Tuesday, May 13, 2014

Researchers give failing marks to national effort to measure good teaching | Education By The Numbers

Researchers give failing marks to national effort to measure good teaching | Education By The Numbers:



Researchers give failing marks to national effort to measure good teaching

Screen Shot 2014-05-13 at 9.47.17 AMSchool systems around the country are trying to use objective, quantifiable measures to identify which are the good teachers and which are the bad ones. One popular approach used in New York, Chicago and other cities, is to calculate a value-added performance measure (VAM). Essentially, you create a model that begins by calculating how much kids’ test scores, on average, increase each year. (Test score year 2 minus test score year 1). Then you give a high score to teachers who have students who post test-score gains above the average. And you give a low score to teachers whose students show smaller test-score gains. There are lots of mathematical tweaks, but the general idea is to build a model that answers this question: are the students of this particular teacher learning more or less than you expect them to?  The teachers’ value-added scores are then used to figure out which teachers to train, fire or reward with bonuses.
Two academic researchers from the University of Southern California and the University of Pennsylvania looked at these value-added measures in six districts around the nation and found that there was weak to zero relationship between these new numbers and the content or quality of the teacher’s instruction.
“These results call into question the fixed and formulaic approach to teacher evaluation that’s being promoted in a lot of states right now,” said Morgan Polikoff, one of the study’s authors, in a video that explains his paper, “Instructional Alignment as a Measure of Teaching Quality,” published online in Education Evaluation and Policy Analysis on May 13, 2014. ”These measures are not yet up to the task of being put into, say, an index to make important summative decisions about teachers.”
Polikoff of the University of Southern California and Andrew Porter of the University of Researchers give failing marks to national effort to measure good teaching | Education By The Numbers:


High school guidance counselors must honor students’ individual dreams, ambitions
In New Orleans schools there are a lot of teachers, principals and guidance counselors who encourage students to go to college so much and so vigorously that it seems as though they are forcing the idea of college on them. I have advisors who encourage me to attend a four-year university at both my high school, Lake Area New Tech, and at Bard Early College, a college preparation program I attend p
A Pennsylvania district takes on cyber charters
The class on dramatic irony promised to be cool. Seniors in Nicole Roeder’s English class at Quakertown Community High School had to watch a set of videos, including the trailers from “Ferris Bueller’s Day Off” and a scene from “Othello” as interpreted by two different theater troupes. But the computer program wasn’t working and the Othello scenes had stalled. So Cheyenne Knight, 18, switched gear