewhere in a dimly lit boardroom, every denomination from here to Scientology just sat up very, very straight.

The logic is elegant in that specifically American way: if you're going to hand out public school charters like Halloween candy, you can't tell the kid in the devil costume he can't have any. The Free Exercise Clause says so. The Supreme Court has been strongly hinting at this for years. And now, Oklahoma — the state that can't seem to stay out of constitutional headlines — has become ground zero for the most gloriously chaotic education experiment since someone decided dodgeball was a learning objective.

The Ruling, Translated From Legalese Into English

Here's what actually happened, stripped of the judicial robes:

  • Ben Gamla applied to run a Jewish charter school in Oklahoma. The state said "Absolutely not — charter schools must be nonsectarian."
  • Judge Russell said "Actually, turning someone away purely because they're religious is unconstitutional discrimination under the Free Exercise Clause." He cited a growing stack of Supreme Court precedents that have been systematically dismantling the wall between public funds and religious institutions — brick by carefully argued brick.
  • The Oklahoma Charter School Board, in a move of spectacular institutional cowardice, essentially shrugged and declined to fight it. A group of taxpayers and education advocates had to jump in as intervenors to defend the nonsectarian requirement themselves.
  • The Establishment Clause crowd — those quaint folks who still believe the First Amendment cuts both ways — argued that funding religious instruction with public money is precisely what the Constitution was designed to prevent. They are not wrong. They are also, currently, losing.

The beautiful irony? Oklahoma's own state Supreme Court already struck down a Catholic virtual charter school — St. Isidore of Seville — as unconstitutional under state law. So Oklahoma simultaneously has a state court saying "no religious charters" and a federal court saying "you must allow religious charters." The state of Oklahoma is essentially a constitutional pretzel at this point.

The Inevitable Parade of Applicants

Here's where it gets delicious. Because the ruling doesn't say Christian schools get a pass — it says religious organizations cannot be discriminated against. And that, dear reader, opens the most spectacular Pandora's Box in American educational history.

Brace yourself for the 2027 Oklahoma Charter School Application Season:

School NameCurriculum HighlightMascot
Ben Gamla Jewish Charter SchoolTorah, Talmud, and Advanced PlacementThe Maccabee
St. Isidore Catholic Virtual SchoolLatin Mass via ZoomThe Fighting Saints
The Satanic Temple Charter School & Bath HouseCritical thinking, bodily autonomy, and AP Goat HusbandryBaphomet the Enlightened
Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster AcademyPastafarian Physics, Pirate HistoryCap'n Marinara
Scientology STEM PrepDianetics, E-Meter Calibration, Celebrity StudiesTom C.
First Church of Cannabis High SchoolAgricultural Science, Mellow PhilosophyThe Blazing Falcons

The Satanic Temple, for the record, is absolutely not joking around. They have lawyers. They have a track record of exploiting every "but we meant OUR religion" loophole with surgical precision. The moment this ruling becomes precedent, their application will be printed, notarized, and hand-delivered with a smile so wide it could only be described as diabolical.

This is, of course, entirely the point. Religious liberty is only principled when it applies to all religions equally. The Satanic Temple has been making this argument — brilliantly, trollishly, and completely legally — for years. Oklahoma may be about to learn this lesson in the most expensive way possible.

The Supreme Court Is Warming Up Its Bible

Legal analysts are watching this with the barely-contained excitement of people who know a blockbuster sequel is coming. The underlying tension is a genuine constitutional clash of titans:

In one corner: The Free Exercise Clause — "Government cannot discriminate against religious organizations in public benefit programs." The Supreme Court has ruled this way in Trinity Lutheran (2017), Espinoza v. Montana (2020), and Carson v. Makin (2022), each decision nudging the door open a little wider.

In the other corner: The Establishment Clause — "Government shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion." Also the First Amendment. Also very much still in the Constitution, despite its increasingly vintage aesthetic in current jurisprudence.

The tension is real, the stakes are enormous, and the current Supreme Court has shown all the restraint of a golden retriever near an open refrigerator when it comes to expanding religious access to public funds.

The St. Isidore case is already knocking on the Supreme Court's door. Ben Gamla just kicked it open from the other side. At some point — probably sooner than anyone is comfortable with — SCOTUS will have to sit down and definitively answer the question:

"Can the government fund a school that teaches your kid that the other kid's religion is wrong?"

The answer will reshape American education for a generation. No pressure.

The Takeaway: Congratulations, You Played Yourself, Oklahoma

The deep, structural irony of this entire saga is that the "school choice" movement — which spent decades arguing for publicly funded alternatives to public schools — has successfully dismantled the legal firewall that kept religion out of the public treasury. The mechanism they built to fund their preferred religious schools is the same mechanism that will fund every religious school, including the ones that make them deeply uncomfortable.

The rules of constitutional law are refreshingly simple: You cannot build a door that only opens for your team. Once you establish that religious identity cannot be a disqualifying factor for public benefit programs, you have established it for every religious identity — the beloved and the bizarre, the mainstream and the magnificently weird.

America is about to find out, at significant public expense, whether it actually believes in religious freedom or whether it just believes in its religion's freedom.

Either way, the school board meetings are going to be spectacular.

The author would like to note that no actual Bath Houses were harmed in the writing of this article, and that the Flying Spaghetti Monster has been a legally recognized religion in several countries since 2005. May you be touched by His Noodly Appendage — and may your charter school application be processed in a timely manner.




Sources & Links

⚖️ The Ben Gamla Jewish Charter School Ruling

🏛️ The St. Isidore Catholic Charter School & Supreme Court

😈 The Satanic Temple & The "Every Religion" Problem

📖 Key Supreme Court Precedents Referenced

These three SCOTUS rulings form the legal backbone of the entire debate:

CaseYearRuling
Trinity Lutheran Church v. Comer2017States cannot exclude religious orgs from public benefit programs
Espinoza v. Montana Dept. of Revenue2020Religious schools cannot be excluded from scholarship programs
Carson v. Makin2022Maine must include religious schools in tuition assistance programs

All three are available in full at Supreme Court of the United States — supremecourt.gov

All links were active and verified as of September 25, 2026. Legal documents and court filings may be subject to updates as litigation continues.




at