Latest News and Comment from Education

Tuesday, November 19, 2013

Shanker Blog » A Quick Look At The DC Charter School Rating System

Shanker Blog » A Quick Look At The DC Charter School Rating System:

A Quick Look At The DC Charter School Rating System

Posted by  on November 19, 2013


Having taken a look at several states’ school rating systems  (see our posts on the systems in INOHFL and CO), I thought it might be interesting to examine a system used by a group of charter schools – starting with the systemused by charters in the District of Columbia. This is the third year the DC charter school board has released the ratings.
For elementary and middle schools (upon which I will focus in this post*), the DC Performance Management Framework (PMF) is a weighted index composed of: 40 percent absolute performance; 40 percent growth; and 20 percent what they call “leading indicators” (a more detailed description of this formula can be found in the second footnote).** The index scores are then sorted into one of three tiers, with Tier 1 being the highest, and Tier 3 the lowest.
So, these particular ratings weight absolute performance – i.e., how highly students score on tests – a bit less heavily than do most states that have devised their own systems, and they grant slightly more importance to growth and alternative measures. We might therefore expect to find a somewhat weaker relationship between PMF scores