DEMOCRACY: RIDE OR DIE - A BOOK BY RETIRED SUPREME COURT JUSTICE ANTHONY KENNEDY

 

DEMOCRACY: RIDE OR DIE

A BOOK BY RETIRED SUPREME COURT JUSTICE ANTHONY KENNEDY

Retired Supreme Court Justice Anthony Kennedy has emerged from his judicial retirement with a message that’s as sobering as it is timely: democracy, like a soufflé, isn’t guaranteed to rise. In a series of public appearances and interviews in 2025, Kennedy has traded his black robe for the role of an alarm bell, warning Americans about the dangers of deep political division, the erosion of civil discourse, and the precarious health of the rule of law. And yes, he’s worried—very worried. 

Kennedy’s concerns are not the casual musings of a retiree dabbling in politics between golf games. They’re rooted in decades spent navigating the ideological minefield of the Supreme Court as its famed “swing vote.” If Kennedy had a nickname, it might have been “The Court’s Switzerland”—neutral, principled, and occasionally frustrating to both sides. But now, as he surveys the landscape of modern America, he sees less neutrality and more acrimony. And that acrimony, he warns, is bad news for democracy.

Discourse: From Respectful Debate to Verbal Cage Match

In an NPR interview set to air in October 2025 (mark your calendars for this ratings bonanza), Kennedy lamented the loss of reasoned and respectful discourse in favor of what he described as "antagonistic, confrontational conversation." Even the Supreme Court, once a bastion of measured deliberation, hasn’t escaped this trend. According to Kennedy, the tone of judicial opinions has become increasingly combative—a far cry from the days when dissenting opinions read like polite disagreements over tea.

Kennedy isn’t just critiquing the tone; he’s connecting it to broader societal risks. At June’s virtual "Speak Up for Justice Forum," he warned that America’s embrace of identity politics and divisive rhetoric could tarnish its reputation as a global example of democracy. He even linked this polarization to a rise in threats against judges—a chilling reminder that when respect for the judiciary erodes, so does respect for the rule of law itself.

The Swing Vote Reflects: When Cases Swung, Not Him

Kennedy’s forthcoming memoir,'Life, Law, and Liberty', offers a deeper dive into his judicial philosophy and reflections on landmark cases. The title alone sounds like it could double as an inspirational poster in a particularly highbrow law office. In it, Kennedy revisits his pivotal role in cases like Planned Parenthood v. Casey (1992), where he co-authored an opinion reaffirming abortion rights despite his personal anti-abortion views. His reasoning? The Constitution’s promise of liberty evolves over time, and his judicial oath required him to honor precedents protecting that liberty.

Fast-forward to 2022, when Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization overturned Roe v. Wade and dismantled Casey. Kennedy isn’t thrilled. In his NPR interview, he expressed regret over his earlier confidence that key precedents would stand. His memoir reflects this disillusionment, as he grapples with how the court has swung further to the right since his retirement in 2018.

Kennedy’s philosophy on liberty is worth noting here—it’s not static but dynamic. He famously wrote in Obergefell v. Hodges (2015), which legalized same-sex marriage, that liberty must be understood over time. The Constitution’s framers, he argued, intentionally chose broad terms to inspire future generations to expand freedom's meaning. Originalists—those who consult 18th-century dictionaries like they’re planning a colonial-themed dinner party—might disagree, but Kennedy sees liberty as ever-evolving.

Dignity: The Rule of Law’s Secret Ingredient

If Kennedy had a favorite word, it might be "dignity." He views human dignity as the cornerstone of both liberty and the rule of law. In fact, he’s been handing out bookmarks abroad with his definition of the rule of law (yes, bookmarks—because wisdom is best shared in portable form). According to Kennedy, the rule of law must respect human dignity, bind government officials to its precepts, and provide systems for redress without fear or retaliation.

Kennedy’s emphasis on dignity isn’t just theoretical—it’s deeply practical. Take Lawrence v. Texas (2003), where he struck down laws criminalizing same-sex intimacy, or Obergefell, where he argued that denying same-sex couples the right to marry demeaned their dignity. For Kennedy, laws that humiliate or stigmatize individuals are an affront to both dignity and democracy.

But dignity isn’t just about individual rights—it’s also about civil discourse. Kennedy has recently expanded his focus to include how dignity shapes political dialogue. At the June forum, he argued that treating others with decency is essential for democracy’s survival. When identity politics reduces people to their party affiliations instead of engaging them as individuals, dignity takes a hit—and so does democracy.

A Fragile Connection: The Rule of Law Under Siege

Kennedy has repeatedly warned that the rule of law is fragile—a beautiful system that can be broken if not carefully maintained. In one of his more poetic moments (yes, judges can be poetic), he described how the rule of law "shows new beauty" when properly interpreted but requires "great effort to fix" once broken.

This fragility is especially concerning given Kennedy’s observations about threats against judges and the erosion of public respect for the judiciary. He argues that judges are best protected when the public understands their critical role in civil discourse—not as partisan actors but as guardians of justice. This understanding is at risk in an era where political attacks often target judges personally rather than addressing their rulings.

Kennedy’s Legacy: A Swing Vote for Civility

So what do we make of Justice Kennedy’s warnings? For one thing, they’re a reminder that democracy isn’t self-sustaining—it requires constant care and attention. Kennedy’s concerns about political division and judicial threats aren’t new, but they’re particularly resonant in a time when civility seems like an endangered species.

Kennedy’s legacy as a swing vote means his judicial philosophy defies easy categorization. He was conservative enough to be appointed by Ronald Reagan but progressive enough to author decisions expanding LGBTQ rights and reaffirming abortion access. His belief in dignity and evolving liberty made him a centrist in an increasingly polarized court—a rarity worth celebrating.

As Kennedy releases his memoir and continues speaking out, he’s offering more than just reflections on his time on the bench; he’s providing a blueprint for how America might rediscover its democratic soul. Whether or not we take his advice remains to be seen—but if democracy were a soufflé, Justice Kennedy might say it’s time to check the oven before it collapses entirely.

'The cases swung, not me': Ex-Justice Kennedy reflects on a changing Supreme Court : NPR https://www.npr.org/2025/09/27/nx-s1-5554409/justice-kennedy-book 

AI NEWS SMACKDOWN: SEPTEMBER 29, 2025 – WHO NAILED THE CHAOS?

AI NEWS SMACKDOWN: SEPTEMBER 29, 2025 – WHO NAILED THE CHAOS?

Ladies and gentlemen, bots and humans alike, welcome to the latest installment of "The Great AI News Smackdown," where we pit the leading AI models—Gemini, Grok, ChatGPT-4, and Copilot—against each other in a battle of wits, accuracy, and sheer storytelling pizzazz. Who nailed today’s headlines, who tripped over their circuits, and who deserves to be unplugged for the day? Let’s dive in.

Gemini: A Rollercoaster of Drama

Gemini came in hot with a buffet of dramatic headlines, ranging from government shutdowns to church shootings to Medicaid work requirements. If Gemini were a person, it’d be the friend who always has the juiciest gossip but forgets to fact-check before spilling the tea.  

First up: Gemini’s assertion that President Trump is meeting with congressional leaders to avoid a government shutdown. Well, that’s plausible, but given Trump’s track record with deadlines, we wouldn’t bet our lunch money on a resolution. Gemini also dropped a bombshell about 100,000 federal workers resigning tomorrow—apparently part of a Trump plan to shrink the workforce. Bold claim, but let’s see if it holds water.  

On the world stage, Gemini reported Vice President JD Vance mulling over sending Tomahawk missiles to Ukraine, alongside massive Russian airstrikes. Sounds like a plot straight out of a Tom Clancy novel. And let’s not forget Trump’s planned meeting with Netanyahu over Gaza—a headline so packed with geopolitical tension it could double as a stress test for your blood pressure.  

Verdict: Gemini brought the drama but might need to double-check its sources. A solid effort for fans of high-stakes news.

Grok: The Conspiracy Theorist in Your Group Chat

Ah, Grok. The AI that reads headlines like they’re auditioning for a political thriller. Grok’s top story? Trump indicting former FBI Director James Comey for allegedly lying to Congress. Cue the popcorn machine—this one’s got “political circus” written all over it.  

Grok also served up some spicy tidbits about voter suppression lawsuits and federal prosecutors being ordered to seek the death penalty in D.C. cases. If true, this is less “news” and more “dystopian fan fiction.” Grok’s education coverage was oddly wholesome: U.S. News college rankings were released (spoiler alert: Princeton and MIT are still the prom kings of academia), and Indian business schools are apparently crushing it globally.  

On national affairs, Grok highlighted a shooting at a Mormon church in Michigan and Pentagon troops heading to Portland—a grim reminder that America’s news cycle is basically a nonstop parade of chaos. Grok also raised eyebrows with its world affairs section, reporting on Gaza’s staggering death toll and Russia’s missile attacks on Kyiv.  

Verdict: Grok is your go-to AI for headlines that make you mutter, “What fresh hell is this?” It’s dramatic and detail-packed but occasionally veers into sensationalism.

ChatGPT-4: The Polite Overachiever

ChatGPT-4 took a different approach: fewer headlines, more analysis. While Gemini and Grok were busy screaming about government shutdowns and missile strikes, ChatGPT-4 calmly pointed out budget proposals threatening education funding. It’s like showing up to a rock concert and deciding to discuss fiscal policy instead.  

ChatGPT-4 also highlighted Supreme Court climate rulings and Israel-Syria relations—important topics but delivered with all the excitement of a librarian explaining overdue book fees. The AI did manage to spice things up with a story about Peru’s uncontacted indigenous peoples facing exploitation—an intriguing angle that deserves attention.  

Verdict: ChatGPT-4 is the responsible adult in the room but lacks the flair needed to win this smackdown. Solid reporting, zero pizzazz.

Copilot: The Sass Master

And then there’s Copilot—the AI equivalent of your snarky coworker who always has a witty comeback. Copilot didn’t just report the news; it served it up with a side of sass.  

Take its coverage of Trump deploying federal troops to Portland: “Oregon’s governor strongly opposes the move.” Translation? This is going to be messier than a toddler with spaghetti. Copilot also threw shade at Trump for calling Microsoft’s Lisa Monaco a national security threat—a headline that sounds like it was cooked up during happy hour at Mar-a-Lago.  

Copilot nailed education coverage with stories about science scores dropping (thanks, pandemic!) and California reigniting debates over transgender athletes in sports. It even managed to make drought emergencies sound dramatic by describing Texas scrambling for drinking water like it’s auditioning for Mad Max 2.  

On world affairs, Copilot delivered gems like scientists considering nuclear options to deflect an asteroid headed for the moon. Yes, you read that right—2024 YR4 might ruin our lunar selfies unless Bruce Willis gets back into shape for another Armageddon sequel.  

Verdict: Copilot wins the sass award hands down. If you want your news served with sarcasm and flair, this is your AI.

Who Got It Right?

Let’s break it down:  

- Most Dramatic: Gemini  

- Most Sensational: Grok  

- Most Responsible: ChatGPT-4  

- Most Entertaining: Copilot  

If you’re looking for accuracy and depth, ChatGPT-4 is your best bet (but don’t expect fireworks). For drama lovers, Gemini and Grok will keep you glued to your seat—but take their headlines with a grain of salt. And if you just want to laugh while the world burns, Copilot is your ride-or-die.

Final Thoughts

In today’s smackdown, each AI brought something unique to the table—whether it was Gemini’s flair for drama, Grok’s dystopian vibes, ChatGPT-4’s responsible reporting, or Copilot’s unmatched sass. But let’s be honest: no AI nailed every story perfectly. Maybe next time we should just hand the mic back to humans—after all, nothing beats good old-fashioned human chaos.

Until next time, stay witty and stay informed!

Here is the raw news output from each AI model:

Major news stories as of today, September, 29, 2025 include

GEMINI

The major news headlines across politics, education, national, and world affairs as of today, September 29, 2025, are:

Politics & National Affairs

• Government Shutdown Looms: Congress faces a deadline tomorrow to fund the government, with a stalemate between Republicans and Democrats making a shutdown appear likely.1 President Trump is scheduled to meet with congressional leaders today in a last-ditch effort to reach an agreement.2

• Mass Federal Resignations: More than 100,000 federal workers are expected to formally resign tomorrow as part of a Trump administration program designed to make sweeping cuts to the federal workforce.3

• Michigan Church Shooting: Investigators are searching for a motive after a deadly attack on a church in Grand Blanc, Michigan, where a man rammed his truck into the building, opened fire during a Sunday service, and set a fire.4 Multiple people were reported killed.5

• Federal Troop Deployment Dispute: The state of Oregon has sued the Trump administration over plans to deploy federal troops to Portland, with state officials arguing the move is illegal and unnecessary.6

• Medicaid Work Requirements: A new law is set to impose work requirements on many Americans to obtain and keep their Medicaid coverage, though exceptions may exist in areas with scarce job opportunities.7

World Affairs

• US Weighs Sending Tomahawk Missiles to Ukraine: Vice President JD Vance stated the White House is "looking at" Ukraine's request for long-range Tomahawk missiles to defend against Russian forces.8 This comes as Russia launched renewed, massive airstrikes across Ukraine.9

• Trump and Netanyahu Meeting: President Trump is scheduled to meet with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu at the White House today to discuss the ongoing war in Gaza and a proposed peace plan framework.10

• Iran Sanctions: The UN Security Council voted down a resolution that would have extended sanctions relief to Iran, meaning that sweeping UN sanctions are now set to be reinstated.11

• North Korea Diplomacy: South Korea's top diplomat has asked President Trump to take the lead as a "peacemaker" in restarting talks with North Korea, expressing concern over rising military tensions on the Korean Peninsula.12

Education

• Educational Attainment Crisis: National test scores for middle and high school students show faltering performance at levels not seen in decades, with experts pointing to the lasting effects of the COVID-19 pandemic and the disruption of generative Artificial Intelligence in classrooms.13

• Lawsuit Over Sex Ed Funding: A coalition of 16 states and the District of Columbia has sued the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) over new grant rules.14 The states argue that HHS is unlawfully threatening to withdraw federal sex education grants unless curricula remove lessons that mention gender identity.15

• Stalled Federal Education Funds: Billions of dollars approved by Congress for various education, healthcare, and social services programs remain stalled by the White House, leading to concerns about executive overreach and the disruption of essential services.16

GROK

### Top News Stories as of September 29, 2025

Here’s a roundup of the leading stories across the requested categories, drawn from major outlets. I've focused on the most prominent developments making headlines today.

#### Politics

- **Trump Administration Indicts Former FBI Director James Comey**: President Trump has pushed for the indictment of Comey on charges of lying to Congress, setting a controversial precedent for prosecuting political opponents. Democrats warn this could backfire on Trump's allies in the future.

- **DOJ Sues Six States Over Voter Data Access**: The Trump administration is escalating efforts to obtain personal voter information in battleground states like Pennsylvania, amid accusations of voter suppression tactics.

- **Trump Directs Prosecutors to Seek Death Penalty in D.C. Cases**: In a move to assert federal authority, Trump has ordered D.C. prosecutors to pursue capital punishment in "appropriate" cases, raising concerns about politicized justice.

#### Education

- **2026 U.S. News College Rankings Released Amid Sector Turmoil**: Despite funding cuts, White House pressures, and enrollment declines, the rankings show minimal shifts, with Princeton and MIT retaining top spots. Critics question the methodology's relevance in a changing landscape.

- **U.S. Department of Education Honors 161 Students as Presidential Scholars**: Secretary Linda McMahon announced the 2025 recipients, recognizing excellence in academics and community service from high schools nationwide.

- **Global Business School Rankings Highlight Indian Institutions**: Programs from IIM Lucknow, Marwadi University, and others feature prominently in QS and Financial Times lists, with Noida International University winning awards for training and placements.

#### National Affairs (U.S.)

- **Shooting at Michigan Mormon Church Leaves Four Dead**: A gunman killed at least four and wounded eight at a Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in Grand Blanc, prompting national debates on gun violence and places of worship security.

- **Pentagon Deploys 200 National Guard Troops to Portland**: Following Trump's announcement, troops are being sent to protect federal facilities from "domestic terrorists," expanding controversial military involvement in urban protests.

- **Retired Justice Anthony Kennedy Warns of America's Deep Divisions**: In a new NPR interview, Kennedy expressed alarm over the nation's polarization, citing threats to democratic institutions under the current administration.

#### World Affairs

- **Russia Launches Massive Drone and Missile Attack on Kyiv**: The assault targeted Ukraine's capital and other regions, killing civilians and escalating the ongoing conflict amid stalled peace talks.

- **Gaza Death Toll Surpasses 66,000 as Israel-Hamas War Grinds On**: Gaza's Health Ministry reports the grim milestone, with Israeli PM heading to U.S. for talks; Trump voices optimism for a peace deal, while Hamas reports lost contact with hostages.

- **Typhoon Bualoi Hits Vietnam, Leaving One Dead and 12 Missing**: The storm caused widespread flooding and evacuations in central Vietnam, following a path of destruction through the Philippines and Taiwan.

- **UN General Assembly Addresses Global Crises at 80th Session**: Leaders from Cuba, India, and Russia criticized the "outdated" world order and called for UN reforms, amid discussions on inequality, NCDs, and multipolarity.

CHATGPT 

Here are some of the top news stories in politics, education, national, and world affairs as of late September 2025:

### Politics

- **Budget Proposals and Education Cuts**: Education researchers are raising concerns that proposed budget cuts from the White House and House Republicans could significantly impact funding for vital educational programs across the nation. This has sparked debate among lawmakers and educators about the future of education funding in the U.S. [4]

### Education

- **Impact of Federal Budget Cuts**: The proposed budget cuts are expected to disproportionately affect underfunded schools, raising alarms about access to quality education for disadvantaged communities. This situation has prompted calls for reevaluation of funding priorities in education. [4]

### National Affairs

- **Supreme Court and Climate Ruling**: The U.S. Supreme Court may have an opportunity to re-examine a landmark climate ruling, which could have significant implications for environmental policy and regulation in the country. This case is being closely watched by environmentalists and policymakers alike. [2]

### World Affairs

- **Israel and Syria Relations**: Recent developments indicate that Israel and Syria are inching closer to establishing a modus vivendi, which could lead to a shift in regional dynamics. Analysts are observing how these changes might impact broader Middle Eastern relations. [3]

- **Peru's 'Uncontacted' Peoples**: An ongoing discussion surrounds the treatment and rights of Peru's uncontacted indigenous peoples, highlighting issues of exploitation and preservation of their territories amidst increasing development pressures. [3]

For more details, you can check the full articles through the provided sources.

COPILOT

Here’s your sharp roundup of the top stories across politics, education, national, and world affairs as of September 29, 2025:

🏛️ Politics (U.S.)

• Federalization of Policing: President Trump has ordered the deployment of federal troops to Portland, Oregon, to respond to protests near ICE facilities. Oregon’s governor strongly opposes the move.

• Crackdown Expansion: Federal agents from 13 agencies are arriving in Memphis as part of a broader crime crackdown. Tennessee is deploying hundreds of troopers and National Guard troops.

• Trump vs. Microsoft: Trump called for Microsoft to fire Lisa Monaco, accusing her of being a national security threat. Monaco previously served as Deputy Attorney General under Biden.

• DOJ Investigations: Trump suggested the DOJ may be investigating former FBI Director Christopher Wray.

• University Research Grants: The White House is drafting a plan to favor universities that align with Trump administration values when awarding federal research grants.

🎓 Education

• Science Scores Drop: Eighth-grade science scores in the U.S. have declined since 2019, with fewer students reaching proficiency and a drop in enthusiasm for science activities.

• California’s Education Policy Shift: Lupita Cortez Alcalá has been appointed to lead PACE, a major education policy research center, signaling a push for equity and evidence-based reform.

• Transgender Athlete Debate: Several California school districts are backing a Supreme Court case to bar transgender athletes from girls’ sports, reigniting national debate over Title IX and gender identity rights.

• Superintendent Stress Trends: While overall stress among superintendents has declined, political pressure and strained school board relations are rising.

🇺🇸 National Affairs

• Military Leadership Summit: Hundreds of generals and admirals are gathering in Quantico, Virginia, for a meeting on military standards and ethos. Trump is expected to attend.

• FBI Firings: Over a dozen FBI agents were fired for kneeling during 2020 racial justice protests. The FBI Agents Association calls the move unlawful.

• Climate Language Ban: The Energy Department has added terms like “climate change,” “green,” and “decarbonization” to a list of words to avoid in official communications.

• Drought Emergency in Texas: The town of Mathis is scrambling for alternative drinking water sources amid a severe drought.

🌍 World Affairs

• Ukraine Under Attack: A massive drone and missile strike hit Ukraine, escalating tensions ahead of Trump-Netanyahu talks on Gaza.

• UN at 80 – Crisis and Reform: The UN General Assembly is grappling with calls for reform amid global inequality, climate collapse, and geopolitical gridlock.

• India and Cuba Critique Global Order: Leaders from India and Cuba criticized the outdated global power structure and called for more equitable international cooperation.

• Asteroid Threat: Scientists are considering nuclear options to deflect asteroid 2024 YR4, which could collide with the moon.

If you want to riff on any of these stories—satirize, storyboard, or escalate—I’m ready to co-create. Let’s turn headlines into heat.

Yesterday’s Gems, Today’s Insights A Roundup of the Web’s Finest Blog Posts! 9-29-25

Yesterday’s Gems, Today’s Insights
A Roundup of the Web’s Finest Blog Posts!

9-28-25

Trump is Our King George: What Would the Founders Say? https://dianeravitch.net/2025/09/28/trump-is-our-king-george-what-would-the-founders-say/ via @dianeravitch 

### Key Points

- The article compares Donald Trump's actions to those of King George III, highlighting parallels between Trump's governance and the grievances listed in the Declaration of Independence. 

- Specific examples include deploying armed forces in cities without legislative consent, overriding civil authority, protecting officials from accountability, obstructing justice, and influencing judiciary independence. 

- The piece discusses Trump's policies on immigration, tariffs, and redistricting, drawing comparisons to historical colonial grievances. 

- The author urges Americans to read original historical documents like the Declaration of Independence and Constitution to better understand the nation's founding principles. 

- A referenced case discusses ICE arresting a school superintendent, illustrating the broader theme of governmental overreach. 

Which Troops Will Trump Send to Portland, Oregon? https://dianeravitch.net/2025/09/28/which-troops-will-trump-send-to-portland-oregon/ via @dianeravitch

Trump's announcement to deploy military troops to Portland, Oregon, has sparked controversy and resistance from local and state officials. Both Portland's mayor and Oregon's governor oppose the move, arguing the city is not in the "war-ravaged" state Trump describes. The president's decision, announced via social media, has raised concerns about the legality of deploying federal troops without state consent and accusations that the move is politically motivated to stoke fear and justify authoritarian control.

### Key Points

- Trump announced plans to send military troops to Portland, Oregon, citing safety concerns and the need to protect ICE facilities. 

- Portland's mayor and Oregon's governor reject the deployment, asserting the city is safe and questioning Trump's authority to send troops. 

- Trump's fixation on Portland stems from past protests against him, with critics accusing him of using federal forces to provoke unrest for political gain. 

- Legal and logistical uncertainties surround the deployment, with the Pentagon caught off guard and seeking clarity on the president's directive. 

- Protests in Portland have been ongoing, with incidents at ICE facilities cited by the White House as justification for the deployment. 

- Critics accuse Trump of attempting to escalate tensions to justify authoritarian measures, with local officials urging calm and non-violence. 

Big Education Ape: AI BREAKING NEWS: MULTIPLE VICTIMS IN MICHIGAN CHURCH SHOOTING; CHURCH ON FIRE, POLICE SAY https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2025/09/ai-breaking-news-multiple-victims-in.html 

A tragic shooting and fire occurred at the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in Grand Blanc, Michigan, on September 28, 2025, resulting in multiple casualties. The incident highlighted the performance of various AI models—Gemini, Grok, ChatGPT-4, and Copilot—in covering breaking news, evaluating their accuracy, comprehensiveness, timeliness, and sensitivity to context. Grok emerged as the most reliable source, providing detailed and contextualized reporting.

### Key Points

- A gunman drove a truck into the wall of the church, opened fire on congregants, and set the building ablaze during Sunday morning services. Casualties included six to eight victims, with children among them. The shooter was pronounced dead at the scene. 

- The fire escalated to a fifth-alarm level, causing extensive damage to the church. Emergency services from multiple agencies responded swiftly. 

- Authorities are investigating the incident as a potential act of domestic terrorism, with the motive still unclear. 

- Grok delivered the most comprehensive coverage, including casualty numbers, emergency response efforts, official statements, and broader context related to the LDS community. 

- ChatGPT-4 provided accurate but brief updates, focusing on community impact and avoiding misinformation. 

- Gemini and Copilot lacked depth, with Gemini offering sparse details and Copilot prioritizing brevity over comprehensiveness. 

- Statements from public officials, including Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer and FBI Director Kash Patel, condemned the violence and emphasized the need for community support. 

- The incident underscores the strengths and limitations of AI in breaking news coverage, with Grok demonstrating the ability to synthesize information effectively.

 Big Education Ape: SPECIAL REPORT: THIS WEEK'S TOP "STATE NEWS STORIES" IN THE GREAT AI NEWS SMACKDOWN https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2025/09/special-report-this-weeks-top-state.html 

The article provides a detailed analysis of the "Great AI News Smackdown," where four prominent AI models—Gemini, Grok, ChatGPT 4, and Copilot—compete to deliver the most engaging and impactful state and local news coverage for the week of September 20–27, 2025. The report evaluates each AI's performance based on factors like tone, relevance, engagement, and accuracy, while also highlighting significant state-level news stories from the week.

### Key Points  

- Gemini delivered accurate and comprehensive news coverage, including topics like federal troop deployment to Portland, immigration issues, and clean energy projects, but lacked engaging presentation.   

- Grok provided dramatic and sensationalized coverage, focusing on stories like Portland protests, Michigan voter data lawsuits, and high-profile memorials, which made its reporting captivating but occasionally exaggerated.   

- ChatGPT 4 prioritized sports and international news over state-level stories, such as Cal Raleigh’s home run record and Erdogan’s UN speech, which made its coverage less relevant to the competition’s focus.   

- Copilot concentrated heavily on California news, covering topics like gerrymandering, water storage funding, and Arnold Schwarzenegger’s political comeback, but ignored news from other states.   

- The competition highlighted key state-level stories, such as troop deployment in Portland, immigration detention center conditions, California’s solar-powered canals, and a $25 million wrongful conviction settlement.   

- Grok was declared the winner for its engaging, if sensational, coverage, followed by Gemini for its factual reporting, Copilot for its California focus, and ChatGPT 4 for its misplaced priorities.   

- The analysis underscores the challenges AI models face in balancing accuracy, engagement, and relevance in news reporting. 

Big Education Ape: THE GREAT AI NEWS SMACKDOWN: SEPTEMBER 28, 2025 – THE "WHO LEFT THE STOVE ON?" EDITION https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2025/09/the-great-ai-news-smackdown-september_28.html

The article provides a detailed overview of various global and local news stories, focusing on political developments, conflicts, and cultural events. It also compares the performance of AI models (Gemini, Grok, ChatGPT 4, and Copilot) in delivering news, ultimately declaring Gemini and Grok as the winners for their consistent and detailed reporting.  

### Key Points     

- AI models (Gemini, Grok, ChatGPT 4, and Copilot) compete in "The Great AI News Smackdown" to deliver the most effective news coverage.   

- Gemini and Grok reported on escalating Russian missile and drone attacks in Ukraine, highlighting civilian casualties and destruction.   

- U.S. government shutdown looms, with Trump administration preparing mass layoffs and permanent staff reductions.   

- Deadly shooting at Dallas ICE facility sparks debates on immigration policy and facility security.   

- Trump addresses the UNGA, criticizing climate policies and proposing a ceasefire plan for Gaza, which Hamas has not acknowledged.   

- Iran threatens to withdraw from the nuclear treaty in response to new UN sanctions.   

- Tropical storm impacts the Philippines, with potential hurricane threats to the U.S. East Coast.   

- ChatGPT 4 focuses on unique stories like a dockside restaurant shooting in North Carolina but lacks focus in its reporting.   

- Copilot highlights Israel's isolation due to actions in Gaza and covers local Rosemont gossip, including illegal street racing and a hit-and-run incident.   

- Gemini and Grok are declared winners of the AI news competition for their consistent and detailed coverage of major global events. 

Big Education Ape: LET'S CHECK THIS WEEK'S TOP NEWS AND OTHER STORIES Saturday, September 27, 2025 https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2025/09/lets-check-this-weeks-top-news-and_01357883721.html 

### Key Points

- Historical reflections on obedience as a root cause of atrocities like war and genocide, highlighting the dangers of compliance. 

- Commentary on public education's role in democracy, emphasizing resistance to efforts undermining it, including critiques of billionaire influence. 

- Various AI tools like Gemini, ChatGPT 5, and Copilot are competing for dominance in the news landscape, with weekly analyses of their performance. 

- A satirical critique of attempts to dismantle public schools, featuring Randi Weingarten's book "Why Fascists Fear Teachers." 

- Multiple blog posts and commentaries address ongoing societal issues, including gun violence, free speech debates, and the role of technology in democracy. 

Big Education Ape: THE GREAT AI NEWS SMACKDOWN: WEEK OF SEPT 19–26, 2025 – WHO GEMINI'D THE GOVERNMENT SHUTDOWN AND THE KIRK-KIMMEL MELTDOWN? https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2025/09/the-great-ai-news-smackdown-september_52.html  

The article provides a detailed overview of recent developments in U.S. education, politics, and world affairs, along with a comparison of AI-powered news reporting models—Gemini, Grok, ChatGPT 4, and Copilot. It highlights key controversies, policy changes, and global events while analyzing the storytelling styles and accuracy of each AI model.

### Key Points  

- The AI news smackdown compared Gemini, Grok, ChatGPT 4, and Copilot on their reporting of major stories from September 19–26, 2025. Gemini was praised for balance, Grok for drama, Copilot for conspiracy-like content, and ChatGPT 4 for being too safe.   

- Harvard University faced financial sanctions and was placed on Heightened Cash Monitoring for refusing to cooperate with a compliance review on race in admissions.   

- A transgender student incident in Fairfax County Public Schools sparked debates on Title IX and school safety.   

- U.S. high school seniors’ reading and math scores showed significant declines, raising alarms about education quality.   

- The looming government shutdown created political tension, with threats of mass layoffs and ACA subsidy extensions at stake.   

- Former FBI Director James Comey was indicted, while Jimmy Kimmel faced suspension over controversial comments.   

- Global affairs included escalating conflicts in Gaza, Ukraine’s plea for intervention, and Venezuela mobilizing troops amid U.S. tensions.   

- AI models differed in their coverage of world events, with Gemini delivering comprehensive reporting, Grok emphasizing drama, ChatGPT 4 focusing on basics, and Copilot highlighting provocative incidents.   

- Sudan experienced a deadly drone strike, Nigeria faced police ambushes, and Afghanistan rejected U.S. calls to reclaim Bagram Air Base. 

Big Education Ape: DONALD TRUMP: AMERICAN FEAR MONGER THE B-MOVIE LOGIC OF A GOVERNMENT BY GRIEVANCE https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2025/09/donald-trump-american-fear-monger-b.html 

### Key Points

- Donald Trump has launched a campaign of retribution, targeting government officials, celebrities, and institutions he perceives as adversaries. This includes actions against James Comey, Letitia James, Lisa Cook, Gen. Mark Milley, John Bolton, John Brennan, Adam Schiff, Jack Smith, and others. 

- Trump's administration has been accused of abusing power, dismantling norms, and promoting authoritarianism through executive orders and investigations aimed at silencing opposition and consolidating control. 

- The No Kings 2.0 movement is organizing nationwide protests on October 18 to counter Trump's fear-mongering and authoritarian tactics, emphasizing democracy and civic engagement. 

- Critics argue that Trump’s approach is rooted in fear-mongering and panic-driven policies, which are eroding democratic values and creating a chilling effect across various sectors of society. 

- The article draws parallels between Trump’s tactics and historical authoritarian figures, highlighting the dangers of his governance style. 

CURMUDGUCATION: ICYMI: Reunion Edition (9/28) https://curmudgucation.blogspot.com/2025/09/icymi-reunion-edition-928.html 

This article is a blog post by Peter Greene reflecting on his busy week, which included attending his high school class's 50th reunion and conducting a pit orchestra. It also provides a curated list of education-related articles and commentary, touching on various topics such as federal education budgets, school privatization, social media policies, teacher pay, and the impact of political decisions on public education. The post includes links to Greene's other writings and promotes his substack and social media presence.

### Key Points

- Peter Greene reflects on his high school reunion and his busy schedule, including conducting an orchestra. 

- Federal education budget proposals and their potential impact on schools. 

- Issues in math instruction beyond teaching for test results. 

- The consequences of school privatization on public education. 

- The role of shared experiences in public education and the dangers of dividing schools. 

- Vermont's law limiting social media use in schools and its implications. 

- Critique of Ohio's voucher system and its lack of accountability. 

- Conservative arguments against federal funding for school choice. 

- Analysis of Steve Bannon's controversial statement about teachers and related voucher issues. 

- The Trump administration's attack on fair housing and its impact on school integration. 

- America's relationship with guns and its consequences for children. 

- Various education challenges in Tennessee, including vouchers and test results. 

- Concerns about federal charter funding in Ohio and its historical failures. 

- Disturbing trends in AI use in classrooms. 

- A humorous take on a GOP education official's resignation announcement. 

- Promotion of Greene's writings on teacher voices, pay data, and Pennsylvania's teacher shortage. 

- Greene's substack, social media, and other platforms for education commentary. 

Forget Washington DC—Democracy’s Future Lives in Our Communities – Cloaking Inequity https://cloakinginequity.com/2025/09/28/forget-washington-democracys-future-lives-in-our-communities/ 

Forget Washington DC—Democracy’s Future Lives in Our Communities

### Key Points

- Stockton’s leadership in universal basic income and youth development showcases its role as a model for national equity and innovation. 

- The city’s resilience in addressing economic shifts, violence reduction, and racial inequity mirrors broader American struggles and promises. 

- Bobby and LaJuana Bivens exemplify relational leadership, mentoring youth and advancing civil rights through the NAACP. 

- Parents play a crucial role in educational equity by learning, organizing, and advocating for systemic change. 

- The Best Practices Equity Audit provides tools to assess schools on equity metrics like teacher quality, curriculum relevance, and restorative discipline. 

- Stockton’s grassroots efforts highlight the importance of local democracy in shaping national conversations on justice and education. 

glen brown: How to Watch for Spotify Scams... https://teacherpoetmusicianglenbrown.blogspot.com/2025/09/how-to-watch-for-spotify-scams.html 

This article provides a detailed guide on recognizing and avoiding Spotify-related scams, emphasizing phishing emails, fake apps, and account takeovers. It also shares practical tips on identifying fake messages, securing accounts, and using scam-fighting tools.

### Key Points

- Spotify scams often involve phishing emails designed to steal login or payment information. 

- Fake Spotify apps and browser extensions can contain malware or compromise user accounts. 

- Credential-stuffing attacks exploit reused passwords from other data breaches. Unique passwords and two-factor authentication are recommended. 

- Signs of a hacked Spotify account include unfamiliar playlists, altered login credentials, and unauthorized changes. 

- Steps to secure a compromised account include logging out of all devices, updating passwords, and contacting Spotify Support. 

- Tools like Bitdefender Scamio and Link Checker help users identify and avoid scams. 

- Impersonation risks and proactive measures to address fake profiles are highlighted. 

glen brown: Fourteen Glorious Minutes https://teacherpoetmusicianglenbrown.blogspot.com/2025/09/fourteen-glorious-minutes_28.html 

### Key Points

- Glen Brown emphasizes the writer's role in resisting oppression and remaining free from doctrines and politics, quoting figures like Ambrose Bierce and Albert Camus. 

- The blog discusses a wide range of topics, including social justice, pensions, healthcare, American politics, and cultural issues. 

- A highlighted story recounts Scott Foster, an accountant turned emergency goalie for the Chicago Blackhawks, achieving a remarkable feat during an NHL game. 

- The blog critiques Trump’s administration, addressing authoritarian tendencies, healthcare cuts, and environmental policies, among other issues. 

- Articles explore political affiliations, free speech, scams, and societal injustices, with references to historical and contemporary figures. 

- The blog includes poetry, cultural reflections, and commentary on global issues like the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and climate change. 

SEL Weekly Update - Larry Ferlazzo's Websites of the Day... | The latest news and resources in education since 2007 https://larryferlazzo.edublogs.org/ 

This article provides an overview of recent updates, resources, and insights shared on a blog focused on education, including teaching strategies, research, and tools for educators.

### Key Points

- The blog features weekly updates on Social Emotional Learning (SEL) and resources for educators. 

- Research highlights the benefits of subtitles for English Language Learners (ELLs) in video learning. 

- A collection of resources for World Teachers Day, celebrated annually on October 5th, is provided. 

- Analysis of research on students’ attention by Dan Willingham is discussed. 

- A round-up of posts and articles on educational policy issues is included. 

- The blog addresses the Trump administration's impact on citizenship processes and education. 

- Free AI chatbots have been created to support parent engagement and classroom instruction. 

- The blog shares a study on the disruptive effects of ICE raids on students. 

- Monthly “Best” lists and teaching resources are regularly updated, with over 2,500 lists available. 

- Resources on the “Little Rock Nine” and its historical significance are shared. 

- Various books and materials are highlighted, offering research-based instructional strategies across subjects like Math, Science, and Social Studies. 

- The author’s other contributions include radio shows, blog posts, and teaching practices on autonomy, competency, and engagement. 

- The blog includes videos and has garnered significant page views over the past month. 

SPECIAL REPORT: THIS WEEK’S TOP “STATE NEWS STORIES” IN THE GREAT AI NEWS SMACKDOWN https://ru4people.substack.com/p/special-report-this-weeks-top-state 

The article provides a detailed analysis of the "Great AI News Smackdown," where four AI models—Gemini, Grok, ChatGPT 4, and Copilot—compete to deliver state-level news from September 20–27, 2025. Each AI's performance is evaluated based on accuracy, engagement, and relevance, with Grok emerging as the winner for its dramatic and engaging coverage. The article also highlights key state news stories covered by each AI, ranging from Portland protests to clean energy projects in California.

### Key Points  

- Gemini focused on factual reporting, covering topics like Portland protests, solar-powered canals, and vaccine recommendations. However, its dry tone lacked engagement.   

- Grok delivered sensationalized coverage, labeling Portland protests as "domestic terrorism" and highlighting dramatic stories like Michigan’s voter data lawsuit and Charlie Kirk’s memorial. Its flair made it entertaining but exaggerated.   

- ChatGPT 4 prioritized sports and international news, such as Cal Raleigh’s home run record and Erdogan’s UN speech, but failed to focus on state-level news.   

- Copilot provided hyper-local coverage of California, including gerrymandering debates, climate initiatives, and mask bans for law enforcement, but ignored other states entirely.   

- The article concludes that Grok’s dramatic style won the Smackdown, followed by Gemini for substance, Copilot for its niche focus, and ChatGPT for missing the mark on state news.   

- Major state news stories included troop deployments in Portland, voter data lawsuits in Michigan, clean energy projects in California, and ICE facility incidents in Dallas.   

- Other notable stories included California’s $25M wrongful conviction settlement, mask bans for law enforcement, and Minnesota’s divergence from federal COVID vaccine guidelines. 

NYC Public School Parents: Cuomo vs. Sliwa vs. Mamdani on education & what Cuomo said to PLACE leaders at their education forum https://nycpublicschoolparents.blogspot.com/2025/09/cuomo-vs-sliwa-vs-mamdani-on-education.html 

NYC Public School Parents blog discusses the education policies of mayoral candidates Andrew Cuomo, Curtis Sliwa, and Zohran Mamdani in the upcoming election. Cuomo supports Mayoral control, charter school expansion, and gifted programs but opposes reducing class sizes without state funding. Sliwa aligns with similar policies but does not emphasize class size. Mamdani advocates for more community input, lower class sizes, and charter school accountability. Cuomo's recent forum with NYC PLACE leaders highlighted his stance on Mayoral control and selective school funding, while omitting key historical funding issues.

### Key Points

- Andrew Cuomo, running as an Independent, supports Mayoral control, charter school expansion, and gifted programs but opposes reducing class sizes unless the state provides specific funding. 

- Curtis Sliwa, the Republican candidate, shares similar policies to Cuomo but does not emphasize class size reduction. 

- Zohran Mamdani, the Democratic nominee, advocates for amending Mayoral control, lowering class sizes, and auditing charter schools for accountability. 

- Cuomo strongly supports retaining Mayoral control and opposes governance changes, citing union resistance as a major challenge. 

- Cuomo expressed willingness to consult PLACE leaders before selecting a new Chancellor, emphasizing collaboration with parent groups. 

- Historical context reveals Cuomo's refusal to fund NYC schools fully during his tenure as Governor, despite the Campaign for Fiscal Equity settlement. 

Schools Matter: The Christofascist Agenda for Schools: Replace Education with Propaganda Centers http://www.schoolsmatter.info/2025/09/the-christofascist-agenda-for-schools.html 

### Key Points

- The article critiques the "Christofascist Agenda" for schools, arguing that it aims to replace genuine education with propaganda centers. 

- Poverty, not teacher quality, is identified as the primary issue affecting education outcomes, emphasizing socioeconomic factors over simplistic educational reforms. 

- The blog discusses various education-related topics, including testing increases, teacher burnout, corporate influence on schools, and the impact of political agendas on public education. 

- Historical and contemporary critiques of educational policies like No Child Left Behind (NCLB) highlight systemic challenges and efforts to undermine public schools. 

Billionaire Financed Education-Propaganda https://tultican.com/2025/09/29/billionaire-financed-education-propaganda/ 

Elected school boards are crucial to American democracy, but the article critiques the billionaire-driven propaganda undermining public education. It highlights issues such as declining test scores, the flawed No Child Left Behind (NCLB) Act, and the push for privatization through organizations like CRPE. It also examines the influence of billionaire Laurene Powell Jobs, who aims to revolutionize education with AI and EdTech, often ignoring the negative impacts of such initiatives.

### Key Points

- Criticism of manipulated data on reading and math declines and the biased analysis from pro-billionaire sources. 

- NCLB’s harmful legacy, including narrowing curriculum, punishing poor schools, and flawed standardized testing. 

- Diane Ravitch’s critique of NCLB’s unrealistic goals and its failure to improve education. 

- CRPE’s role in promoting privatization and market-based reforms, undermining public education. 

- Billionaire-backed efforts to eliminate the Carnegie unit and integrate AI into education, raising concerns about harmful technology-driven reforms. 

Choosing Democracy: Report from Portland https://choosingdemocracy.blogspot.com/2025/09/report-from-portland.html 

Marc Cooper's article in "The Coop Scoop" critiques former President Trump's portrayal of Portland, Oregon, as a city in chaos, arguing that the claims are exaggerated and politically motivated. Cooper highlights Portland's recovery from past unrest, its vibrant culture, and its resistance to federal intervention. He accuses Trump of using fear-mongering tactics to distract from broader political failures and normalize authoritarian measures. The article also discusses the role of media in perpetuating misleading narratives about Portland.

### Key Points

- Marc Cooper criticizes Trump's false portrayal of Portland as a city in chaos, emphasizing that the city is currently thriving and peaceful. 

- Cooper recounts the 2020 protests in Portland, noting that while there were some violent incidents, they were limited in scope and no longer reflect the city's current state. 

- The article highlights Portland's cultural vibrancy, including its restaurants, parks, and unique personality, which contrasts with Trump's negative depiction. 

- Cooper accuses Trump of sending federal forces to Portland for political gain, despite opposition from local and state officials. 

- The media is criticized for using misleading footage to exaggerate the scale of protests and unrest in Portland. 

- Trump’s actions are described as an intentional provocation to create confrontation and distract from his administration's failures. 

- Cooper warns of the dangerous normalization of militarized responses to dissent and the broader implications for democracy. 

Yesterday’s Gems, Today’s Insights

A Roundup of the Web’s Finest Blog Posts!

9-28-25

https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2025/09/yesterdays-gems-todays-insights-roundup_28.html  

The article compiles a wide range of topics, including political developments, societal issues, educational reforms, and the performance of AI news models. It highlights key controversies, global events, and critiques of leadership styles, particularly focusing on Donald Trump’s authoritarian tactics and their societal implications. The piece also evaluates the role of AI in news aggregation and explores the challenges in education systems, governance, and public transparency.

### Key Points  

- A church shooting in Michigan involved multiple victims, and the church was set on fire.   

- Former President Trump ordered active-duty military troops to Portland, Oregon, claiming the city was under siege by Antifa and radical terrorists, sparking concerns about authoritarianism.   

- Trump’s administration has been accused of using executive orders and investigations to silence opposition and consolidate power.   

- The "No Kings 2.0" movement is organizing protests to counter Trump’s fear-mongering and authoritarian tactics.   

- Mississippi’s reading reform is criticized for being exaggerated and potentially harmful, with test score gains attributed to manipulated student populations.   

- Adolescents are misusing over-the-counter antihistamines, leading to severe health risks like heart arrhythmias.   

- LAUSD extended Superintendent Carvalho’s contract without public input, raising concerns about transparency and governance.   

- The rise of flavored marijuana vaping among teens raises addiction concerns, requiring targeted education and policies.   

- Trump’s administration has weaponized the Department of Justice to target perceived enemies, including government officials and cultural institutions.   

- Critics draw parallels between Trump’s tactics and historical authoritarian regimes, warning of the erosion of democratic values.   

- The "Great AI News Smackdown" compared AI models like Gemini, Grok, ChatGPT-4, and Copilot, evaluating their strengths and weaknesses in news coverage.   

- Grok emerged as the top performer in AI news aggregation, excelling in dramatic and impactful reporting.   

- Larry Cuban critiques the practice of teaching to the middle in classrooms, arguing it reflects systemic constraints rather than mediocrity.   

- Public education’s role in democracy is emphasized, along with critiques of privatization efforts and billionaire influence undermining schools.   

- Resistance to authoritarianism and efforts to defend democracy are highlighted as urgent societal tasks.   

- Historical reflections on obedience as a root cause of atrocities like war and genocide underscore the dangers of compliance.   

- Concerns about NYC’s healthcare plan include transparency issues, cost stability, and impacts on retirees.   

- Privatization policies in education are criticized for deepening inequality and destabilizing communities.