Rob Levine, a Resistance-to-Privatization blogger in Minneapolis, reports here on the failure of the Bush Foundation’s bold “teacher effectiveness” initiative, which cost $45 million. All wasted. The foundation set bold goals. It did not meet any of them. Levine writes: Ten years ago the St Paul-based Bush Foundation embarked on what was at the time its most expensive and ambitious project ever:
The federal Charter Schools Program handed out $440 Million this year. Betsy DeVos uses this money as her personal slush fund to reward corporate charter chains like KIPP ($89 million), IDEA (over $200 million in two years), and Success Academy ($10 million). Originally, it was meant to launch start-up charters, but DeVos has turned it into a free-flowing spigot for some of the nation’s richest c
George Packer, who usually writes for the New Yorker, recently wrote an angry tirade about the progressive elementary school in which he enrolled his child. Readers quickly identified it as Brooklyn New School, one of the most progressive in the city. He complained, among other things, that he and his child felt pressured to “opt out” of state testing, and he seems to like the state tests. But th
Did Los Angeles board member Nick Melvoin share privileged information with the representatives of the charter school industry? Please sign this petition to call for an investigation.
The New York Times Magazine published a heart-breaking photo essay about the abandonment of schools in Puerto Rico, first because of its debt crisis, then because of federal privatization policy after hurricanes in 2017. The Island has been strangled by financiers, then raped by DeVos-style policies, and the public schools were the victims. The writer was Jonathan M. Katz. It begins: During the b
Students are joining protests today to demand action on climate change. One teen has become the face of this movement: Greta Thunberg. She has been tireless in calling attention to the need to take action now to save the planet. https://www.cnn.com/2019/09/20/us/greta-thunberg-profile-weir/index.html In the U.S., Trump has been tireless in rolling back every environmental protection. Even his chi
Amy Frogge was a two-term elected member of the Metro Nashville school board. She is a lawyer and a parent activist. She posted this fascinating account on her Facebook page. Amy Frogge is one of the heroes of the Resistance who is featured in my forthcoming book Slaying Goliath: The Passionate Resistance Against Privatization and the Fight to Save America’s Public Schools (January 21, 2020). She
Investigative journalist Jeff Bryant has published a bombshell article about entrepreneurs who operate superintendent searches, then call on their Superintendents to buy professional development, technology, training, and other services. The conflicts of interest and self-dealing are shocking. Districts lose millions of dollars and buy services they don’t need, while the search service continues
Tom Ultican, a former teacher of physics and advanced mathematics in California, is diligently analyzing the tentacles of the Corporate Reform Movement, which he calls the Destroy Oublic Education Movement. Relay Graduate School: a Slick “MarketWorld” Education Fraud In this post, he scrutinizes the Relay “Graduate School of Education,” a program run by the charter industry to give master’s degre
Teresa Hanafin writes “Fast Forward” for the Boston Globe, where this appeared. I love her writing. Trump has no public events on his schedule today, probably clearing the decks so he and his toadies can figure out how to explain away a troubling revelation by The Washington Post: This summer, during communications with a foreign leader — one US official said it was a phone call — Trump made a pr
Rhode Island Governor Gina Raimondo is a true believer in corporate reform. She wants to fixlow test scores by opening charter schools and hiring TFA teachers to staff them and the public schools. Governor Raimondo was previously an investment banker. Bob Shepherd, expert teacher, curriculum writer, assessment developer, and author, has an offer for Governor Raimondo: Dear Governor Raimondo: I ca
Faced with low test scores in Providence, Central Falls, and other districts, Rhode Island Governor Gina Raimondo wants more teachers from Teach for America, who have only five weeks of training. She is a deep-dyed Corporate Reformer who believes in the magic of privatization by charter schools and inexperienced, ill-trained TFA. This will not end well for the students.
Nancy Bailey posted this great piece last May, but I missed it then. It remains super-timely. 35 Ways They Dumb Down America: Still, There’s Hope! She writes. If you’ve ever worried what the future will hold without public schools, watching legislators destroy those schools in Florida and Tennessee this past week was gloomy. But there they were with smiles in Florida, and a little less jubilant i
The definition of insanity: funding an experimental education program, discovering that it failed, then funding it some more and expecting different results. Another definition of insanity: funding a voucher program that depresses student achievement, then demanding more voucher funds so more students can fall behind. Why fund failure? Despite Poor Academic Results Groups Sue to Grow Private Scho
Audrey Watters writes a brilliant blog about Ed-tech and its misadventures. It is called HEWN, or Hack Education Weekly Newsletter. She wrote a post recently about what happened when a tech investor tweeted that he refused to invest in AltSchool because it was a truly bad idea. AltSchool raised $174 million to demonstrate that the solutions to the problems of education were embedded in technology
Every year since 2014, Democrats who fervently support the privatization of public schools have gathered at a conference they pretentiously call “Camp Philos.” https://campphilos.org/ Check the agenda of meetings present and past. There you will see the lineup of Democrats who sneer at public schools and look on public school teachers with contempt. These are the Democrats who support the DeVos a
The Denver school Board is up for grabs, and a battle looms between progressives supporting public schools and a slate controlled by Stand for Children, Democrats for Education Reform, and groups controlled by Wall Street and billionaires. The “reformers” support school closures, disruption, charter schools, and high-stakes testing. The powerful, who control the board, say that any challenge to t
Assistant U.S. Secretary of Education Scott Stump traveled to Arizona to celebrate the success of charter schools, and he did so at a public magnet school! This top education official insisted that Tucson’s University High is a charter school. When he was corrected by a reporter after his news conference, he continued to insist that the public high school was a charter school. Like his boss, Bets
This is one of the best of Jan Resseger’s many brilliant posts. In it, she quotes a surprising source, who explains the importance, centrality, and necessity of public schools as anchors of their communities. As you may have guessed, I am a huge admirer of this insightful, wise woman. Please print this out, email it, tweet it, put it on Facebook, share it with your friends. I never quote a post i
Trump took action today to prevent California from having fuel standards tougher than those of the federal government. This is a Republican who doesn’t believe in local or state control or in the Environmental Protection Agency l, created by President Nixon. Conservatives conserve. Trump destroys and despoils. https://www.latimes.com/environment/story/2019-09-17/trump-revokes-california-environme
Politico Education reports that Secretary Betsy DeVos and her political appointees are fanning out across the country to promote charters, vouchers, and educational “freedom” from public schools. She will be in Indiana and Ohio, which already have vouchers and charters, most of which are low-performing. Under DeVos, the official mission of the U.S. Department of Education is to destroy and privat
Please register before it is too late! Don’t be left out! Register now and take advantage of the Early Bird reduced rate to our 6th National Conference: Neighborhood Public Schools: The Heart of Our Communities, which will take place March 28-29 in Philadelphia. Make sure you reserve your spot soon. We are limited to only 500 registrations this year, and availability will go quickly. Early Bird r
Peter Greene demonstrates here (yet again) that there is nothing that money cannot buy (and corrupt). Now it is Sesame Street (although as he points out, HBO already bought Sesame Street). Is there anything not for sale? Open the link and read the whole sorry story. If you haven’t been paying particularly close attention, you may have missed the Chan-Zuckerberg Initiative slowly inserting its hyp
Mike Klonsky writes here about the advice of former Duncan aide Peter Cunningham to Chicago: When trying to revive devastated black communities, bring in “new people.” Klonsky begins: Just when you think we’ve heard the last from the disastrous duo of Arne Duncan and Peter Cunningham , they become media go-to guys on (of all things) gun violence and community development. Remember, this was the p
Patents in Wisconsin are furious that Betsy DeVos came to their state to tout vouchers while ignoring the vast majority of students, who are enrolled in public schools. Heather DuBois Bourenane, the Executive Director of the Wisconsin Public Education Network, says that the state has had vouchers for 30 years with unimpressive results. http://www.wisconsinnetwork.org/blog/devos-response?fbclid=Iw
This is an excellent article about “The Perfect Storm of Education Reform” by three scholars: Sheryl J. Croft, Mari Ann Whitehouse, and Vera Stenhouse. It begins like this: No Child left behind (NCLB), Race to the Top (rt3), and now Common Core embody over a decade of federal and state education reform purport- edly designed to address inequities for global majority and low-income students. Howev
Stephen Dyer, former legislator and Senior fellow at Innovation Ohio, reviews Ohio’s school report cards here. http://10thperiod.blogspot.com/2019/09/charter-schools-overrepresentation-of.html Remember when charter schools were going to “save poor kids from failing public schools”? What happens when public schools outperform charter schools, as happened in 2019? Remember when charter schools were
Ohio released its school report cards. Bill Phillis summarizes the results: Charter schools report card grades dismal If there is any value in the state report card scheme, it is that it reveals the failure of the charter experiment. 71 charters or 23% received F grades compared to only seven tenths of one percent of school districts. Six charters or .3% received A grades compared to 5% of school
Mercedes Schneider writes here about a program in New Orleans to recruit new charter teachers. In the all-charter district, the teachers seem to be dropping like flies. Almost 40% of its teachers have less than three years experience. The program at Xavier University issues a certification for life, but here is the catch: the certification is valid only in New Orleans! On September 09, 2019, the
Mark Weber, aka Jersey Jazzman, recently completed a study of teachers in New Jersey. As you may know, Weber teaches in the Garden State, and he recently completed his doctoral studies. When he is blogging, he is Jersey Jazzman. When he produces studies, he is Mark Weber. In Brief: New Jersey’s Teacher Workforce, 2019 Highlights: • Teachers in New Jersey make substantially less than similarly edu
Yale opened a dining hall for its students in 1901, called The Commons . It was a common meeting ground for students who lived in many different buildings. A recent history of The Commons described it like this: They say Hogwarts’s Great Hall, home to treacle tarts and pumpkin juice, was modeled after it. That’s not true — the honor belongs to the dining hall in the College of Christ Church at Ox
Feeling the backlash in a big way, Jeb Bush’s “Chiefs for Change” issued a call to end the “Toxic Rhetoric” about school choice, especially charters. Chiefs for Change are strong proponents of privatization. Here are the current members. Is your superintendent a “Chief for Change” who wants to divert money from public schools to the Betsy DeVos agenda of school choice? They say: Recent attempts t
Rocky Killion, superintendent of the West Lafayette, Indiana, public school district, is a fighter for public schools. A few years ago, he helped to launch an outstanding film about the extremist assault on the public schools by privatizers; it is called Rise Above the Mark , and it showcases the good work done in Indiana’s public schools. Now Rocky Killion is suing the state of Indiana for permi
Here is news you can use! Carol Burris and Leonie Haimson now have a regular one-hour radio show on WBAI In New York. The show is called TALK OUT OF SCHOOL, and it will appear weekly. WBAI is part of the progressive Pacifica Network. I n their first show, t hey discussed student privacy, a subject on which Leonie is a national advocate and expert, and they analyzed current controversies about div
The Chronicle of Philanthropy published a fascinating story about a young woman who worked in the development office at MIT when the institution was seeking Jeffrey Epstein’s money. She knew it was wrong, but she was young, a newcomer, and who would care what she thought. Development support staff are rarely in the limelight, even within their own organizations. But Signe Swenson has had a whirlw
William J. Gumbert has prepared statistical analyses of charter performance in Texas, based on state data. Charters boast of their “success,” but the reality is far different from their claims. They don’t enroll similar demographics, their attrition rate is staggering, and their “wait lists” are unverified. Their claims are a marketing tool. They are not better than public schools. They undermine
Rhode Island Officials—Governor Gina Raimondo and State Commissioner Angelica Infante-Green—are looking at the expansion of the no-excuses Achievement First Charter chain as part of the “solution” to the low-scoring Providence public school district. Achievement First is a national charter chain known for high test scores, high suspension rates, and high teacher turnover. It was launched in Conne
Regular readers of this blog have often encountered comments by Susan Schwartz. Susan was a celebrated teacher in District 2 in New York City. Now she is retired and has become a very successful photographer. She mentioned recently that her work had been accepted for an exhibit, and another reader asked whether Susan would be willing to share her work here. I asked her and she responded with this
Shawgi Tell, a professor of education at Nazareth College in upstate New York, has a straightforward answer to the question he raises. His answer: No. Charter schools are not public schools . He writes: Charter school advocates have always desperately sought to convince themselves and the public that privately-run nonprofit and for-profit charter schools that operate like businesses are actually
Leonie Haimson, executive director of Class Size Matters and co-founder of the national Parent Coalition for Student Privacy (and a member of the board of the Network for Public Education) writes here about the threat to student privacy in New York. The New York Board of Regents is currently considering whether to approve a radical weakening of the state student privacy law, which would allow the
Maurice Cunningham is a political science professor at the University of Massachusetts, who has a remarkable passion for tracking Dark Money. In this post , he warns that the Walton Family has funded an AstroTurf group called “the National Parents Union,” which hopes to organize parents to demand privately-managed charter schools and to fight teachers’ unions. Cunningham is very familiar with the
Bill Phillis of the Adequacy and Equity Coalition of Ohio fears that the Supreme Court’s conservative majority, to which Trump added two religious zealots, is on the verge of eliminating the separation of church and state. This would be a huge victory for Betsy DeVos, ALEC, and the anti-government crusaders of the Right. Some states—such as Ohio, Indiana, and Florida— have already decided to igno
New York State Attorney General Leticia James stated that the Sackler Family was wiring money out of the country to protect their assets from litigation related to the opioid crisis. New York Uncovers $1 Billion in Sackler Family Wire Transfers In a court filing, the state attorney general’s office says that it has found new account transfers by members of the family that owns Purdue Pharma, the
Laura Chapman, our loyal reader and diligent researcher, writes: If you want to get past the Dintersmith rhetoric, carefully contrived to make an appealing plausible story (with some help from Frameworks Institute.org), you need to look at the website Education 2020 (ED 2020) to see the underling incoherence (hot air) in Dintersmith’s project, and who is supporting it. About Education 2020: “We (
Education is always ablaze with the latest fad (think “grit,” “think “self-esteem,” think “character education,” think “growth mindset,” think a hundred other hot topics). Now it is “social and emotional learning.” You might think that SEL is simply built into the classroom experience. But no, there is now a demand from some quarters to teach it as a separate activity or even subject. Peter Green
This is a fascinating investigation by ProPublica of the life and exaggerations of the webmaster behind the Trump campaign. Brad Parsquale is a Trumpian figure who is running Trump’s re-election campaign and is paid big bucks to market his life story of rags to riches. But it ain’t necessarily so.
Los Altos has a problem. Wealthy residents opened a charter school for their children, drawing money from the public schools to support their charter. The Bullis School is a private school that calls itself a “public” school and is funded by public dollars. Vladimir Ivanovic wrote the following update on the community’s efforts to compel the Bullis School to act like a public school, not a privat
Nancy Bailey describes here the determined effort by policymakers to stamp out play and childhood, all in the name of teaching reading long before children are ready to learn to read. Because kindergarten has become more advanced, preschool is seen as the time children must have prereading skills for kindergarten. If they don’t, it’s seen as a red flag. This makes teachers and parents push childr
Ted Dintersmith was honored by the NEA for his advocacy on behalf of public education. In this article, which appeared in Forbes, he urges support for a national commitment to investing in education and the future of our society. He writes: Education is the single most important issue determining our democracy’s future. If we continue to get it wrong, we’re headed for collapse. But if we bring th
Think dirty politics, think North Carolina. Yesterday, while some Democratic legislators and Governor Roy Cooper attended a 9/11 memorial service, the Republican legislators called a snap vote to override the governor’s veto of the state budget. They had repeatedly assured the Democrats that no votes would be recorded that morning, but they lied. If the full body of representatives had been prese
Tracy Abbott Cook, a parent in District 4 represented by Nick Melvoin, testified to the LAUSD board and asked it to investigate him based on the emails leaked to Michael Kohlhaas. The emails showed that Melvoin had collaborated with opposing counsel from the California Charter School Association. Ms. Cook believes this is a violation of Melvoin’s obligation to the voters who elected him and to hi
Sarah Sparks writes in Edweek about a curriculum company that is suing a parent in Wake County, North Carolina, for criticizing its math program. The company says the parent is defaming its product. The parent’s lawyer says the company is attacking the parent’s First Amendment rights. As the story notes, this is a SLAPP suit, a suit meant to silence public criticism. The last time I encountered t
This is an interview with Dr. Julian Vasquez Heilig, the scholar who was recently named dean of the University of Kentucky School of Education. JVH’s scholarship focuses on equity. He has written about charter schools and Teach for America. https://progressive.org/public-school-shakedown/segregation-worse-charter-schools-vasquez-heilig-miller-190909/ From the Progressive: Vasquez-Heilig and his c
Jack Hassard Taught science education for many years. He used to write a blog called “The Art of Teaching Science,” but became so upset about current events that he renamed his blog “Jack Hassard’s Blog.” In this post, he excoriates Trump’s war on science. He begins: Science was under assault last week by an un-educated President and his staff who believe that they can supercede the findings of s
I posted Gay Adelmann’s account of her efforts to see the financial records of the Kentucky PTA. Both sides ended up in court. https://dianeravitch.net/2019/09/09/kentucky-what-is-the-state-pta-hiding/ I heard from S. Coy Travis, whose law firm represents the Kentucky PTA. He wanted readers to know both sides. I invited him to write a commentary, and he did. He wrote: Isn’t Kentucky PTA subject t
Steven Singer, a teacher in Pennsylvania, has concluded that there are no good charter schools. The problem, he says, is not implementation but the concept , which, he insists, is wrong. He writes: The problem with charter schools isn’t that they have been implemented badly. Nor is it that some are for-profit and others are not. The problem is the concept, itself. Put simply: charter schools are
Four years ago, the Hechinger Report described a third-grade class in an affluent suburb of New York City where children spend 75% of the day on their iPads. Is this the future? It is not a cost-saver, since there is still one teacher
