Tuesday, December 13, 2011

All Things Education: In which I nitpick on the achievement gap, charters, and Rhee's legacy in DC

All Things Education: In which I nitpick on the achievement gap, charters, and Rhee's legacy in DC:

In which I nitpick on the achievement gap, charters, and Rhee's legacy in DC

With the release of the NAEP TUDA stats, there's been a lot of conversation swirling around achievement gaps and the efficacy of neo-liberal education reforms in urban districts. In particular, there's been some talk about how to judge Michelle Rhee's legacy, especially in light of the fact that that DC has the largest achievement gap between black and white students and one of the highest between poor and non-poor of all the cities featured in the report. Education journalists such as Alexander Russo weighed in here and Dana Goldstein offered some mostly solid analysis here.

Some folks are saying that Rhee's policies caused the gap. I don't agree with this. While Rhee's policies are no good, let's be honest: that gap was there way before Rhee came to town. Furthermore, DC has always had