Wednesday, February 27, 2013

A Moratorium on School Closings Makes Sense « City School Stories

A Moratorium on School Closings Makes Sense « City School Stories:


A Moratorium on School Closings Makes Sense

A School’s Value Cannot Be So Easily Calculated
Originally posted on the Notebook Blog by Frank Murphy on Feb 26 2013
Posted in Commentary


Superintendent William Hite has changed a flawed school-closings plan, and the revision was an encouraging sign. Hearing the concerns and suggestions of individual school communities was exactly what Dr. Hite needed to do in order to demonstrate that he is pursuing a school reform agenda responsive to the best interests and needs of city neighborhoods. It is time that the members of the School Reform Commission do the same.
To fully grasp the impact that a school has on the children it serves, one must first understand the neighborhood where those children live. A school is not an island. It is part of the social web of a community. With schools operating in economically distressed areas, they can, and often do, serve as beacons of hope. They are lighthouses, so they shouldn’t be judged in the same way as other institutions.
Meade Elementary at 18th Street near Cecil B. Moore Avenue in North Philadelphia, a school where I was once principal, acts as a vital part of the community. That did not stop District officials from putting it on the original closure list. Although it was subsequently taken off the list, we still aren’t sure how officials calculated its value in reversing their decision. So let me do that for you.
At present, Meade provides good instruction, offers a wide array of other services like parent outreach programs