The bottom line on student tracking
In recent days I have published two pieces on the practice of grouping students by ability in schools,one post against and one post in favor of it. Here is a new piece on the subject in the form of a response to a story in Monday’s New York Times, titled, “Grouping Students by Ability Regains Favor in Classroom.” This post was written by Kevin Welner, director of the National Education Policy Center, housed at the University of Colorado Boulder School of Education.By Kevin Welner
Readers of an article on ability groupings on the front page of Monday’s New York Times couldn’t help but come away uninformed in at least three different areas.
1. While ostensibly about ability grouping, the practices described in the article appear to be in-class regrouping, or differentiation, within elementary school classrooms. The article does make clear that it’s focused just on elementary schools, but readers will likely be confused when it shifts to a broader discussion of tracking. At the secondary school level (middle and high), tracking is a very different animal – students are placed in a given level or “tracked” classroom based on their perceived abilities.
The elementary school practices described in the article are certainly “grouping” but they have few of the characteristics that dominate actual between-classroom tracking at the secondary levels and sometimes at the elementary level. The article describes
Texas governor signs legislation to reduce standardized testing
Bending to popular outrage over high-stakes standardized testing, Gov. Rick Perry signed school reform legislation Monday that revamps high school graduation requirements and cuts the number of mandatory end-of-course exams from 15 to 5. Perry had not revealed his decision … Continue reading →
Record number of twins found in a single grade at one school
A little diversion from the school reform fare: An Illinois school has 24 sets of twins in a single grade. This Associated Press story reports that the discovery was made by 11-year-old twins Luke and Ryan Novosel, who attend Highcrest … Continue reading →
How cookie-cutter school reforms cement class, race divisions
Here is an insightful look at the consequences of corporate-influenced school reform on class and race divisions in this country. It was written by Natalie Hopkinson is a contributing writer to The Washington Post. You can reach her at NHopkinson@hotmail.com. … Continue reading →
Where the National Security Agency isn’t so secret: Schools
The National Security Agency is the super-secret organization that has been in the news because of disclosures that it has, for years, been conducting U.S. surveillance programs. But in at least one area, the NSA hasn’t tried to be so … Continue reading →