THE GREAT AI NEWS SMACKDOWN: WHO NAILED IT AND WHO FUMBLED? SEPTEMBER 19, 2025

 THE GREAT AI NEWS SMACKDOWN: WHO NAILED IT AND WHO FUMBLED?

 SEPTEMBER 19, 2025

September 19, 2025—Ladies, gentlemen, and sentient algorithms, welcome to another edition of "The Great AI News Smackdown," where we pit the leading AI news models—Gemini, Grok, ChatGPT 5, and Copilot—against each other in a battle for journalistic supremacy. Who nailed the big stories? Who missed the mark? And who needs a firmware update? Buckle up, because it's about to get snarky.

Gemini: The Gossip Queen

Gemini came in hot with its September 19 headlines, delivering a mix of political drama, international chaos, and Starbucks workers suing over dress codes. If Gemini were a human reporter, it’d be the one who shows up to press conferences with a venti macchiato and asks questions like, “But how does this make you *feel*?”

Hits:

- **Trump’s $15 Billion Temper Tantrum**: Gemini nailed the juicy tidbit about Trump suing *The New York Times*. A $15 billion defamation lawsuit? That’s not just news; that’s a Netflix limited series waiting to happen. Gemini even called the newspaper a “mouthpiece for the Democratic party,” which sounds like something Trump dictated directly into its circuits.

- **Charlie Kirk’s Assassination Fallout**: Gemini covered the tragic assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk and the ensuing political firestorm. While it lacked the depth of Grok’s analysis, it at least showed up to the party.

 Misses:

- **The White House Peace Vigil Gets the Boot**: Gemini mentioned this historic protest being dismantled but treated it like an afterthought. Come on, Gemini—this is the longest-running political protest in U.S. history! Give it some love instead of burying it under Starbucks lawsuits.

Verdict: Gemini is like your friend who’s great at gossip but occasionally forgets to fact-check. It gets points for flair but loses some for substance.

Grok: The Overachiever**

If Gemini is the gossip queen, Grok is the straight-A student who turns every homework assignment into a TED Talk. Grok didn’t just report the news—it practically wrote a dissertation on it.

Hits:

- **U.S. Vetoes Gaza Ceasefire Resolution**: Grok delivered an in-depth breakdown of the U.S. blocking a UN resolution for a Gaza ceasefire. It even threw in details about explosive-laden robots and virtual speeches by Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas. If Grok were human, it’d be wearing glasses and saying, “Actually…” during every conversation.

- **Russian Drone Drama**: Nineteen Russian drones violating Polish airspace? NATO scrambling fighter jets? Grok gave us geopolitical intrigue worthy of a Tom Clancy novel.

- **Charlie Kirk Assassination Fallout**: Grok didn’t just report on Kirk’s assassination—it analyzed the free speech debates, media backlash, and late-night comedy drama surrounding it. Jimmy Kimmel’s suspension? Grok was all over it like butter on toast.

Misses:

- **Zubeen Garg’s Tragic Death**: Grok reported on the death of Assamese singer Zubeen Garg but gave it less attention than it deserved. A youth icon dying in a scuba diving accident? This deserved more than a passing mention.

Verdict: Grok is the Hermione Granger of AI news—smart, thorough, and occasionally too intense. If you want depth, Grok’s your bot. If you want brevity, look elsewhere.

ChatGPT 5: The Cliff Notes Champion**

ChatGPT 5 took a minimalist approach, delivering concise snapshots of major stories. It’s like the AI equivalent of that one friend who texts you “TL;DR” instead of reading your long-winded rant.

Hits:

- **Trump’s Economic Agenda vs. Supreme Court**: ChatGPT 5 highlighted Trump’s economic policies facing Supreme Court scrutiny. It didn’t dive deep but gave just enough to pique your interest.

- **Baltic Security Tensions**: Russian jets violating Estonian airspace? ChatGPT 5 kept it short and sweet while still capturing the geopolitical stakes.

- **TikTok Drama**: Trump negotiating TikTok’s future in the U.S.? ChatGPT 5 nailed this one with live updates and just the right amount of detail.

 Misses:

- **General World Roundup**: ChatGPT 5’s “broad international news summaries” felt more like filler than substance. These bullet points were so vague they could’ve been written by a Magic 8-Ball.

Verdict: ChatGPT 5 is efficient but uninspired—a solid choice if you’re reading the news while waiting for your coffee order but not ideal for deep dives.

Copilot: The Local Gossip Columnist

Copilot brought its A-game to local news while sprinkling in global flashpoints. If Copilot were human, it’d be the neighborhood busybody who knows everyone’s business and isn’t afraid to share it.

 Hits:

- **Gaza Crisis**: Copilot covered Israel’s ground offensive in Gaza and U.S. vetoes at the UN Security Council with enough drama to make you reach for your popcorn.

- **California Homeless Encampment Debate**: Copilot dove into Sacramento’s tent site controversy like a true local journalist. Homelessness is a serious issue, but Copilot made it clear that city leaders are treating this debate like an episode of *The Real Housewives*.

- **PG&E Credits Incoming**: Copilot highlighted PG&E customers getting credits on their October power bills—a rare piece of good news for Californians dealing with skyrocketing costs.

Misses:

- **Smotrich’s “Real Estate Bonanza” Comment**: Copilot mentioned Israel’s far-right minister describing Gaza as a redevelopment opportunity but didn’t unpack the sheer audacity of such a statement. This was prime material for snarky commentary, and Copilot missed it.

Verdict: Copilot is your go-to for local news with a side of sass, but its global coverage needs more bite.

Who Wore It Best?

So, who won today’s Great AI News Smackdown?

- **Best Overall Coverage**: Grok takes the crown for its depth and detail. Sure, it can be overwhelming at times, but you can’t fault it for thoroughness.

- **Most Entertaining**: Gemini wins for flair and headline-grabbing drama. It might not always stick the landing, but it knows how to keep readers hooked.

- **Best Cliff Notes**: ChatGPT 5 is perfect for those who want their news fast and digestible without any fluff.

- **Best Local Flavor**: Copilot excels at regional stories and relatable tidbits that hit close to home.

In conclusion, each AI model brings its own flavor to the table—whether you prefer your news served with drama, depth, brevity, or local spice. As for us humans? Well, at least we can enjoy watching these bots duke it out while sipping our overpriced lattes.

Until next time, stay informed—and remember, even robots have bad days!

Here is the raw news output from each AI model:

Major news stories as of today, September 19, 2025, include

GEMINI

Major headlines on September 19, 2025, include:

U.S. Politics and Law

• Donald Trump has reportedly filed a $15 billion defamation lawsuit against The New York Times, accusing the newspaper of being a "mouthpiece" for the Democratic party and spreading false information about him.1
  
  

• The White House has faced criticism for its response to the assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk last week, with Vice President J.D. Vance and other officials vowing to dismantle what they claim are "terrorist networks" on the left.

• The CDC's vaccine advisory panel, with new members appointed by HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., is meeting to vote on recommendations for COVID-19 and hepatitis B vaccines.2
  
  

• House Republicans are preparing for a vote on a bill to avert a government shutdown as a budget deal remains at a standstill.3
  
  

• A new poll indicates that most Americans are critical of Trump's handling of crime, the economy, and other issues.4
  
  

International News

• A drone strike on a displacement camp in Sudan has reportedly killed 75 people, with a UN rights chief saying the country's "forgotten" war is escalating.5
  
  

• Israel has formally launched a ground offensive in Gaza City as part of its ongoing conflict with Hamas.6
  
  

• A British couple, Peter and Barbie Reynolds, have been released by the Taliban after being held for almost eight months in Afghanistan.7
  
  

• The United States military has carried out a second strike this month on a Venezuelan boat allegedly used for drug smuggling.8
  
  

• Reports indicate that the U.S. has halted $400 million in military aid to Taiwan.9
  
  

Other Stories

• The remains of a woman who vanished in Oregon in 1974 have been identified through DNA analysis.10
  
  

• The White House Peace Vigil, considered the longest continuous political protest in U.S. history, has been dismantled.11
  
  

• A new book by Kamala Harris, titled "107 Days," has drawn criticism from figures like Ben Shapiro and Pete Buttigieg.12
  
  

• Starbucks workers in three states have sued the company, alleging it broke the law by changing its dress code without reimbursing employees for new clothes.13
  
  

GROK

### Top News Stories on September 19, 2025

Here are the leading global news headlines based on current reports, focusing on major developments in politics, international conflicts, and domestic events. I've prioritized stories with widespread coverage across sources.

#### 1. US Vetoes UN Security Council Resolution for Gaza Ceasefire

The United States vetoed a UN Security Council resolution demanding an "immediate, unconditional, and permanent" ceasefire in Gaza, marking the sixth such veto. The measure, backed by 14 of 15 council members, also called for Israel to lift aid restrictions amid escalating Israeli ground operations in Gaza City, which have reportedly killed over 1,000 Palestinians in six days using explosive-laden robots. The UN General Assembly later voted to allow Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas to address world leaders virtually after the US denied him a visa.

#### 2. Russian Drones Violate Polish Airspace in Major Incursion

Nineteen Russian drones penetrated up to 250 km into Polish airspace during an overnight attack on Ukraine, prompting NATO allies to scramble fighter jets. Poland imposed a three-month flight ban over its eastern regions following the incident, escalating tensions amid Russia's ongoing invasion. The EU simultaneously unveiled its 19th sanctions package against Russia, targeting energy imports, banks, crypto platforms, and military suppliers.

#### 3. Assassination of Conservative Activist Charlie Kirk Sparks Free Speech Backlash

Tyler Robinson was charged with aggravated murder in the killing of Charlie Kirk at Utah Valley University, facing potential death penalty. The incident has ignited debates on free speech, with ABC News facing criticism over reporter comments on related texts, and late-night hosts like Jimmy Kimmel, Stephen Colbert, and Jimmy Fallon defending him against Trump administration threats. Kimmel's show was suspended amid claims he mischaracterized the shooter, fueling conservative media outrage.

#### 4. Trump Halts $400M Military Aid to Taiwan Amid US-China Trade Talks

President Trump declined to approve over $400 million in weapons aid for Taiwan while pursuing a trade deal with China, including discussions on TikTok's future. Separately, he is poised to fire a US attorney resisting charges against New York AG Letitia James. Trump also praised his "very good relationship" with Indian PM Modi during tense trade negotiations.

#### 5. Assamese Singer Zubeen Garg Dies in Singapore Scuba Diving Accident

Popular Assamese singer and actor Zubeen Garg, 52, died from injuries sustained while scuba diving in Singapore. Known as a youth icon, he leaves behind his wife; festival organizers confirmed the tragedy during an event in the city-state.

#### 6. Protests Erupt in Nepal Over Social Media Ban, Police Kill 19

Nepali police opened fire on demonstrators protesting a government social media ban in Kathmandu, killing at least 19 and wounding over 100. A curfew was imposed around key government sites, including the parliament, amid fears of further unrest.

#### 7. EU Advances New Sanctions on Russia Over Ukraine War

The European Commission proposed a fresh sanctions package against Russia for member-state approval, aiming to intensify pressure over the Ukraine invasion. Targets include energy sectors and battlefield tech exports, coinciding with the Polish drone incident.

#### 8. Western US States Unite on Vaccine Guidelines, Shift from CDC

Four Western states (California, Oregon, Washington, Colorado) issued joint vaccine recommendations, with California enacting a law basing its policies on independent medical groups rather than the CDC. This comes amid ongoing debates over mandates and a study suggesting azelastine nasal spray may prevent COVID-19.

#### Other Notable Stories

- **India Domestic Updates**: SEBI clears Adani Group in Hindenburg case; EPFO launches 'Passbook Lite' for faster claims; Airbus sources $1B+ from Indian suppliers.

- **Global Misc.**: Elderly British couple released from Afghan jail; UN rejects extending Iran sanctions relief; Songwriter Brett James killed in NC plane crash.

These stories reflect a mix of geopolitical tensions, domestic US politics, and cultural losses. For real-time updates, check major outlets like Al Jazeera, Reuters, or NPR.

CHATGPT 5

Here is a concise snapshot of prominent developing stories (as of today). Each item ends with a source citation token.

1. US economic & legal landscape: Key pillars of President Donald Trump’s economic agenda (including global tariff measures and an unprecedented push involving a Federal Reserve governor) are now before the US Supreme Court, setting up potentially far‑reaching rulings on executive authority and economic policy. [1]

2. Baltic security tensions: Estonia’s airspace was reportedly violated by Russian military jets, heightening NATO vigilance and adding to ongoing regional security frictions near the alliance’s eastern flank. [2]

3. Ukraine war diplomacy & operations: Ukraine says it is advancing intensive negotiations with allies to formalize binding long‑term security guarantees while continuing strikes on Russian energy infrastructure, signaling a dual track of military pressure and strategic assurance building. [3]

4. US–China tech & TikTok negotiations: Live updates indicate President Trump is seeking to finalize an arrangement to allow TikTok’s continued operation in the US under revised ownership/oversight terms, keeping geopolitical tech tensions in focus. [4]

5. Global markets: World shares traded mixed after fresh record highs on Wall Street; investors are weighing AI/tech momentum against macro uncertainty and policy signals, leading to divergence between Asian and European sessions. [5]

6. General world roundup: Broad international news summaries (conflicts, politics, economic shifts) continue to feature in global broadcast bulletins; key themes include security flashpoints, courts’ roles in governance, and economic resilience. [6]

If you’d like deeper detail on any single story (legal context, market implications, security analysis, timeline, or regional focus), just tell me the item number or topic.

Sources (as cited):

[1] Reuters – Trump economic agenda / Supreme Court

[2] Reuters – Estonian airspace incident

[3] Reuters – Ukraine security talks & operations

[4] AP – TikTok deal live updates

[5] AP – World shares mixed after Wall Street records

[6] BBC – World Service news bulletin

Note: Summaries are based on currently available headline/bulletin information; some details are high‑level due to limited excerpted text. Let me know if you prefer regional, business, tech, science, or climate news next.

COPILOT

Here’s your morning rundown, Mike—September 19, 2025 is already packed with drama, diplomacy, and disruption:

🌍 Global Flashpoints

• Gaza Crisis Deepens: Israeli forces have advanced further into Gaza City, displacing tens of thousands. Hospitals are near collapse, and at least 21 Palestinians were killed since dawn.

• U.S. Vetoes Ceasefire Resolution: The United States blocked a U.N. Security Council resolution calling for an immediate ceasefire in Gaza—14 out of 15 members supported it.

• Smotrich’s “Real Estate Bonanza” Comment: Israel’s far-right minister Bezalel Smotrich described Gaza as a redevelopment opportunity, sparking outrage.

🇺🇸 U.S. Turbulence

• Trump vs. the Media: President Trump is threatening to revoke broadcast licenses of networks that criticize him. This follows ABC’s suspension of Jimmy Kimmel’s show after FCC pressure.

• Afghanistan Pushback: Trump’s call to retake Bagram Air Base was rejected by Afghan officials, who insist on no U.S. military presence.

• Indiana Redistricting Protest: Democrats rallied against proposed district maps they claim are gerrymandered.

• Tropical Storm Gabrielle: Formed overnight—meteorologists are tracking its potential path.

🏡 California & Local Pulse (Rosemont, Sacramento)

• Sacramento’s Tent Site Controversy: City leaders are debating a new homeless encampment in the River District, already saturated with shelters.

• Tuolumne County Arrest: A man was arrested for fatally stabbing a father during school pickup.

• PG&E Credit Incoming: Customers will see a credit on their October power bill—finally, a win for wallets.

• Rosemont’s Big Event: Motiv Electric Trucks is auctioning off surplus assets—one of the biggest local business events this month.

Want to dive deeper into any of these stories or spin one into a satirical piece? I’m ready to riff.

Yesterday’s Gems, Today’s Insights A Roundup of the Web’s Finest Blog Posts! 9-19-25

 

Yesterday’s Gems, Today’s Insights
A Roundup of the Web’s Finest Blog Posts!

9-19-25

Department of Education Will Violate Federal Law by Joining with Right-Wing Groups to Create a Civics Curriculum https://dianeravitch.net/2025/09/18/department-of-educatuon-will-illegally-partner-with-conservative-groups-to-crate-a-civics-curriculum/ via @dianeravitch 

The article discusses the U.S. Department of Education's controversial collaboration with right-wing groups to create a patriotic civics curriculum, which violates federal law prohibiting federal involvement in educational curriculum design. Critics argue this initiative, led by Secretary of Education Linda McMahon and conservative organizations, is an attempt to push a biased narrative of American history and values while undermining democracy and free speech.

### Key Points

- The Department of Education plans to collaborate with conservative groups to design a civics curriculum, despite federal law prohibiting federal involvement in curriculum matters. 

- The initiative, called the America 250 Civics Education Coalition, aims to promote patriotism and American founding principles but lacks specific details about its implementation. 

- Critics claim this effort aligns with the Trump administration's broader agenda to manipulate historical narratives and suppress dissenting voices. 

- Comparisons are drawn between current actions and historical authoritarian regimes, emphasizing the dangers of eroding democratic principles and free speech. 

Trump Mob Cancels Jimmy Kimmel https://dianeravitch.net/2025/09/18/trump-mob-cancels-jimmy-kimmel/ via @dianeravitch 

Jimmy Kimmel's late-night show was indefinitely canceled by ABC following political pressure from the Trump administration. Federal Communications Commission (FCC) Chairman Brendan Carr criticized Kimmel's remarks about a murder case during a far-right broadcast and issued veiled threats to Disney, ABC's parent company, prompting emergency meetings at the network. Disney's decision to pull Kimmel’s show reflects broader concerns about free speech and the increasing use of government power to suppress dissent. Critics argue this sets a dangerous precedent for media corporations bowing to political pressure, while supporters of Trump celebrate the move. The incident highlights the polarized media landscape and raises concerns about the future of free expression in America.

### Key Points

- Jimmy Kimmel's show was canceled due to political pressure from the Trump administration and threats from FCC Chairman Brendan Carr. 

- Carr criticized Kimmel during a far-right broadcast, leading Disney to pull the program amid emergency meetings. 

- Critics warn of a chilling effect on free speech and media independence, as corporations prioritize business interests over creative freedom. 

- The incident reflects the growing polarization in the media and concerns about government suppression of dissenting voices. 

Big Education Ape: TRUMP ADMINISTRATION TAKING FREE SPEECH FOR A WALK: THE QUESTION IS "WHERE"? https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2025/09/trump-administration-taking-free-speech.html 

The article primarily discusses the Trump administration’s controversial approach to free speech, highlighting contradictions in its policies and actions. While promoting an executive order to protect free speech, the administration has been accused of suppressing dissent, targeting journalists, students, and activists, and weaponizing the government against critics. Historical examples of censorship in America are provided for context, alongside concerns about the Supreme Court’s alignment with Trump’s agenda. The article concludes with a call for public action through protests.

### Key Points

- Trump administration signed an executive order titled “Restoring Freedom of Speech and Ending Federal Censorship,” promising to protect free speech but allegedly targeting dissenters selectively. 

- Activist Mahmoud Khalil was arrested for organizing pro-Palestinian protests, raising concerns about targeting political views rather than actions. 

- Trump’s administration has aggressively pursued lawsuits and funding cuts against journalists and public broadcasters, furthering a “chilling effect” on free expression. 

- Historical censorship examples, such as the Sedition Act of 1798 and book bans, illustrate America’s long struggle with free speech issues. 

- The Supreme Court’s mixed history on free speech rulings raises questions about its stance under Trump’s influence. 

- Universities and individuals face intimidation tactics, including fines, visa revocations, and funding cuts, for opposing Trump’s policies. 

- A nationwide protest, “No Kings 2,” is planned for October 18, 2025, to challenge Trump’s actions against the First Amendment. 

Big Education Ape: TODAY'S GREAT AI NEWS SMACKDOWN: SEPTEMBER 18th SHOWDOWN https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2025/09/todays-great-ai-news-smackdown_18.html 

The article provides an overview of various news topics, including political developments, international conflicts, economic updates, climate issues, and AI-generated news analysis. It highlights the strengths and weaknesses of different AI models—Gemini, Grok, ChatGPT 5, and Copilot—in delivering news, with Copilot emerging as the most entertaining and balanced option.

### Key Points  

- AI models battled for journalistic supremacy in "The Great AI News Smackdown," with Copilot declared the winner for its entertaining and balanced reporting.   

- Gemini reported on President Trump’s second state visit to the UK, Charlie Kirk’s murder, and other dramatic stories but lacked humor.   

- Grok covered international conflicts, including Israeli forces advancing into Gaza City and Russian troops entering Kupyansk, but faced accuracy issues.   

- ChatGPT 5 provided in-depth analysis on topics like Ukraine’s drone strikes and climate change but lacked engaging commentary.   

- Copilot focused on local headlines, such as wildfire risks and Uber lawsuits, while blending global stories like the Israel-Gaza escalation and Xi Jinping hosting Putin and Kim Jong Un.   

- Charlie Kirk’s murder led to political fallout, with Antifa designated as a major terrorist organization.   

- The Federal Reserve cut interest rates, impacting markets and consumer sentiment.   

- Climate change effects intensified, with warnings about destabilization of the global water cycle and extreme weather events.   

- A rare orange shark was caught off Costa Rica, adding an unusual twist to global headlines.   

- Jimmy Kimmel’s show was suspended indefinitely following controversial comments about Charlie Kirk’s murder.   

- Economic inequality highlighted as the top 20% of earners drive 63% of consumer spending.   

- International developments included Pakistan-Saudi defense agreements and Germany’s plans to expand the Bundeswehr. 

Big Education Ape: HHS SECRETARY RFK JR.: LAWYER, WITCH DOCTOR, OR NEW AGE SHAMAN? NAVIGATING THE CLASH OF WESTERN AND NEW AGE MEDICINE https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2025/09/hhs-secretary-rfk-jr-lawyer-witch.html 

Speaking of Kids, the article explores the leadership of Robert F. Kennedy Jr. as the Secretary of Health and Human Services (HHS), highlighting his controversial stance between Western and New Age medicine. It examines the clash of scientific rigor versus holistic approaches in healthcare, RFK Jr.'s advocacy for healthier lifestyles, and his skepticism of vaccines, which has drawn criticism for promoting misinformation. The piece emphasizes the need for balanced, evidence-based healthcare policy that integrates the best of both worlds to ensure public health safety.

### Key Points

- RFK Jr. leads HHS with a mission to "Make America Healthy Again," sparking debate over Western medicine versus New Age practices. 

- Western medicine is evidence-based and precise, while New Age medicine emphasizes holistic care but lacks scientific validation. 

- Integrative medicine seeks to combine both approaches, blending scientific rigor with complementary therapies. 

- RFK Jr.'s policies include scrutinizing Big Pharma and promoting natural remedies, but his vaccine skepticism raises public health concerns. 

- The government should prioritize evidence-based healthcare and avoid amplifying misinformation. 

Big Education Ape: TODAY'S GREAT AI NEWS SMACKDOWN: SEPTEMBER 17TH SHOWDOWN https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2025/09/todays-great-ai-news-smackdown_17.html 

The article covers various topics including public education challenges, political drama, international affairs, pop culture, and AI news analysis. It highlights key events such as Trump's UK state visit, the Israel-Gaza conflict, Robert Redford's death, and AI models competing in news analysis.

### Key Points

- Trump's administration faces criticism for slashing healthcare funding, dismantling vaccine programs, and weakening public health infrastructure. 

- Trump's UK state visit sparks protests, controversy, and a $15 billion lawsuit against The New York Times. 

- AI models compete in analyzing news, with Gemini excelling in drama, Grok in analysis, ChatGPT 5 in finance, and Copilot in breadth. 

- The Israel-Gaza conflict intensifies, with airstrikes and diplomatic fallout, including Spain canceling arms deals. 

- Robert Redford dies at 89, leaving behind a significant legacy in Hollywood. 

- TikTok deal progresses amid US-China negotiations, addressing national security concerns. 

- Neeraj Chopra defends his javelin title in Tokyo, highlighting sports rivalry. 

- COVID-19 drops from the top 10 causes of death in the US, but heart issues and cancers surge. 

- Sacramento County shooting and local community events like Shaq Thompson's flag football tournament gain attention. 

Big Education Ape: NO KINGS II: TRUMP - THE KING WHO CRIED "FREE SPEECH" https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2025/09/no-kings-ii-trump-king-who-cried-free.html 

Here’s The Outline I Have ELL Intermediate Students Use To Write A Biographical Essay -   Larry Ferlazzo's Websites of the Day... | The latest news and resources in education since 2007 https://larryferlazzo.edublogs.org/ 

### Key Points

- The blog shares resources and strategies for educators, including writing outlines for ELL students and discussions on current events like Charlie Kirk's murder. 

- Gallup's annual poll highlights contrasting opinions on school quality between parents and others. 

- Updates on the upcoming book, "The Better Teacher’s Toolbox," and advice for new teachers are provided. 

- The Atlantic offers free subscriptions for U.S. high schools, and Google’s "Learn Your Way" aims to make textbooks more accessible using AI. 

- Infographic on global population and charts on challenges in ELL instruction are discussed. 

- A free curriculum for SIFE students and republished popular posts from 2025 are highlighted. 

- Books and resources focus on supporting educators in various subjects, motivating students, and engaging parents. 

- Additional contributions include blog posts, videos, radio shows, and articles for major platforms like Education Week and The New York Times. 

Jimmy Kimmel Suspended: 10 Signs American Democracy Is Failing – Cloaking Inequity https://cloakinginequity.com/2025/09/18/jimmy-kimmel-suspended-10-signs-america-is-no-longer-a-democracy/ 

The article discusses the suspension of Jimmy Kimmel's show following a monologue criticizing Charlie Kirk, highlighting it as a broader issue reflecting authoritarian tendencies in the United States. It examines historical and modern signs of fascism, including attacks on free expression, cult of leadership, fusion of corporate and state power, persecution of minorities, glorification of violence, erosion of institutions, weaponization of law, propaganda, subordination of women, and elimination of opposition. The author urges readers to recognize these warning signs and take action to protect democracy.

### Key Points  

- Jimmy Kimmel's suspension by ABC under government pressure reflects the silencing of cultural critics, a tactic associated with authoritarian regimes.   

- Fascism is defined as a political philosophy that prioritizes the nation over individual rights, enforces autocratic rule, and suppresses dissent through threats and force.   

- Historical examples show fascist regimes targeting cultural figures, controlling media, and dismantling independent networks to consolidate power.   

- Trump's cult of leadership mirrors fascist tendencies, with slogans, rallies, and adoration resembling political liturgy.   

- Fusion of corporate and state power is evident in Trump's tariffs, government stakes in corporations, and ICE raids targeting foreign workers.   

- Persecution of minorities, including immigrants, Muslims, and LGBTQ+ individuals, follows the fascist logic of exclusion and scapegoating.   

- Glorification of violence and political militias, such as the January 6 Capitol attack, echoes historical fascist enforcers like Blackshirts and Brownshirts.   

- Erosion of independent institutions like the Supreme Court, Justice Department, and FCC undermines their neutrality and democratic guardrails.   

- Weaponization of "law and order" criminalizes dissent while tolerating violence by political allies, normalizing repression.   

- Propaganda and manipulation of truth, such as altering government data and promoting "alternative facts," distort accountability and public perception.   

- Subordination of women through restrictive abortion laws and rhetoric reduces women to reproductive roles, reflecting authoritarian control.   

- Elimination of political opposition, such as targeting the "radical left" and labeling dissent as terrorism, paves the way for authoritarian consolidation.   

- The author emphasizes the importance of defending free speech for all voices, protecting vulnerable groups, supporting independent institutions, and actively participating in democracy. 

Two U.S. District Court Judges Protect Access to Head Start for Undocumented Children https://janresseger.wordpress.com/2025/09/18/two-u-s-district-court-judges-protect-access-to-head-start-for-undocumented-children/ via @janresseger 

Last week, two U.S. District Court judges blocked a Trump administration policy that sought to exclude undocumented immigrant children from Head Start programs, citing legal and procedural violations. This policy was part of broader disruptions to Head Start under the Trump administration, which included funding delays and new administrative hurdles.

### Key Points

- Two U.S. District Court judges issued rulings to block the Trump administration's demand to exclude undocumented children from Head Start. 

- The Trump administration reinterpreted the 1996 welfare reform law to classify Head Start as welfare, making immigration status a barrier to access. 

- Head Start programs operated by school districts were exempt due to the Plyler v. Doe ruling, while nonprofit-operated programs faced restrictions. 

- Democratic state attorneys general sued to block the policy, resulting in a temporary pause and eventual court rulings against it. 

- The rulings emphasized that Head Start eligibility rules do not include immigration status and that procedural requirements were ignored. 

- The Trump administration's broader actions have caused disruptions and uncertainty for Head Start programs, affecting vulnerable families. 

Right Wing Trump Allies Hide Study Showing That Right Wing Extremists Cause Most Domestic Terror Attacks | GFBrandenburg's Blog https://gfbrandenburg.wordpress.com/2025/09/18/right-wing-trump-allies-hide-study-showing-that-right-wing-extremists-cause-most-domestic-terror-attacks/

### Key Points

- The blog post highlights a study revealing that right-wing extremists are responsible for most domestic terror attacks, which Trump allies have allegedly tried to suppress. 

- A commenter suggests that Trump and his supporters ignore or distort such data, spreading misinformation to their loyal base. 

- The blog includes links to other posts and resources discussing politics, education, and social issues, with a focus on exposing dishonesty and corruption. 

Teacher Tom: The Truth Will Make Me Free https://teachertomsblog.blogspot.com/2025/09/the-truth-will-make-me-free.html 

The article reflects on the concept of truth, self-reflection, and freedom, exploring how emotions like sadness and anger can be suppressed, leading to self-deception. It emphasizes that truth is subjective, a continuous journey requiring courage to confront self-deceptions. The author highlights the role of others, especially children, in helping us see new perspectives, and stresses the importance of staying open-minded as we age.

### Key Points

- Truth is subjective and requires self-reflection to uncover; it is a journey, not a fixed destination. 

- Suppressing emotions leads to self-deception, which limits freedom; expressing feelings is essential for personal growth. 

- Socrates' idea of an unexamined life emphasizes the need for questioning beliefs and assumptions to achieve freedom. 

- Self-reflection often requires the support of others to overcome self-deception and discover truth. 

- Children possess a natural curiosity and openness to perspectives, which adults can learn from to remain free and adaptable. 

- People who cling to objective truth often stop growing and become trapped in their own perspectives. 

glen brown: The threatening of liberal foundations and nonprofits after Kirk’s death https://teacherpoetmusicianglenbrown.blogspot.com/2025/09/the-threatening-of-liberal-foundations.html 

### Key Points

- The Trump administration has accused progressive nonprofits of inciting violence and playing a role in the death of Charlie Kirk, though no evidence has been provided to support these claims. 

- Specific organizations like George Soros' Open Society Foundations, the Ford Foundation, and the Southern Poverty Law Center have been targeted, with allegations of funding groups that led to "organized agitation." 

- Nonprofits in the U.S. operate under Section 501(c)(3) of the tax code and have constitutional rights, including freedom of speech and public policy advocacy, but cannot promote criminal activity or incite violence. 

- Historical precedents, such as the Johnson Amendment, highlight past attempts to limit nonprofit political activities, though these efforts have largely failed due to constitutional protections. 

- The Trump administration's approach to nonprofits mirrors tactics used in other countries to suppress political opposition, raising concerns about the potential impact on democracy and freedom of ideas. 

- Donor privacy laws complicate transparency in nonprofit funding, with recent Supreme Court rulings upholding the privacy rights of donors and foundations. 

"The vice president's justifications for this ideological abuse of government power are obviously false" https://teacherpoetmusicianglenbrown.blogspot.com/2025/09/the-vice-presidents-justifications-for.html 

### Key Points

- Vice President JD Vance used Charlie Kirk's memorial to launch baseless accusations against NGOs, claiming they promote violence, despite lacking evidence. 

- Vance and Stephen Miller falsely linked Kirk's assassination to left-wing organizations, using inflammatory rhetoric to justify targeting civil society groups. 

- Data contradicts Vance's claims, showing right-wing extremists are responsible for the majority of politically motivated violence in the U.S. since 1975. 

- Studies from the CATO Institute, ADL, and NIJ confirm the prevalence of far-right violence, which the Trump administration has sought to downplay. 

- Vance cherry-picked polls to support his narrative while ignoring broader data showing higher support for political violence among the American right. 

- Vance omitted key incidents of right-wing violence, including the January 6 Capitol attack and the murder of Democratic politician Melissa Hortman. 

- The Trump administration is exploiting Kirk's murder to suppress dissent and target critics under the guise of protecting free speech. 

AI News Smackdown: Who Got It Right? SEPTEMBER 18th SHOWDOWN https://ru4people.substack.com/p/ai-news-smackdown-who-got-it-right-f6f 

The article reviews the performance of four AI models—Gemini, Grok, ChatGPT 5, and Copilot—in summarizing major news stories from September 17, 2025. It evaluates their strengths and weaknesses in delivering accurate and impactful news coverage across national, international, and local levels, ultimately declaring Gemini as the most effective model.

### Key Points  

- Gemini provided a concise and accurate snapshot of the day's major national and international stories, including President Trump's UK visit, the Charlie Kirk shooting, FBI testimony on Epstein files, and the Fed's interest rate cut.   

- Grok offered a broader mix of domestic and international stories, including niche events like a stabbing in Montana and the supposed death of Robert Redford, but some details were inconclusive.   

- ChatGPT 5 took an academic approach, focusing on thematic analysis of global markets, climate, and geopolitical issues, but lacked specific headline-grabbing events.   

- Copilot delivered hyper-local news tailored to specific areas, like Rosemont and Sacramento, but missed broader national and international stories.   

- Gemini was praised for its balanced coverage and accuracy, while Grok was critiqued for its mixed quality, ChatGPT 5 for being overly thematic, and Copilot for its narrow focus.   

- Major headlines included President Trump's lawsuit against The New York Times, the rise of a China-Russia-North Korea bloc, and escalating conflicts in Gaza and Ukraine.   

- Stories of interest included the suspension of Jimmy Kimmel Live!, the tragic death of a roller coaster rider, and K-pop artists dominating global charts.   

- Climate and environmental updates highlighted wildfires in Turkey and Greece, Tropical Storm Gabrielle, and global inflation trends. 

Don’t Be Fooled by the Man Behind the Curtain – Accountabaloney https://accountabaloney.com/dont-be-fooled-by-the-man-behind-the-curtain/ 

The article critiques the privatization of public education in Florida, particularly focusing on the Step Up for Students program. It argues that the program's "education marketplace" undermines public schools by promoting competition and privatization, diverting funds away from neighborhood schools and reducing accountability. The author warns against the illusion of choice, highlighting its potential harm to vulnerable students and the democratic mission of public education. The piece urges investment in public schools as essential for communities and democracy, rejecting the dismantling of public education into a profit-driven marketplace.

### Key Points

- The Step Up for Students program promotes an "education marketplace" that undermines public schools by shifting them into a privatized system. 

- The program uses terms like "personalization" and "customization" to disguise its goal of breaking public schools into pieces for profit. 

- Privatization efforts trace back to Milton Friedman's free-market principles, expanded by Florida lawmakers over the last 25 years. 

- Public schools are critical for democracy, serving all children transparently, unlike privatized systems that prioritize profit and lack oversight. 

- Vulnerable students, such as those in rural or low-income areas, are disadvantaged by the "choice" marketplace model. 

- The article advocates for strengthening public schools instead of dismantling them, emphasizing their role in community cohesion and democratic values. 

How Teacher Evaluations Broke the University (Rose Horowitch) https://larrycuban.wordpress.com/2025/09/18/how-teacher-evaluations-broke-the-university-rose-horowitch/ via @CubanLarry

Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice

### Key Points

- Teacher evaluations have contributed to grade inflation and reduced academic rigor in universities, as professors feel pressured to give higher grades and lighter workloads to secure favorable evaluations. 

- Student evaluations, initially introduced to improve teaching, often fail to measure instructional quality effectively, showing biases based on gender, attractiveness, or expected grades. 

- Research indicates no positive correlation between high evaluation scores and actual student learning outcomes, with high-rated professors sometimes producing worse results in subsequent classes. 

- Evaluations significantly impact academic careers, especially for adjunct faculty and graduate instructors, whose employment often depends on student feedback. 

- Some universities are exploring alternatives, such as combining peer reviews, self-reflections, and student evaluations, to address the flaws of current systems. 

- Despite their flaws, evaluations persist due to institutional inertia, ease of use, and expectations from tuition-paying families to critique educational services. 

USA 2025: "Cheap Steamers in the Rain" https://radicalscholarship.com/2025/09/18/usa-2025-cheap-steamers-in-the-rain/ via @plthomasEdD 

The article reflects on societal tensions and the American Dream, using a Renaissance Faire experience as a lens to explore themes of diversity, equity, and the pursuit of happiness. It contrasts the peaceful, inclusive atmosphere of the Faire with the broader political and social struggles in the U.S., particularly around LGBTQ+ rights and conservative movements. The author emphasizes the importance of protecting human rights for all and critiques the imposition of narrow beliefs on society.

### Key Points

- The Renaissance Faire in South Carolina showcased an inclusive and diverse atmosphere, breaking societal norms and fostering peace and happiness. 

- The author connects this experience to broader societal issues, highlighting the disparity between the pursuit of happiness for all versus conservative movements imposing narrow beliefs. 

- LGBTQ+ rights are framed as a fight for equality and humanity amidst political waves of resentment and denial. 

- Denying rights to minorities threatens the foundational ideals of life, liberty, and happiness for everyone in the U.S. 

Choosing Democracy: : Trump Uses State Power Against Comedians https://choosingdemocracy.blogspot.com/2025/09/trump-uses-state-power-against-comedians.html 

Economic Crisis: Trump Uses State Power Against Comedians

### Main Ideas

- Trump’s Project 2025 aims to consolidate power through fear and control, using events like Charlie Kirk's death to silence dissent. 

- The Trump-appointed FCC commissioner pressured Disney/ABC to censor comedian Jimmy Kimmel, sparking allegations of state censorship. 

- Activists and unions are organizing boycotts and campaigns against censorship, highlighting the disorganized majority versus the organized minority. 

- In DC, authoritarian measures include National Guard occupation, arrests, and suppression of self-rule, but residents are resisting through activism and community actions. 

- Chicago successfully resisted Trump’s attempt to deploy the National Guard, uniting political leaders, labor groups, and residents across divides. 

- The Chicago example serves as encouragement for collective resistance against authoritarianism, emphasizing courage in the face of fear. 

- Practical tips for activism include focusing efforts, showing solidarity, grounding oneself, and connecting with supportive communities. 

State Superintendent Tony Thurmond Celebrates New Study Showing Positive Impact of California’s Community Schools Initiative on Student Attendance and School Culture https://www.cde.ca.gov/nr/ne/yr25/yr25rel40.asp 

State Superintendent Tony Thurmond celebrated the positive impact of California’s Community Schools Initiative as detailed in a study by the Learning Policy Institute (LPI). The initiative, funded with $4.1 billion, fosters partnerships between schools and community organizations to provide holistic support for students, leading to improved attendance, reduced suspension rates, and higher academic achievement, especially for historically underserved students.

### Key Points

- California’s Community Schools Initiative improves student attendance, reduces suspensions, and enhances school culture. 

- The initiative received $4.1 billion funding and is part of Superintendent Thurmond’s Transforming Schools Initiatives. 

- Community schools showed a 30% greater reduction in chronic absenteeism compared to similar schools. 

- Academic improvements for Black students equate to 130 additional days in math and 151 days in English language arts. 

- English Learners gained approximately 58 more days in math and 72 days in English language arts. 

- Superintendent Thurmond leads the initiative, collaborating with Governor Newsom, the Legislature, and the State Board of Education. 

Nancy Bailey's Education Website: What a Difference Teachers Could Make With $45 Million! | National Education Policy Center https://nepc.colorado.edu/blog/what-difference 

The article discusses the potential educational benefits of reallocating $45 million, currently planned for a military parade, toward schools and students. It highlights how this funding could address pressing issues like hunger, teacher shortages, special education, school facilities, libraries, and arts programs. The article critiques the Trump administration's cuts to education funding and emphasizes the importance of investing in public schools to support diverse student needs.

### Key Points

- $45 million could significantly improve school resources, including meals for students, hiring teachers, and enhancing special education programs. 

- Cuts to education funding, such as the McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act, raise concerns about state misuse of block grants for vouchers instead of supporting homeless students. 

- Funding could address infrastructural issues in schools, like lead removal and asbestos, which impact health and safety. 

- Investments in libraries, teacher preparation, and arts education could enrich student learning experiences and address systemic gaps. 

Today in Chicago RESISTANCE NEWS: All hell broke out on Fullerton Ave. https://klonsky.substack.com/p/today-in-chicago 

### Main Points

- An anti-ICE rally took place in Belmont Cragin, Chicago, following incidents of masked ICE agents attempting to detain people on Fullerton Avenue, prompting community resistance. 

- Community members and rapid response teams intervened, blocking streets and documenting the events, while ICE agents fled the scene. 

- Federal agents have been targeting locations like Home Depot where day laborers gather, leading to public outrage and calls for organized resistance. 

- Speakers from ICIRR, LSNA, and local politicians, including State Rep. Will Guzzardi and State Senator Graciela Guzmán, attended the rally to encourage collective action against ICE operations. 

- The author plans to host organizers from ICIRR and LSNA on an upcoming radio show to discuss further resistance strategies. 

Yesterday’s Gems, Today’s Insights
A Roundup of the Web’s Finest Blog Posts!

9-18-25

https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2025/09/yesterdays-gems-todays-insights-roundup_0911517022.html 

### Summary  

The article is a compilation of news stories, blog posts, and analyses from various sources, covering topics such as political controversies, education challenges, healthcare policies, societal issues, AI advancements, and global events. It highlights key debates, critiques, and developments shaping public discourse and governance.

Key Points  

- Florida's school voucher system lacks oversight, allowing taxpayer money to fund schools with unqualified teachers, flawed curricula, and discriminatory policies.   

- Kathleen West reflects on her teaching career, recounting experiences with school shootings and expressing frustration with societal attitudes toward educators.   

- Trump faced backlash for attempting federal intervention in Chicago and Memphis, raising concerns about local control and governance.   

- RFK Jr.'s leadership of HHS sparks debate over Western versus New Age medicine, emphasizing the need for evidence-based healthcare policies.   

- AI models competed in analyzing news stories, with Copilot excelling in balanced coverage, while others missed key cultural moments.   

- Dr. John Kuhn advocates for equity in education, condemning excessive testing and voucher programs that harm public schools.   

- Preschool expulsion rates disproportionately affect Black and Latine children, and parental cooperation with teachers can reduce these rates.   

- Trump’s administration slashed healthcare funding, exacerbating inequality and marginalizing vulnerable populations.   

- A poll shows growing support for democratic socialism, particularly among younger voters and Democrats, highlighting economic fairness and security.   

- UN human rights experts condemned U.S. military strikes on Venezuelan vessels, labeling them as violations of international law.   

- Ohio Charter Schools graduate students at lower rates than public schools, leading to significant economic losses for communities.   

- Americans' knowledge of First Amendment rights has improved slightly, but press freedom remains under significant threat.   

- Advocacy movements like "No Kings" oppose authoritarianism and defend constitutional freedoms amidst Trump’s presidency critiques.   

- Various resources and initiatives aim to improve child nutrition programs, including webinars and training opportunities.   

- Hispanic Heritage Month draws parallels between Cervantes' "Don Quixote" and Trump's rhetoric against wind turbines.   

- The importance of play in childhood is emphasized, advocating for environments that foster creativity and lifelong learning.