School District court case opens up questions about 'pay to play'
by Helen Gym on Nov 13 2013 Posted in Commentary
“Pay to play” is a universally reviled practice in government, but that’s effectively what the District's legal argument would establish through its challenge of an Open Records case in state court.
For more than ten months, Parents United for Public Education and our lawyers at the Public Interest Law Center have been fighting to make public the Boston Consulting Group’s list of 60 school closings and the criteria it used for those closings. In 2012, BCG contracted with the William Penn Foundation to provide “contract deliverables,” one of which was identifying a list of 60 public schools for closure. William Penn Foundation solicited donations for this contract, including some from real estate developers and those promoting charter expansion. The “BCG list” was referenced by former Chief Recovery Officer Thomas Knudsen in public statements. But District officials refused to release the list, stating it was an internal document and therefore protected from public review.
Last spring, Parents United and PILCOP won our case with the Pennsylvania Office of Open Records, largely because the District appears to have shared the BCG list with top officials at the William Penn Foundation. Now, the District is taking its challenge to state court.
District officials aren’t just going to court to block the release of the BCG list. They want to completely redefine what it means to declare a document internal. In particular, the District's arguments show that it believes that certain and selectively defined groups -- specifically donors -- can essentially buy their way to specialized access otherwise denied to the rest of the public.
Here’s their rationale.
“William Penn Foundation’s role was that of a grantor who funded the second phase of BCG’s consultant services. As grantor, the philanthropic entity had the right – and indeed an
After counselors, District brings back assistant principals, teachers, secretaries
With the $45 million in state aid released by Gov. Corbett, Superintendent William Hite has restored 40 additional positions to schools. Nearly half of those, 19, are assistant principals. The 40 are in addition to 80 counselors that were restored earlier. The Notebook calculates that with each position costing approximately $100,000 (the assistant principals cost closer to $150,000 each, includin
Students risk a lot to buy into charismatic principal's vision
by Kevin McCorry for NewsWorks Anthony Majewski learned at an early age what it means to lose trust in the powers that be. As a 6th grader, he says he was "jacked up" by a math teacher who told him he was "never going to be anybody." "Like, he actually jacked me up, and put me up against the wall, 'cause I don't sit still too well," Majewski said, chuckling. "I d
Notes from the news, Nov. 13
Witness tells how charter's documents were doctored. Inquirer Philadelphia schools see cash in old classrooms. NY Times William Penn alums want to revive shuttered school. Daily News Philly guidance counselors transferred to teaching duty. NewsWorks Who are the educational reformers and why should anyone listen to them? NewsWorks McCall school’s partnerships give students tools to succeed. Tribune Volunteers open doors to reading for grade schoolers. Tribune This Penn student cofounded a national network of high school hackathons. Technically Philly How an independent political party helped r
by Anne L. Hunter First grader Anthony Powell Jr. can’t live without supportive services. Without them, he – like many other children with autism – he has nothing to steady him. Dawn Powell, Anthony’s mother, remembers his first bus ride to preschool at the Center for Autism. “He had to have someone sit next to him because he would take the seatbelt off and rise from his seat. It was a whole bunch of issues,” she said. “Anthony will try everything and anything he can. His challenge is to learn boundaries.” read more
YESTERDAY
Philly guidance counselors transferred to teaching duty
by Kevin McCorry for NewsWorks Wanda Raudenbush does not consider herself a teacher. Yet for the first two months of school, she woke up every school day, went to Fox Chase Elementary School, and willed herself to teach 4th grade. For the four years before this, she was a guidance counselor. This year, she was a teacher. Image: Image Caption: Wanda Raudenbush and 37 of her guidance cou
Notes from the news, Nov. 12
District, Catholic, charter schools share applications. Inquirer Activist spearheads movement for historical marker at old Edison High. Liberty City Press Dystopian Philly schools now physically, not just psychologically, unhealthy. Philly Mag Philadelphian comes clean on "How I Helped Teachers Cheat." Daily News Teaching physics with felt. Edutopia Charter school eyed by FBI, Pa. watchd